Bio
I work full full time.  I am married and have two little humans. I pushed through post partum depression both times. I write and tell jokes for...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Recent Comments

Son, You May Have My Fears,

but You're Learning How

To Swim

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 20
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Today was the first time I took my five year old son swimming. That is not strictly true; we have been swimming quite a lot. We did lessons and had a regular Saturday morning playdate in the pool when he was 3-4, but he has always been terrified of the water. Bath time has been an absolute nightmare until we came up with a complicated system where I had a towel ready, rinsed his hair and immediately wiped any excess water from his precious widdle face. Daddy is not allowed to do the rinse process, only me. Otherwise the result is BLOODCURDLINGSCREAMS!!!!!! So, this was the first time we were going to lessons to properly learn how to swim. As a grown up five-year-old.

I too do not like water on my face. On my honeymoon, I was presented with a terribly excited '9 headed shower!!' which I confidently entered into...only to find water was attacking me from every angle. And... surprise surprise... the young man has picked up the ame wimpy gene I possess.

Swim LessonsSo when he was crying in the car going to the swim lessons, begging me not to go because he didn't want to put his face in the water, I promised him that he didn't have to do anything he didn't want to. I would talk to the swim teacher and explain his fears and that maybe he needed to go slow. He sniffed in agreement and off we went. So I pulled the rather robust swim teacher aside while she downed a thermos of what I can only hope was coffee and said in my low voice that D was feeling scared about putting his face in the water.

"He'll be fine," she barked.

"Well, he's is feeling terrified and..."

"If he wants to learn how to swim, he's got to put his face in the water!"

I gave her one of my "I completely disagree with everything you're saying" looks. But she just bounded on through the group of parents waiting with their little fishes, her voice rising as she continued lecturing me to the crowd now.

"Everyone has to put their face in the water. Dump a bucket of water over their heads in the bath! Everyone has to put their face in the water!"

Suitably shamed, I nodded and sat down to watch my son, who was much bigger than the other children. I watched him cry and shake, biting his lower lip and shaking his head when she pulled out the hullahoop and each child slipped under water and through the hoop. Eventually he reluctantly eased 3/4 of his head under water. I was embarrassed for him. It was like seeing a grown ass child in a push chair. I was so sad and I wanted to go over and pull him out and make it all okay.

Then I remembered -- crying never killed anyone.

Some of my best parenting lessons have emerged from that lovely phrase. Swimming is a life-skill and it is, in my opinion, non-negotiable. In the same way that crossing the road is a life-skill: We can't just stop and cry in the middle of the road and feel comfortable with the process. It is literally a sink or swim experience.

So suck it up princess. I did learn to dive under water. I hated swimming lessons, but I know that if I ever fall into the water, I get wet rather than die! I have to toughen up, so I will dump water on his tender sweet head in the bath tonight while he wails in response, because I am the Mama. Stronger than the girl riddled with fears that lives in my past. Mama!

 

 

Get busy living or get busy dying

Photo Credit: icma.

  • 20
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
catdelouise 6 pts

My child has an intense fear of the pool. He also has OCD, Anxiety, some sensory issues and more. You know your own child but my son who is now five is absolutely terrified of the water and I refuse to torture him any more after spending a couple of years trying to get him in the pool. Sometimes it is more than just a fear of water for some kids.

suebob 13 pts

I was the fifth child and I was a screamer. All my sibs learned to swim, but I guess my mom was sick of the whole thing by the time she got to me, so she packed up and we left when I started my tantrum. The outcome was that I missed out on years of fun by not knowing how to swim. I went to a high school where every student had to pass a swimming test, so I learned at age 16 and became an avid swimmer. I wish she had made me stay through my tantrum.

Vinobaby 10 pts

I know it pains you, but I am a total advocate of teaching your child to swim. He may never love the water, but all children need to know this survival skill. Period. My husband has investigated so many accidental drownings, dozens and dozens of children gone because they didn't know how to save themselves.

I hate to pimp my blog, but I did write a post about this in May:

http://vinobaby.blogspot.com/2011/05/swimming-for-...

Sometimes it is such a struggle to be a good parent, to know the right thing to do, but we must force ourselves to follow our brains and not just our heart.

I hope it gets easier for you -- good luck.

fuckedupmommy 5 pts

I should update my progress....it ain't working thus far. The battles are doing my head in. God this parenting malarky is tough! It is so easy for the swim teacher to simply proclaim - WE ALL HAVE TO PUT OUR HEADS IN THE WATER but I can't stand my boy screaming and crying during what used to be a lovely bath time experience - it is now the Somme. I don't know if I can do this. It's only been a week and two days and it sucks. Any advice bloghers?

rockle 7 pts

fuckedupmommy do you have to be there when lessons are going on? can you be outside the pool area, or somewhere where he can't see you? my daughter is a goldfish but there are other things she doesn't like to do -- until we say, "hey, you're doing it anyway," and we walk away and don't come back until lessons are over (all the while watching from a safe distance, where she can't see us). and then we practically give her a nobel prize for going through with it when it's over.

nellewrites 19 pts

fuckedupmommy I can't say this is what he's feeling, but for me, lack of confidence and embarrassment were big players. I had to test it out on my own - and make it work - first. Perhaps if you do some one on one work with him, at a place where no one is watching, he might respond.

katilak 5 pts

fuckedupmommy You are telling my story!! My youngest son was always scared to submerge his face in the water. We had very similar bathtime experiences...oh, the carrying on!! I got tired of that & actually had him start taking showers with his older brother, Yes, crying never killed anyone, but it sure grated on me!!

I had him in group lessons for the last few summers, but he did not overcome his fear, and grabbed for his teacher or edge of the pool whenever possible. I had been a lifeguard and swim instructor during college, so I had had students like him! He knew I would not cave in!!

He outgrew his bike last year and asked for one for Christmas. I told him he couldn't get one if he didn't learn how to swim. I paid for a few private lessons. I believe that is what made the difference. I totally wish I had done that sooner and would highly recommend that! He overcame his fear.

This past summer, he went right into group lessons, also learned how to surf, and got a bike for his birthday!

BoyMomBlogger 5 pts

fuckedupmommy OMG!! I have been there done that! I am actually going to post a positive testimony about this on my blog. So, my 4yo son would SCREAM bloody murder EVERY TIME he went swimming. And this lasted ... for MONTHS! Now, I would have TOTALLY pulled him out but his dad persisted. The coach said we needed to up the # of times he attended so we went from 1/wk to 2/wk. He still screamed! I mean snot going in the pool and everything. I couldn't stay and let his dad take him. Found out my child was putting us on tho b/c one day granddad went to practice and we didn't hear a peep out of him. (CAN YOU BELIEVE IT?) Still took him awhile to catch on. Anyway, here we are about 6 months later and just this week he swam a little - no feet on the floor or anything. So - it can happen. But it's PAINSTAKING!!

nellewrites 19 pts

I wasn't one to scream over lessons, me, I just went quiet after declaring I'd not do it. At that stage, I'd grow roots and not care what came my way. My parents knew it would not work, and it wouldn't have. I'd have stressed and internalised and well...

I wasn't ready. At age 12 or so, on my own, I was ready, because that is now I learn best, with me seeking solution, rather than one imposed.

It is hard to get a read on a child's personality, and it isn't for me to say what a parent should do, I only speak from my personal experience. Both of my daughters learned to swim at a far younger age than I did.

JennaHatfield 68 pts

Oh man. I struggle with some of these things, but I'm going to have to remember your line: crying never killed anyone.

Thank you!

--

Jenna | firemom

BlogHer Family Editor | blogherfamily

BlogHer Events Editor | blogherevents

http://stopdropandblog.com | http://thechroniclesofmunchkinland.com

Conversation from Facebook

Nelle Douville
Nelle Douville

I'm skittish about coercing an unwilling and deeply resistant child to swim in a group setting. One on one work, away from a group teaching session and where their peers are would help remove anxiety. If a child has fear, relaxing is important to learning how to function in water. Perhaps later group lessons would work, but initially, big mistake to follow that track.

Corrie Beebe
Corrie Beebe

Okay, Esther, I can see that as a valid point. I did say he does need to learn how to swim. I can put my face in the water, I just hate it. Maybe I am just unhappy with the swim instructor for not taking his fears into consideration. It seems to me that having that knowledge would be critical for the instructor to work with him without causing MORE fear. The author does go on to state (in the later comments) that he is still freaking out and screaming when getting water dumped on him. So clearly, to me, the fear itself is not being resolved, and could in fact be getting worse. It is critical for kids to trust their parents, and if the mom is perpetuating the fear...how can he trust her?

Esther Kraig
Esther Kraig

But Corrie, what if he falls into the pool? Or a lake? He FELL< he got his whole body submerged - including his head. If that elicits instant panic, he's dead.
He NEEDS to learn how to NOT panic just because his face gets wet. THAT is the point of forcing him to put his face in the water. Do it in a controlled circumstance where you can AFFORD to panic and then learn better. Don't wait until it's an emergency and you die because you panicked.

Melissa Soucy
Melissa Soucy

Yes I did and I am gald I did

Corrie Beebe
Corrie Beebe

I agree that he needs to learn to swim, but I gotta say...as someone who also hates having my face wet, there is no way I would make my kid stick their face in the water if they were crying and freaking out. No way. I STILL have memories of my dad FORCING me to do things that freaked me out. I would be crying, freaking out, scared and paralyzed and he wouldn't let me stop. Did that teach me anything? Only to not trust my dad, and to not get myself into situations where he would force me to do something like that. Look into some other options for this poor kid! His swim instructor is wrong! YOU CAN swim without getting your face in the water. I do it all the time. I have a boat, and we swim and play every year, but I never get my face wet. I swim for fitness, and never get my face wet. It is not required. Sure, that's how you are supposed to do it, but not at the expense of my kid's psyche!

Anne-Marie Ross
Anne-Marie Ross

Scared or not scared, it's scarier to have a kid who might panic in a real emergency and has no swim skills.

Kathleen Fluhr
Kathleen Fluhr

Absolutely! It is too dangerous for a child to not know how to swim! My youngest son was always so scared of swimming....mostly because he was scared to submerge his face in the water. He outgrew his bike last year and asked for one for Christmas. I told him he couldn't get one if he didn't learn how to swim. I paid for a few private lessons: it was the right investment at the right time! He overcame his fear. This past summer, he went right into group lessons, also learned how to surf, and got a bike for his birthday!

Sarah Burkett
Sarah Burkett

My son was scared, but once the lessons started, he was excited for each and every time we had to go!

Tammy Gigon
Tammy Gigon

Completely agree with her decision.. my son is a bit afraid also, but we live right near the beach so he will learn to swim!

Tarrant Figlio
Tarrant Figlio

All children should learn to swim