Bio
Rita Arens authors Surrender, Dorothy and Surrender, Dorothy: Reviews. She is BlogHer.com's senior editor.  Her parenting anthology and BlogHer'...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Recent Comments

Grandparents and Their Truckloads of Gifts

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 13
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Ah, the holidays. They've arrived, and along with them come all the grandparents with large plastic toys and gadgets and clothes and more toys and where the heck are you going to put all that STUFF?

Not to mention -- are your kids getting a wee bit spoiled?

If this is baby's first Christmas, brace yourself. You may think your parents understand your wishes for environmentally friendly organic toys and the least amount of packaging possible. You might think your in-laws will send just something small since they've already been so generous at the baby shower.

HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA

The problem with babies is ... their stuff? It's cheap. So cheap, in fact, that the grandparents may go, well, a little overboard. Chris at Christmas Rants writes of the grandparents arriving at their child's first Christmas with THREE LOADS of inexpensive plastic toys:

With our grandparent "situation", the problem was they had decided ahead of time the amount they would spend on each grandchild and stick to it. They wanted to be fair and treat all the grandchildren equally - a noble intention gone wrong.

I distinctly remember the moment in which I realized I personally had to stop buying stuff for my baby. When she was brand new, we didn't have anything, so it seemed every time I went to the store I had to pick up some bibs or a paci or a little toy for the diaper bag or SOMETHING. As I stood in the baby aisle at Target one day, I realized we don't need anything. It was a relief, but also sort of a disappointment, because it's fun to buy stuff for babies! So fun! But at some point, you have to back away from the baby aisle. The grandparents don't live with you, so they may not even realize they are overwhelming you more than helping you once you've hit cute-blanket saturation.

As kids get older, they start expecting whatever they've had in the past, and this is where the present train can really go off the rails. You know what I'm talking about: spoiling. Kids who've received boatloads in the past will keep expecting boatloads without realizing the presents they want get more expensive every year.

Spoiling seems to be the major grandparent-present concern across the blogosphere. Grandparents are often in a position to spoil what with their lack of raising-the-children expenses that parents experience. Also? They don't have to store all that junk.

If you have grandparents who buy too much, talk to them, but remember to be tactful and kind. They're not barraging your kids with presents because they hate you and want to bury you in Polly Pockets shoes and Star Wars miniature plastic light sabers. They just love your kids. And they've forgotten how painful it is to step on those things with bare feet.

G is 4 Girl offers gift-giving tips for grandparents who have a tough time deciding on presents for grandkids. Here's my favorite from her list:

A special keepsake. I still have my grandfather’s cufflinks. I bought a woman’s blouse that I can wear them on and I wear them often. Every time I do, I think of him. I doesn’t have to be something from your closet, but consider giving an older grandchild a gift they can keep and use well into adulthood. Jewelry, a wristwatch or a keepsake box is something they can appreciate now and for years to come. I still have two dolls my great-grandmother gave to me as a child. Now my young daughter plays with them!

Lest you begin dreading the holidays for their present-bearing issues, take a deep breath and consider the alternative. Allison Gilbert writes about being a parentless parent at The Huffington Post:

Imagine not being able to go home for the holidays. Now imagine if you couldn't go home next year either. Or, ever again. What would it be like to never smell those smells from your childhood or re-taste those special tastes? That's what it's like for me now that both my parents have passed away.

I hate to end on such a sobering note, but it's so easy to get wrapped up in all that annoys us about the December holidays and the school programs and the extra shopping and the credit card bills and the pressure to cook things in Pyrex pans and the decorations and the credit card bills and the hauling ourselves back and forth across the country, peeing in dirty gas station bathrooms

  • 13
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
21st Century Grandparent 5 pts

I really try hard to abide by my daughter and son-in-laws wishes when it comes to gift buying.  I've never understood the grandparents that ignore the parents wishes and go crazy with gifts the parents don't want for their children.  I always ask first. I live across the country from my granddaughters so if it's little things for the special days like Valentines Day, Easter, 4th of July, etc. I usually send a box of fun things (That $1. item area when you walk into Target is awesome!)  I know I don't need to ask first.  When it comes to birthdays and Christmas I always get their suggestions first.

Embracing and sharing the joys and challenges of grandparenting in the 21st century!

justlinda 10 pts

NOW I read this...  when it's much, much too late.

I'm convinced my father-in-law hates me because he chooses the most obnoxious toys for my children, with the maximum number of pieces and parts and the kind that really, really HURT if you step on them with bare feet in the dark of night. 

Bastard! 

(OK, that last part was just UNCALLED for.  Where are the terms of service?  Perhaps someone should ban me.)

JustLinda fabulously imperfect Nothing to See Here... Just Linda ( http://justlinda.net )

RaisingAmazingDaughters 5 pts

When I was a young mom, I got lots of advice about spoiling kids. I even had some well-meaning experienced moms suggest that you could hold and hug your babies too much and that would spoil them. Here's what I concluded, there are never too many hugs, but too much gifty crap is never a good idea.

My daughter and her husband just spent Christmas with his family. They bought what they thought were fun gifts for their nieces, ages 3 and 6. When I asked how the girls liked the gifts my daughter said, "They barely noticed them in the avalanche of presents they opened. I don't even think they saw what they were in the 50+ gifts they tore through." So, I thought about that. Does it make sense to overwhelm kids with present overload? What are we teaching them with that kind of "generosity"?  I have always loved giving my girls presents. They are delightfully grateful, even today, now that they're grown. But, I think part of the reason is that we always, whether times were good or bad financially, held fast to our gift-giving strategy. We gave them a small number of gifts. They didn't get everything they wanted. (The American Girl dolls never lived here, although they were always a wish.) But, they wanted everything they got and they were always happy to get the gifts. To this day, when we exchange gifts we do so slowly and one at a time so that all of us can watch the recipient open and appreciate the gift. It's the best part of the gift exchange. Yes, it takes a while longer but it is just so much fun to see how happy a gift makes someone. So, if I had parenting to do over, would I do gift-giving the same way? Yes, I would and my grown-up daughters' delight in gift giving and receiving is proof that it worked out for the best.

Please check out my blog at http://raisingamazingdaughters.wordpress.com

glensgirl 5 pts

We have a small house, so for practicality's sake (and my sanity!) we decided that we had to get this problem under control. I actually just wrote a letter, asking our family members to please not give our kids toys anymore. Books, clothes, a gift certificate to a place they love, clothes for their American Girl dolls...but PLEASE, no more toys! I wrote a post about it here:

http://blog.wantingwhatyouhave.com/2008/10/keeping...

Believe it or not, it worked. Both sets of grandparents seemed to understand this request, and they've stuck to it pretty well.  To further prevent the huge influx of stuff, we scaled the girls' birthdays back too...no more big parties.

http://blog.wantingwhatyouhave.com/2008/09/no-more...

Life is much easier because of it, and the girls don't seem to notice any difference.

Sbroadus 5 pts

My husbands parents only have our 2 daughters as grandchildren and boy does it show!We literally cannot leave their hosue on Christmas without them following us home because all the gifts dont fit in our car (and we have a HUGE SUV!)

I have asked them to limit gifts to 2 per child. His mother sews and makes the most adorable outfits, I would be pleased with just an outfit from her but nope, off it is to the boutique to buy someone else's creation!

How do you fix this problem when it is your inlaws? My parents have 7 grandkids so it isn't as much of an issue with them

ChristineMM 5 pts

If you live near the grandparents a simple solution is pick the toys you hate the most, biggest noisiest or whatever and bring them to their house. Say, "These are for when we visit!"

Second make wish lists of stuff you do want them to have. My mother was happy to get a catalog with items circled and she placed the catalog offer.

Ask if they will buy books instead. Make a wish list of books in a catalog i.e. Chinaberry I used for a while which was great as Grandma could read the long review and picks what she liked. Or an online wishlist with an online bookseller if they are internet savvy.

Lastly put away what you don't like and rotate it.

Give stuff away to charity.

Ask for college money instead. But I know some grandparents want to see the kid opening the gift and being happy about it so that doesn't always work.

As the child grows this stops being an issue. When they get into video games each game is $50-60 each and the spending slows. Or some kids want clothing that is expensive $50  for one pair of jeans etc. and the grandparents say, "Hey these prices are crazy I'm not spending that!"

LucindaA 5 pts

My husband and I are not big on "stuff".  We never have been so it was pretty overwhelming when our daughter was the first grandchild on both sides.  Holy cow!  That first Christmas when she was only 3 mos. old you would have thought that she loved opening gifts with the number she received.

So we repeated to the family over and over again how we wanted our daughter to adopt our values and if she got overwhelmed with all her "stuff," that we would give it away.  We also encouraged savings bonds.  A lot.

8 years and many grandchildren later I am pleased to say that the message has been received and our kids get a few meaningful gifts instead of tons of useless crap.  My point is just like vegetables, if you introduce it repeatedly, eventually it sticks.  : )

Rita Arens 7 pts

I hear you -- when one set of grandparents tries to hold the line but the other doesn't, it gets hard. I actually don't have a problem with either set, but I've heard anecdotally that this is a real issue for many parents at the holidays, so I thought I'd see what you all have to say.

Rita Arens writes at Surrender Dorothy ( http://surrenderdorothy.typepad.com/ ) and BlogHer and is the editor of Sleep is for the Weak ( http://tinyurl.com/9pg62e ). She is BlogHer's assignment and syndication editor.

TheBlackTortoise 5 pts

It's tough to hold the line when the other grandparents are so generous.  Grandpa and I decided long ago to give at Christmas in this manner:

A book, A toy, and a hand-made pair of pajamas.  The PJ giving is a family tradition, passed down from my Gramma to my mom, who even passed some of her patterns to me.  My kids get together with me and Gramps on New Years Day.  It's glorious:  traditional family food, nobody hurrying to get to the next place, no fatigue-driven melt downs, a perfect relaxed ending to the holiday season.

On birthdays I decorate a cake and we give a coat or jacket, or some other needed piece of clothing,  and a toy.  Grandpa and I hide small, silly toys in the pockets, or for the older kids enough dollars to match their age.  The idea is the hunt, more than the contents.

It's tough to hold the line with the other set of grandparents seem to fill the closets and stuff the toyboxes.  Once one of those other grandma's even said outloud "Clothes?  Throw those aside.  Where's the good stuff."

We have eleven grandchildren now.  It doesn't really work to put a dollar value on the gifts, because the wish-lists range from toddlers to teens. 

My own family of origin, nine kids, never really focused on gifts so much.  We drew names and the limit for gifts was $1!  That took a lot of imagination and forethought to come up with something of value.  As we grew and became adults, that limit changed to $5.  Now that we're all post-forty, getting together with Mom on the Saturday before Christmas is a family tradition.  No gifts.  Except for Mom, of course.  She deserves every token of our gratitude we can garner.  (She's got 50 grandkids and 25 great-grands.)

PS:  I also send out Epiphany cards, rather than Christmas cards.  The season doesn't really end until after New Years.  It seems we're in such a rush to start the season, that by the time it gets here, we just want to box it up and be done with it.  I love holding on to it.

Adela www.theblacktortoise.com ( http://www.theblacktortoise.com )

Laurie PK 5 pts

Sorry my comment posted twice! I got an error the first time, so redid it....

Laurie

See Jane Soar ( http://bit.ly/199Qci )

Quips & Tips for Achieving Your Goals ( http://bit.ly/NHcZG )

Laurie PK 5 pts

Hi Rita,

We don't have kids yet, but my hoard of nieces and nephews are buried under tons of stuff every year! My husband and I contribute to the crap because we want to show our love, and -- let's face it -- its fun to open presents and play with new toys. That's what Christmas is all about, isn't it??  (just KIDDING!)

It would help if parents gave us loving family members an alternative to the stuff. What do you want your kids to receive? Remember, family members want to give something....we just don't always know what! One of my favorite gifts is an annual pass to the zoo -- and an offer of taking the kids twice a year -- is a fantastic, fun alternative to stuff.

Signed,

A stuff-hater but a niece-and-nephew-lover,

Laurie  :-)

See Jane Soar ( http://bit.ly/199Qci )

Quips & Tips for Achieving Your Goals ( http://bit.ly/NHcZG )

Laurie PK 5 pts

Hi Rita,

We don't have kids yet, but my hoard of nieces and nephews are buried under tons of stuff every year! My husband and I contribute to the crap because we want to show our love, and -- let's face it -- its fun to open presents and play with new toys. That's what Christmas is all about, isn't it??  (just KIDDING!)

It would help if parents gave us loving family members an alternative to the stuff. What do you want your kids to receive? Remember, family members want to give something....we just don't always know what! One of my favorite gifts is an annual pass to the zoo -- and an offer of taking the kids twice a year -- is a fantastic, fun alternative to stuff.

Signed,

A stuff-hater but a niece-and-nephew-lover,

Laurie  :-)

See Jane Soar ( http://bit.ly/199Qci )

Quips & Tips for Achieving Your Goals ( http://bit.ly/NHcZG )