He's Shorter. Now What?
by Zandria

I've always thought that if I'm interested in a guy, he should at least be my height, if not taller. It's just...easier, you know? People don't think twice when they see a shorter woman with a taller man, but when it's the other way around it tends to create chatter. I would say that most women I've ever heard from about this subject have said they have this preference, too.

Some people would ask, well, what about guys who are a little shorter than usual? Is it unfair for someone like me, being 5'9", to eliminate a guy from romantic consideration if he's, say, 5'6"? What's my hang-up?

On an online dating site, if you do a search for people and attempt to narrow the number of results (in addition to searching for something obvious like geographic proximity), one of the many filters you can use to eliminate people from your search results is minimum height. I haven't used this search feature for a number of months, but I remember what I originally set as the minimum height -- 5'10", which is an inch taller than me.

I have a hypothesis, though. A guy would probably say it's unfair for a taller woman not to give him a chance (if a height difference is the only thing holding them apart from mutual attraction), but I think there are many guys who specifically look for shorter women. This doesn't hold true all the time, for sure -- there are always exceptions to any rule -- but, well, here's the thing. I'm basing this assumption on personal experience. I've dated a few guys who weren't substantially taller than me and the subject of height has always come up, usually sooner rather than later.

Sometimes it'll be a comment, like the guy will say, "I've never dated a woman as tall as you before." Or when we're standing face-to-face, they'll straighten up as tall as they can, just to make sure the top of their head is above mine. (To the other tall ladies out there, have you noticed that when someone does this and you're wearing shoes, they automatically look down to see how much height your shoes are adding?)

And, really, come on -- it's not like I'm an Amazon. What must it be like for women who are 6' or taller?

(And yes, certainly, sometimes there are positive comments as well. Like the tall guys who say it's nice not to have to bend down so far when they come in for a kiss.)

I've thought about what it might be like to go out with a guy who's shorter than me. I know there would be absolutely no difference in the person -- it would all come down to how comfortable I felt about having him be the one to tip his head back when it came time for a kiss. I'm not sure how I'd feel about that. And on the flip side, I think there are a lot of guys who wouldn't know how they feel about that, either.

I don't know what made me start thinking about this recently. Maybe because I've now gone out with men who were older than I said I'd go out with, and I've gone out with people who had a different overall look/body type than my "normal" preference. I guess it just makes me wonder what other things I thought were what I wanted may not really be the case.

Ladies, have you ever dated someone who was noticeably shorter than you? Guys, have you dated someone taller? If you haven't, do you think you'd be okay with that?

Related Reading:

At The Frisky, 6'1" Susannah Breslin has some advice for How To Date A Tall Chick.

When other guys see a guy with a woman who's taller than he is, they assume one of two things: A) He has a lot of money, or B) He's really good in bed. Bagging a six-footer is big-game hunting. If you land one, everyone will assume you're a baller. Now, get out there, and find yourself a tall woman. I bet she's waiting for you -- with her heels on.

Double X: Julia Childs' Height Was Not a Handicap

Tall women's struggles are more subtle. You're not aware of this unless you're tall, but there's a vortex of silence around tall female public figures, and a total dearth of tall female role models. Sure, there are lots of very successful tall women out there. But you probably don't know who they are. Because they don't talk about it.

Kaye Dacus published a novel with a plus-sized heroine who also happens to be 5'11". She said she wanted to address the stereotype of tall men and short women, women "who are short enough the top of their head barely reaches the hero’s shoulder."

(Contributing editor Zandria blogs at Zandria.us.)

Comments

 

He ain't worth it!

That's not true -- there are a lot of great guys out there that are shorter than I am (5' 7") but I won't be dating them.

I dated a guy that was an inch or two shorter than me and it was always on my radar.   I just felt big all the time, and I didn't like it.  Luckily he wasn't also a swimmer's physique type, or I don't think I would have made it past the first date.

For body dysmorphia purposes, I really just need to be the one who is at least the inch or two shorter.

In short, (ha ha, pun intended -- couldn't resize resist!) I can't repeat petite.

 

Daniella - http://www.daniellaland.blogspot.com - Free corndog if you fall off of anything.

 

Usual

It's good that you're thinking about this.  I don't know how this started, but it's a typical brainwashing that I've definitely been caught up in myself.

I would never have been inclined to seriously date a woman taller than I am.  That's not to say that I don't find taller women attractive and wouldn't mess with them.. Just saying that the concept doesn't make any sense.  I think you hit it on the head with "uncomfortable".  It's odd.

In my case, I don't have to worry about that anyway, because I've found shorter gals to be cooler.  I don't know why that is.  I know that for shorter guys, charisma plays a larger part in dating and I would assume the same thing for shorter gals.  You need more mental presence to shine in a room full of taller people and I think that's what attracts me more.

Anyway... The dilemma for a female that's looking to fall in love is whether she's willing to restrict her set of potential suitors to only the guys that are taller than her.. or only the guys that live in her neighborhood.. or only the guys that make more money than she does, etc etc etc.

Funny thing is.. The longer a gal remains single, the more lax her requirements become until she's finally willing to accept whomever's actually a good fit for her. :)

~ Bill
I blog at billcammack.com

 

I don't care if he's shorter than me

as long as I like him.  Then again, I'm not tall so I really haven't had that problem.

(My blogs are http://flightkeeper.blogspot.com and http://cutefuncool.blogspot.com)

 

So I'm 5'10" and have been

So I'm 5'10" and have been taller than many guys that I know. And when I was younger I turned down guys that were shorter than me all the time. My significant other now is 5'10" as well (or maybe 5'9" in all honesty) and it has been for the most part not an issue. The only time it creates a problem is when I want to dress up and wear heals, then I kinda tower over him. Maybe its because we are about the same height but its never really been an issue for either of us.

 

Height doesn't really matter

From my personal experience - I would say that the first time you date a guy shorter than you it is kind of on your mind.  But after you get over it - it never bothers you again!  I suppose its different for everyone but hey - everyone is the same height lying down!

 

I often wonder about this

This concern has shaped how I "shop" for men online. Most of my shorter girlfriends don't seem to get because they have never had to be the tallest person in a room or group picture. These types of petite girls are the same size as my best buds in middle-high school and though I loved them, think they contributed to some of my insecurities. Ah, well, I think I really should get over it as the tall men I meet are doing me any good either!!

 

LadyBird

http://notyetacrazycatlady.blogspot.com/