Bio
Nordette is a freelance journalist, published fiction writer, poet, and the mother of two children. She is also a BlogHer.com Contributing Editor an...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Recent Comments

First Grandmom Goes to Washington: Is Michelle Obama Dodging Mom Duty?

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 29
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

When I heard that Marion Robinson, First Lady Michelle Obama's mother, would join the first family in Washington, D.C.,  and live at the White House to help her granddaughters, Sasha and Malia, adjust to life as first kids, I thought how sweet.  I also wrote about it at WSATA.  Nothing at all about Robinson's final decision to go to the White House struck me as odd, a grandmother choosing to be around her grandchildren or helping to care for them regularly.

Her possible move with the First Family seemed an obvious and ordinary decision to me because I wasn't carted off to daycare when I was little.  My grandmother didn't live with my parents, but I spent a lot of time at my grandmother's house.  My mother had the benefit of my grandmother keeping me while she went to work, and I count that as a blessing, one I wish my own children had experienced.

My grandmother was a natural caregiver, a nurturer and consistent disciplinarian.  With my grandfather, she  not only raised five children of her own, all of whom finished college during a period when African Americans usually did not attend universities, but she also raised foster children. In many ways she was the stereotypical grandmother, preparing huge Sunday dinners to which we all looked forward and maintaining a sanctuary upon which the entire family converged for holidays 

While I'm speaking of my grandmother, let me get this off my chest.  I was my grandmother's favorite!  Hear that, cousins, and you too, baby brother, should you come across this post. ;-)  I was MaDear's number one!  Did she ever bring a three-layer, valentine-shaped cake with pink frosting that she made from scratch to school for your birthdays, hmm?  I don't think so.

Back to the Obamas:  I've been a little suprised that Marion Robinson moving in to help her daughter and son-in-law, President Barack Obama, with Sasha and Malia would be controversial.  From all I've read, Grandmother Robinson was the after-school care provider for Sasha and Malia and a rock for the Obama family long before the president decided to run for office.  Furthermore, I've read that the move may be only temporary. Robinson's "not sure she will stay," writes Lynn Sweet at The Chicago Sun-Times.

I've considered that perhaps Robinson's move to the White House should be permanent, whether she wants it to be or not, because it's been strongly established that Mrs. Robinson is an important member of the Obama family.  Her life could be in danger should she return to her Chicago home to live alone as though her son-in-law never became the first African-American President of the United States of America and her face hasn't been on every major network, a figure in the background of many Obama family photos. If a domestic terrorist or assassin can't get to the first family then why not go after First Grandma?

Consequently, I don't get the people leaving comments on Michael Shear's very brief post about Robinson moving into the White House and complaining:

Granny Robinson knows EXACTLY what she is doing...a free life of luxury at OUR EXPENSE. I would be more understanding if she had lived with the family prior to the election, but she didn't. I am willing to bet that the expense of having grammy living there will exceed $500K over the course of the next 4 years.

We did not vote for Michelle Obama, so she needs to raise her children while her husband is the president.(comment from The Running Nurse on a WaPo blog post)

Actually, what I said isn't quite correct.  I do grasp this kind of comment in that it sounds like the anger of the misinformed opposition.  As Shear said, Robinson will not be the first mother-in-law to spend time in the White House because former First Lady Laura Bush's mother stayed there frequently, especially over the holidays.

What bristles through this kind of complaint is the animosity toward First Lady Michelle Obama as though she and her children have nothing at all to do with the president himself and by extension that her mother is not as important as the mother of the president would have been if she were alive. It's as though some people view her as Obama's "baby mama," the insulting image cast by Fox News via Michelle Malkin during the campaign. A "baby mama" does not receive the honor of legal wife.

I've read similar comments on other posts about the First

  • 29
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
sondon 5 pts

http://gagasisterhood.com
Where grandmas bond, brag, and benefit

First let me compliment you on your post – it’s thought provoking and tackles a lot of issues. It obviously generated a lot of interest but none from a grandmother. So let me add my two cents!
I write a blog called gagasisterhood.com for enthusiastic grandmas. After President Obama was elected, I wrote a post that said I was more excited about the new First Grandma in the White House. And here’s why:
Mrs. Robinson is focusing more attention on the important role we grandmothers bring to our families, and the issues and conflicts we face. I wrote that I also hope she’ll raise the status of grandmothers in America.
As you point out, there are always two sides to every story and many people just love to take stabs at the First Family.
As an adoring grandmother of two precious granddaughters with a rich, fulfilling life of my own, I completely understand the dilemma Marian Robinson faces. If my daughter asked me to be the caretaker for my two granddaughters so she could follow her career, I would be torn. As much as I love them and would not want someone else to care for them, I would feel resentful having to give up my life.
I have already been a full-time mom and put off my career for my children. Now I’m enjoying a second career – creating an organization for vibrant grandmothers called the GaGa Sisterhood.
Would I give it up if asked? If my daughter were not able to care for them, I definitely would but not so she could work.
Being the caregiver changes the relationship between grandmother and grandchildren. Instead of being the special star that comes and goes in my granddaughter’s lives, I’d be there 24/7 – like mom!
Being grandma comes with privileges – I don’t have to do the daily grind that mom and dad do. It’s so much easier being grandma, having fun and then being able to go home to my other life.
But sometimes grandmas have no choice. I know a grandma who is raising her three grandchildren because her daughter isn’t able. And I would do the same if that were the case.
Marian Robinson couldn’t say no and I understand. But I can’t help wondering what her innermost thoughts are. Would she rather be in her own home and just be the visiting star or be there on the front lines for all the daily grind? We’ll probably never know.

Donne

http://gagasisterhood.com

Nordette Adams 6 pts

It's good to get along with your mother-in-law so well that her keeping the kids is a blessing and not a headache.  Sounds like a fantastic grandmother in your children's lives.  Thanks for commenting.

Nordette ( http://blogher.org/blog/nordette ) is a BlogHer CE, personal blog WSATA ( http://bigsole.blogspot.com ). Also @ Twitter ( http://twitter.com/nordette_verite ).

Nordette Adams 6 pts

I know I would not be the type of grandmom who'd take on the daily task of looking after grandchildren. Just not in my nature, but if child care issues arose with whoever was watching them (should I ever get them) I'd be glad to pitch in as a temp. back-up.

But as said before, it's about giving people choices, and yes, it's a non-issue.  I think the public bruhaha shows we're still a nation of busy-bodies and gossips.

Nordette ( http://blogher.org/blog/nordette ) is a BlogHer CE, personal blog WSATA ( http://bigsole.blogspot.com ). Also @ Twitter ( http://twitter.com/nordette_verite ).

TheFeministBreeder 5 pts

My Mother In Law retired last year and now takes care of my two sons 5 days a week so I can work.  I'd rather not work, but being the smart feminist I am I went and painted myself into a corner by making more than my husband, and now I can't quit my job to be a stay at home mom the way I'd love to.  Michelle Obama's got responsibilities too.  She's not just a "baking cookies" kind of lady, like Hillary once said.

I cherish every moment that my MIL agrees to stay with her grandkids.  They love her, and she has so much to offer them.  She's a mexican immigrant and speaks to both boys only in Spanish, so my 2 yr old is bilingual.  What an amazing advantage my boys will have with that added skill.  She is an invaluable caregiver, and damn anybody who puts me down for letting her be such an integral part of her grandchildren's lives.  Would you rather me stick them in daycare?  Seriously people.

The Feminist Breeder
http://thefeministbreeder.typepad.com/

kdc521 5 pts

If the Grandma wants to move in and help the family out with the grandkids, that's their business. 

Personally, I don't think that I would want to if I were here.  I've made sacrifices to be the primary caregiver for my own kids.  I would like for them to make their own childcare arrangments - not including me (except for as the "doting grandmother") in the equation- when they have their own families.

To each their own choices though.  Really, our country has more pressing issues at hand!

-Kimberly/Mom in the City ( http://mominthecity.com )

Nordette Adams 6 pts

I agree.  Thank you for commenting. I think Robinson's presence gives the new First Lady and President Obama peace of mind, and that's invaluable given the responsibilities they've taken on.

Nordette ( http://blogher.org/blog/nordette ) is a BlogHer CE, personal blog WSATA ( http://bigsole.blogspot.com ). Also @ Twitter ( http://twitter.com/nordette_verite ).

Nordette Adams 6 pts

Finally, who's to say that Grandma Robinson isn't thrilled to be part
of this history making event. As an elderly Black woman, no one
deserves more to experience the administration of the first Black
President than she does.

It's about what she wants, not what we want.  People seem to forget that.  I've also thought about her having a eye on history. That's exciting to me.  Maybe it's exciting to her as well, and perhaps she beleives taking care of her granddaughters is the most important contribution she can make.  I think it's great, also, that the Obamas value her opinions.  

I heard once that after our parents raise us, they move from parental authority to counseling authority.  So many of us plug our ears to our detriment.

Thank you, Lisa. 

Nordette ( http://blogher.org/blog/nordette ) is a BlogHer CE, personal blog WSATA ( http://bigsole.blogspot.com ). Also @ Twitter ( http://twitter.com/nordette_verite ).

Nordette Adams 6 pts

Thank you for dropping by, DJ.

Nordette ( http://blogher.org/blog/nordette ) is a BlogHer CE, personal blog WSATA ( http://bigsole.blogspot.com ). Also @ Twitter ( http://twitter.com/nordette_verite ).

I Wanna Be A Celeb 5 pts

I would never trust anyone were I in the Obamas position. Grandma is
possibly the best security the First Family has for their children. It
is a reality now that a nanny would probably be approached by our
enemies to get to the children-and sadly, some people can be bought.
Remember-Jackie O married Aristotle Onassis primarily because he had an
isolated residence where her children could be safe. First children are
always vulnerable. And by extension, as you said, the First Grandma is a
target now, too. There are two areas where security costs are
lessened.The First Lady has to be available at a moments
notice for visiting dignitaries. There are so many reasons to have
someone around 24/7 for the children, and grandma is truly the best
choice. Why is this even
news? Critics need to find something real to complain about-not about "Granny Goes To The White House".

http://iwannabeacelebbutimtoopoortoaffordit.blogsp...

Nordette Adams 6 pts

My mother died in November and while my father had help coming in 5 hours 5X per week to help care for her and they both lived with me, much of her care fell to him.  He's 88 now. He's looking for something to do and feels his purpose has gone since he no longer has to get up and see about my mom each morning.  He's putzing around the house trying to fix the cabinets and diagnosing what's wrong with my lawnmower.

Before my mother showed clear signs of Alzheimer's she came to visit me and my family when we lived in NJ b/c I was ill.  Her complaint:  We wouldn't let her help.  She got mad and left.  She was looking for purpose after retiring from teaching and my dad had talked her out of keeping the part-time job she had at a tutoring program because he was afraid for her safety, hearing so much about New Orleans crime.

I think of my mother and the elderly who retire only to return to the workforce as volunteers at hospitals and through church programs.  This idea that every elderly person longs to sit down and gaze at the sunsets seems to put our elderly in a box of tissue.

Some people fade away to an earlier grave because they have no work not because they've worked too much, and work you enjoy is not so much work as it is therapy or sanctifying passion.

It's all about choice. People need to have the right to say "Yes, I will" or "No, I won't." 

My mother's sisters are still alive, women in Robinson's age range, and they will tell you what they will and won't do.  If they want to go to the spa, then the spa it is. When they want to keep their grandchildren, then the grandchildren they have.  And we're are aware that we should not impose because if we do we'll get an ear full. Eventually their health will fail and they won't be able to do all they want to do, but until then they've earned the right to do as they please.

Thank you, Irina.

Nordette ( http://blogher.org/blog/nordette ) is a BlogHer CE, personal blog WSATA ( http://bigsole.blogspot.com ). Also @ Twitter ( http://twitter.com/nordette_verite ).

Nordette Adams 6 pts

Thank you for asking the question how is a nanny any different, Amber, because you're right where I am.  Unless the grandmother is a danger to the children, dislikes children, or has declared she wants to travel to Europe and visit spas or something the rest of her life or revive a career, then a grandmother who wants to be with her grandchildren and is good with children is preferable to a nanny in my opinion.

But either way the Obamas need child care so why do people care if it's Sasha and Malia's grandmother, the woman who's helped look after them since they were babies, or a stranger?

And yeah, they're not considering the security issues that get solved by Robinson continuing the role she's had for a long time.

Nordette ( http://blogher.org/blog/nordette ) is a BlogHer CE, personal blog WSATA ( http://bigsole.blogspot.com ). Also @ Twitter ( http://twitter.com/nordette_verite ).

Nordette Adams 6 pts

Thanks for commenting.  Yes, she has lots of work to keep her away from the White House or at a desk when she's there.  I think many of the people harping on the First Grandmom "issue" have never paid attention to what first ladies actually do. Certainly they have not researched how the First Lady's duties have evolved over the years, and so they speak from a place of ignorance and often sexism too.  And they hide behind words like "her children come first," as though the First Lady would put her children second.

Nordette ( http://blogher.org/blog/nordette ) is a BlogHer CE, personal blog WSATA ( http://bigsole.blogspot.com ). Also @ Twitter ( http://twitter.com/nordette_verite ).

Nordette Adams 6 pts

The tax payer money complaint is a non-issue. People with that complaint generally don't know what they're talking about.

Thanks for commenting, Erin.

Nordette ( http://blogher.org/blog/nordette ) is a BlogHer CE, personal blog WSATA ( http://bigsole.blogspot.com ). Also @ Twitter ( http://twitter.com/nordette_verite ).

Nordette Adams 6 pts

I think this tendency to exclude our elders is more of problem than inviting them to play a role in molding our children's futures.  Now, I know not all grandmothers want to help with their grandchildren, nor are they good with children, but when you have a grandmother who wants to be involved and who is not a danger to the child (recognizing there are some parents who are now grandparents but who terrorized their own children while they were raising them) then it's good to find ways to keep that connection. It doesn't have to be that they watch your children while you're at work, but some time with their grandchildren is a good thing for everyone. I thought we had more data to indicate time with the elderly benefits children than any data that suggest otherwise.

Nordette ( http://blogher.org/blog/nordette ) is a BlogHer CE, personal blog WSATA ( http://bigsole.blogspot.com ). Also @ Twitter ( http://twitter.com/nordette_verite ).

Nordette Adams 6 pts

I've been surprised that Robinson's role in the lives of the Obamas has rattled so many people, at least people online, and can only think that there are other issues beneath the surface that are bugging them.  And then there's this tendency to want to judge parents, especially mothers.

Thank you for taking the time to comment, byJane.

Nordette ( http://blogher.org/blog/nordette ) is a BlogHer CE, personal blog WSATA ( http://bigsole.blogspot.com ). Also @ Twitter ( http://twitter.com/nordette_verite ).

Blue State Cowgirl 5 pts

First of all, First Ladies do plenty of service to the country -- all in an unpaid position. So we are in no way being robbed as taxpayers. I can't believe there will be any more staff hired because Grandma is living with them. And I believe nannies have been provided for every president who has young kids in the White House. It's probably a taxpayer saving to have Grandma Robinson. Besides, the kids are in school, there are cooks and staff at the White House, so her duties will be very light -- certainly not something that, as one reader suggests -- will drive her into the grave.

 Finally, who's to say that Grandma Robinson isn't thrilled to be part of this history making event. As an elderly Black woman, no one deserves more to experience the administration of the first Black President than she does.

 From what I've read, Obama respects and values her opinions as well. He grew up in a time when opportunities for Black kids were increasing. Malia and Sasha probably have no concept what it was like as recently as the Sixties. I look at Marion as a valuable historical link to a different era. I hope she can continue to be the valuable voice my reading suggests she already is to Obama. 

Blue State Cowgirl

djnelson 5 pts

This should not be an issue however I understand that some people thrive off of making mountains out of mole hills.  

DJ Nelson, Founder
All Diva Media ( http://www.alldivamedia.com )
The Women's Blog Network

( http://www.twitter.com/alldivamedia )

EllieAndMe 5 pts

The whoe contriversy seems rediculous. The girls have to be cared for by someon when the parents attend to their official duties. Who better to do it: loving grandma or a White House nanny? Whie helping to reaise grandkids involves a certain amount of sacrifice , I don't think doing so in the White House with the help of a staff and with close involvement of the children's parents equals digging an early grave.

Irina

http://amomswhatsnextblog.blogspot.com

AmberS 5 pts

I can't imagine that any First Lady could do that job and not have help.  If she's ever going to travel, or attend events, she will need child care of some kind.  How is having a nanny any different?  The fact that her own mother is willing and able to fill this role is great.  I'm in no position to judge what's best for someone else's family.  I can't believe that others would presume that they are.

And as for living in the White House, as you pointed out it's likely the most practical solution.  There are safety issues to consider among other things, and it's a very large residence.  Of course things will be different there than they were back in Chicago.

~ Amber

www.strocel.com ( http://www.strocel.com )

zchamu 5 pts

The reality is that Michelle Obama is now the consort of the President of the United States. As such, she does have a role, and that role is not simply to be "Mom"; it is to support the most powerful man in the world, both publicly and privately. Publicly, this will include commitments such as dinners, trips abroad, and many other commitments to her time. Privately, it will also require a great deal of her time and attention. Therefore, there is a requirement in the Obama's lives for childcare. They could have hired someone to care for the children, but they have chosen bring in someone who is already a strong, stable presence in the childrens' lives to fill that role. Frankly, I think this will end up being cheaper than hiring separate childcare in the long run, not to mention being better and more consistent for the kids. 

But you know, Moms are damned if they do, damned if they don't, no matter what they do. 

Visit my blogs at ThreeSeven ( http://www.threeseven.ca ) (all that's irrelevant and amusing) and
ecochick ( http://www.ecochick.ca ) (all that's green, cool and Canadian).

Erin Kotecki Vest 5 pts

My mother lives 3,000 miles away in Florida and whenever I travel or have an extended work project...guess who I fly in or fly too?

My mother.

I brought my Dad into town so I could see Barack Obama become President.

I ENTIRELY relate to Michelle Obama bringing her mother to the White House and find it not only refreshing but EXACTLY WHAT I WOULD DO.

I'd bring my mom to live with me right now to help take care of the kids if I could.

Right now.

People upset that there is taxpayer money involved can #suckit. And I give the Obama's FULL PERMISSION to take ALL MY TAXMONEY to pay for Grandma's secret service detail.

Politics & News Contributing Editor
Queen of Spain ( http://queenofspainblog.com/ )

Wilma Ham 5 pts

 What are we doing? Why so ready with negative comments and judgments. I would have loved my mother looking after my girls, who wouldn't. The fact that the elder live so seperate from us is ridiculous, they have so much to offer and my daughters would have loved the attention  a grandparent could give them.
I feel I could give my grandchildren different things than their mother could if I had any grandchildren that is.

I am with Jane, lets stop this bickering and lets support any woman who needs it. 

Wilma Ham

www.wilmasblog.com ( http://www.wilmasblog.com/ )

ByJane 5 pts

 I can't barely read this because it makes me so mad.  So mad that I'M SHOUTING! And saying, goddamit, people--don't we have enough real stuff to worry about in the world today without creating an issue every time we disagree with someone?  Is the to-do over this topic an indication that Obama's honeymoon is over and the daggers are out?  

By Jane

http://byjane.blogspot.com

http://midlifebloggers.com 

Nordette Adams 6 pts

That's the part that gets me the most, Susan. It's like a grandmother is not worthy of protection and is unimportant.  It smacks of not honoring our elders.

Thanks for commenting.

Nordette ( http://blogher.org/blog/nordette ) is a BlogHer CE, personal blog WSATA ( http://bigsole.blogspot.com ). Also @ Twitter ( http://twitter.com/nordette_verite ).

Nordette Adams 6 pts

You saw that summary and thought it was much ado about nothing.  I understand. :-)

Nordette ( http://blogher.org/blog/nordette ) is a BlogHer CE, personal blog WSATA ( http://bigsole.blogspot.com ). Also @ Twitter ( http://twitter.com/nordette_verite ).

lilmommythatcould 5 pts

My sister spent much of her young life at my Grandma's when my mom went back to school.  My sister has so many fond memories and now has an unbreakable bond with my grandma, which I am soooooo jealous of.  When I heard the president's girl's grandma was helping out, it seemed so natural.  I can't even begin to think how this would be a bad thing.

Imagine if Michelle stayed home 24-7 she would be accused of not taking on her First Lady duties.  Or if the Obama family decided to get a nanny-they'd probably be accused of being elitists.  Basically they can't win

Through all this nonsense talk I am reminded of that day not long ago when Barack talked about setting aside our childish ways- this argument, to me, is just childish.

~Susan

http://lilmomthatcould.com/

editor- Mommytalk.com

writer Wisconsin State Journal Mom@Life

Clamo88 5 pts

I shouldn't have been so harsh in my statement...it just boggles my mind the silly things that people choose to take issue with.

Wheat Among Tares ( http://wheatamongtares.blogspot.com )

Nordette Adams 6 pts

To be fair to Lisa, and while I disagree with her view on the First Grandmother's taking care of Malia and Sasha, her whole post is about women, black women in particular, who too often put the needs of others ahead of their own needs.  The push to live up to the image of Strong Black Woman, bearing it all and caring for all, has damaged some women's lives, sending them to their graves early, if not the grave then to mental and spiritual collapse.

Nevertheless, I think it's a case of women needing to break free of the expectations others have for them and do more introspection.

I don't see Robinson as one of the women digging her own grave, however.  She seems too strong-willed to me to let anyone pressure her into doing something she doesn't really want to do.  Furthermore, I think if we're not careful in that particular discussion, we begin to sound as though we don't value the work of caring for children, still see it as a mammy's work that anyone can do.

Furthermore, I think some people are conjuring up their images of what a grandmother caring for grandchildren means while devaluing the power of work to give a person a continued since of purpose and dignity.  I doubt Marion Robinson will be running around the White House cooking for the girls and doing laundry.  She' more there to be a watchful eye and a soothing, familiar  presence, I think.

Thank you so much, Terri, for coming by and commenting.  I agree that many of us would give our right arms for the kind of support and loyalty that the Obama family has.

Nordette ( http://blogher.org/blog/nordette ) is a BlogHer CE, personal blog WSATA ( http://bigsole.blogspot.com ). Also @ Twitter ( http://twitter.com/nordette_verite ).

Clamo88 5 pts

 She asserts a woman Robinson's age shouldn't be helping to raise her grandchildren, that she's done enough, and should be relaxing in a spa. 

That's just a crazy and stupid statement.

I don't see why anyone cares whether she's there or not.  She's a part of their family.  I think it's great to have her there.  That's the kind of loyal family support that many people would give their right arms for.

Wheat Among Tares ( http://wheatamongtares.blogspot.com )