Bio
I'm a professional cook, stay-at-home mom, writer, and wife. I love food, life, and my family.
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Recent Comments

Good Cooks Don't Need Recipes

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 31
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

I think all us have that one friend who’s cooking is so good, they know it, you know it, and they just make it look so easy, but when you ask them  for the recipe they reply, almost smirkingly, “Oh I don’t use recipes, good cooks don’t need recipes.” Now you feel awful, you live off recipes, you spend hours looking at recipes, planning your meals and orchestrating your next project. Well, I disagree. While good cooks may not be held hostage by recipes, they certainly do need them.

A good cook doesn’t let a recipe hold them back, and they’re not afraid to improvise, but how do you think cooks learn from each other? It is impossible to be an expert in every kind of cuisine. It is impossible, even after years of experience to have infinite knowledge of all things food. It is a craft that continuously changes, yet stays true to the basic techniques taught by the French masters of the late 19th and early 20th century.

Chefs rely on recipes to establish consistency in their restaurants. Otherwise, the flavor and appearance of the dishes would vary according to the cook. Recipes are essential to transmitting the chef’s vision from raw ingredients to the finished dish served to the guest. The only way the ego-driven line cooks will ever cook something the same way twice is with a recipe. Recipes are also essential to determining food cost of each particular menu item.

All the chefs I know have a massive cookbook collections. Why? They learn new techniques, look to them for inspiration, and of course admiration. What about the home cook? The problem with home cooks is that they sometimes can’t tell a good recipe from a bad one. Most home cooks look online to find their recipes, it’s easy and convenient, and some sites even make a shopping list for you and print the recipes to various sizes. There are a lot of good recipe sites and blogs out there, but there are also a lot of bad ones.

 

I have an OK cookbook collection. Now, I rely mostly on the public library to check out the books I can’t afford to buy. The one I use the most is The Flavor Bible, which ironically is not a cookbook in the traditional sense. It has no recipes; it is merely a list of ingredients. Below each ingredient is a list of the foods that best complement it, when the ingredient is in season, the cooking techniques that best work for that particular ingredient, and examples of flavor combinations used by renowned chefs. The book gives you the resources necessary to use your knowledge of cooking to develop your own style and creativity, without using somebody else’s recipe.

If you’re looking for recipes online try: Epicurious for recipes from Gourmet and Bon Appetit, Simply Recipes for detailed recipes with pictures for almost every step, Steamy Kitchen for creative recipes with an Asian touch and great photos, for Mexican recipes visit Pati’s Mexican Table, and finally for dessert try David Lebovitz.

If you are going to use somebody else’s recipe, please give them credit for it, nobody will think less of you because of it.

  • 31
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Maynekitty 5 pts

Good cooks do use recipes. Whether from a cookbook or received by word of mouth it's still a recipe. A recipe is a map that provides basic information to reach a destination and there are many ways to reach that destination. I think of them as guidelines to use when trying something new or 'exotic' and then filed away perhaps to be passed along to the newly arrived young person down the road just beginning to set up a household.

Anne @ Domesblissity 5 pts

I consider myself a good cook and I'm always referring to recipes, especially baking. Not so much with a spaghetti bolognese or other evening meal. If I'm trying to cook a cuisine from another country, eg Indian or Thai food well yes, I'll definitely use a recipe. Bechamel sauce is something I can make with my eyes closed but I always look up the pancake recipe.

Anne @ Domesblissity

midnightbliss 7 pts

i love cooking but i didn't collect or keep any recipe. if i want to make something that i don't know, i just ask google, read several different recipes and formulate my own combining what i have read. it works for me because i really not good with measurements, and i just rely on my taste. that's the same reason why i don't bake. lols

culinarycara 5 pts

I think the key word here is "need." I consider myself a great cook, and usually go from memory. I wasn't always that way. Once upon I time I followed recipes to the tee every time, until I was able to understand what ingredients did what, and how much to use. It's all part of the learning process, but still valuable no matter how good you are.

Don't get me wrong, I still use recipes to this day. Mostly to make sure I still "got it," and to tackle uncharted territories. I always believe in learning everything I can about food, because it's something that impacts our lives everyday.

As for some great books, I have a couple of recommendations from my personal collection (which is about 40+ and growing) :

The Joy of Cooking - I bought it from a used book store for about 12 bucks, but you can also find it on amazon.com for about 25. Many of the professional chef friends have this book and encouraged me to get a copy. It's a great collection of timeless recipes, tips, and great information about many ingredients we all cook with.

Jacques Pepin's Complete Techniques - some culinary schools use this as a textbook of sorts, because it's an exceptional comprehensive collection of tips and techniques necessary for fundamental cooking, and even expert level skill. I got this one on amazon.com for about 30 dollars on paperback (hardcover is much more expensive).

I can understand why professional kitchens aim for consistency, but there's something to be said about the imperfectness of home cooking. It's real and it's delicious.

Polish Mama on the Prairie 16 pts

Completely agree :) My mother once told me something after a friend said that same smug comment "Oh I don't use recipes, good cooks don't use recipes." My mother turned to me later and whispered "Don't let people trick you. She has a recipe that either she does not want to share or it is from a cookbook and she can't remember the recipe she followed. Even world famous chefs have recipes."

I personally have a collection of 23 cookbooks (over half of which are in Polish and one in French) and also have 3 notebooks I personally filled with either recipes I changed to make my own or got from a friend or family member or cooking show. I also have a recipe box passed down from my husband's grandmother to me. Many of my cookbooks (and of course the notebooks) have margins filled with handwritten notes by me, changing this, adding that, or just writing "Big fail with the family. Don't make again."

That doesn't even count the numerous books I also borrow from the library.

This was a great article. I'm interested in now checking out the Flavor Bible. That sounds like a great book, perhaps even worth purchasing down the road. :)

Dora'sTable 7 pts

Polish Mama on the Prairie Check it out, The Flavor Bible will really help you develop your own style of cooking. Thanks for reading

Kathy K 13 pts

I rely a lot of America's Test Kitchen/Cooks' illustrated cookbooks. I have learned a lot from them.

isthisthemiddle 288 pts

Kathy K I agree-- I love the America's Test Kitchen cookbooks. I just made a slow cooker beef stew with dark beer from them and it was divine. Some slow cooker recipes are not great, but ATK's are wonderful.

HomeRearedChef 295 pts

isthisthemiddle I agree! Kathy K ATK's has taught me a lot, too, over the past years.

lainierenee 14 pts

Exactly. I kind of follow a recipe but, the innate cook in me is always looking to substitute ingredients. This is probably the reason why I am not a great baker because you have less leeway to do so. Thanks for posting this!

Dora'sTable 7 pts

lainierenee Have you read Michael Rhulman's book: Ratio. It's a great book if you want to learn how to improvise without it affecting your finished product. Thanks for reading!

lainierenee 14 pts

Yay! I love his writing style. I am definitely going to check it out. Thanks for the tip! Dora'sTable

isthisthemiddle 288 pts

lainierenee I substitute often, too. You're right-- it works better in some categories than in others, but we learn!

HomeRearedChef 295 pts

Loved your blog! I don't even know where to begin, you've said so much and I agree with everything you've said here. Wow!

My husband and I love to cook and experiment often with recipes. And in the 29 1/2 years we've been married we have collected over 200 cookbooks ~ Bon Appetit, Southern Living, Julia Child, Paul Prudhomme, and much more ~ not including magazines that I just can't part with either. And you are so correct, because there is so much that we have learned from reading and studying cookbooks. I have actually posted recipes giving credit to the Chef that may have inspired my altered recipe.

I never went to a culinary school, though I wish with all my heart I had. But I've been busy raising my family, and I practiced my heart's desire at home. (Smile!) I have enjoyed your blog very much. Thank you!

~Virginia

isthisthemiddle 288 pts

HomeRearedChef Hey-- school is nice, but certainly not all that important in my mind. What matters is how does it taste? I bet you could cook circles around some culinary school grads. :-)

I like the Southern Living cookbooks, too.

HomeRearedChef 295 pts

Thank you, Melanie, and dinner is on me, here at home, one of these days. Smile! isthisthemiddle

Conversation from Facebook

Florida Girl in Oklahoma
Florida Girl in Oklahoma

none! I just wing it. Although I do have a lot of cookbooks. I'm just a collector. I do have a recipe box that I consult with family recipes.

Kittie Johnson
Kittie Johnson

Any cookbook by Southern Living along with church/community/jr league type cookbooks have always done me well to get ideas sparking...now I tend use www.food.com all the time cause I love to read the reviews from other people as to how they've tweaked the recipe. Mostly I use all of the above to just give me ideas cause I'm physically incapable of leaving a recipe alone LOL!!!

Jackie Labik Schroeder
Jackie Labik Schroeder

Hands down, The America's Test Kitchen cookbook! It has everything one can imagine plus recommendations for brands of items too!

Krista Lord
Krista Lord

My Better Homes and Gardens cookbook, and my Vegetarian cookbook. I also find tons online.

JL goes Vegan, and other musings
JL goes Vegan, and other musings

Great Vegetarian Cooking Under Pressure by Lorna Sass is my go-to book.

Cheri Loughlin
Cheri Loughlin

Variety of appetizer & tapas cookbooks. Excellent for mini meals, snacks, parties & terrific sampler dinners for the family.

Merik Hollis King
Merik Hollis King

all - I am constantly flipping through my cookbooks mulling over recipes to try.

Vanessa Linn
Vanessa Linn

Martha is the go to woman.

Jennie McCluskey
Jennie McCluskey

www.allrecipes.com

Kimberley Allan Mulla
Kimberley Allan Mulla

I don't use many but Martha's Baking Handbook, an old children's cookbook my mom gave me when I was little, and Julia Child

Cindy Reed
Cindy Reed

How to Cook Everything by Mark Bittman. I almost use nothing else.

Michelle Byerly Lefebvre
Michelle Byerly Lefebvre

Church/community cookbooks, Super Suppers, online and "make-it-up-as-I-go". :)

Dawn Mitchell Chace
Dawn Mitchell Chace

Saving Dinner the Lowcarb Way by Leanne Leanne Rouch Ely

Florinda Lantos Pendley Vasquez
Florinda Lantos Pendley Vasquez

This relates a little to one of the BlogHer Book Club discussions for HOW TO BE AN AMERICAN HOUSEWIFE. And I tend to agree with the premise, to be honest.