Bio
I'm a zen master in a neurotic sheep's clothing.
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Recent Comments

Gay on the Playground

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 25
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

My mother didn’t want me to have children. She had given up trying to change my lady-loving ways but was adamant that I not bring a child into my “lifestyle”. She argued that if we had a boy, he would never learn to pee standing up and if we had a girl, we wouldn’t know how to do her hair. Given arguments with such substantial merit, it’s amazing that I had the courage to persevere. I reminded my mother constantly about our intention to have kids – every time we saw a baby or a commercial for diapers and even when I ran across a conversation heart that said “baby”. It became a game – “Ways to Remind Mom We Intend to Have Kids” which was a lot like Family Feud but with more feuding and less cheering. Each time, she simply pursed her lips, closed her eyes and shook her head. When I finally got pregnant and told her the news, she was absolutely silent – no sighing, no audible pursing of the lips. Then she asked what I expected her to say and I suggested that most people go with “Congratulations”. For the record, she did not go with “congratulations”.  My mother believed what many people believe – living as an out lesbian is my choice but an unfair burden on children. 

When I pick up my kids from school, I like to hear that they had a great day. I want to hear that they worked hard, played well with others and, time permitting, saved a kitten from a burning building. I do not want to hear, “Mom, you’re going to get a call from my teacher tonight.” This happened recently when Miguel told me that he had been in a heated argument on the playground. He had barely finished speaking when I launched into one of my stock lectures on getting along with others and respect and I used my stern voice and glared into the rearview mirror for emphasis and then he exclaimed that it wasn’t his fault so I launched into the respect-adjacent lecture on accountability and glared a little more and then, as we arrived home, I turned around to give my most serious parental look of outrage which just happens to include the lip pursing made famous by my mother and he snapped, “MOM! He used the word ‘gay’ as an insult!” I just closed my eyes and dropped my head because I did not have a stock lecture for that.

Queer. Faggot. Pervert. Dyke. I’ve heard them all. They have been shouted at me from passing cars, yelled at me in parking lots and on sidewalks. They have been whispered behind my back at restaurants, in city markets, in public bathrooms and at weddings. And yet, I consider myself lucky – lucky that I’ve never been physically hurt and especially lucky that my children have never witnessed any of this. But, that doesn’t mean they don’t know. They know about ignorance and hate. They have noticed the stares. They’ve been asked about their family, sometimes out of curiosity and sometimes in confusion. They know that we cannot get married, that we are not equal under the law. Kids are smart in this particular way – they measure their experience against the world around them and quickly determine their differences. 

We went into the house and he paced and growled in anger while I sat silently on the couch drawing a mental flow chart of possible responses. When I finally opened my mouth to speak, he said through clenched teeth, “I WILL defend my family! I did it for me but I also did it for you!” I reached out and took his hand. I pulled him towards me and onto my lap with some effort. His jaw was set. His body was taut with anger. I looked at him – his messy hair, his freckles just like mine – and felt that familiar ache, an ache born from my desire to protect him from the world and my inability to lie. I wanted to tell him that this would never happen again, that it didn’t matter. But it will and it does so I told him the truth. 

I told him that people hate what they don’t understand and there will always be people who say hateful things. I told him that I won’t hide, that I won’t pretend to be someone I am not and then – I started to cry. Tears are so very inconvenient when trying to project confidence. As parents, we

  • 25
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
kgirl 5 pts

Fist bump, mama. Awesome post.

Karen knows The Kids Are Alright ( http://kidsarealrightto.blogspot.com/ )

because of, or perhaps, despite, her.

LizaWasHere 5 pts

Thanks, Vikki & Denise, for your thoughts. I am trying to stuff my head back down in the sand for a little while, but you both reminded me of something I think is important when I'm not freaking out. :)

Like Vikki said, I take my role as an ambassador of the queer community very seriously.

And like Denise, I waver on where the balance between safe space and that ambassadorial role falls. But given that the language immersion school is unlikely to be an *unsafe* space, even if it may be less of a *highly safe bubble* space, I should calm down.

Last thought, and this is for Polly too, just as those little neural pathways are still forming, making it an optimal time for our wee ones to learn another language, it is also an optimal time for developing neural pathways that learn "having two moms is no big deal."

Liza Barry-Kessler
Personal: LizaWasHere ( http://www.lizawashere.com/ )
Professional: Privacy Counsel LLC ( http://www.privacycounsel.net/ )

Lesbian Dad 5 pts

Also chilling. My kids are about Liza's kids' ages, and I have the same feeling of dread. You and Denise are further along.

It's definitely, absolutely, for sure, my worst fear. OK, second to worst. Worst is violence.

You sound like you did the only thing a loving parent could do under the circumstances, which was: try to keep it together, and absolutely be honest. That your being honest also broke you up sounds (a) humungously painful, and (b) a part of a very difficult but important lesson for Miguel (and later, Zecca). I've only had to teach it verbally, and fairly abstractly, to our oldest. I can see her very sharp mind trying to grasp it all. But it's nothing like it's going to be when she comes home after the first incident like Miguel's.

Sorry it took me so long to see this post, BTW! And thank you for sharing it here!

Vikki 5 pts

I think you have to choose the school based on which one will provide the best education for your children. If it ends up being the one outside of the progressive bubble, then so be it. I feel a real sense of responsibility to be a queer ambassador and I have no doubt that you would be an excellent ambassador. This is how change happens. Keep me posted!

Denise 9 pts moderator

That's the frustrating thing. You are parents and you should be able to make the decision about your children's education without taking your orientation into consideration.

But. We don't live in that world, so I hear you.

And I'm torn.

I've always said that our kids need to learn that there's a big world out there with a lot of people who don't understand glbt folks. I've always said that I thought it was important that the kids understand that in the great big world, odds are high that theirs will be the only family with two moms.

Kids need to learn to deal with being unusual because... they are. Their family is.

But, I've kind of changed my mind.

I lean more toward "will your child be safe?" - that doesn't mean he'll never hear any hate speech or deal with any problems. In every school there will be problems. But will it surround her every single day and will she have any strong allies to help her deal with that if she's in that situation?

In your particular case, it seems a more difficult choice since I doubt either situation will put your kids in a really horrible situation. At the language school, you may be the only gay family but I'm betting it's probably a pretty progressive school with progressive families.

If that's the case, I'd go with the best educational environment. If I'm wrong, and you're really concerned about bullying, hate speech, physical abuse that your kids may have to deal with - then don't move. There's time later for them to face that hatred.

~Denise
BlogHer Community Manager
Life. Flow. Fluctuate.

LizaWasHere 5 pts

Ok, Vikki (and Denise), I keep thinking about this post, the comments, and my family.

One of the choices we are struggling with is whether or not to leave Noah & Josie in the progressive, little, public charter, Montessori school where they are now, or switch them over to a more convenient, highly regarded, public language immersion school. Noah's BFFs (my BFFs kids) go to the language school, my parents helped found it, continue to be active with the associated foundation, and my sister & cousin were in the first graduating class.

But we would probably be the only 2 mom family at the language school. There's another one at our current school, and the heterosexual parents at our current school are mostly progressive, hipster types who are comfortable with our family. (We joke that it's only our being lesbian that gives us enough hipster cred to stay at the school.)

So we go in endless circles about what to do. And we have at most another 11 months before the language school option is closed to us.

Liza Barry-Kessler
Personal: LizaWasHere ( http://www.lizawashere.com/ )
Professional: Privacy Counsel LLC ( http://www.privacycounsel.net/ )

Vikki 5 pts

It's good to know that the secret lair has a sinister room should it be necessary in the future.

everydayjill 5 pts

Except that you wrote a beautiful post with this.
Brave and beautiful boy. Brave and full of grace Mama.

Faiqa 5 pts

Parents, regardless of orientation race, etc. have a responsibility to raise children who recognize and respect the humanity in every person. It's not your choice to live a life that is true and real that created this awkward situation. It's the lapse in another parent's assumption of this responsibility to teach specific principles of respect.

I'm sorry that your mother treated the news of your wanting (and having) children that way. While it is not the same thing, I want to tell you that when my husband and I decided to get married, my father was basically enraged. We were too different... what about when we had children... where would they fit in... what community would accept them.

Vikki, my husband and I are a hetero couple, both speak the same languages besides English, are both Sunni Muslims and are both from the Northern part of the Indo-Pak region. We even kind of look alike. You know what my dad's objection was? That *we* are of Pakistani heritage and they are of *Indian* heritage. For goodness sakes... they were the same country sixty years ago.

I sometimes wonder if people like my dad and your mom rely on making up all these rules about who is supposed to be with who and what is okay for "the children" so they can feel safe, special, better, more sure of how the world works, more in control.. whatever.

They just don't seem to realize that there is no greater advantage in a child's life than parents who love one another and are absolutely authentic in the way they choose to live. They also don't realize that it's not our choice to love that may make their grandchildren's lives difficult, but that it's THEIR choice to be bigoted that is the problem.

You hang in there, my friend... I am with you... and when my children are on the playground? They *will* be with your children, supporting them and defending them and treating them with the respect and love that they most certainly deserve.

*As a side note, if that doesn't work... we can always just tie those kids up and send them to the sinister room of my secret lair which has been designated specifically for the re-education of those that would DARE annoy my most esteemed High Minister of the Liquor Cabinet.
;-)

Also, yipes... long comment, sorry. Great post.

Living A Cultured Life At: www.Native-Born.com ( http://www.Native-Born.com )

Judy Schwartz Haley 6 pts

Beautiful story. Beautiful Child. Beautiful Mama.

Judy Schwartz Haley is battling breast cancer while raising her toddler daughter. She is a full time college student, as is her husband. She blogs about it all at Coffee Jitters

Vikki 5 pts

Thanks to all of you for the kinds comments and for sharing your own stories.

LizaWasHere 5 pts

That was not to say this wasn't a great post. It was. Really, that's my problem. That and my own fear.

Liza Barry-Kessler
Personal: LizaWasHere ( http://www.lizawashere.com/ )
Professional: Privacy Counsel LLC ( http://www.privacycounsel.net/ )

LizaWasHere 5 pts

Jeez, Vikki. Can't I keep my head in the sand awhile longer? I don't WANNA deal with this stuff. I don't WANNA imagine Noah in this scenario. I don't wanna.

Liza Barry-Kessler
Personal: LizaWasHere ( http://www.lizawashere.com/ )
Professional: Privacy Counsel LLC ( http://www.privacycounsel.net/ )

tkrbl 5 pts

We've experienced similar issues for different reasons. When I was younger and dated my first black man my mother was hysterical. She hadn't raised me to be prejudiced and kept saying she didn't have a problem with "them" it was the idea that we'd have a kid that would be biracial. Well, I ended up marrying a black man and we had a beautiful baby girl. AND my mother, like yours, absolutely adores her granddaughter.

We live in a predominantly white area. We've had our share of "looks" and people talking behind our backs. But our daughter had ZERO issues until middle school. Her freshman year it was a daily occurrence. She learned that it really was ignorance. When she started "teaching" people instead of defending she found that it mostly went away. (She actually had to tell people why the "N" word wasn't OK even in a song.)

She's a junior now and believes herself to be a member of the first generation of a large biracial community, the end result of the Civil Rights Movement. Now she writes articles for her school newspaper about Black History Month and is a school leader. We have a ways to go still but the "Dream" is slowly being realized for her.

Your kids are part of their own community, those that have been raised by gay parents. They are leading the way. Any time you lead the way, you have to expect bumps in the road. You should all be proud of your hard work because of you others that follow will find the path much smoother. You are all part of today's Civil Rights Movement.

Side note: One of my daughter's friends came out to her during her freshman year. My daughter shrugged her shoulders and said "Yeah, so?" not knowing it was THE first time she'd ever told anyone. They laugh all the time now about how little my daughter reacted. But that girl chose my daughter to tell because she saw how strong she was and thought that if she told her first she might have a strong supporter. She did.

I wish you and your family nothing but the best. Your kids can gain strength from this and will become better people because you are teaching them tolerance and respect. Encourage them to teach others.

Christina

single_M0M 5 pts

I just wanted to leave a comment in support of you and your family. In my opinion, anyone who WANTS to have kids should be supported in every way.

Your son is learning so much but also teaching many.

Sondra Santos Drahos

Happy Healthy Hip Parenting

Honoring Families | Supporting Parents | Enriching Relationships

Vikki 5 pts

Yes, there is always something that sets us all apart. My mother died in 2008 but we were at peace. She'd come a long way, baby :)

Vikki 5 pts

Whenever I think of that movie, I think of that marathon speech Julianne Moore gives at the end. Love that.

Vikki 5 pts

Wow - that sounds horrible. Standing up for yourself and others is so important and so hard to do in such extreme circumstances.

Denise 9 pts moderator

My older son got into his first real fight, in 9th grade. He's a very non-violent kid so when I got the call from the school, I was in complete shock.

I drove up, listened as the Dean told me that my son had thrown another boy into the wall and threatened him. And that both boys were getting suspended. I couldn't believe it!

The Dean sent my son out and then told me more about what happened... the kid my son fought with is always in trouble but this particular instance, the guy said something like, "I'm going to get my gun and shoot the next faggot I see."

This was after ranting during the whole break period about gays.

The Dean, of this very southern, small town high school empathized with my son and recognized that the real problem wasn't Chris - it was the other kid. But, school violence is school violence and he was being suspended. (Which I agreed with.)

After talking to my son later, it was clear that this kid used a lot of hate speech, aimed at any sort of minority (except his own) and Chris said he just couldn't take it any more. Not with the mention of "gun".

So yea, while I do not ever condone violence and I'm perfectly able to handle any hate speech that comes my way - it's harder when it's your kid dealing with it.

~Denise
BlogHer Community Manager
Life. Flow. Fluctuate.

Southerngirl 5 pts

This was a beautiful post. I loved your way of dealing with this as I would have probaly been yelling and calling the school.

Michelle

I blog at http://www.mommycan.blogspot.com/

stampinbuzz 5 pts

This post is beautiful in so many ways. Beautifully written, with so many wonderful messages woven within.

Loved it.

A 50 something Nana who loves politics, history, traveling with my darlingman, home improvement and crafting projects of all kinds. Blogging about paper crafts at The StampinBuzz ( http://stampinbuzz.com )

Chupachups 5 pts

You are definitely doing it right. You are rocking this mom gig and I am glad your mom came around to see it!

Side note: I love your writing; it is thoughtful and poetic. I look forward to more posts :)

suebob 7 pts

Every child is burdened by their parents with something, aren't they? If the worst thing your child is burdened by isn't your abuse or addiction or neglect, but seeing the cruelty of others toward your loving relationship - well, that's not that bad.

I'm sorry it happened. I wish it didn't. But your kid can handle it because he has 2 good, loving moms who are working hard to be great parents. There are other kids who have far less to rely upon and far greater obstacles to happiness and success. I wish your mom could realize that.

Deb Rox 5 pts

As the lovely Annette Bening once said (or was it Julianne Moore?), I'm thinking the kids are all right.

Deb Rox

3 Smart Girlz ( http://www.3smartgirlz.com/ ) consulting

Blog ( http://www.debontherocks.com/ ) like a freaking butterfly, sting like a Tweet. ( http://www.twitter.com/debontherocks )