Bio
Mother to C, 4, and K, 1. Wife to Yubo. Writer. Bibliophile. Novice crafter. I am one of the co-founders and a contributing editor for Kimchi Mamas...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Recent Comments

Help Wanted for the Red Lipstick Challenged

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 15
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

I know it's past Valentine's and red is oh-so-passe already, but it's been cold and rainy here and something about the weather just makes me want to go all siren-like and paint my lips red. The thing is, I'm so not a red lipstick kind of gal. If you took a peek into my already small collection of lipsticks and glosses, you'd find an array of nudes and pinks, all with a underlay of mousy, blend-into-the-wall sort of brownishness. And more often than not I can be found sporting a slick layer of chicken poop (my lip moisturizer obsession de jour). 

So on Valentine's, when I started to feel this need to go red, I dug through my makeup stash only to find some Benefit lip stain, long neglected and probably past its prime, but still willing to do the job. (And now I realize, searching for the link, it is so old that it is now defunct in favor of its more popular sister the lip and cheek stain, Benetint. Here is what I have though. This might be its current incarnation.) So, anyway. Even though it had a nice rosy smell and was definitely more red than anything else I owned, it wasn't red red. Like stop you in the street red, if you know what I mean.

And I've been through all this before. I go through this old Hollywood glamour longing every once in awhile and I can never, ever find that perfect shade of knockout red. There's always something wrong with the red. It's too sheer or too strong or too pinkish or too whatever

So I wonder if it's the lipsticks or if it is just...me. I know all the rules - line inside your lips before applying lipstick, don't do red lipstick and super dramatic eyes, pick the right shade of red (plum base if your face is pinkish, brown base if your face has yellow tones) - but the reds just never look quite right. So I wonder if with my super pale skin and general aversion to dramatic makeup (see plethora of nude lipsticks and boring brown eyeshadow in my bag), I just can't embrace my inner siren.

Maybe I want to wear red, but I don't really want to wear red.

Clinique red lipstick

Sigh.

I haven't given up hope yet though. I have to believe there is more than virginal pinks and nudes in my lip's future. If only because it's grey and cold outside and a burst of bold, sexy color would be such a pick-me-up right now. In theory I'd like to buy something inexpensive enough that I won't have to cry over if it doesn't work out, but I'm also not totally opposed to spending some money for The Perfect Red. I'd love something that could make for a new everyday look (because even the fabulousness of chicken poop gets old sometimes), but I'm not really going to kid myself into thinking I'll be able to pull off that kind of color day in and day out. But even if it's just for chilly, romantic sort of days...

I'm eyeing Clinique's red lipsticks, if only because I once had a long love affair with their Almost Lipstick in Black Honey, but I have no idea how to choose. Different Lipstick in Angel Red? High Impact in Sassy Spice? Or Long Last Soft Shine in Red Red Red? M.A.C. also has its fans. Or what about that legendary Chanel red? Or would a stick of Wet N Wild do the job? Help! 

image courtesy of Sephora.

  • 15
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
crat3rs 5 pts

Whether it's valentine or not red mac lipsticks ( http://www.www.moderncosmetics.com/MAC-Lipstick ) will always stand out with other color. But I like the Magenta color, or any dark red lipstick.

sylinthecity 5 pts

I love the Butter Shine formula because it moisturizes and goes on kind of glossy, so you don't feel like your grandma putting it on. As for the red, I like  cranberry cream  ( http://www.sephora.com/browse/product.jhtml?id=P12... ). It is deep, but looks very classy for a bold red (not too winey, or bright, not orangey at all). It's so awesome that I don't even use any eye makeup when I wear it (well, mascara), so the look is very "effortless glamour", haha. 

http://www.somewherethesunisrising.com

Ron Robinson 5 pts

Womens Wear Daily just reported today that makeup artist, Susan Posnick, is launching a new line of lip color called Color Essential.  The goal of this line is to make it easy for any woman to wear bold lip color, including this season's hot color, RED.

http://tinyurl.com/bboahj

http://www.beautystat.com

Down Comforters 5 pts

I feel your pain & angst about the whole red lip thing :)  I'm really fair-skinned & haven't used any bright lip color in FOREVER.  I still can't quite get myself to take the plunge.

http://www.shopdownlite.com 

JamiSings 5 pts

Just speaking from personal experience here. Red is definantly NOT for everyone. For me ANY shade of red makes me look like I have some sort of infecious rash. Be it lipstick or clothing, I cannot wear red. I just look horrible in it. So do not despair if you find yourself in the same boat. Red is just not for everyone. I think red lipstick is over rated anyway. It makes women look like they're extras in some bad vampire movie.  

There are bolder shades of pink out there, you know. While I'm not a lip gloss fan because of how sticky it is, Victoria's Secret has lip plumping lip glosses that come in a dark, bold pink. Avon has a pink lipstick that has flecks of gold in it. Pink doesn't have to be boring. Not if done right. And frankly looks better then red 99.9% of the time.

~Jami JoAnne Russell~

www.jamisings.com ( http://www.jamisings.com )

msjeanneb 5 pts

I love Lipstick Queen; that was going to be my next recommendation!

--

Jeanne

- The Periodic Elements of Style: http://periodicstyle.blogspot.com

jasmine 5 pts

Ugh, I hate it when my favorite lipsticks get discontinued. Must be why I'm always buying new ones? I was about to recommend NARS Kink as a replacement but I think that's been discontinued as well! Have you tried Lipstick Queen ( http://www.lipstickqueen.com/ )?

jasmine 5 pts

Red lipstick is my hobby. I have three tubes of it on my person, and about 20 more at home. Currently, I'm wearing NARS liptick in Red Lizard. That's not counting glosses and tinted lip balms.

Have you tried starting with red glosses and building up to red lipstick from there? I like NARS lip lacquer ( http://www.narscosmetics.com/Lip-Lacquer-C13_makeu... ) in Diablo, which is easy to build up until you find the intensity that you like. Something that is a bit more sheer is T. LeClerc's Rouge Cerise Lip Gloss ( http://www.t-leclerc.co.uk/product_info.php?cPath=... ).

miguelina 5 pts

My favorite (Congo red) is discontinued, so when I run out I'll have to try something else. I like that Nars reds have a bit of brown, which flatters my skin tone. Try them!

msjeanneb 5 pts

They're classic!

If you're not afraid to try asking at the department store counter, I say go for it! MAC has a great bunch of reds as Ms. Jen pointed out (Russian Red and Ruby Woo are both classics). Sometimes it helps to just go to the counter and tell them you have something specific in mind. That's how I came away with Russian Red -- I went in and asked for a film noir red, and that's what they suggested for me.

--

Jeanne

- The Periodic Elements of Style: http://periodicstyle.blogspot.com

Kian Yamaguchi 5 pts

I totally recommend Arbonne's "Bravo" lipstick. It's a true red, will look good on any skin tone (and judging from your pic here, it will look FABULOUS on you). It's creamy, full coverage, very va-va-voom! Plus, it's vegan-certified, botanically based, no added chemicals, so it's good for you. I just got it (by accident actually) and I LOVE IT! I think it's the perfect red!

http://mamafasha.blogspot.com ( http://mamafasha.blogspot.com/ ) my fabulous must-read blog ;)

http://MKSkinCare.myarbonne.com ( http://mkskincare.myarbonne.com/ ) check out our new line FC5!

charlieandnina 5 pts

You are so right about that. Hopefully finding a red I like will help me on that path to make up fun?

msjen 5 pts

Wear the lipstick and eye stuff that you want to wear.  The new rule of no lipstick with dramatic eyes is LAME it makes lots of poor defenseless young women who read too many women's magazines look like they forgot to put on lipstick.  

Serioulsly. I live in SoCal the land of Mac Dramatic Eyes and many of the ladies sporting Dramatic Eyes need to step up their game and put some lipstick on.  Preferrably Mac Russian Red or Ruby Woo.  

Would you go swimming with only half your swimsuit on?  Only the top but wearing jeans or only the bottoms but wearing your bra? No.

Have fun with make up.  When it ceases to be fun, throw the silly magazines/blogs and all their made up rules out the door.

So says the lady with a real fetish for RED Lipstick.  ;oD

Black Phoebe :: Ms. Jen ( http://www.blackphoebe.com/msjen )

FemmeLily 5 pts

The brand's Shanghai Express is known among my friends as the "magic red."  It's worked on my lily white self, my Chinese best friend and a virtual rainbow of skin tones found among our friends (including African American, Latina and Italian).

Give it a whirl!

Ron Robinson 5 pts

There are so many shades of red lipstick. Browny-reds, purply-reds, pinky-reds etc. I think it is just a matter of expirementing with which ones look best with your complexion.

Beware of the bright orangey reds which do not look the best on many skin types.

http://www.beautystat.com