Bio
I write Stirrup Queens when I'm not reading other people's blogs, cooking, or chasing after my twins. I'm the author of two books: Life from Scratch,...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Recent Comments

Does the Internet Make Women More Honest About Their Friendships?

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 26
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

I have 574 friends on Facebook. I chalk this up to the fact that (1) I've lived in a bunch of places and (2) I have a good track record for keeping friends. Most people on my friend list have been close friends at one time, and Facebook has allowed us to keep in touch without a lot of effort. It leaves the door open so I can jump back into those friendships (and often do) at any point.

But in this day and age, "friending" has taken on an entirely different meaning. There are people looking to build friendships with me online, people I've never met who have never even e-mailed with me. They send a friend request without even letting me know who they are. Which sort of begs the question: What does friendship mean in the Internet age?

Does having a lot of Facebook friends mean anything?

Or having a lot of followers on Twitter?

Or a lot of subscribers to your blog, comments on your Flickr photos or views of your video on YouTube?

Close-up of two young women using a laptop and smiling

The Bloggess had a wonderful post last winter about this when she asked her Twitter followers to vote for her in the Weblog Awards, and she came in 7th. "Also, I just want to point out that I have 5700 followers on Twitter and only got 547 votes so that means that 90% of my followers couldn't be bothered to push a button."

The post was tongue-in-cheek, poking fun at awards that tally votes, but it does beg a vital question. If someone I consider a friend asks me to do something, I do it in a heartbeat. I've dropped everything to type up a recipe, watch a friend's child or pick up a few extra things while grocery shopping. But if someone I follow on Twitter asks me to do something, does that carry the same weight? What if they're a good friend online, one I converse with daily over e-mail? Does that move me to action more than if they're someone I vaguely know from reading their blog?

Rancid Raves asks these very questions this week, especially looking at how online friendships change the way women communicate. Because, on the whole, women like to sidestep around confrontation. We let friendships go by not returning phone calls (or gently protesting that our lives are so busy when someone calls us on it instead of admitting that we just don't see the value in the friendship anymore). We are encouraging, nurturing and supportive. Which is not to say all women are like this, but my husband can count on one hand the number of times he has been kept up at night worrying about a friendship whereas I would need several additional limbs to even get cracking on tallying up the sleepless nights in the past last year.

Rancid Raves asks,

I do wonder how social media such as Facebook is affecting women in the way they communicate. Most women do not like to tell the truth in how they feel about someone or the relationship - I am most certainly guilty of this. I do not like hurting someone's feeling, so I will go to great lengths to avoid confrontation ... Will social media force women into being more genuine in friendships?

And then, with deep honesty, are those friendships suddenly more valuable? Don't we all treasure the friend who isn't afraid to tell us that we have spinach in our teeth (and save us from embarrassment down the road) or who steers us away from terrible decisions? There is something about the distance that being online affords that allows us to be more honest with one another -- whether we're being direct with our words or whether we're simply unfriending someone who no longer brings positive energy to our life.

Online, we can't just slip away with an unreturned phone call. Sites such as Facebook mark our decision to separate ourselves from another person by deducting a number from our friend count. If you've ever been on the receiving end of a dropped friend on Facebook, you know how hurtful and infuriating it can be to have tangible proof that it's not someone else's busy schedule or life getting in the way of your friendship -- it actually is all about you.

So what we have are friendships of

  • 26
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Lavender Luz 6 pts

"With Twitter, I see it more as peeking in the windows and FB as being allowed through the front door."

Great analogy.

Weebles Wobblog ( http://www.weebleswobblog.com/ ) ... yin-yanging my way.@LavLuz
Examiner ( http://www.examiner.com/x-13701-Open-Adoption-Exam... )for Open Adoption.
( http://twitter.com/LavLuz )

Melissa Ford 5 pts

What is un-fan? See, there are all sorts of nooks and crannies of the Internet that I haven't found yet.

Melissa writes Stirrup Queens ( http://stirrup-queens.com ) and Lost and Found ( http://lostandfoundandconnectionsabound.blogspot.c... ). Her book is Navigating the Land of If ( http://thelandofif.blogspot.com/ ).

Melissa Ford 5 pts

"I think that's one of the unexpected gems of the digital age."

Absolutely. There are online friends who fulfill needs that no one in the face-to-face world can at that moment. And there are plenty of times when that online person steps out from behind the screen and becomes a face-to-face friend.

Melissa writes Stirrup Queens ( http://stirrup-queens.com ) and Lost and Found ( http://lostandfoundandconnectionsabound.blogspot.c... ). Her book is Navigating the Land of If ( http://thelandofif.blogspot.com/ ).

Pamela Jeanne 5 pts

...who "un-fan" something you've done.

I have a much smaller circle -- always have, always will, I'm guessing. All the same, scalewise, I truly can't decide which stings more being "unfanned" or being "unfriended" -- especially when you're poured your heart and soul into something...

Good thing I've developed thick skin. I truly have needed it more than once!

Great post, Mel!

Pamela Tsigdinos

http://www.silentsorority.com

Melissa Ford 5 pts

I sort of wish they hadn't used the term "friends" either. What about connecting? Do you want to accept this connecting request? How many connections do you have, etc.

Melissa writes Stirrup Queens ( http://stirrup-queens.com ) and Lost and Found ( http://lostandfoundandconnectionsabound.blogspot.c... ). Her book is Navigating the Land of If ( http://thelandofif.blogspot.com/ ).

Melissa Ford 5 pts

...and who could possibly access it. Just because you think someone doesn't know about your blog or Twitter account or FB page doesn't mean that they wouldn't find it if they tried looking for it.

Melissa writes Stirrup Queens ( http://stirrup-queens.com ) and Lost and Found ( http://lostandfoundandconnectionsabound.blogspot.c... ). Her book is Navigating the Land of If ( http://thelandofif.blogspot.com/ ).

Melissa Ford 5 pts

Twitter also feels lower stakes in one way because the relationship doesn't have to be mutual. With FB, both people have to agree to be linked to each other. With Twitter, I see it more as peeking in the windows and FB as being allowed through the front door.

Melissa writes Stirrup Queens ( http://stirrup-queens.com ) and Lost and Found ( http://lostandfoundandconnectionsabound.blogspot.c... ). Her book is Navigating the Land of If ( http://thelandofif.blogspot.com/ ).

Melissa Ford 5 pts

It's also hard when those online friendships and offline friendships mix in this online space and the way you share with the two groups needs to be balanced.

Melissa writes Stirrup Queens ( http://stirrup-queens.com ) and Lost and Found ( http://lostandfoundandconnectionsabound.blogspot.c... ). Her book is Navigating the Land of If ( http://thelandofif.blogspot.com/ ).

Melissa Ford 5 pts

REALLY good advice. I think too often we jump into burning the bridge without getting a sense of whether there was anything wrong on the other side.

Melissa writes Stirrup Queens ( http://stirrup-queens.com ) and Lost and Found ( http://lostandfoundandconnectionsabound.blogspot.c... ). Her book is Navigating the Land of If ( http://thelandofif.blogspot.com/ ).

Melissa Ford 5 pts

I wouldn't be hurt if someone I wasn't close to unfriended me. But if it was someone I was close to and had to face in the hallway at the school the next day? That would smart.

I got emotional about an unaccepted friend request once too. I couldn't believe he'd take all our other mutual friends and not me.

Melissa writes Stirrup Queens ( http://stirrup-queens.com ) and Lost and Found ( http://lostandfoundandconnectionsabound.blogspot.c... ). Her book is Navigating the Land of If ( http://thelandofif.blogspot.com/ ).

Rusty Hoe 5 pts

I think it is really easy to get caught up in the whole numbers thing whether it's FB, blogs, twitter etc. It depends how you look at 'friendship' both in the real and digital world. If I really looked at my real life friends I would day there are only a handful of close friends, then some work friends, some kids sports friends, the coffee lady I see eah morning friend and so on. Each of these groups fulfil a different role in my life and no doubt me in theirs.

The same has happened on line. There are people who have friended me and never or rarely comment. I tend to 'hide' these people rather than 'unfriend'. I'm not sure if that is the wussy way out or not but I don't really feel the need to 'unfriend' anyone unless they are toxic. For me these people are the internet equivalent of the person who you know is a regular in a store and gives you the 'hi' smile and move on.

I do think that you can met some incredible people on line (and many freaks to). People who you would never have the chance to meet in real life. For example, I have a rare illness. I met a girl in the US (I am in Aus) initially through my blog and then on FB who is like my long lost twin, same age, same number and ages of kids, same issues, same sense of humour. She has given me more support than any of my face-to-facers ever could and I would definitely class her as a friend. I think that's one of the unexpected gems of the digital age.

The anonymity of a digital identity can also allow you more freedom than in real life. It's easier to be open sometimes with people who don't know you, though I am careful in what info I give out.

I think we often forget that online friends are just people like our real-life friends and each will have their pros and cons and fulfil different roles in our lives.

vomviersen 5 pts

For me, this dates back to LiveJournal days, when I asked myself (and others too, I'm pretty sure I posted about it): why am I calling some of these people my "friends" when what they really are is "online sort-of acquaintances who read my posts and I read theirs after I read those of my real friends"?

Social media has truly devalued the word "friend" for me and that makes me a little bit sad. Although thankfully it hasn't devalued the concept of friendship - I still feel that I have good friends out there that I just haven't met in person yet, and more of those than of fake FB friends that never really were friends in any true sense of the word.

vomviersen :: Kathi Wilson
http://rottweilers.brilliant-disguise.net/
Chicago, IL

Elizabeth Howell 5 pts

I see a lot more sharing, yes, but you still have to be careful about what sort of information is online.

Personally I keep the chit-chat about harmless things and when it comes to anything personal, I send a private message inviting them out for a coffee.

Elizabeth Howell | Space Blogger/Journalist

Pars3c ( http://www.pars3c.com/ ) - turning space on its head, 3.26 light years at a time

Erin White 5 pts

I tend to use Facebook for personal interaction with my real life friends and family. If I don't know someone, I will not accept their friend request.

There are plenty of other places, notably Twitter and blog commenting systems, where I can fraternize with online contacts and acquaintances. I don't allow myself to feel pressured to accept more friends on FB for the sake of the friend count because that's not what Facebook is all about for me. Therefore, my FB friend list does not become artificially inflated in the same way that, for instance, Twitter follower counts can sometimes become, and I can say truly that what my FB friend count "means" is that I have X many friends in real life.

Out of all the social media venues you mentioned, I think probably the Flickr and YouTube metrics can get close to "meaning" something. If a link to your photos or videos is being passed around, that means your content has some appeal and that people want to share. So a visitor/view spike can represent that particular meaning.

It gets harder to ascribe meaning with Twitter because of the ridiculously inflated numbers there. You're following 50 thousand people? Really? Do you not have a job or sleep? :) In reverse, however, it may mean something. For instance, there seems to be 121,105 followers who are interested in what @Scobleizer has to say, even in 140 character bursts - however, I doubt very highly that Scoble is actually keeping up with every one of the 18,298 he's currently "following". So... what does it mean to have @Scobelizer following you? Not much that I can see!

Interesting subject, thanks for posting it.

Erin

My Mobile Adventures *~*~* ( http://MyMobileAdventures.com ) - Mobile/photo blog | @BellTinkR

The Single Rider ( http://TheSingleRider.com ) - The fine line between "alone" and "free" | @TheSingleRider

LiteMochaMom 5 pts

Really found this to be thought-provoking as I learn to navigate my online friendships and balance them with my "in-real" life friendships. The connections that I make online have been real and in some cases, profound. I'm absolutely honest with my online friends, I show them parts of myself that I don't necessarily share with others. I think that's because our online friendships are, in some ways, anonymous. I don't mean this to suggest that we don't know each other, but the friendships can be somewhat fleeting. It's a lot easier to stop visiting a blog, or to unfollow someone on Twitter than it is to do that in real life.

I work, I parent, I write
Visit me at www.coffeesandcommutes.com ( http://www.coffeesandcommutes.com )

DeanaBirks 5 pts

Wow. I'm sorry to hear that being unfriended made you cry. Now I'm wondering about the people I've unfriended on Facebook.

See, when I joined, I was just so excited to find all these people I hadn't spoken to in 20 years that I friended everyone I've ever known. After about a year, my mom and other close relatives joined and I started thinking about what I was doing on Facebook and with whom and who was overhearing it all.

So, I pruned my friends by about 90%. For every person, I asked myself, "Is this person an actual real-life friend or just someone I used to have an art class with in 4th grade? Does this person actually talk to me on Facebook?"

If someone was an actual friend, they stayed. If someone had talked to me at all, they stayed. But the people I used to know when I was 6 and they've never said a word to me since accepting me friend request...all of them got deleted.

And I honestly never considered that anyone would be hurt over it.

However, I was hurt that one college roommate did not accept my friend request. I tried twice. :(

Deana Birks
Eat. Drink. Read. Blog. ( http://www.deanabirks.com )

ddicorcia 5 pts

There are times I wanted to unfriend a friend in facebook because of something they typed. I have to remind myself that it was ’typed’ not 'said’. Many of things are misunderstood on the internet because you are not seeing the emotion or the facial expressions behind the word. Non-verbal communication is lost in social media.

If you feel offended by what you have read, here is the cure. Call the person! Have some personal contact then you will figure out it wasn’t meant they way it was read.

www.thejerseyshort.com ( http://www.thejerseyshort.com )

ddicorcia 5 pts

There are times I wanted to unfriend a friend in facebook because of something they typed. I have to remind myself that it was ’typed’ not 'said’. Many of things are misunderstood on the internet because you are not seeing the emotion or the facial expressions behind the word. Non-verbal communication is lost in social media.

If you feel offended by what you have read, here is the cure. Call the person! Have some personal contact then you will figure out it wasn’t meant they way it was read.

www.thejerseyshort.com ( http://www.thejerseyshort.com )

Melissa Ford 5 pts

It depends on the type of follower. If a random person from high school unfriended me on Facebook, I'd probably wrinkle my brow and then go about my day, not caring. If a close friend who wasn't telling me anything was amiss during our face-to-face contact suddenly unfriended me, it tells me that something is also wrong in that face-to-face friendship--but I don't know what.

Melissa writes Stirrup Queens ( http://stirrup-queens.com ) and Lost and Found ( http://lostandfoundandconnectionsabound.blogspot.c... ). Her book is Navigating the Land of If ( http://thelandofif.blogspot.com/ ).

Melissa Ford 5 pts

That's my feeling too. I would save unfriending for someone who is toxic, someone who I don't wish to have private information about me (and access to my wall), someone who has hurt me emotionally in the face-to-face world. Unless there is animosity, I wouldn't delete, just knowing what the other person goes through emotionally due to that deletion.

Melissa writes Stirrup Queens ( http://stirrup-queens.com ) and Lost and Found ( http://lostandfoundandconnectionsabound.blogspot.c... ). Her book is Navigating the Land of If ( http://thelandofif.blogspot.com/ ).

Joandthenovelist 5 pts

My 'unfriending' experiences on Facebook have been from people who sent *me* the friend request in the first place - which I find a little insulting. "Be my friend? Oh, no, you're boring DELETE!"

What's worse is, they've always been people I know here in reality. One girl I even lived with for a year - you can't get more personal!

My basic rule of thumb is this; if your basic contact, in reality or online, dwindles into nothingness, then I guess the friendship has too. But that's not to say a swift deletion doesn't hurt - what's the harm in keeping a Facebook connection even if the friendship has dwindled?

For all the latest neurotic behaviour and novelling tantrums, visit Jo and the Novelist ( http://joandthenovelist.blogspot.com )

SouthBayRantsnRaves 5 pts

One of my Twitter followers posted a quote "If you agonize over losing a follower, it's time to step away from the computer."

This is so very true. How many times are we more worried about online relationships than real life?

As far as facebook, I've gone through my friendlist a few times per year & sift through my friends list. If there's some friends that haven't contacted me in two years, I go ahead & unfriend them. I never got any drama of "why'd you unfriend me?" etc... it makes me feel better too because I don't like having ppl on my friends list that I don't communicate with. It makes no sense.

Some ppl in HS that were rude to me wanted to be my friend & I found that amusing since they wouldn't give me the time of day & all of a sudden they want to be my friend. Sad huh?

~Bianca~

Bianca is the writer behind South Bay Rants n Raves ( http://southbayrantsnraves.wordpress.com/ )

Melissa Ford 5 pts

I haven't unfriended someone yet, though I think if I did, I would give the person an explanation. There would be a clear reason. Because I know when I was unfriended, I didn't receive a reason and it hurt tremendously. Isn't it silly? It's just a website, but I cried my eyes out.

Melissa writes Stirrup Queens ( http://stirrup-queens.com ) and Lost and Found ( http://lostandfoundandconnectionsabound.blogspot.c... ). Her book is Navigating the Land of If ( http://thelandofif.blogspot.com/ ).

Melissa Ford 5 pts

I didn't know that about Myspace. How awful! Josh used to joke that they should make a companion site called "I am not your Friendster" where people could list and link to people who thought they were your friend but really weren't. The same way you'd happily skip to your inbox to see what friend requests have been accepted with FB would be an equal and opposite reaction to nervously opening your "I am not your Friendster" account.

Melissa writes Stirrup Queens ( http://stirrup-queens.com ) and Lost and Found ( http://lostandfoundandconnectionsabound.blogspot.c... ). Her book is Navigating the Land of If ( http://thelandofif.blogspot.com/ ).

cagey333 5 pts

Within a month of each other, I unfriended someone, then was unfriended myself. Actually, I agonized over the unfriending of someone more than being unfriended.

When I discovered over the weekend my friend had cut me off, I was relieved that the agony of being her friend was over. Because it has gotten to the point where it was agony and the entire Facebook Friend Thing is what had dragged it way past its expiration date.

And yes, I have also spend many sleepless nights over the past year pondering friendships. Sigh.

 Kelli Oliver George

Rancid Raves ( http://rancidraves.blogspot.com/ )

Snapgifts.com ( http://www.snapgifts.com/ )

soosee 5 pts

It really is amazing how much this "matters", right? And I think it stems back to even farther than myspace where you could arrange your "top" friends in numerical order to show importance of each one - or how they stacked in your myspace life. If you remember when aol came abt and "buddy lists", and I remember mine consisted of who knows who at one point.
I stopped tweeting when it blew up. I couldn't keep up. I've tried to keep my list on facebook 'short', but don't know if over 100 is considered short.
I've also been on the receiving end of a friendship deletion and indeed it sucks. But in this day in age, it's as easy as confirming your button click.