Bio
Josette Crosby Plank is an Appalachian coal cracker and generally swell person biding her time in the deep suburbs of Central Pennsylvania. Decades a...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

French Parents Are Superior -- Just Like All Other Parents

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 71
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Dear New Parents,

Hi!

How's it going?

Feeling a bit tired? Maybe a little less spry these days what with the 2AM feedings or trying to keep up with a toddler whose main occupation is trying to find new ways to turn your hair gray -- licking outlets, hurtling themselves down stairs, not eating antioxidant rich foods?

The author, back in the day,  messing-up her first kidMaybe you're feeling a bit overwhelmed. Out of your league. Like you'll never get the hang of this parenting thing and the guilt is starting to seep in with more and more "Oh, what have I done?" moments.

How can this be? You aced Calculus, run your own successful business, maybe you even know how to drive a stick.

And yet you can't quite get over the feeling that if there were a parenting pop quiz tomorrow during Gymboree class, the best you'd get might be a C+. B- if you had a venti cafe mocha and a Red Bull.

All other parents seem like they have it under control. Know what they are doing. Are even -- dare you say it -- better at this parenting thing than you are.

I'm going to save you some wondering:

They are.

Other parents are better.

They are better than you in all ways.

They are better at disciplining their kids, motivating their kids, and keeping their kids out of harm's way.

Their children will have more friends in school, lead more fulfilling lives, and never need therapy.

Their kids will rule. And it will all be because other parents were much better parents than you can ever hope to be.

Sorry.

It's a truth I learned too late to save my own kids. It took me 13 years -- on the Internet reading parenting message boards, reading parenting books and magazine articles, then reading parenting blogs, and finally downloading the "Why Other Parents Are Better Than You" app -- to understand completely all the ways I would never measure up.

It's been disheartening.

But more upsetting was the sheer length of the process of fully coming to terms with the fact that, well, I kinda suck.

I mean, compared to other parents.

Most recently, The French.

So, to spare you my time and effort in learning all the ways I could change (but probably won't) in order to be more awesome (but probably can't), here is the definitive list of all the parents who are better than I am.

In no particular order.

  • Strict Parents
  • Laid Back Parents
  • Urban Parents who give their kids access to lots of Culture and Street Smarts
  • Suburban Parents who have Backyards, Good Schools, and Soccer Coaches From Brazil
  • Country Parents whose kids Learn Responsibility by Running Large Farm Equipment and Who Know Exactly What To Call The Chicken Hole That Eggs Come From
  • Parents who vaccinate
  • Parents who don't vaccinate 
  • Parents who keep a clean house and who carry hand sanitizer in order to keep their kids healthy
  • Parents who allow their kids as much contact with germs as possible in order to build up their immune system and keep their kids healthy
  • Breastfeeding Parents
  • Bottlefeeding Parents
  • Religious Parents
  • Atheist Parents
  • Parents who don't know whether or not God can help them be better parents
  • Conservative Parents
  • Liberal Parents
  • Anarchist Parents
  • Noam Chomsky
  • Free Range Parents
  • Kiddie Leash Parents
  • Natural Parents
  • Hi-Tech Parents
  • Unplugged Parents
  • Parents who don't allow cell phones at the age you gave your kid a cell phone
  • Authoritarian Parents
  • Authoritative Parents
  • Positive Parents
  • Permissive Parents
  • Persuasive Parents
  • Mary Poppins Parents
  • Dr. Sears
  • Dr. Brazelton
  • Dr. Laura
  • James Dobson
  • "I Love Ezzo" Parents
  • "I Hate Ezzo" Parents
  • Younger Parents
  • Older Parents
  • Parents of only children
  • Parents of two children
  • Parents of many children
  • The Cosbys
  • The Brady Bunch
  • The Waltons
  • The Duggars Kramer (The Dad, not Kramer The Mother)
  • Parents who pick up crying kids
  • Parents who don't pick up crying kids
  • Parents who co-sleep
  • Parents who don't co-sleep
  • Parents who spank
  • Parents who don't spank
  • Parents who care enough about their kids to send them to public school
  • Parents who care enough about their kids to send them to private school
  • Parents who care enough about their kids to send them to homeschool
  • Parents who birthed their kids vaginally
  • Parents who birthed their kids vaginally at home with help
  • Parents who birthed their kids vaginally at home with no help
  • Parents who birthed their kids vaginally with no help in a rain forest on the summer solstice
  • Parents who didn't birth kids vaginally just because they like fancy groin scars
  • Parents who didn't birth kids vaginally because they are men
  • Parents-to-be who will never make any of the parenting mistakes you made
  • Madonna and Angelina Jolie
  • Straight Parents
  • Gay Parents
  • Married Parents
  • Single Parents
  • Sister-wife Parents
  • Parents with a high school diploma
  • Parents with a college degree 
  • Parents with a graduate degree
  • Parents with no fancy book learning
  • Parents who read parenting books
  • Tiger Moms
  • Russian Moms
  • Scandinavian Moms
  • Southern Moms
  • Your Mother-In-Law
  • Mother Teresa
  • Martha Stewart
  • Crafty Moms
  • Parents who blog about their kids
  • Parents who don't blog about their kids
  • Parents who update all their kids' baby books
  • Parents too busy parenting to update all their kids' baby books
  • Uber Moms
  • Type A Moms
  • Good Enough Moms
  • Slacker Moms
  • Parents who take time for themselves
  • Parents who get down on the floor and play with their kids
  • Parents who get down on the floor and teach their kids
  • Parents who teach their kids to put in flooring
  • Parents who stay at home
  • Parents who work at home
  • Parents who work outside the home
  • Parents who are at home outside
  • Parents who let their kids drink from the garden hose outside
  • Parents who let their kids eat Chicken McNuggets from the garden hose
  • Parents who let their free range chickens hose down the home as one of their chores
  • Parents who pay their free range chickens an allowance to hose down the home as one of their chores
  • Parents of chickens
  • Parents of Chuck Norris
  • My Mom

I may have missed a few.

I'm kinda subpar at blogging definitive parenting lists.

But surely, that's enough to convince you that you'll never measure up, either.

So, you know...carry on.

  • 71
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Iggyzam 6 pts

This was the single best thing I have ever read!! Truer words never written. Just brilliant.

AspiringChange 6 pts

Josette, this is such a fantastic blog post, thank you for making me laugh! and I just had to share it. Here is my blog post with your mention: http://www.aspiringchangelifecoach.com/blog-by-aspiring-change-life-coach/295-the-problem-with-parenting.html

Josette Plank 19 pts

AspiringChange Thanks for that mention! And yes...argh...guilt. I'm pretty sure most of us - especially most of us who mull things over enough to write about them - are our own toughest critics. We don't need a critique from everyone else. It only muddles things. Don't "tsk tsk" me. Either ask how you can help, or go have a slice of pie. I recommend the pecan. :-D

MimiLRN 6 pts

I read the article, "French Parents are Superior", in the Wall street Journal. Then, I read Pamela Druckerman's book professing the wisdom of French parenting. As an American, married to a Frenchman, having lived in France and now in Belgium, I'd like to add my 2 centimes worth to the discussion. Here's my post on the subject of French parenting: http://www.gn-st.com/2012/02/third-culture-story-why-french.html

Josette Plank 19 pts

MimiLRN Great post, Mimi! I've lived a bit here, there and everywhere, and certainly there are geographical differences, but honestly, I find plenty of differences - and different ways to think about all areas of living - even within my own neighborhood. Thanks for sharing!

Cooking Contest Reject 9 pts

Funniest and most refreshing thing I've read all week! Thank you!

Josette Plank 19 pts

Cooking Contest Reject Thank you!

Josette Plank 19 pts

Klutz Capacitor Unintentional oversight, I can assure you!

creativejuicez 20 pts

As far as reading all the parenting books & magazines...I did it for about a year and realized they had no clue who they were talking to. Those books and magazine articles are suggestions and they don't work with every child. After spending a week without sleep because my first child was colicky, I called my mom for a morale boost. She laughed and said "Let's be honest, sweetling...kids don't come with an instruction manual."

I have 2 boys...you'd think since they came from the same (damaged) gene pool they would BE the same. OMG! Not even close. The oldest is so laid back that nothing...and I mean nothing...seems to bother him. He should have been born to a "surfer" who spends their time searching for that perfect wave. When he was in high school the guidance counselor gave up asking him what he wanted to do after high school because all he'd say is...work enough to enjoy living. The youngest...is the COMPLETE opposite. He's a Type A personality with a little OCD mixed in! It's no wonder he wants to be a trauma surgeon. Neither one of them is like me nor their dad.

Dealing with 2 completely different personalities was challenging. We made mistakes with both of them. Were the mistakes so bad we'd end up on the "Jerry Springer Show"? Absolutely not. Our kids learned that their parents are human and by no means, perfect. We all learned along the way just like everyone else.

So give yourself a break...don't compare yourself to "the experts" or worse, yet, your family, friends, or neighbors. I can guarantee, they made mistakes too.

PS...Trying to catch a two year old is comparable to trying to catch a chicken.

Josette Plank 19 pts

creativejuicez Great comment - Thank you! And this --> "PS...Trying to catch a two year old is comparable to trying to catch a chicken." LOL! Truer words were never written! Now, if we could only get them to lay eggs. :-D

creativejuicez 20 pts

Josette at Halushki I know! At least I'd have some eggs after all that running around!

simplyjune 16 pts

LOVED this post!!! Most of my friends spend half the time thinking they may need major medication & therapy to get through some days as a mother but for the most part I think we do the best we can with what we have been given. And when that doesn't work as well as we may have hoped, I feel much better when I hear about my friends going through the same stuff. Read whatever books you want, but always trust your own instincts. Thanks for the great read!

Josette Plank 19 pts

simplyjune Thank you! I will still admit to the occasional supplementary ibuprofen and retail therapy (aka home decorating magazines <---whole other type of guilt/craziness).

Mamamzungu 6 pts

Love love love this post!! I kind of glossed over the list because I got your point, but then I went back and read it and it's laugh out loud funny (and strengthens your point even more).

I've been obsessing over comparative parenting (especially since I live in a place where most mothers parent differntly than I do), and Tiger Mom and Superior French Parenting have not helped. Thank you so muh for helping me to laugh at the whole thing and putting it into perspective!

Josette Plank 19 pts

Mamamzungu You're very welcome! It was extremely cathartic to write. Although, I still want to be a Parent to Chickens even though the township won't let me. I'm wondering whether I can bribe someone with fresh eggs, but I'll save that for another post. :-)

Cindy La Ferle 12 pts

Absolutely fantastic post! Back in the day when we didn't have access to as much information on how to be the perfect or good-enough parent, mothers worried a lot less. I wish I had a dollar for every parenting book and blog I read while my son was growing up. Usually, my own instincts were pretty much on target. I think I would have kicked back and enjoyed parenthood more. Just sayin.

Josette Plank 19 pts

Cindy La Ferle I think that back in the day, a lot of parenting advice was handed down via our family tribe. Or clan. Or over the washline. Which was a good thing, but I think we can all imagine the challenges there are well (e.g. the nona who lived across the street from me in South Philly and wrung her hands over the fact that my infant daughter wasn't wearing a hat or socks in the 99 degree heat). Being a little more adrift these days, I understand the search for inspiration and experience as we learn to trust our own, I appreciate the different sciences of parenting, but I love my own art just as much.

Josette Plank 19 pts

Cindy La Ferle Sort of a Jackson Pollock approach today.

Suburban Kamikaze 6 pts

It is nearly impossible to keep up with all the ways of failing your children these days!

SK

Josette Plank 19 pts

Suburban Kamikaze Someone just identified themselves to me as a Kit Kat parent. If this involves actual Kit Kat bars, I may sign on. ;-)

Lady Jennie 13 pts

I have had so many people send me that article (I live in France). I find that in many ways I am as strict as French parents, if not more so. However, they are my role models in how they teach their children about food, about mealtimes, about taking the time to digest and talk and build relationships over the meals.

And I know that's totally not your point. :)

Josette Plank 19 pts

Lady Jennie I lived in south France for a while back in the 1980s and gratefully and willingly gained 25 glorious pounds, most of those at lunch time being fed lovely couscous stews, salads, cheeses, and breads over the course of 2 hours every afternoon . Also, the bread in the morning was lovely as well. As well as the crepes on the city street carts.I know this goes against everything stated in certain recent dieting books, but so what. Only my name is French. :-) Of note, I was the only one in the family to pack on that amount of "winter weight", so perhaps the skinny-lady French book is the one I need to re-read. A French chef just sent me a fantastic recipe for red beet salad. Due to my local organic farm share, I've recently discovered red beets after a very traumatic boiled red beet incident enacted by a very strict PA Coal Region parent during my youth. Of course, if any other chefs from any other cultures want to send me recipes for red beets, I am a member of the global (eating) village.

sharongreenthal 28 pts

So hilarious. I learned fairly quickly how pointless it was to compare myself to other parents, but until I did it was not pretty. And the truth is, you can parent your kids in a gazillion different ways, but one thing many young mothers (and fathers) forget is that those little people are born with a personality all their own...and we need to learn what works best for them, not for the rest of the world!

By the way, my kids ate happy meals and they turned out ok.

Josette Plank 19 pts

sharongreenthal 'Zactly! I have three kids and although we have certain non-negotiables as a family, and I have an over-riding philosophy of what kind of parent I want to be, I've also learned to be flexible - sometimes a kid need more direction, other times I back off and let consequences fall as they may. Sometimes I use cunning. Oftentimes, I'm stealthy. Like a ninja. After 13 years of this, my parenting now flows forth in mysterious ways. I don't think it could be contained in a mere book. Perhaps, I think, a song on the shamisen.Also, I ate a McFlurry today.

sharongreenthal 28 pts

Josette at Halushki McFlurry...mcyummy! You go mom!

KatieCanavan 10 pts

"Parents who let their free range chickens hose down the home as one of their chores." HI-larious. I just laughed while sitting alone in a public cafe!

Josette Plank 19 pts

KatieCanavan I actually wish I had some free range chicken to hose down my house. I think it's against our township's zoning, though. :-)

XLMIC 6 pts

HA! I read that article about French parenting and the comments...and left one of my own. It was written by a Francophile...and ex-pat living in Paris. Obviously, she's going to praise the French. I've spent enough time in France and my kids go to a French immersion school here in the US so I've been exposed to enough French parents to know that French parents suck just as badly as American parents...just in some different ways. Boy did I want to go on and on and on in a comment there...and now here...but I'll refrain. We're all just doing the best we can. And all we need is LOVE :) Thanks for writing this post...I love it :)

Josette Plank 19 pts

XLMIC I lived in Grenoble for a while in college. I don't remember much of it. Skiing. Wine. Some guy named Jay who I hiked through a sheep meadow with and got chased down by a dog. So I can't really speak to French parenting. Most of the French kids I hung out with were into old leather jackets and listening to The Cult, so if that's the end goal, I think both French and American parents have a pretty equal shot of getting there.I will say one thing about the French: they didn't pronounce my name incorrectly. My Polish-Lithuanian mother had a real sense of humor giving me some fancy -pants French name.

Conversation from Twitter

halushki
halushki

lisabelkin :-D Thanks!

DawnRoode
DawnRoode

EVERY other parent is superior—I know you've felt it too! RT: lisabelkin halushki. | BlogHer http://t.co/z3Ag1lfS

karenlebillon
karenlebillon

blogher Love the halushki article! But French do have kids food figured out-see http://t.co/W9rc3zLR: amazing French kids school lunches

karenlebillon
karenlebillon

ritzking French parent's aren't perfect, but have great approach to #kidsfood. See amazing French school menus! http://t.co/vKBAcPvG

RitzKing
RitzKing

karenlebillon Certainly US gov't could learn a thing or two w/school lunches. Just not sure most US parents need the lesson. We're on it.

karenlebillon
karenlebillon

ritzking Totally agree! Parents are dedicated to healthy #kidsfood but govt legislation not helping. Will blog this week about that!

halushki
halushki

ritzking I've seen a change myself in my kids' school with packed lunch/snacks even within the past few years. But cafeteria food...uhhhmm.

halushki
halushki

karenlebillon Seriously, I'm trying the red beet popsicles. And the red beet salad. One kid said it sounds good, so it's all go!

mlparentcoach
mlparentcoach

halushki included this post on my FB page!! www.positivelyparenting.com. Thanks!! :))

thehelpcompany
thehelpcompany

halushki I agree. I think that first article was more about a type of parenting than a specific culture.

halushki
halushki

WithoutBollocks blogher Glad you enjoyed it! Extra points for using the word "malarkey"! :-D

WithoutBollocks
WithoutBollocks

halushki blogher I'm Australian, what can I say? xxxx

halushki
halushki

WithoutBollocks blogher Ahhhh! I thought I detected an accent on your Tweet!

Conversation from Facebook

Josette Crosby Plank
Josette Crosby Plank

All this talk about wine makes me want some! ;-)

Polish Mama on the Prairie
Polish Mama on the Prairie

Yeah, I've heard French kids whine before as well. Trust me.

Josette Crosby Plank
Josette Crosby Plank

Ahhh, Cheryl, I completely sympathize...I know, whining kids are tough to take. Believe me, I know.

I've worked a lot with children of all ages as a job and as a volunteer. I even lived in Grenoble for a while with a family that ran a day care. I can tell you that even the strictest, no-nonsense parents have days when all their best parenting can't quiet a tired/hungry/overwhelmed 2yo.
Look at the bright side - at least you weren't on a 10 hour flight. :-)

Cheryl Tomaselli Baden
Cheryl Tomaselli Baden

I read the article about French parents, then I went out to the mail box and tried to have a chat with my neighbor and her 2 year old, maybe the French are on to something, the whinning was intolerable.

Josette Crosby Plank
Josette Crosby Plank

:-D Thank you!