Bio
My name is Amy Gates (also known on the ‘net as amygeekgrl or the Crunchy Domestic Goddess). I live in Colorado with my husband Jody (yes, he’s a guy...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Recent Comments

Health Care Reform Lends Support to Breastfeeding Moms, But Is It Enough?

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 7
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

If we've heard "breast is best" once, we've heard it a thousand times. Health experts agree the benefits of breastfeeding for both the baby and the mother are numerous. A study published earlier this week by the journal Pediatrics points out just how valuable breastfeeding can be. "If 90 percent of new moms in the United States breastfed their babies exclusively for the first six months, researchers estimate that as many as 900 more infants would survive each year, and the country would save about $13 billion in health care costs annually."




It seems that while everyone gives lip service to the importance of breastfeeding, there isn't a lot of support for women once they make the decision to breastfeed. Women have been asked to cover up or leave restaurants, water parks, airplanes, and stores when they try to give their baby what's "best." Maternity leave in the United States is, at best, 12 weeks. Women who work outside the home have often been forced to pump their breast milk in bathroom stalls, hide under a desk, or sit in their car just to get a little bit of privacy because rooms for nursing/pumping mothers just don't exist. So yes, breast might be best for baby, but until there are more regulations in place that allow moms to breastfeed without so many roadblocks, how can breast be "best" for moms?

There is, however, a bit of good news on the horizon. Health Care Reform is lending some support to breastfeeding moms with the Reasonable Break Time for Nursing Mothers law.

  • Section 4207 of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (also known as Health Care Reform), states that employers shall provide breastfeeding employees with “reasonable break time” and a private, non-bathroom place to express breast milk during the workday, up until the child’s first birthday.
  • Employers are not required to pay for time spent expressing milk, and employers of less than 50 employees shall not be required to provide the breaks if doing so would cause “undue hardship” to their business.

Tanya from The Motherwear Breastfeeding Blog thinks this is a step in the right direction. "I'm not thrilled that it extends the right for only up to 1 year (I pumped longer for my son), but what a huge difference this would make for mothers in the many states, mine included, that do not extend this right under state law!"

Currently, only 24 U.S. states, Puerto Rico, and the District of Columbia have legislation related to breastfeeding in the workplace. Yet women now comprise half the U.S. workforce, and are the primary breadwinner in nearly 4 out of 10 American families. The fastest growing segment of the workforce is women with children under age three.

Doula-ing is excited about the new law and calls it "a giant leap forward for mother's who want to continue to breastfeed their babies once they return to work."

Kim Hoppes, who doesn't appear to be a fan of Health Care Reform is, however, pleased with this change. "Well, something good came out of the health care reform nightmare. Places now have to give breaks to nursing moms so they can pump."

Lylah from Boston.com Moms seems to think the new law is not enough and asks, "How can we expect 90 percent of new moms to breastfeed without support in the workplace?"

One thing seems pretty clear: If it's in the country's best interests to have new moms nurse their infants exclusively for at least six months -- and the billions of dollars in health care savings indicates that it may be -- then new moms should get at least six months of paid leave in which they can do so. The United States and Australia are the only two industrialized countries in the world that do not offer paid maternity leave. And moms in the Outback have a sweeter deal than we do: In Australia, your job is protected for a year, but in the United States new working moms only get that guarantee for 12 weeks.

What do you think about the Reasonable Break Time for Nursing Mothers law? Is it too much? Not enough? Just right? None of the government's business?

Photo credit: http://www.flickr.com/photos/tundakov/2550864384/

Contributing editor Amy Gates blogs about green living, attachment parenting, activism and life with an anxiety disorder at Crunchy Domestic Goddess. Follow Amy on Twitter at

  • 7
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
lorioc 5 pts

I am glad we are finally moving in the right direction with our rights in the workplace, as I had to use the men's room at my office (which was just disgusting) and was occasionally given a hard time about having to take the time to pump. But I have to say, my son was breastfed for 6 months, and he is sick just as much as any other child who was formula fed. So I challenge the statement "If 90 percent of new moms in the United States breastfed their babies exclusively for the first six months, researchers estimate that as many as 900 more infants would survive each year, and the country would save about $13 billion in health care costs annually."

justlinda 9 pts

Is likely due to FMLA - companies with fewer than 50 employees (or even satellite offices of smaller employees where the office has fewer than 50 people) are not even required to adhere to FMLA. Many of them do, of course, but they aren't required to by law. I'm guessing that this was written with those same well-entrenched guidelines as FMLA.

My oldest child is nearly 27, and my youngest is 5. I've breastfed all of them for some duration. I'm glad to see the progress continue. I know that some people get frustrated and demand MORE and FASTER. Change just doesn't happen quickly, but make no mistake - the landscape IS changing. Definitely. We're on the right path.

JustLinda

fabulously imperfect Nothing to See Here... Just Linda ( http://justlinda.net )

Twitter @JustLindaSTL

MrsD 5 pts

It's a start. And it's only how many years in the taking? *sigh* Maybe my (yet unborn) granddaughters will take paid maternity leave and breastfeeding acceptance for granted.

HelloLadies 5 pts

http://www.helloladies.com

I think the law is a step in the right direction. But I wish it covered companies that employee less than 50 people. The small companies often go unchecked. I remember when I was pumping in the wiring closet at work, surrounded by spiders, and would read in magazines about companies with private break rooms for nursing mothers-maybe at a Fortune 100 but not at a small biz.

verassong 5 pts

Well, I agree it's just a start. I was thinking about this just this week - first when my PCP told me that if not losing weight continued to bother me, I should just wean my baby at 6 months so he could give me an appetite suppressant. Then at my pediatrician's office yesterday, I watched the nurse carry a giant armful of formula into one of the exam rooms. These are two doctors who have both said the whole "breastfeeding for at least a year blah blah blah" thing. It does seem like everyone has those words memorized, but there's still precious little REAL support for breastfeeding. I am lucky in that I have always had a private office with a door that locks, and lots of freedom and privacy to pump. However, I know so many women DON'T have that, and practically speaking, I'm not sure how many women would be willing to keep up pumping for at least a year under less ideal conditions and with pressure from their boss not to. I also think unfortunately that's even more so the case with blue collar workers - I'm not sure where I would be willing to pump in a factory or a fast food restaurant! - which is so sad, since these women and babies need breastfeeding the most!

GraceGoesThruLife 5 pts

As with everything, these are baby steps in the right direction. Folks just have to continue pursuing this change so that people's perception and acceptance of breastfeeding increases. I know that my sister's company in CA has a room on each of the two floors they occupy where new Moms can pump. Each room has a comfy chair, a table with a radio, and a small refrigerator in it. Nice, eh?

Jessica Anne 5 pts

It's a start, I guess. However, the enforcement is an issue. I live in CA that currently has that law in effect. Although I worked in a very accommodating business, with two other women who were also pumping for their kids, we still had to use a bathroom. It was big enough to bring a chair inside, so we didn't have to sit on the toilet or sink, but it was still a bathroom. I suppose I could have complained, but really, the business would have had to build another room to meet the standards of the law, which doesn't seem very reasonable to me.

As far as "reasonable time", that's hard to say. How fast milk lets down is very individual. Where I worked, me and another woman could fill two 9 oz bottles in 5-10 minutes with a hand pump. The other woman pumped religiously for 20 min. three times a day hooked up to a double electric pump, and left work with less than 6 oz. most days. (She had to supplement with formula, she couldn't produce enough, and she stopped breastfeeding at 6 mos, it was too stressful for her.) So, 2 of us took 20-30 min worth of breaks a day and one an hour, is that reasonable? Should the woman who wasn't producing as much be allowed even more time?

We really need longer maternity leaves in this country. At least 6 mos, so working moms don't have to worry about not producing enough milk for their babies and then, maybe, we'll reach that 90% for 6 mos. our kids deserve.

Jessica

You can find me lurking about at
http://adventureswiththreegirls.blogspot.com