It's no secret that the recording industry doesn't exactly approve of file sharing, but I was pretty shocked when I read this, courtesy of Last Year's Girl.
The BPI (the body which represents the UK record industry) wants all UK ISPs to sign up to a so-called three strikes policy - where users of file sharing networks get two warnings and are then disconnected if they are sharing copyright files.
She adds:
It’s a bit disappointing that the message (which ended up in my spam folder and was only spotted by accident - sucks to be you, Web Sheriff) related to my favourite band - whose “unreleased” album is, by the way, officially out on iTunes and has been since 9th June - but such is life in our heavily policed modern world. The number of people I’ve turned on to this particular band is, of course, irrelevant because copyright is copyright is copyright. Treatises on whether a twenty-year-old law best serves an internet that could never have been predicted back in 1988 are as tired as they are unlistened-to by those in power.
Looking back at the number of lawsuits against music fans (and grandmothers ) for illegally downloading music, it's something I don't want to touch, and as a music blogger, I'd be lying if I said my site didn't suffer for it. As much as I'd love to pepper my blog with a few obscure MP3s, I fear being slapped with a lawsuit more than I fear having a boring site. I use YouTube (like everyone else on the planet) and its vast archives of obscure videos from the fringes of MTV.(Annie Zaleski from theA to Z blog is a whiz at finding some long-forgotten music via YouTube.) But people love to share music, and much to the irritation of the recording industry, blogs are a perfect medium for sharing songs. Even those who don't write about music exclusively love to share their tastes (like Sweetney has done this week), and sites like Muxtape make it all too easy. Popular MP3 blogger Largehearted Boy links only to legal MPs offered by record labels, but what other alternatives are out there? You can easily set up radio stations from Pandora and Last.FM or link to the samples provided at sites like iLike.
Some sites are still willing to take the risk and offer MP3s to their readers, usually with a disclaimer like the aptly-titled, and sorely missed Copy, Right?:
MP3s on this blog are available for a short time and are here for sampling purposes only. My only goal is to share my love/hate relationship with cover songs and to turn readers on to artists of whom they might not have otherwise been aware.
Other sites offering MP3s:
Curiously Tasty
I AM FUEL, YOU ARE FRIENDS
Come Pick Me Up
If you're thinking about posting copyrighted music on your site, think of the consequences, but do what's comfortable for you. If you have a favorite artist that you feel needs more exposure, offering a taste of their music might just be what the world needs.
Comments
Totally agreed, & applause for those willing
to take the chance
I'm not going to name names, but I know of a blogger who has posted in much the same manner you are talking about - "for sampling purposes only" - some tracks off an album that are not available on the current release of the same album, and to my knowledge are the only existence of the tracks anywhere online. Even the band itself, which has virtually all of its other tracks online for listening or for purchase, doesn't have these tracks up. I don't think the band cares, but I've been a little concerned that the record company in question that still holds the original rights might go after the blogger in question.
But I applaud the blogger for doing so - unless I ever get my hands on a copy of the original release (and that's unlikely, it's a bit obscure), I would have never heard this handful of songs.
My opinion? The songs aren't available ANYWHERE else and even the band doesn't have them online when they have everything else up, so who is it hurting? Nobody. But record company greed concerns me, of course. (PS the tracks also aren't downloadable, so again - hurting no one.)
The Lynnster Zone & Lynnster's Music Zone
Miss Money Hunter's Guide to Making Money Online