The father of a friend of mine died recently. Here’s how it happened: She was driving home from a board meeting thinking about the finishing touches that she needed to put on a grant. Her cell phone rang. It was her brother telling her that her father wasn’t feeling well. He’d been a bit under the weather. She rushed to his home. He was talkative and joking. A couple of hours later, he had a heart-attack and died surrounded by his children and other family members.
“He died the way he wanted to,” she said. “He was very vocal about not wanting to suffer or be a burden to the family. He was adamant about not having a long, slow death caught in the grip of Alzheimer’s disease like his wife had been.” While my friend M misses her father dearly, she, too, is glad that he had “a good death.”
I think about death every day but not morbidly. I think about it mostly because I read obituaries in the paper. Reading obits introduces me to people I’d never have known about otherwise. There are so many wonderful people in the world! Some of them have great accomplishments and have won accolades. Others of them were ordinary people whose small accomplishments supported their families and their communities.
Obituaries often recount how people lived their lives. One woman who’d loved to garden was restricted in her nineties to a wheelchair and so she had her garden beds raised so that she could tend to them from the wheelchair. Another woman taught into her eighties and continued to tutor after that. A gentle-man worked at his law office every day until he died. A 19-year-old felled by ovarian cancer spent her last months cramming all sorts of loving activities in and awakened in her family a zest for living. While the deaths of children and young people sadden me deeply because they are or feel before their time, they are no less instructive about how to live.
Marilyn Johnson, a former obituary writer, celebrates the cult and culture of obituaries in her riveting book, The Dead Beat: Lost Souls, Lucky Stiffs, and the Perverse Pleasures of Obituaries.
There are dozens of examples of inspired obituaries in the book as well as stories from the annual conference of obituary writers. An example from the book shows that obituaries can be humorous:
"Selma Koch, a Manhattan store owner who earned a national reputation by helping women find the right bra size, mostly through a discerning glance and never with a tape measure, died Thursday at Mount Sinai Medical Center. She was 95 and a 34B."
Another book about obituaries has gotten great reviews, although I haven’t read it and therefore can’t personally vouch for it: OBIT. Inspiring Stories of Ordinary People who Led Extraordinary Lives by Jim Sheeler
A good death. If I must die (I say this seriously because up until about 10 years ago, I’d convinced myself that I wasn’t going to die) I hope to have a good death. Would that it be peaceful. Would that it also be scandal-free. Recently, certain high profile deaths also got me to thinking about the notion of having “a good death.” A refrain from a hymn often sung in the church I grew up goes like this:
I wouldn’t be a sinner.
Tell you the reason why
When my master called me
I wouldn’t be ready to die.
For some people, the ways they die overshadows who they were and what they may have accomplished. The deaths of singer, Michael Jackson, actor David Carradine, and reality show star Anna Nicole Smith, struck me in this way. Mr. Carradine’s death was not a good death at all caught as he was in a private sexual act that to my mind is unseemly for any age but most especially for a man in his seventies.
His and other “not good deaths” get me to thinking about things I’ve done that I wouldn’t want to be my parting act or part of my lasting legacy. (I dare not share them here.)
2009 is the 40th anniversary of the publication On Death and Dying written by Dr. Elisabeth Kübler-Ross, psychiatrist, who passed in 2004. This groundbreaking classic and best-seller outlined the "five psychological stages of dying" (denial, anger, bargaining, depression and finally acceptance. Throughout the 1970's, Dr. Kübler-Ross led hundreds of workshops and spoke to standing-room-only crowds throughout the world. Always outspoken, her work challenged the medical profession to change its view of dying patients and advanced many important concepts such as living wills, home health care, and helping patients to die with dignity and respect.
In preparing my living will and health care proxy, I had a conversation with my sister and found out that she wants all life-extension methods employed while I want no extraordinary measure taken if there is no chance for me to have quality of life. “I plan to wear out, not rust out” my sister always says as she lives with the demands of lupus.
BlogHer contributing editor, Megan, on "Sometimes Out of Death Comes Life: Happy Birthday Megan's Minute" writes about a friend's death that inspired her to start blogging as a way of sharing her writing.
Another post on BlogHer, End-of-Life Care: Working within the Laws Nature by Caregiving begins with these profound words:
"This is hard to hear, but important to know: When caring for an aging relative, you are helping a family member die well. The process of helping someone to die well begins early on in your caregiving journey. It begins when you first hear a diagnosis. Or, when you first notice that your mother just isn’t able to keep up the house as well as she used to. Or, when you celebrate your grandmother’s 95th birthday and wonder: Where did the time go?."
Angelina on her blog, Dustpan Alley, asks How do you Mourn Death?
She writes:
"It also reminds us that no one lives forever. We will all have our time in the sun and then we will move on. This is a non-denominational truth. It 100% doesn't matter what your spiritual beliefs are: we all die and whatever happens in that instant isn't about god or atheism or beliefs. Death does not require you to believe anything. It just is. It is."
And continues:
"The message of life and the message of death are almost indistinguishable. Like identical twins who learn to speak and dress differently but who, when stripped down to bones, were still split from a single cell. Life and death were split from a single cell too."
I apologize for the rambling nature of this piece but I am now ready to go back to my original point - a good death - I hope I have one and I hope that I will be ready when my time comes.
Comments
I Like Obits Too
I thought I was the only one who enjoy reading the newspaper obits. You read about the fascinating lives of the departed. It makes you look at what you're doing in the day to day. Obits and Entertainment are 2 of my favorite sections.
Welcome to the Obit Readers Club
You really must get the first book I reference in the article - you'll love it. I agree with you that reading the obits help you "look at what you're doing in the day-to-day." Thanks for commenting.
http://blog.candelarisilva.com
Good and plenty!
We all do it
I, too, think about death. My 33 year old aunt died of cancer when I was 13 years old, and I suddenly realized that life isn't guaranteed. I love the point you made that some people's scandalous deaths overshadow their lives. May I also add that I know some people who aren't even mourned after they pass? It is my hope that when I go, I am missed. :) However, my greatest hope is that my legacy will be the gratitude and kindness that lives on in my children.
Legacies...
"May the work I've done speak for me" is a line from one of my favorite hymns from childhood. A legacy of "gratitude and kindness that lives on in my children" is certainly one of the most important legacies one can leave. I would bet you're well on your way to achieving that.
Thanks for commenting.
http://blog.candelarisilva.com
Good and plenty!
I've witnessed a good death
My husband's Grandfather passed earlier this year. He had been in failing health for several months and was at home being cared for by Hospice.
We had gotten a call the day he died, to say that he was declining quickly and that the family was gathering at the home to be with him and my husband's Grandmother.
When his final moment came, the family was 2 and 3 deep around his bed. If there wasn't a hand on him, it was around the person in front of them. I'd never seen beauty in death before, but on that day I did. It's odd to think of a death as "beautiful", but I know it can be.
http://raisedqueer.squarespace.com
Death as Beautiful
Thanks so much for sharing this beautiful death with BlogHer readers! What a wonderful way to pass and how much better it must have felt to witnss his passing. http://blog.candelarisilva.com
Good and plenty!
There's a book I want to read
Called "Chin Up Girls: a book of women's obituaries from the Daily Telegraph." People live such interesting lives.
Where I grew up they still announced "the deaths" on the radio...actually I think they still do. It wasn't a rather condensed obit, along with visiting hours, etc. A common phrase from my childhood was "Shh. I need to hear the deaths." Wow, I hadn't thought of that in ages.
Sassymonkey and Sassymonkey Reads.
How interesting!
Announcing deaths on the radio - what a wonderful way to show that people have lived! I'll check out the book you recommend as well. Thanks for sharing.
http://blog.candelarisilva.com
Good and plenty!
My mom
My mom died a good death as well. She passed the night after Memorial day. We had all been home that weekend. I spent that day just sitting with her. Her cancer had mastisized to her brain and there was nothing left but hospice care. From March until the night she died she was surrounded by family and friends who loved her more than we knew. Her hospice nurse said she had never seen anyone so surrounded by love in the 10 years she had been doing hospice. She said she was just for show becuase my mom only needed her for pain management. The night she died my sister was lying on one side of her my aunt on the other and her grandchildren were asleep on the sofa in her room. she went with people who loved her holding her and praying for her. When I got the call the first thing I heard was her telling me after she found out that the cancer had gone to her brain that she had victory either way. She said imagine the tetimony she would have if she lived through this and the time to spend with her family would be worth it all. But as a true sold out Christian she knew when she died she would be with her heavanly father.
My family and I often joke that if my dad is the first person we see when we die we will be nervous but if it is my mom we know we made it!
Michelle
I blog at http://www.mommycan.blogspot.com/
How poignant & funny!
How blessed to die surrounded by love. That is actually one of the few positives about having an illness before one dies - the time to say goodbye and for people to show their love to you.
Like you, I worry about who I'll see first when I die and who I might follow. (As a widow who's remarried...hmmm...complications. I think I'd follow my Mom or my sister - safer bets.)
Thanks so much for sharing!
http://blog.candelarisilva.com
Good and plenty!
Good for the Dying or the Loved Ones
Ok not to get all controversial on y'all, but I think it's worth distinguishing between two different types of good deaths. When I was first diagnosed with cancer, I went through a long phase of wishing I'd just been hit by a car or had a stroke or some other sudden, quick demise. I know this idea of "saying goodbye" really resonates with people, but sometimes I think that's selfish. I get that the loved ones left behind can be filled with remorse and anger for the things left unsaid, but isn't it kinder for the person dying to not spend hours/days/weeks/months filled with fear and pain and anguish? I hope that those reeling from the sudden death of a loved one can maybe find some solace in the idea that their beloved was whisked away with speed and mercy.
Elly Lou @ www.bugginword.com
You make a good point!
I think feelings about this are as varied as the individual. I have friends and family members who have suffered years with cancer, pain and other debilitating illnesses who have said they never hoped for death but only for the pain to end. Thanks for your comment and for giving me something to think about.
http://blog.candelarisilva.com
Good and plenty!
Excellent post!
Dear Candelaria Silva,
I loved this post! Superbly Done.
I believe there are "Good deaths" & "Bad Deaths." I believe that people will die as they lived: Good or Bad....
What I disagree with is what Angelia says about death: "It 100% doesn't matter what your spiritual beliefs are: we all die and whatever happens in that instant isn't about god or atheism or beliefs.
To me, the God part is EVERYTHING. One's Beliefs are highly SIGNIFICANT. It 100% Matters!!!!
I mean, if one assumes they will be placed into the ground and mix with the elements ...becoming nothing and insignificant and worthless, what does it all mean? What's the purpose?
A good death is also knowing where one in going afterwards!!! That's just my opinon!
Loved this blog :)
Can't touch this except to say
You make a good point. Our beliefs do influence our feelings about death. I am glad this post resonated with you and so many other people. Ultimately, I guess we each have our own wishes for how we'd like to die. Thanks for taking the time to write such a thoughtful reply.
http://blog.candelarisilva.com
Good and plenty!
What A Great Post!
Hi Candelaria,
There I am reading your post and thinking how fascinating it is only to find you had linked to me in it as well! Thank you.
I was never an obit reader but you make me curious to check out the books you mentioned.
Megan
BlogHer Contributing Editor, TV/Online Video
My Personal Entertainment Blog: Megan's Minute
My Review Blog: Meg's Rad Reviews
Twitter:@MeganSmith
Join the obit readers club
You'll like them for sure. And, yes, your post was definitely one that I had to link to. Having a close friend die without achieving their goals can be an incentive to embrace our skills, talents, hopes and dreams. Continued success in your writing journey and thanks for commenting.
http://blog.candelarisilva.com
Good and plenty!
No Such Thing!
My father died 10 days ago. The priest chose this "good death" terminology in his mass. Actually, I think he used the term "happy death" -- it was the same priest who was in the hospital room with us when my father passed. The words "happy death" hit me like a brick between the eyes -- and I thought, "were we in the same room?!" -- his point was, my father didn't die alone, but surrounded by family. Sure, nobody should die alone, but does the simple act of being surrounded by aching family members make it a "good or happy" death?
I encourage all who read this to be CLEAR about your wishes as it pertains to using extraordinary measures. My father indicated that he *wanted* all means used to SAVE his life, but once that decision is made, it is a slippery slope that the next of kin face -- as in when is enough enough, or, too much.
I'm sure my pain is too raw, too fresh to hear the true meaning in your message -- because as inevitable as it might be, in my mind there is no such thing as a GOOD or HAPPY death, because there is always someone left behind to mourn.
My condolences to you
http://blog.candelariasilva.com
Good and plenty!