Bio
Rita Arens authors Surrender, Dorothy and Surrender, Dorothy: Reviews. She is BlogHer.com's senior editor.  Her parenting anthology and BlogHer'...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Recent Comments

Holiday! Vacationing With an Only Child

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 19
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

We're standing in line to check bags at the San Diego airport, surrounded by large families hoisting enough luggage to sustain the Northwest Passage. And once again, I am thankful we are a party of three.

When we first decided to keep our family this size, we used to wonder if we'd have to borrow a kid on vacation.

Midway 8

We don't.

But there are pros and cons to traveling light. If you've ever wondered what it's like to have one child, here's a glimpse.

Pro: Nothing's Set in Stone

We can change direction on the fly, decide where to eat in ten seconds and negotiate kid vs. adult time with a minimum of fuss. You want the zoo? Fine, I want the sailboat ride. Everything is negotiated directly with the person in play, so your parenting style and rules can change according to the situation, as there's no need to keep things fair between different kids of different ages and maturity levels.

Con: You Are the Playmate

You can never tell your kid to go play with her sister. You are that child's companion, like it or not. That can be a big con when you're ready to relax in the hot tub with a glass of wine after a long day at Sea World and your daughter wants to swim in 65 degree weather.

Pro: You'll Probably Travel More Often Because It's Cheaper and Easier

If we'd taken the vacation we just took with another child, it would've cost at least an additional $800. Since we try to pay vacations off immediately or use cash, we would most likely not be able to save up to go somewhere every eighteen months or so. Or we'd be vacationing in an RV or in Branson, and I'd have to stick a fork in my eye.

Con: Your Kid Will Get Bored and Lonely If There Aren't Enough Kid Activities

Just because you *can* go to a restaurant with tablecloths every night doesn't mean you should. Only children do act a bit like little adults, but you have to remind yourself they're not -- just like everything else, you have to flip back and forth between adult stuff and kid stuff. I recommend carrying around at least one puzzle book and one sticker book at all times. They come in tiny sizes and can fit into any purse. And you have to engage -- there is no ignoring the only child while you're waiting for your table. It's not fair.

Pro: You Will Literally Travel Lighter

Without so much stuff to carry and keep track of, packing and unpacking go faster. You can get on and off a bus without going back and forth to the curb ten times and you don't need to rent a minivan just to get to your hotel.

Pro: You Have Only One Kid's Needs to Schedule Around

Either she takes naps or she doesn't. Either she can eat dinner at 8 p.m. or she can't. Either she needs a stroller or she doesn't. Once you pass a high-maintenance stage, you need not revisit it.

Conclusion:

In our case, family size was very planned and tailored to our personalities. If we'd accidentally had more kids, we would've welcomed them with love and gotten comfortable with the Ozarks. I'm not arguing people who have more kids are not having any fun or suffer in lives of toil -- I'm writing this for the parents out there who are wrestling with the desire to stop at one and worry their child will grow up lonely and unhappy.

We made our decision to stop at one when my six-year-old daughter was two, and we made it permanent when she was four. Everything is different in our lives from all of our two- and three-kid family friends. We have very few in-town friends with only children and only three other parties of three between both of our large extended families. But I can tell you that the stereotype of the lonely only child is not self-fulfilling -- it doesn't have to be that way. You just need a slightly different breed of parent to make

  • 19
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
RitaV 5 pts

Hello! ( Apologies in advance, I'm not a native english speaker, so be patient while reading)

I am also a mom of an (almost) 6 years old only child, and I'd love to share with you my concerns and joys about daily life.

Now it's our fisrt day on summer vacations. I'm thinking about to put him on a summer course (curso de verano), because my husband and I work during the morning (we work at university, but on these days we can work at home).

The problem is that my son wants to stay at home. It's difficult for me to work at home while he's asking me to play, and it´s not my idea to let him stay seated in front of the TV the whole day. On the other hand, I have great memories of my summer vacations, staying at home with my sister, creating our own games, and I dont want to force him to go for a summer camp if he prefers to be at home.

What have been you experiences about this? I would really apreciate your ideas.

mickmom 5 pts

thanks so much for this enlightening article...I have one six year old son - but tried IVF for more and nothing yet (he was conceived through IUI). He is always asking why he doesnt have a brother or sister like his cousins (!). It breaks my heart but now that I am 42, cant really see it happening. We are looking into adoption but as time goes on, I am wondering if I want to rock the boat. He is so awesome & as he gets older I can see its getting easier. He is a dream to be with and we have brought my niece to Disney World as a playmate. Both my husband and I come from families with 4 kids. I grew up surrounded by large families so this is some adjustment that my reality may be parent of only one. Thanks to all the parents of one for sharing very true positive views & benefits of having one child.

SunFish 5 pts

There are certainly advantages to having only one child, as you make in this article.

I can also tell you that a big family, though more "cahotic" to some degree, need not be a problem. I am one of 4 kids and I cherish my siblings. Thanks to my parents, we all got along great growing up and had no problem behaving in public places, which in turn enabled our parents to take us many places, to the awe of other adults.

Family size is a very important and personal choice. There are pros and cons to both.

Thank you for presenting that side of the issue.

MiriamAnton 5 pts

Rita, I'm just catching this post and it's really a refreshing read! I too have just one with no plans for more. Being a twin myself with a perpetual playmate by my side, I have wondered what life might be like for my 6 yr old son if he had a sibling. My husband however, is an only child so he has a different take and claims never to have felt a lack of companionship. Since your post relates to travel, I'll have to agree that it's a nice perk from a cost perspective. My favorite perk is all the extra time you get to spend with your "just one".

Rita Arens 7 pts

I think I am just going to print out this list of comments and tuck it under my pillow for when people say something mean about me "not providing a sibling" for my little girl. We're happy, but sometimes it's hard to ignore the comments. I so appreciate everyone's thoughts here.

Rita Arens authors Surrender Dorothy and is the editor of Sleep is for the Weak. She is BlogHer's assignment and syndication editor.

paulag01 5 pts

Hi Rita, I am an only child as well and I loved it. Sure there were times I had wished I had a sibling, but truly all that didn't matter because my parents truly wanted me and loved me. An excellent family of three. On our longer summer vacations we often traveled with another family who had 2 kids, one of which was a close friend of mine. So I had built in company and alone time. A few years I got to invite a friends to come along for the week. Some trips were just the three of us. So a nice variety.

As an adult, being an "only" has been ok too. Sure one might wish in times of need (like recently when my Mom got ill and died) that there were other siblings to help, but I see so many of those situations go into drama (whenever there is >1 person there is exponentially more opinions) or the sisters/brothers check-out and don't show up that I don't truly see an advantage/disadvantage solely on whether someone is an only child or not. Truly depends on the people involved and family dynamic.

So I agree with you that no one should choose to have another child because somehow "only" isn't "enough".

Paula Gregorowicz
The Paula G Company
http://www.thepaulagcompany.com

Experience Life Alchemy(tm) and learn 5 Steps to Move from Fear to Freedom ( http://www.thepaulagcompany.com/feartofreedom ) (free)

Susan Getgood 5 pts

My son is my only child (my husband has a daughter who was 24 when our son was born.) I was in my late 30s when he was born, and felt 1 was the right choice in part for that reason, but also because of the ability to still travel and do more things as a smaller unit.

Of course it means that I am now stuck playing Frontierville and Happy Island with him on Facebook because I will only let him friend family members and close family friends, and he needs someone (me) to send him gifts.

My version of the sticker book I guess.

Susan Getgood blogs at Marketing Roadmaps ( http://getgood.com/roadmaps ), Snapshot Chronicles ( http://snapshotchronicles.com ) and Snapshot Chronicles Roadtrip ( http://snapshotchronicles.com/roadtrip ).

accidentalcitygirl 5 pts

and even though I think my parents did very well providing vacations and fun activities for us, I also remember how stressed out they were trying to make our lives as peaceful and care-free as possible. My siblings and I get along very well, NOW. I count them both as friends, but we didnt enjoy each others company as children and made our parents crazy with the fighting. My boyfriend is one of 7 children and we plan to only have one because we think it will be best for us and our vision of our family.

accidentalcitygirl blogs at Chronicles of an Accidental City Gir ( http://accidentalcitygirl.wordpress.com/ )l when she isn't exploring Chicago, taking photos or wrangling 3 cats and 1 giant spaz of a dog

Nordette Adams 6 pts

I was an only child for the first seven years of my life. My daughter was an only child for the first 10 years of hers. I don't recall asking for a sibling, but my daughter prayed for one. Now, WOW! is she sorry! Just kidding. :-)

I don't remember too much traveling when I ended up with two b/c they were so far apart in age, the 10-year-old could help with the new addition.

I recall my brother driving me insane. I'm sure by now everyone on the Internet has figured out I'm nuts, and I blame him.

When I was around three, my family traveled by car to California, but even then I wasn't alone for the whole trip. My older cousins were in the car on the way there or was it the way back? Can't remember.

Lonely? Not sure b/c I read a lot. I do, however, remember wishing there were more children my age in my neighborhood.

Stick to one, Rita. At some point my two ganged up on me.

Nordette Adams ( http://www.bookotopia.com ) is a BlogHer CE ( http://www.blogher.com/haystackprofile/viewprofile... ) & you can find her other stuff through Her 411 ( http://her411.com ).

crousehaus 5 pts

and she is an only child. That little girl goes everywhere with her mother and she is so much fun and very adventurous. She has loads of friends and I think she's a great example of how fine it is to be an only child.

I do have to say that I have two children and I am their companion. They don't seem to play well together unless I'm in the mix, so I'm in the pool with them, on the floor playing games with them, making crafts with them.... I'm hoping one day they'll be closer, but I'm finding that having two kids doesn't guarantee that they'll be best buds.

DigitalGal512 5 pts

I am an only child and I always wished that I had either a brother or sister to play with. I was ALWAYS jealous of my friends who had a sibling to ride the bus home with, share chores with, and make mother’s day gifts with together. That being said, my mother was a great a playmate while growing up and I know that this special one-on-one time is what shaped our relationship into what it is today. Now that I’m older though, I still have tiny jealous moments when my fiancé talks of all the fun he had during his childhood playing/exploring out in the sticks where he grew up with his three siblings. I have every intention to ensure that I don’t have just one child (when I’m ready)…

-Ashley-

blogging for beginners 5 pts

I only have one child by choice. We have fun being together always. My son is hyper-active that is why I always see to it that we go out once a week to have some outdoor activities. Having friends is his happiness. He is so smart at Five. I think it really helps a lot if we let them enjoy their being a child while guiding them all throughout.

Anyway, thanks for this article! Thanks for sharing!Blogging for Dummies

amberpagewrites 5 pts

We are currently trying to decide whether to leave it at one or enter the baby dancing arena again... It's good to know that not everyone feels you have to have two (because it sure seems that way).

DebbieB 5 pts

We played, colored, combed doll's hair, caught a Frisbee, swam in way-too-cold water and did just about everything a good playmate does. At the same time, my daughter sat nicely at fine restaurants (with a book to amuse herself at times), traveled to many cool places, and grew up comfortable in the company of grown-ups as well as kids. She also could always keep herself amused (without the TV or computer).

Rita Arens 7 pts

They say all kinds of things that make me think they assume we throw our daughter out into the world by herself or lock her in the backseat for hours without speaking to her. When I say "be her companion," I mean we literally are her playmates as well as her parents. We get in the water with her, we ride the coasters with her and we do the sticker books with her. It takes more energy than sitting back, but I see it pay off in spades when she doesn't appear bored or lonely in the least.

Rita Arens authors Surrender Dorothy and is the editor of Sleep is for the Weak. She is BlogHer's assignment and syndication editor.

DebbieB 5 pts

It wasn't a choice, but it ended up being a good thing. She would have loved a sibling (so she thinks) and I would have loved another child, but we got what we got and we were thrilled to have her. I am horrified that anyone ever told you anything remotely close to your "exaggerated" words above (your child will suffer a lonely and boring existence, most likely to emerge on the other side of parenthood a shriveled, spoiled, friendless shell of the robust human she could've been. Geez. My daughter is now 20 and none of those things! We did bring a cousin on a vacation once but it was no better than the many times we vacationed with just the three of us. Wherever we went my child learned, at a very young age, how to make friends. A wonderful skill that has served her well.

Julie Heinrich 5 pts

Thank you for writing this. We have an only child. By choice. And we have had to defend that choice for many years to family and friends and even complete strangers.

We go on wonderful vacations each year simply because we have only one child and it is far less expensive and cumbersome. My daughter is nine years old and she is getting to see the world! She is an excellent traveller and will eat just about anything so we never have the "picky" food problem.

www.julieheinrich.com ( http://www.julieheinrich.com )

Rita Arens 7 pts

Every time we go to the pool, my daughter seems to make a new friend. We usually bring an extra floatie or whatever so if she meets someone she can share toys.

Rita Arens authors Surrender Dorothy and is the editor of Sleep is for the Weak. She is BlogHer's assignment and syndication editor.

JennaHatfield 9 pts

I was an only child for eight years. Those first eight years of (many many many) family vacations with my parents are some great memories. We never took another child which was actually a huge plus for me. Why? I made friends with some other kid on every vacation we took.

Mostly boys because I loved the boys. ;)

We have pictures of me with random children everywhere from Cedar Point to the NC shoreline and beyond.

Then my brother was born and ruined everything. Ahem. (I love him dearly.)

Jenna Hatfield (@FireMom ( http://twitter.com/FireMom )), from Stop, Drop and Blog ( http://stopdropandblog.com ) and The Chronicles of Munchkin Land ( http://thechroniclesofmunchkinland.com ), is a freelance writer and newspaper photographer.