Bio
I’m Jill and I'm much scarier than I may appear. Or, at least I like to think so.   My son named me Scary Mommy during a phase where he was scar...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Recent Comments

Play Time: The Fine Art of Ignoring Your Children

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 24
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

We had dinner at our friend’s house a few weeks ago. Half-way through the evening, one of the other dinner guests complimented our children. She asked what our secret was to having such well-behaved kids who were so content simply playing together, rather than bickering and running upstairs every five minutes like the other kids there. We just smiled and said thank you, beaming inside and exchanging proud glances. But, there is actually a secret and I’m going to share it with all of you right now: We ignore our children. And they are better for it.

Yes, it’s true.

Boy (10-12) lying on bed watching twin sister tidy away toys, close-up

Our kids are night owls; they are often up until 9:30 or 10:00 at night. It sucks to not have everyone tucked in and sleeping by eight, but our solution is to make them stay upstairs and play together while we pay as little attention to them as possible. And, they do. They play for hours and hours and hours while we try and pretend they are sleeping. They play zoo and teacher. They play restaurant and camp. They play babysitter and grocery store. They actually use the million stuffed animals that line their beds. They play and play and play, endlessly. They can play anywhere and everywhere because of it and I think it’s been the best thing we’ve done for their sibling relationship.

It doesn’t end there. When they fight, I don’t run in to break it up immediately and eventually most spats seem to resolve themselves. Some even end in a spontaneous explosion of giggles when they realize how ridiculously they’ve been behaving. I don’t jump up at each and every minor injury and they simply run over for a quick kiss and then they are back to the game at hand.

Call it laziness, call it parenting of convenience, call it whatever. But, it’s been working. Sure, they’re not perfect (at all) and they drive us crazy more often than not, but they really are more capable of entertaining themselves than most kids we know.

The New York Times just wrote about the "Effort to Restore Children’s Play." The movement has focused on the educational value of play, with efforts beginning made to restore recess and unstructured playtime to early childhood and elementary schools. A coalition called Play for Tomorrow staged a giant play date in Central Park last fall which attracted more than 50,000 people. Scientists and experts are weighing in on the benefits of play verses extra-curricular activities or computer time. But, it’s really not that complicated: Just ignore them and they will play. No computers, no TVs, no gadgets. Just good old-fashioned play.

Sometimes, the less you do as a parent, the more they get. So, go ahead: Leave them alone. Put on some ear plugs, grab a cup of coffee, a trashy magazine and reflect on my guidance.

You’re welcome.

Jill presents an honest take on motherhood; the good, the bad and the scary at her blog, ScaryMommy.com. Her unique take on parenting has appeared in numerous publications, including The New York Times, CNN, Redbook, and Ms. Magazine, and she was a keynote speaker at BlogHer in 2010.

  • 24
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
mommyhanginon 5 pts

I love this topic and also love that you are so brave to write about it. I want my two daughters (ages 2 and 3)to be able to entertain themselves when they're older and not come to me and say that they "bored" like many of our friends' kids do!

stdiane 5 pts

Aargh! In the middle of my most profound, wise and amazing bout of wisdom my pc died without saving my response to your post. So...in brief....assuming my children are older than yours I'd like to share with you the outcome of ignoring them through to adulthood.
I had the pleasure of overhearing my 20 year old son telling the mother of his best friend that I had made sure to teach him how to look after himself when he left home. My recollection was that he thrived on neglect because I was unwilling to do for my children anything they could do for themselves. Whilst not the same as your point....I'd like to say that I also allowed leniency at bedtime as long as they were entertaining themselves. I endured much criticism from my parents but I also put up with the children of friends who were unable to enjoy any real "adult" time because their children did not allow their parents to ignore them.
How are these children going to copein the real world I wonder?

Jane Byers Goodwin 5 pts

One of the saddest sights in all the world is a person of any age who must be entertained from WITHOUT and who has no idea how to amuse himself/herself from within. These, by the way, are some of the very worst classroom disrupters, and most annoying husbands. :)

"Don't be content with being average. Average is as close to the bottom as it is to the top."

Jane blogs as "Mamacita" at Scheiss Weekly, ( http://janegoodwin.net/ )hitting the fan like nobody can.

JCK 5 pts

I subscribe to the same parenting philosophy - let the kids have lots of free play time together. I feel blessed that both children are also good at playing by themselves. I think that is just luck. I have many friends who would love to do the "ignoring", but their children need them all the time...right by their side.

I needed your reminder today. I was filled with the SHOULDs. I should get the kids outside, it's a beautiful sunny day. But, they are happily playing together on the top bunk with a bed full of puppets.

JCK of Motherscribe

http://motherscribe.blogspot.com ( http://motherscribe.blogspot.com/ )

honeybearlane 5 pts

My mom has 11 kids and there's no way she could have played with all of us all the time. In fact, I don't really remember ever playing with her. I always had lots of siblings to entertain me and when I was older, I was constantly with friends.

But Mom always brought us back together by having a family dinner and doing family activities on some nights.

If you feel guilty about 'ignoring your children,' don't. You are nourishing their capability of independent play. Without it, you will be raising a needy and incapable child. Kids need to learn to solve their own battles from time to time.

We, as moms, should be there to provide opportunities to teach our kids and help them feel loved, and that doesn't necessarily include playing trains with them for hours. Unless you kinda like it, like me. :)

Heidi
www.honeybearlane.com ( http://www.honeybearlane.com )

minnie 5 pts

nice! I love ignoring my kid!

The Idle Parent ( http://www.amazon.com/Idle-Parent-Laid-Back-Parent... ) is an amusing read about this very thing.

Love, Minnie

Parenting and Crafting: Thank You For Not Being Perky ( http://www.thankyoufornotbeingperky.com/ )

Fin DIY picks: Indie CraftGossip ( http://indiecrafts.craftgossip.com/ )

Jennie Pone 5 pts

try having a hyper-active kid. Maybe I should go "tiger mom" on them lol.

Nobody wants to be Ethel 5 pts

I tried ignoring my son - who is now 22 years old. No matter how hard I tried the kid found me and pestered me, at times, ad nauseam. He has kind of figured it out now. H

The Patty Beat can be found at  http://pattyabr.wordpress.com where The Fearless Cook resides ready to take on your most feared items in the kitchen.

jellybeanz 5 pts

Thank you so much for writing a blog that a lot of moms would feel guilty for even thinking about. I have four children ages (10,8,2,1)and I have ignored all of them. If not for this fact I could not have taken showers, fed everyone,or even gotten a job. I too believe that you are not ignoring them but giving them time to develop their imaginations and social skills. These are skills that they will later thank you for when they run into those kids whom freak out when real life smacks them in the face because they've always had a parent in their back pocket. My children can play together because they're forced to just like me and my brother were. Statistically kids play 50% less now then they did just 20 years ago, now that's sad. I knew I was doing something right when in a restaurant I too was complimented by an older gentleman about how well behaved my kids were as they waited for me playfully folding napkins at the table while I ordered food at the register. Thank you for spreading the word.

from Blahnik to Birkenstock 5 pts

i'm a single mom, so there are times when i just have to ignore my son. and i'm delighted to say that, at 1 1/2, he is totally capable of playing on his own for awhile. sometimes that's 5 minutes, sometimes it's 45 minutes... but he can self-entertain better than most little guys his age! it's definitely shown me that i don't NEED to hover every second and it's good for him to be able to play on his own. it also gives me time to do exciting things like go to the bathroom and cook dinner!

aligee 5 pts

My daughter is 7 and she is an only child. This is how I have always been with her! I remember being a child and playing by myself and having these unbelievable imaginary adventures! We have a fenced in backyard and a big doggie door(she loves using it!) and DD comes and goes as she pleases in and out- My mom has even called me "benignly neglectful" b/c she thinks I am not in her business enough!! BUT my daughter is constantly garnering compliments like yours do- "she's so sweet, so quiet, so well behaved" so I must be doing something right!

 You can find Ali online @ ksmb.com ( http://ksmb.com/article.asp?id=525987 )  or if you are in  Acadiana tune  in to94.5 KSMB FM on your radio dial Monday thru Saturday 6am-10am & some Saturdays 2-6p

Jweitl5 5 pts

I love the thought that this strengthens the sibling relationship. :) Maybe I'll have a cup of coffee this afternoon and let my trio duke it out after they are all up from nap!

Jamie blogs about life and motherhood at her blog Sticky Feet: Part Deux. ( http://www.stickyfeet2.com

skinnerstudio 5 pts

Love this article! It is so true. My brother and I spent our whole lives playing together while my mom did who-knows-what in the house. I've followed her example and my boys get along great, having all kinds of adventures and of course creating all kind of housework disasters - but they are much happier for it, much more self-sufficient, and I have much more time to myself than a lot of my friends.

skinnerstudio 5 pts

Love this article! It is so true. My brother and I spent our whole lives playing together while my mom did who-knows-what in the house. I've followed her example and my boys get along great, having all kinds of adventures and of course creating all kind of housework disasters - but they are much happier for it, much more self-sufficient, and I have much more time to myself than a lot of my friends.

imnotasupermom 5 pts

I don't think of it so much as ignoring as teaching children to learn to be self reliant.
As kids, we all learned to play with others and entertain ourselves when we were alone.
It's a skill that will serve them well as they get older as your children show.

My Site: I Am Not A Supermom ( http://imnotasupermom.com/ )  

Contemplations of an Army Wife 5 pts

I do this, and I feel guilty about being passe...now I have some backup! Thanks!

@NinaBadzin 5 pts

Jill, you need to write a book. You'll be The Common Sense Mom instead of The Tiger Mom.

Nina :)

http://ninabadzin.com

THE WRITING LIFE, MARRIAGE, AND MOTHERHOOD.

alysia75 5 pts

and I couldn't agree with you more. I'm not the cruise director, my kids have a responsibility to amuse themselves.

@gracoKaren 5 pts

My daughter plays very well by herself. Son, not so much. I try and believe it's my son's age since he's only 2. They have had very different beginnings one in full time daycare since 6 mo and the other home with Dad since 6 mo.
I think I need to get them to play more together and see what happens. :-)

Squashed Mom 5 pts

Great post, Jill. I have a night owl, too. Unfortunately, his twin is autistic and an early to bedder, so this strategy totally doesn't work for us (kids just not capable of playing together). Would that it did, though. You are awesome!

Varda is the Squashed Mom from The Squashed Bologna: a slice of life in the sandwich generation. ( http://www.squashedmom.com/ )

sherrikuhn 5 pts

You are right on with this advice, and it's probably the best kept secret of parenting, don't you think? So many parents just seem to feel the need to fill the moments of their child's day, then jump in immediately when it's not "right". Kudos to you for letting kids be kids!

Sherri blogs at Old Tweener ( http://www.oldtweener.blogspot.com/ ), where she writes about parenting and anything else that makes her laugh (or cry) while living in those years between changing diapers and wearing them.

mommyneedsavacation 5 pts

I loved this post on Jill's blog and I still love it just as much! I totally believe in the fine art of ignoring kids. As a matter of fact, as I write this comment, they are playing with choo-choo trains in my son's room while I am out in the living room!

foodiemama 5 pts

I just spent the last hour listening to my daughters (2 and 4) act out scenes from their favorite movie, "cook" in their kitchen, and pretend to be princesses hosting a tea party while I surfed the internet, cleaned the bathroom, and my husband napped. It's great!

I know I might have it a little easier than others because my kids are close in age, but as the previous poster pointed out, even only children can learn to entertain themselves if they're forced to. :)

www.quinoaandcornchips.blogspot.com ( http://www.quinoaandcornchips.blogspot.com )

texasebeth 6 pts

I've been ignoring my son for the past 2 years and never knew it made me a better parent! LOL

My son is an only child but I wanted him to learn how to play by himself without me having to constantly keep him entertained. That is what I admitted to people.

Truth - I don't want to play Hot Wheels or watch kid TV all the time. I want to read, sew, be on the computer, etc. sometimes. This means my kid has to fend for himself most afternoons after school, snack, and homework. He has learned how to entertain himself. I love listening to Charlie play.

Is Charlie perfect? Heck no. Does he want me to pay attention to him sometimes? Yes and some days we do play together. But it is not a NEED which is wonderful for everyone.

Elizabeth

@texasebeth ( http://twitter.com/texasebeth )  and My Life, such as it is.... ( http://texasebeth.blogspot.com )