Bio
Rita Arens authors Surrender, Dorothy and Surrender, Dorothy: Reviews. She is BlogHer.com's senior editor.  Her parenting anthology and BlogHer'...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Recent Comments

How Do You Deal With Bossy Kids?

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 3
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Although I was quite bossy as a child, my daughter doesn't seem to be. She will complain and sometimes cry when one of her friends won't let her have her way, but she usually goes along with the crowd, rolls with the punches, or just walks away. I often hold my tongue to avoid inserting myself where I probably don't need to be inserted.

I've struggled with the difference between my daughter being a good hostess and letting her friends choose every activity. As a parent, I tire of settling arguments between a bossy kid and my offended spawn (who usually will come to me instead of standing up for herself). I am bossy myself, so I find it difficult to understand why she doesn't just say no.

Vanessa Van Patten of Radical Parenting has these tips (which I'm paraphrasing to avoid lifting her entire post, which you should read):

1. Call them on it.
2. Bring in another alpha.
3. Take a break.
4. Democracy rules.

But what if (gulp) your kid is the bossy kid? Jenne at Life Beside the Creek offers this insightful suggestion:

Seems like a bossy child is really a leader in disguise...one who likes to be in control of situations. And a bossy kid needs to learn and understand that ultimately their peers makes their own choices - right or wrong. They will choose to do the right thing, or do the wrong thing. To follow the leader or make their own way.

Statmama of Static Vox, whose daughter has autism and possibly Asberger's, has found a way to channel her bossiness into leadership by following scripts. Which, you know, could be helpful for many adults who suffer from nothing but bossiness.

However, I do not want to enable controlling behavior. What appears to outsiders to be a positive attribute (leadership skills) is actually a need for control and a struggle with rigidity. The difference between Reese and The Bossy Kid No One Likes (i.e. me as a child) is that (a) Reese has loads of self-esteem, and (b) she smiles all the time and knows how has scripts for being a good friend. Thus, bossy and domineering appears enthusiastic and helpful. What a difference the delivery makes! For it appears that a smile may be a fabulous cloaking device for Asperger's!

Why are people bossy? Is it well-developed self-esteem? A lack of empathy for others? Simple impulse-control problems? Normal childhood development?

  • 3
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
justeatit 5 pts

I'll admit my daughter is bossy, very bossy. She's very kind though and often goes up to kids (invading the 3 foot of privacy rule) and hugs them. She also looks out for others. As long as the quiet children cooperate everything is fine:) No really, she has a true ability to lead and to be kind.

It's just hard for me to watch because I was the introverted kid (still am) and I hated bossy people. They made me crazy. So, I just try to observe and if I feel she is stepping on someone's toes, I try and redirect her. It's a learning process that's for sure. 

Just Eat It

Momz Rulez 5 pts

They may or may not be natural leaders, but they need to be taught to recognize how their opinions (because that's what they are) impact others.

 When my kids were young I'd get in the middle of a situation to empower them and to take some of the momentum from the more aggressive child to keep them from steam rolling the others in the group.

 Now that they are older my kids are leaders.  Were they naturals?  I don't think there are truly naural leaders (except in rare instances).  I think there is a fine line between restraint and respect and speaking your mind and defending a sound position.

 IMHO, the first trick is to teach manners and respect.  And then you can teach leadership.  Otherwise it's running amok at the expense of those around you.

On the other hand, I'm one mom.  There are a thousand different approaches, and probably just as many positive outcomes.  I think each parent needs to really search to find their platform.  It would be so much easier if there was a guaranteed approach...

Beth Engel 5 pts

But they need to learn to be kind, empathetic leaders - and that's part of our job as parents. 

--

Beth I've been running my own personalized gifts ( http://epicmerchandise.com/ ) online store since 2003.