Bio
I'm Annie, an inactive lawyer who spends my days homeschooling my three sons, running a computer company, and pursuing my own creative endeavors. We...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

How Do You Handle an Advanced Reader?

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 1
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

So, what do you do with an advanced reader?

My oldest is eight, and I recently realized that he reads at about a high school level. While I'm delighted on one level, I'm realizing that this creates a new problem. How much should I monitor his reading?

I am certain about a few points. I firmly believe in the right and the freedom to read what each person wants to read. I think that is a necessary component of freedom of thought, and I believe the freedom of thought may be the saving grace of mankind. I also believe that no subject should be completely off limits if the boys want to ask a question or know more. For the most part, I believe it is better to encourage an open discussion than to make a subject verboten. Furthermore, I think that becoming aware of adult concepts, be it anything from death to sexuality to nuclear arms, in small doses from books is not necessarily a bad thing. By that I mean that if I had my choice between keeping the boys completely in the dark about a subject and then springing it on them in some weighty discussion or having them become slowly aware through references in their reading, I think I would prefer the latter. On a more selfish level, I also know that I want time to read my own books.

All of that said, I am still left with the question of how much I should monitor my oldest's reading? Do I need to read every book before he reads it so I can know everything to which he is exposed, thereby ending my own free reading? Should I read to protect him (and his intense love of reading) because he is sensitive and doesn't want to confront certain realities? Or should I give him the freedom to read whatever he wants while letting him know that my door is always open to discuss any questions he might have? Or is there some other happy medium?

Thoughts, anyone? 

 

Annie

www.learnateveryturn.com

www.curiousmindgarden.com

  • 1
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Cybermomma 5 pts

I have struggled with this same problem ever since my 9 year old was 5.  By the middle of K, he could easily read high school level books...but should he?  At first, I only allowed him to read books I had read before him.  But I quickly ran into the MY reading time problem as well.  He read The Hobbit at 6.  I didn't know where to go after that.  I didn't want tons of exposure to adult content.  I decided to steer him towards classics.  That has worked to avoid some of my concerns.  I have also worked to direct him towards biographies and non-fiction. 

The problem I run into most often now is the emotional content of some of the books he chooses.  He recently read the Cornelia Funke Inkheart series.  He loved them, but told me he needed to take a break halfway through the second book because it was 'too stressful'.  We found that if we read the 'stressful' sections aloud together, he can deal with the issues.  I have purposefully directed him away from books like Anne Frank's diary for those reasons.

A friend also once told me that just because he CAN read at that level doesn't mean all he reads HAS to be at that level.  My son still enjoys the Magic Tree House books.  I equate them to junk food for him.  I tell him it's okay to have some of that in your diet, but the majority of what you eat should be healthy.  I don't want him to miss some of the children's classics because they are 'too easy' for him.

I hope my thoughts help. :-)

~Education is not the filling of a pail but the lighting of a fire.
Adventures in Cyberschooling ( http://adventuresincyberschooling.blogspot.com )