Bio
My name is Genie. I was born in Washington D.C. While there are plenty of people in the D.C. area with a penchant for gardening, I was not one of tho...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Recent Comments

What Does Hunger Look Like? Restaurant Critic Goes From Expense Account to Food Stamps

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 15
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

In this economy, the fact that someone is using food stamps to make sure they have enough food to feed themselves and their family is, sadly, no longer news. But when the person on food stamps is a former restaurant critic, that's a totally different story.

Ed Murrieta, former food critic at the Tacoma News Tribune, used to have a $1,300-per-month expense account for dining out... on top of his newspaper salary. But in 2008, he chose to leave his job to pursue an entrepreneurial alternative, wound up without a job and eating on $200 in food stamps per month.

"As a professional assignment, writing about a thing such as shopping and eating on a budget is abstract. As a gut-punching, ego-bruising, bank-busting predicament, eating on the food lines is real. After six months of it, I still feel the occasional memory pang of expense-account indulgences gone by, but I don't cry in my cabernet."


"It's a worthwhile piece, and provides plenty of food for thought," writes Rebecca Marx of the Village Voice blogs.

Kim Burgess of Behind the Byline calls Murrieta's story a "poignant example of the industry’s struggle for survival."

But Lauren Kelly of the Poverty In America blog on Change.org points out that though Murrieta is most certainly dealing with hardship, his experience is hardly the average.

"The interesting part is that, far from being a woe-is-me tale, his article actually makes living off food stamps sound ... not that bad," Kelly writes. "Of course, the reality of living on food stamps is not so easy for everyone. For many families, there are epic delays, bureaucratic red tape, social stigmas, food deserts and worse to contend with. That doesn't make Murrieta's struggles any less valid or give him any less right to receive government aid to feed himself. Food stamps are meant to support people who need help — whether they're students, Whole Foods shoppers or unemployed restaurant critics. But I do worry a bit about splashy news stories that can come off as romanticizing life on food stamps. All the kudos in the world to Murrieta for being able to maintain a decent diet on food stamps, but the Seattle Times should think about following up with a piece about a family living a few miles away who may not be so lucky."

Murrieta's experience made at least one blogger grateful for what she has.

"Thanksgiving is not just for November," wrote Karoline of Sweet Karoline after reading about Murrieta's situation. "Take a moment each day to remember the little things that make life worth living."

Kimberly Morales of Poor Girl Eats Well is a blogger who not only remembers gratitude, but has turned her experiences into blog posts that demonstrate how she manages her cash-strapped life without resorting to unhealthy food options.

There are a lot of "cheap eats" and "budget food" websites out there and most of them have something interesting to offer. Poor Girl Eats Well is quite different from other blogs in that I try to make most of my meals as healthy as possible, with a sinful treat thrown in here & there for good measure. I'm not the type who is satisfied eating cheaply the "easy" way, which is usually through fast food or fat and salt-laden, pre-packaged meals. Though I don't avoid fast food entirely, I have never liked the idea of having to subsist off the 99-cent menu, especially considering that most of the menu items would be really unhealthy for me to eat on a regular basis. I also do not believe that it is "too expensive" to eat healthy food and try to show that in most of my recipes.

Check out some of Kimberly's healthful and quick recipes like Quinoa with Mushrooms, Tomatoes & Scallions and Garlic-Black

  • 15
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Genie Gratto 9 pts

Candelaria, I love the idea of working with one luxury ingredient per pay period -- that ought to spark some creativity!

--- Genie, The Inadvertent Gardener ( http://www.theinadvertentgardener.com )

Genie Gratto 9 pts

notUrtypicalGma, I'm sure this completely changed his relationship with food. I know that even when I've just done the Hunger Challenge for a week at a time, it has completely changed how I think about food.

--- Genie, The Inadvertent Gardener ( http://www.theinadvertentgardener.com )

Genie Gratto 9 pts

Jaelithe,

That's a great idea -- I love the thought of the healthy food stamp recipe cookbook. I agree -- it's totally unrealistic for people to think that someone who has so much other stress in their life is going to have hours and hours to cook complicated healthy dishes.

--- Genie, The Inadvertent Gardener ( http://www.theinadvertentgardener.com )

Genie Gratto 9 pts

Angie, I wonder how much of the norm that behavior represents, actually. It seems like people generally have to work harder to stretch their food stamp benefits further, so it doesn't seem like that would be the normal way things would be...but perhaps I'm wrong? Thanks for sharing your perspective, regardless.

--- Genie, The Inadvertent Gardener ( http://www.theinadvertentgardener.com )

Genie Gratto 9 pts

Those are great tips, Candelaria. Thanks for sharing your ideas!

--- Genie, The Inadvertent Gardener ( http://www.theinadvertentgardener.com )

Genie Gratto 9 pts

Calliope,

That's really interesting about Whole Foods -- I didn't know that. So bizarre. But I'm glad to hear that Trader Joe's does accept food stamps, and I'm applauding your efforts to keep things as unprocessed as possible -- that's got to be quite the challenge, and I wish more people would try that route.

--- Genie, The Inadvertent Gardener ( http://www.theinadvertentgardener.com )

Genie Gratto 9 pts

Melissa, that's a really compelling story, and yes -- it's ridiculous to me that there is so much food available, yet so many who can't afford it.

--- Genie, The Inadvertent Gardener ( http://www.theinadvertentgardener.com )

Genie Gratto 9 pts

Jenna, I will admit that while I know it's got to be difficult to get and keep the benefits, I don't know all that much about it. Definitely something to look into!

--- Genie, The Inadvertent Gardener ( http://www.theinadvertentgardener.com )

Candelaria Silva 5 pts

I pretty much buy what's on sale that I eat and a buy one luxury ingredient that I will use regularly per pay period. I use Farmer's Markets a lot during the summer months, use frozen vegetables in winter and in-season veggies like butternut squash which can be prepared in many delicious ways. I even get bargains from Whole Foods - as in tuckey thighs for 99 cents. Trader Joe;s is helpful,. And I've gotten wonderful olive oils, olives, etc., from TJ Maxx and Ocean State Job Lot stores. Cooking mostly from scratch and reading food blogger recipes has helped me eat deliciously on little money. It can be done,. Unforunately, most of the food coupons aren't useful to me because I don't use the foods they are for, although I celebrate when I find a coupon for Greek Yogurt, etc. When I was on food stamps years ago, there were lots of restrictions on the type of food one could buy. Having not used them in many years, I have seen people look to see what people who are using food stamps have in their baskets. I never understood that. Anyhow - it is possible to eat well cheaply but it is a lot of work.

http://blog.candelariasilva.com ( http://blog.candelarisilva.com/ )

Good and plenty!

Angie McGowan 5 pts

watching people when I was a kid fill up their grocery carts with steaks, pork and seafood and pay for it with their food stamps made me so so envious. We hardly got to eat any amount of meat. We fished alot, not for fun, but necessity. Recently I watched a couple put a goose, A GOOSE in their cart, I was so curious by the looks of them I got behind them in checkout and the people paid for it with a foodstamp card. Jealous, very. I'm sure some people that need it get it, but I'd like to see the whole program eliminated, seriously. There are many many organizations, like angel food ministries that can take over.

Eclectic Recipes ( http://eclecticrecipes.com )

jaelithe 5 pts

I think it was courageous act for him to write this - I imagine he wondered and worried about his old colleagues, restaurant critics and high-level chefs who are still gainfully employed and eating gourmet food every day, reading about his food stamp adventures and thinking less of him in some way. No matter what he says about the food stamp stigma being less than he expected, discrimination against the poor and unfortunate just for being poor and unfortunate is deeply ingrained in our society and I am sure he feels it (hence his apparently intense shame at accidentally "stealing" food from a church donation basket that was meant to go to hungry people like him anyway).

But I agree with others that he (probably totally accidentally, since he apparently just hasn't spent a lot of time as a poor person) paints a somewhat unrealistic picture of what life is like for MOST people who live on food stamps - the working poor. WORKING poor means you do have a job, but it doesn't pay enough to support your family. Some people who use food stamps work 40 or even 50 or 60 hours a week; many of them lack reliable cars and so face long commutes on inadequate public transportation to get to and from work. Not every single working parent has 3 or 4 hours a day to spend cooking fresh food. (Making stock from celery ends? Homemade hollandaise sauce? After a day of hard physical labor and cleaning your house and taking care of your kids? Not likely.)

I would really like to see more resources for people who would like to eat healthily while on public assistance but don't have a lot of time to spend puttering around in the kitchen (and who maybe never even learned how to cook in the first place and need help with basic kitchen skills). I wonder if Murrieta himself has considered putting together a book of quick and easy healthy Food Stamp Recipes, with advice on where to shop to find good cheap food that can be prepared quickly with simple tools, that might help other people in his situation who do not have his culinary expertise.

notUrtypicalGma 5 pts

poor guy wow takes a food critic to draw discussion about the not so bad foodstamp stigma? whats the world coming too. if i had a 1300 dollar a month expense account ida kept my day job, and sadly he gets about as much foodstamps as i do for 3 people in my household so while i really do not give a piss about being able to shop at whole foods with my ebt card i am right there with the gal who wants more discussion about how to feed your family on a budget and feed them well. we do ok and even have shrimp and steak occassinally and even though one time a cashier at a local savemart told me the watermelon with seeds was cheaper cheaper than the seedless variety i looked at her and said "well than you buy it". stigma exists and thats ok cause i am a full time working mom who is the sole income in my household and i unfortunately have subsisted off of foodstamps and whatever cash has been left over for food for a long time! so hmmmm maybe i need to start that group on blogher! any takers? and no i am not hard hearted hannah i empathize with the poor guy. he took a risk and it did not pan out but this time on foodstamps probably shed a whole new light on his relationship with food, its not always eaten for pleasure. trust me there have been days where i told my kids to eat the free lunch at school because dinner was going to be pasta with butter and parmesan! these things though have made me a wise shopper more appreciative of where my food comes from and a great goddamned cook! maybe i better write that cookbook!

Calliope 5 pts

As someone that is currently on foodstamps (& living within a duality of thankfulness and shame) I really found his article fascinating. I know that there are times that I might be able to stretch my food stamp allotment out just a bit more if I bought more processed foods, but food stamps and state assistance shouldn't equal unhealthy food. Thankfully Trader Joe's accepts food stamps and their affordable produce and dairy is the first thing we budget for.

(& just as an aside- Whole Foods rarely accepts food stamps. It is a store by store basis and within my area not a single one of the 8 stores within a two hour driving distance accepts them.)

Calliope
blogging about Alzheimer's, Infertility, and Single Motherhood

http://creatingmotherhood.com

Melissa Ford 5 pts

Not unemployed, but paid too little to subsist on (I couldn't afford a garbage can--I used old bags tied to the back of a door), I remember both the gratitude and shame from having to accept a free meal from an area Jewish organization every Friday night. The second I had a real paycheck, I turned around and paid for someone else to eat there. Much more emotional than not being able to afford a garbage can, CDs, or books was the idea of not being able to pay for food. It grows everywhere, and yet it felt strangely out of reach. I found his article eye-opening.

Melissa writes Stirrup Queens ( http://stirrup-queens.com ) and Lost and Found ( http://lostandfoundandconnectionsabound.blogspot.c... ). Her book is Navigating the Land of If ( http://thelandofif.blogspot.com/ ).

JennaHatfield 9 pts

Interesting on all fronts, from the article itself to the varied reactions. I do know that there is a lot of red tape involved in applying for and keeping said assistance and would similarly like to see a discussion as to the difficulties that non-fraudulent applicants/recipients have with those issues.

Jenna Hatfield (@FireMom ( http://twitter.com/FireMom )), from Stop, Drop and Blog ( http://stopdropandblog.com ) and The Chronicles of Munchkin Land ( http://thechroniclesofmunchkinland.com ), is a freelance writer and newspaper photographer.