Bio
Katherine is author of the blog Postpartum Progress, and a writer for Babble's Strollerderby. She has also been syndicated on BlogHer. You can follow...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

How Does A Mom With Postpartum Depression Get Help When She Can't Even Brush Her Teeth?

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 33
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

In previous posts on BlogHer, I've shared a list of symptoms of postpartum depression and anxiety, told you the key things you need to know about these and related illnesses, and connected you to a wide variety of resources to help you get better. 

Woman with hands covering face

I want to acknowledge, though, that it's really easy for me to sit here with my laptop and tell you to talk about what's going on openly with others, make that call, go to that appointment and advocate for yourself.  It probably sounds like I'm telling you to "pull yourself up by your bootstraps."  (Shudder.)

I want you to know that I realize it isn't in any way easy for you to actually do these things.   I know you are in a dark and scary place.   You may be so far down that you can't do anything but cry, or scream, or sleep, or hide, or shut down entirely.  

I remember the wide gap between the dangerous riot going on inside my head and the stoic, even emotionless face others probably saw on the outside.  For several weeks, even though it was likely clear to my loved ones that something about me didn't seem right, I kept the extent of my true feelings inside.  I was afraid, and besides, I didn't even know how to form the words to describe what was happening to me. 

I think it is quite understandable that I didn't speak at first.  It is the very antithesis of every expectation of motherhood, no matter where you live around the world, that a new mother would be sick, miserable and filled with regret, or rage, or defeat. 

It is also the very antithesis of our strong survival instinct to raise one's hand and say "Hey!  Look at me!  I've got a serious problem.  The kind of problem (Hello?! Mental!) that a lot of people don't understand, and some even look down on."  How can you protect yourself if you tell the truth?  You have your relationship, your friends, your job, your neighbors, your health insurance and your reputation to worry about.  And then there's the ultimate fear of all fears: What if they take away your child? 

On top of these feelings, you really are sick.  You may be incapable of even brushing your teeth, much less making a phone call.  It's a cruel trick that this illness incapacitates you to prevent you from fighting it.  It's like the perfect germ warfare.

Nevertheless, something must be done.  You can't stay this way.  Your life is too important.  Your new child's life is too important.  If you can do only one thing, call Postpartum Support International (PSI) at 1-800-944-4PPD.  Tell them this is the only phone call you can make and that you need as much help as you can get but you can't do much more on your own.  Alternatively, tell the closest person to you to make that call to PSI.  Tell that person you need him or her to find out where you can go, make your appointments, check into what your insurance covers, help you with childcare.  If you need to, tell that person not to ask you any questions and to simply offer you love and support until you are ready to talk.

I understand the fears you have.  I've had them too.  But none of them really materialized.  And even if a few had, I think I would still have made the same decision to reach out for help.  I'll take being healthy over anything else.

Katherine Stone is the founder and author of Postpartum Progress, the most widely-read blog on postpartum depression, postpartum OCD, postpartum anxiety and postpartum psychosis.  You can also follow her on Twitter: @postpartumprogr. 

  • 33
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
ginnycrandall 5 pts

This is encouraging. I am pregnant with my first child, and I fear that I will get PPD. I know that I shouldn't be worried about something like that, but my emotions are in over-drive right now. I have a good friend that believes in dual diagnosis treatment (from http://www.westbridge.org ), which I might try. Reading this has given me hope, though, that everything will be ok. Thank you.

Middle Ground Sages 5 pts

Jules Steffen, LMHC

Middle Ground: Where Sages Dwell ( http://middlegroundsages.wordpress.com/ )

This mother's own personal early pre- and perinatal experiences are likely being triggered - she's back in those very early times, the wounding that may be there from her own early journey into her own life - and she's unable to accomplish even the most simple things. When she gave birth to her own child, her own wounding came forward - all the things from here early existence that are not yet healed. If she were to be able to find someone who can professionally hold her early material for her as she processes it, she may likely find the healing she needs to move forward and be more present for herself and for her new baby.

Parag 5 pts

Postpartum depression is depression that occurs soon after having a baby. Risk factors include previous major depression, psychosocial stress, inadequate social support, and previous premenstrual dysphoric disorder.
Mom Depression

katstone 5 pts

First, it is so out-loud AWESOMESAUCE! that you found Postpartum Progress helpful.  That means a lot to me.

Second, thank you for sharing your story.  I hear from more than a few women who are as natural as natural gets who had PPD and avoided treatment for a long time (whether meds or therapy).  They felt with exercise, supplements, nutrition and sleep and whatever else they should be able to get over it.  (Some do, which is great.)  They didn't but continued to suffer.  They then sought professional help and were pleasantly surprised. 

I think the best thing to do is listen to your body.  If you're doing everything you can and not getting better, you may need to try something different.

Katherine Stone Postpartum Progress http://postpartumprogress.typepad.com ( http://postpartumprogress.typepad.com/ )

Christina28 5 pts

Dear Judy Anne,

Postpartum depression is a DISEASE. It may be categorized under disorder but it is a disease. I am a granola loving hippie mom who had a natural birth with midwives.  I was determined to do everything naturally. We eat organic, shun conventional medicine and all that jazz. I believed, like you, that BIG PHARMA IS EVIL. I just knew that antidepressants would make me crazy, a zombie or soulless. I suffered for 9 wretched weeks with postpartum severe onset OCD and severe PPD. I almost lost everything, for an ideal! I couldn't sleep, I couldn't eat and I was going crazy. I tried everything. Reiki, osteopathy, supplements, nutrition, exercise, therapy etc... During my pregnancy I took 10 grams of fish oil a day!! I saw a naturopath etc...They all shrugged their shoulders while I was losing my life to my beliefs. Their was no disappointment at my husband's reaction or other b.s! I was sick.  I took antidepressants. They worked quickly, with few side effects and gave me my life back. I plan  never to go off of them. I don't want to. And the funny thing was, my psychiatrist was more compassionate than my midwives. My biggest help was Postpartum Progress because she gets it. I will not listen to anyone telling me what I should do anymore. I do what works.

sera22 5 pts

First of all, Katherine - I continue to be amazed at the comments being left by survivor moms. Thank you for sharing your story and creating an environment where we can all talk about this stuff. To all of you moms leaving comments about your struggles - a big "heck yes!" to you for making it through - one way or another - and for sharing parts of your stories here.

Finally,  I want to list some resources/sites that support my views in response to my last response from Judy Anne.

It may have been more accurate for me to use the word "disorder" or even "medical illness" (http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/depression/DS0017... as opposed to the word disease, although there is a philosophical debate out there relating to this very subject (http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/evil-deeds/200... ( http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/evil-deeds/200... )), so I do not feel that my wording was inappropriate.

The National Alliance for Mental Illness does cite depression as a biologicially-based brain disease, though, as the following quote states:

"During the last few decades, however, scientific research has greatly expanded our understanding and firmly established that mental illnesses like major depression are biologically based brain diseases." http://www.nami.org/Content/ContentGroups/Helpline...

That being said, I think that whole issue is small potatoes compared to what I was trying to get across in my post. Disease vs. disorder? I don't think the semantics are what's important in this discussion.

I also realize there are many, many different opinions on the heated topic of whether or not to use antidepressants. I love the fact that we are all free to express our opinions, and even when we disagree, we can still learn from each other. I am not here to engage in a debate or an argument, I just respectfully disagree with some of your thoughts.

I would just like to include further sources regarding my original comment, for you and for any other readers who would like to know about the resources that support some of the views I discussed.

In that first comment, I referenced the book "Women’s Moods" by Dr. Deborah Sichel and Jeanne Watson Driscoll as the source that helped me learn about the more scientific aspects of women’s moods and emotions. Other things I wrote were my opinions that I thought came across clearly as opinions, but since we’re on the topic, I will go ahead and add some sources below (none of which are propaganda from pharmaceuticals), just to show that there are experts and what I believe to be credible resources out there that support my views.

I did see that you referenced Dr. Hyman in your comment, and in response to that - I also discussed that I was on fish oil and I was not one of the lucky ones who has a lower chance of getting depression because of it. There seemed to be a big emphasis on lack of things in our diet, etc. But, what some of us are trying to say is that even when those gaps are filled, we may still suffer from depression.

It was statements like thisone of yours that bothered me...

"Giving someone an antidepressant not only posses more health risks, but about half of the patients say they don't work, further showing they aren't the answer for most people."

It bothered me because it had no solid research and or resource backing up this statement. I have no problem with people voicing opinions, but I am concerned that some mothers who are suffering alone and do not have much info on PMD may take this the wrong way:

So, to illustrate my point, I am including the following information below. 

Points 1, 2, and 3 are all from the following resource:

http://www.nami.org/Content/ContentGroups/Helpline...

1. “Biological treatments are effective overall, and most people with biological depression get significant relief from medications—whether the depression is mild or severe, recent or long-term”

2. “The STAR*D study noted above has already shown that it can take up to six to eight weeks to get a good response to treatment and that people should keep trying different strategies. For instance, one-third of people who did not get better with a first treatment got all symptoms reduced (into remission) with the addition of a second medicine. Another one-quarter improved to remission after switching to another antidepressant. This study helps to support the idea that staying with the battle against depression is essential.”

3. “It is recognized that the longer a person remains depressed, the harder successful treatment becomes.”

Doctors and patients can decide together whether or not the risks outweigh the benefits. This a personal decision that a woman needs to make with a medical professional.

Let's also consider these additional statements...

Numbers 4 and 5 are from:

http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/depression/DS0017... ( http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/depression/DS0017... )

4. "Numerous depression treatments are available. Medications and psychological counseling (psychotherapy) are very effective for most people."

5. "Usually the most effective treatment for depression is a combination of medication and psychotherapy."

Number 6 is from: http://www.cdc.gov/Features/Depression/

6. "Most adults see an improvement in their symptoms when treated with antidepressant drugs, psychotherapy, or a combination of both."

Number 7 is from:

From: http://www.nami.org/Content/ContentGroups/Helpline...

“Psychotherapy is another way to help manage depression and research demonstrates that a combination of medication and psychotherapy is often the most effective treatment.”

Ok, that's all. :)

alexistlesa 5 pts

I've suffered from clinical and postpartum depression with both of my children, and I've taken antidepressants twice, after the births of each. The first time I noticed I was depressive after my first child, I was eyeing a kitchen knife, wondering if it would hurt to slit my wrist. So no, I don't think I would have responded well had someone told me that I needed to change my diet to deal with suicidal thoughts. There's a time when changes in diet may help prevent the onset of depression, but there's also a time for medication. I'm convinced that psychotherapy and antidepressants saved my life, and have since saved the life of a very dear friend.

Also, lack of sleep may be a huge part of depression, but try telling a new mother with an infant that all she needs to do to save her own life is to get more sleep -- she'll probably tell you to bugger off. Not everyone is able to get 8 hours of sleep a night, not everyone is able to make the diet changes that will help curb depression symptoms: I could barely make a sandwich when I was in the depths, let alone design a healthy eating plan.

I think it's just irresponsible to label pharmaceutical companies as the enemy. Yes, pharmaceuticals is a hugely profitable business, and as such, there are motivations other than the wellbeing of consumers in play. However, the money being funneled into the industry is what makes way for innovation in treatments; without the money being generated, there would be no capital for research. So while it's important to be educated about the medication you're being prescribed and to make an effort to seek out different methods of treatment, it's not a crime to take antidepressants if you are truly suffering from major depression.

There's already enough of a stigma around depression and antidepressants without people who don't know any better thinking that you can treat PPD and depression with fish oil. I don't discount the research that this may help in the long run, but as many of the other commenters have said, sometimes antidepressants are just the thing you need to pull yourself out of the mire. And that's OK.

alexis

www.depressionsandconfessions.com ( http://www.depressionsandconfessions.com )

Just_Margaret 8 pts

I completely appreciate your approach--what we consume has *major* implications to our overall health, physically and mentally.  But I would hesitate to discount meds as a last resort only.

When I suffered from PPD myself, concocting an entirely new diet to attempt to battle my depression would have sent me reeling even further.  Too much work, frankly...I was one of those PPD cases that could barely drag her self out of bed and brush her teeth.  

I found that therapy/counseling in conjunction with medication, got me where I needed to be.  And that place is where I am now--managing depression (I do suffer from SAD as well) with diet and exercise. I wouldn't be here typing this today if I hadn't 'gotten over the hump' with antidepressants--I did have a chemical imbalance, and I had to effectively train my brain to fire properly again. The meds helped in that respect.

I think it's the appropropriate route for some sufferers of PPD.

~Margaret

Just Margaret ( http://maurhoffbarney.blogspot.com )

Work Experience Edublog 7 pts

Sera22, unfortunately you have a misunderstanding of what depression is categorized as, it is not a "disease" as you have claimed. It is listed as a "disorder" (DSM) and there are different types of depression.

I'm glad you pointed out that we shouldn't listen to an opinion without backup (as I provided in my post), but didn't notice where your information was gathered from. Taking facts, from valid sources, (not pharma companies propaganda) is what's needed.

Did you know that most of the people who thought that the antidepressant that "helped" them actually did nothing and they felt better because they weren't clinically depressed? They actually had a minor episode due to the usual ups and downs of life--something that doesn't require medication--but rather talk therapy instead. Too often people lump depression into one pile, herein lies the problem.

PPD is a complex issue that is still being investigated. Some other issues that play into it could be: disappointment with a partners reaction (lack of help from them), finding out the partner has committed adultry during pregnancy (unfortunately, all too common), vague feelings of being "cheated" in some way (possibly from pressure to have a child), loss of routine (job, social contacts, sleep), etc. These additional reasons show that it's important to get to the root of the issue, as I've said previously, not put a band-aid on it, causing more problems. It might be more than one issue, but several in play, such as diet and overwhelm (exhaustion from lack of sleep can make one feel psychotic).

Data regarding meds in breast milk, being transferred to the baby, should raise concerns too. I don't believe anyone mentioned that at all here.

Being intelligent, getting valid information, making wise decisions and doing what does the least amount of harm to mother and child, first, is what I advocated. Sometimes it means changing doctors, researching as much information as possible from different sources, and relying on those around you (partner, family, friends, co-workers) to support you.

Stating that someone bringing in a cautious approach is "assuming" too much shows some overreaction at best.

Judy Anne Cavey-Educator/Writer-Work Experience Edublog creator: http://workforcedevelopment.edublogs.org/

katstone 5 pts

"Women's Moods" (by Dr. Deborah Sichel and Jeanne Watson Driscoll) is actually the very first book I read that mentioned postpartum OCD, which is what I suffered.  I couldn't believe someone had actually put what happened to me into words.  It's a great book for all women as it covers women's emotional health throughout life, from hormones' impact during menstruation, to pregnancy, to the postpartum period to perimenopause and menopause.  I highly recommend it.

Katherine Stone Postpartum Progress http://postpartumprogress.typepad.com ( http://postpartumprogress.typepad.com/ )

katstone 5 pts

Thank you Mama Murtz!  And way to go to your OB!  A well-trained obstetrician or pediatrician who makes it his or her business to watch out for perinatal mood and anxiety disorders can have such an amazing impact on the health of a new mother. 

Katherine Stone Postpartum Progress http://postpartumprogress.typepad.com ( http://postpartumprogress.typepad.com/ )

katstone 5 pts

I'm so sorry to hear about your family's losses.  What an incredible burden.  I am glad, though, that you have found what works for you and have had a great 4 years.  I wish you many more years of continued wellness!  Keep reading those books!

Katherine Stone Postpartum Progress http://postpartumprogress.typepad.com ( http://postpartumprogress.typepad.com/ )

katstone 5 pts

I guess we are going to have to agree to disagree, Judy Anne.  I do not believe antidepressants should always be a "last resort" as you state.  In fact, I think it's dangerous to convince women of that.

The research I believe you are referring to finds that antideressants are, in fact, effective for people who have severe depression ( http://postpartumprogress.typepad.com/weblog/2010/... ), and perhaps even for moderate depression as well.  They don't seem to have much effect, though, for people who have mild depression, in that one study. 

I worry that someone who reads your words and has severe depression will avoid medication.  She may prolong her suffering and that of her family and child ( http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=m... ).  I'm sure you wouldn't advocate a woman ending up having chronic depression the rest of her life because she remained untreated for postpartum depression ( http://postpartumprogress.typepad.com/weblog/2010/... ), or used treatments that weren't effective.  

By the way, I still take an antidepressant for my OCD prescribed by my expert psychiatrist, I have no shame in taking it, and I would like to stay there's not a thing about me that is "zombie"-like.  I do believe that there are lots of doctors irresponsibly whipping out prescriptions.  Something needs to be done about that.  I also can't stand the TV commercials for and overmarketing of medications.  I wish something would be done about that as well.  But those are completely separate issues from women seeking medical help for severe perinatal mood and anxiety disorders.

Katherine Stone Postpartum Progress http://postpartumprogress.typepad.com ( http://postpartumprogress.typepad.com/ )

Lauren Hale 5 pts

Sera -

Thank you. Your post was very well stated too.

I really do not like mothers being judged for choosing or needing to take medication to recover. It's also not fair to dismiss an entire course of treatment for women. Granted, it's one that should be approached with an educated view but to assume that there are all these mother just "taking pills" really irritates me.

Be the change you wish to see. - Mahatmas Ghandi

Dearest Fatty 5 pts

I had Post natal depression with my eldest child. I felt there was nothing I could do. I wasn't close enough to my mother to tell her, my husband had his own depression and the NHS way of finding out if you have PND is to have the health visitor ask you on week 3 if you have PND!!

Of course EVERYONE smiles and says no....because you want to be seen to be coping.

I personally think  that mothers who have had difficult births, preemie babies or are far from their families should be flagged by the health system to be treated as though they do have PND. To be given extra visits, help, even just encouraged to go to mother and baby groups so you can talk ot other mothers.

The internet would have been a godsend to me in 2000 (when I had no computer), places like BlogHer help mothers to talk honestly about their feelings without worrying about being seen as flakey.

Is it your flab or your brain you need to fight? Answers on a postcard please. My blog is HERE ----> http://thealmostcarlessfamily.blogspot.com/ Ah go on..you kow you want to peek ;)

sera22 5 pts

Lauren, I just wanted to say how much I appreciate what you had to say. Very well put, and very encouraging. Thank you.

katstone 5 pts

Dearest,

I'm so sorry to hear that the resources weren't there for you in 2000.  I thought I'd mention that there are some groups now in the UK to support women with postnatal depression.  [For readers in the US, in the UK postpartum depression is called either postnatal illness (PNI) or postnatal depression (PND).]  Some of those groups include:

United Kingdom

Perinatal Illness UK ( http://www.pni-uk.com/ )

The Association for Postnatal Illness ( http://apni.org/ )

Postnatal Illness ORG UK ( http://www.pni.org.uk/index.htm )

Mother's Voice ( http://www.mothersvoice.org.uk/ )

Action Postpartum Psychosis ( http://www.app-network.org/ )

Take A Break's Chums4Mums ( http://www.takeabreak.co.uk/chums4mums )

Meet A Mum Association ( http://www.mama.co.uk/ )

Also, the risk factors you mentioned (premature birth, difficult birth and lack of social support or being far from their families) are all things that can lead to a higher likelihood of postpartum depression.  These are things the obstetrician should watch for.

Katherine Stone Postpartum Progress http://postpartumprogress.typepad.com ( http://postpartumprogress.typepad.com/ )

Lauren Hale 5 pts

I whole-heartedly agree that taking a pill does not fix anything.

It's a bit akin to putting the key in the ignition and then sitting back and waiting for your car to start itself.

Sure, there are some cars out there that have push-button technology and will start right up. But other cars need more care, more finessing. And you know what? It's NOT their fault. It's just how they were built - a difference in engineering if you will.

In addition to putting the key in the ignition, you have to provide forward force to turn the key - to create sparks and get the engine revving which is what starts the journey. For many of us who have fought severe Postpartum Depression, we needed help to create our sparks. WE needed the medication to propel us forward. We also needed therapy, exercise, and proper nutrition.

TO assume we are simple "taking a pill" is absolutely ludicrous. How do you know we did not exhaust all possibilities? Have you read our medical records? Have you had a deep and intimate conversation with our prescribing physicians, our therapists, our family members? Do you truly think that it was an easy decision for us to make? We were mothers faced with a very difficult decision indeed. Unable to function, unable to enjoy what everyone else told us we should be smiling and laughing about. So yes, some of us took pills. Some of us combined them with therapy, exercise, supplements, and mother's groups.

I can assure you that I encourage new mothers seeking help to have their doctors rule out all other physical causes for their depression. I warn them that taking an anti-depressant when there is in fact, a thyroid or anemia problem can cause additional issues which is why it is SO important to request these tests when talking about depression during pregnancy or the postpartum period. I advise them to run, not walk, from any doctor shoving a prescription at them after barely listening to what's going on in their lives. Because you are absolutely right - there ARE irresponsible physicians out there writing scripts for anti-depressants when they are not needed. The key here IS for more patients to be educated and aware of the causes, the choices, and to truly advocate for the best care possible for themselves.

The reason I am so passionate about helping women with postpartum mood disorders is not to get them hooked on Big Pharma. It is to help them realize they are not alone. It is to educate them and guide them through their difficult experience. I was hopelessly alone during mine and yes, I took meds. I even had a bad reaction to one. So I know what the cost is to take them. But the decision to take a med is between a woman and her doctor. All I can do is offer education/guidance for both sides of the situation and let her take the lead. And then, I listen. Without judgment, without prejudice, I listen. Filled with compassion and offering open arms. Because the last thing a struggling new mom needs to feel is more guilt and anxiety. 

Warmest,

Lauren

Be the change you wish to see. - Mahatmas Ghandi

sera22 5 pts

While I will agree that many things play an important role in our mental and physical well-being, such as proper nutrition, getting plenty of sunlight, exercising regularly, taking vitamins/supplements as appropriate, getting therapy, etc., we cannot forget the fact that depression is a disease, and it deserves to be treated as such.

For example, people with high cholesterol can make changes to their lifestyle, but many still need to be on a medication to effectively manage it. The same goes for depression. Each individual's circumstances may vary, as will their response to various treatments. Sometimes lifestyle changes simply do not do the trick.

I went 3 months suffering from postpartum depression and anxiety before I was diagnosed. I did not have a diagnosis of either of these before I had my daughter. Once I became aware of what was going on, I modified my lifestyle (more exercise, more time outside, better food choices, etc.), and got counseling, but those things alone did not do the trick. I would also like to add that I was taking fish oil during my entire pregnancy and postpartum period, and that didn't stop me from getting depression.

Eliminating antidepressants as an option, or giving women the message that they should only be used as a last resort, reinforces the guilt and the unrealistic expectations we tend to put on ourselves already, as if to tell mothers that something is wrong with us if we can't simply "fix" our depression by eating right, exercising, taking omega-3s, etc. I can't imagine how much more my family and I would have suffered if I'd waited any longer to get on some medication!

For me, antidepressants made a tremendous difference in my life. It wasn't until I got on an antidepressant and it began working effectively that I realized I'd forgotten what it was like to feel like myself. Antidepressants gave me myself back.

Are they for everyone? No. But to present such a one-sided opinion that is not even backed up with specific research is simply not fair to mothers who are vulnerable and may be suffering.

To those who wonder about whether antidepressants are just a ploy by the pharmaceutical companies and whether or not women can just "snap out" of depression after giving birth, I'd invite you to read Women's Moods: What Every Woman Must Know About Hormones, the Brain, and Emotional Health. ( http://www.amazon.com/Womens-Moods-Hormones-Emotio... )

The book really helped me to understand the very delicate hormonal balances in the brain, and how they can be disturbed at various points in a woman's life. It helped me realize that it is not my FAULT that I suffer from depression, but that being pregnant and giving birth threw my brain chemistry a bit out of whack.

I have tried one time, with my doctor's approval, to stop my antidepressants, and another time, to decrease the dose (again, with my doctor's approval) - I found out very quickly after each trial period that it was simply not an option for me to be off the medication I think I just had to prove to myself that I couldn't do it alone.

It's also common knowlege that one can find research to back up whatever one's opinion is. There's research that says antidepressants are effective, and research that states the contrary. All we need to do is a simple Google search to find an article that backs up whatever our opinion is.

I thought depression could be "cured" on one's own or by making simple changes - until I suffered from it myself.

I would just like to say to any mothers who may be out there and feel that they may be having symptoms of a postpartum mood disorder - there are MANY ways that you can get better. Some of us need medication, and some of us don't. How you get well doesn't matter - as long as you reach out to get the help you need. Do your own research - weigh your options, and talk with a professional that you trust.

And be careful what information you choose to take to heart. It's always a red flag when strong opinions are presented with no resources to back them up, and when both sides of an issue are not presented.

katstone 5 pts

There is ZERO excuse for it taking 6 months for people to call you back.  I would say if that ever happens with a PSI coordinator, one should call the PSI main office immediately and ask why.  Or email me and tell me where you live and we will find someone who WILL call back.

In terms of not having the resources to get the help you need, I wrote this post about that on my blog Postpartum Progress: How To Get Help For Postpartum Depression If You Have No Insurance ( http://postpartumprogress.typepad.com/weblog/2009/... ).  You may find the tips helpful.

Katherine Stone Postpartum Progress http://postpartumprogress.typepad.com ( http://postpartumprogress.typepad.com/ )

Anderzoid 5 pts

This post will be part of my hospital bag and this phone number will be next to the pediatricians. Thank you for suggestions on how to slowly ask for help. With my first pregnancy, the hospital had a contract for you and your partner to look over and sign. It basically had a few of the differences between baby blues and PPD. Unfortunately, every resource I called on that list didnt quite understand that I was unable to actually GO get the help they were suggesting (nor could I pay for it as  newly SAHM). It was 6 long months of waiting for the local PPD resources to even call me back. My husband believed it was my responsibility to take care of myself and the baby. When I was finding these difficult, it felt like I was an unfit mother. It still is a worry as I wait for my second child; will my family continue to believe that if you struggle then you shouldn't be a mom? Who is it safe to ask for help? I wish I would have had this short script to say, can you please call for me and wait to ask me questions.

Anti-depressants can definitely be the first resort. With a clear mind I was able to start getting help myself.

Mama Murtz 5 pts

I wasn't aware that I was living with PPD for over one year.  It was much more than sadness, indecision, and lack of interest.  I mourned the loss of my pregnancy (which fruited me a beautiful, full-term princess), and I couldn't stand the thought or sight of a pregnant woman.  I tolerated them, but was very uncomfortable.  That was the least of my worries.  When I went for my OB appt one year after my daughter's birth, my OB pinned me right there.  I had been living with PPD for over a year, and I was so glad she found it.

Thank you for this post, thank you from so many parts of me. :)

Hey Jen 9 pts

Going to get way personal here...

I was practically forced onto antidepressants after my brother died. When I was 20, about a month and a half after my baby was born, my brother died unexpectedly at the age of 11. In the aftermath I also lost another brother directly related to our brothers death. He didn't die, but his innocence did and he was taken from us. I happened to be seeing a therapist at the time and she shoved me off onto a psychiatrist immediately who prescribed me drugs right away because they were worried I might hurt myself or worse. I have a history of severe depression/suicide attempts so it was understandable that they might be worried about it, but I never took them. My children helped ground me and kept me from sinking into oblivion. 

I still get depressed on and off, but I have learned how to take it day by day/hour by hour and even to self-medicate by reading. I've gone through periods where I have gone through 20 to 30 books in less than a month. It helps me, unless I'm buying the books. Then it just gets damned expensive. :|

It's been nearly 4 years since I last had an episode. It's not a fun place to be and I truly hope that anyone who is feeling depressed will try to reach out. It's hard, sometimes desperately hard, but all you have to do is reach out. 

Work Experience Edublog 7 pts

I certainly didn't count out one entire treatment, I said antidepressants should be approached as basically the last resort after investigating the logical others. I think you need to do some research on antidepressants and their lack of effectiveness, dangerous side affects and how pharma companies are making billions off of people taking them. The rate at which antidepressants are prescribed is beyond alarming. Our country now has millions of people who are "zombies" because of the irresponsible way doctors are doleing out these potent drugs.

The rates of suicides attributed to antidepressants should scare the Food and Drug Administration into clamping down on how they are too easily distributed. As if that isn't bad enough, we are flooded with TV ads to sell these drugs.

When someone is suicidal, or likely to hurt someone else due to their depression, then that is a case for therapy and possibly antidepressants. It depends. But again, all avenues should be investigated before being put on meds.

It's not what "a woman feels comfortable" doing, it's doing what she needs to actually take care of the root of the problem. Taking a pill is not the answer.

Judy Anne Cavey-Educator/Writer-Work Experience Edublog creator: http://workforcedevelopment.edublogs.org/

katstone 5 pts

I don't think it's fair to say that antidepressants should be off the list of treatment options.  There are several options.  Psychotherapy is quite effective.  There is research now looking into Omega-3s, acupuncture ... I think a woman needs to try what she is comfortable with.  But to count out one entire treatment option isn't fair.  For some, an antidepressant is what works.  For others, it may be exercise and nutrition.   If what you choose leads you to be able to be a happy and healthy mom, then wonderful!  It is my hope that more and more research can be done so that we can identify the most effective treatments with the least side effects.

I do agree with you, though, that it is important for the doctor to look for underlying conditions that can mimic or cause the symptoms of postpartum depression, like thyroiditis. 

Full disclosure:  in my case I took an antidepressant and went consistently to therapy.  Both things worked for me.

Katherine Stone Postpartum Progress http://postpartumprogress.typepad.com ( http://postpartumprogress.typepad.com/ )

Work Experience Edublog 7 pts

While the depression associated with postpartum is very real, it also has a component with what the mother needs to be eating.

Much research is being done on how we are not getting the nutrients we need, along with the toxins in our environment, affecting us mentally and physically. In The UltaMind Solution, by Dr. Mark Hyman, he points to a lack of Omega3's as being the issue with postpartum depression.

Flax seed meal and salmon both provide a good dose of the Omega3's needed for optimum mental and physical health.

Dr. Hyman points out, "DHA from fish oils is a critical part of a mother's milk that helps neurological development in the baby" and "Women who have higher levels of Omega3 fats in their tissues have lower rates of postpartum depression."

With so many in our country on antidepressive meds, unnecessarily I might add, we need to stop trying to treat depression with pills. We first must look at the most common factors for depression: diet, low functioning thyroid, Seasonal Affective Disorder (lack of sunlight in winter months), etc., and treat accordingly. Giving someone an antidepressant not only posses more health risks, but about half of the patients say they don't work, further showing they aren't the answer for most people.

Judy Anne Cavey-Educator/Writer-Work Experience Edublog creator: http://workforcedevelopment.edublogs.org/

Maria Niles 9 pts

This is an excellent post, Katherine for women going through PPD because of your ability to speak honestly and generously from your experience. But it is also good information for anyone dealing with depression and for those of us who haven't dealt with PPD to be better able to support women around us who might be in need. Thanks.

BlogHer Contributing Editor ( http://www.blogher.com/blog/maria-niles ) PopConsumer ( http://consumerpop.typepad.com/popconsumer ) Beyond Help ( http://mariax.vox.com/ )

katstone 5 pts

You did the best you could at the time.  Those things do happen.  But you know more now, and some day you may in fact be able to speak if you see something like that again.  That's all we can do.

Katherine Stone Postpartum Progress http://postpartumprogress.typepad.com ( http://postpartumprogress.typepad.com/ )

katstone 5 pts

You are definitely NOT alone.  It's so nice to know that, isn't it?  I thought I was when I had postpartum OCD.  It still blows my mind to this day to know there are hundreds of thousands all around me going through the same thing.

Katherine Stone Postpartum Progress http://postpartumprogress.typepad.com ( http://postpartumprogress.typepad.com/ )

IsleDance 5 pts

Well said.  I wish I'd had the words to speak up for someone years ago.  Maybe she wouldn't have left her baby and family behind...

One Friday night, Isle Dance ( http://isledance.blogspot.com ) loaded up her life and headed out...

celiapants 5 pts

i read this and can't help but get a bit teary.  i feel so much better now (my baby is 11 months old) and i don't know if there ever was anything truly 'wrong' with me.  but there were long months when i was just so happy when the morning came and i felt like it might be a good day.  there were days when i would stay in my jammies and cry and wonder why every one else who had had a baby lately was just fine and thought it was easy-peasy and i was finding it SO hard.  there is and was nothing i wouldn't do for my little girl but i hated being me and doing it...i felt like i was depriving her of something important - a mommy who wasn't such a wreck and a failure. 

reading your post makes it a little bit more real to me that i wasn't and am not alone. 

thank you

www.sweetlittlebrowneyes.com ( http://www.sweetlittlebrowneyes.com )