Bio
Stephanie is a former behavioral health clinician who traded in the glitz and glamour of human services for stay-at-home motherhood. She is the proud...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Do Crying Kids Really Bother You All That Much?

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 43
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

I had an experience a few months ago, and then again last night, that gave me pause, and I'd really like to know: Do kids crying in public really annoy you? I mean, does that really bother people?

I will admit, before my propagatory ship came in, I was the first person to belch out, "Ugh! Kids!" at any appropriate juncture. The mere mention of children and the possibility that I may have to share real estate with them automatically activated the Eye Roll/Melodramatic Sigh Reflex. I realized, however, that children were people, too, and I couldn't discriminate based on inability to control one's impulses, form a sentence, or wipe one's own tush, as much as my insides quaked to do so. I accepted children, much as I do reality TV stars, as a functional part of our society, and moved on.

Violet Studying The Crying Baby

Before Christmas, I had been afforded a quiet afternoon at the mall with my son. We strolled around Macy's, browsing clothing racks and Christmas decorations. A few ornaments caught my eye, and I decided to pick them up. Excited to include my son in our newly formed Christmas traditions, I allowed him to inspect and guard our ornaments until we were ready to leave the store.

When we arrived at the customer service kiosk, I knew I'd have to wrestle them from his hands, causing a potential tear-and-glitter storm. I eyed a big wheel truck sitting nearby, and offered a trade. He'd unhand the ornaments, and I'd let him borrow the truck for a few moments. This plan went swimmingly until it was time to leave -- without the truck.

I use the Band Aid Approach often, and it works, so I leaned down, asked him for the truck, and told him it was time to go. A wandering employee had taken notice and attempted to give me a hand. She bent down into the stroller and asked him if she could see the truck. He handed her the truck without realizing he wouldn't get it back, and then started kicking, as large tears fell from his eyes. I attempted to roll away quickly, which would have both a) changed his mind, and b) gotten us the freak out of there, but the employee, so affected by the tragedy before her, gave me the exaggerated sad face and whined, "Awwwwwwwwwwwwwww. He's crying! Can I give him back the truck?" Seriously? Seriously, lady? Can you give him back the truck? Are you kidding me?! No, dammit, you can't give him back the truck! Walk away! Walk away NOW!

"Oh, no. Thanks," I managed. "We have plenty of trucks at home. I'm, uh, we're -- just going to get going now. Thank you," I smiled, lowered my eyes, and rolled my son away. He sniffed for a few seconds, and -- Poof! -- all better!

Not thirty seconds later, another employee, walking in the opposite direction, eyed my son, leaned in, told him how handsome he was, and then noticed the fresh tears on his cheeks.

"Ooooooohhhhh. He's got tears on his face. Was he crying?" No. I just freshened him up. He needs a bit of a spritz from time to time.

"Oh," I responded, "It's nothing. He wanted a toy and, well, we have to go."

"Aw, he can't have the toy?" she asked, cocking her head in my son's direction.

At that point, I was ready to lose it. I told her that no, indeed, he couldn't, and that we needed to go, and continued towards the exit. And I seriously considered taking a long, hard look at a Macy's policy manual.

So I ask you, is it that painful to see a kid cry? Don't kids, like, cry a lot? Isn't that a hallmark of being a baby? Par for the course of parenthood? Call me cold and objective, but crying children don't really stab at my heart, unless there's a reason, a real reason for their tears. For the most part, they cry, they stop, they cry again, they move on, and we move on. That's it. I realized the sound of children bothered me all those years, but certainly not the individual sounds they were making.

Now, last night, after a very successful afternoon out, we decided to attempt dinner at a restaurant. This had only been done three times since the addition of the twins to our family, and only once successfully. I was optimistic, but by no

  • 43
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
robotheart 13 pts

While the sound of children crying *does* bother me (especially if the venue is not particularly kid-appropriate), I would never, ever say in front of a child, to the parent, that the parent should cave to whatever it is the kid's crying about. Who does that? Not only is it undermining, but unless the parent is physically hurting the child, what on earth business is it of mine?

jayellehughes 6 pts

yes... especially when I'm enjoying my coffee and laptop in Starbucks lol. I watched my friend's baby once for just an hour and he started crying. I was like, WOW I don't know how much more of this I can take... just being honest!

Polish Mama on the Prairie 27 pts

Clever sales tactic they used there, trying to guilt trip mom into buying a toy to avoid looking mean. *roll my eyes* You did the right thing. I'll admit, before kids, I didn't understand why parents couldn't just make them quiet. Then I had kids and realized there is no "off" button, silly me. And I love children now. Even when they cry.

mommabethyname 17 pts

Polish Mama on the Prairie Me too! Even though I wasn't much of a fan in my earlier years.

Sand In My Eyes 8 pts

When my son was a baby, it felt like my heart was being ripped out of my chest when he was crying; I was sure that everyone around me was feeling the same level of discomfort as I. By the time my daughter was born, I had more experience with being aware of how I was affected by crying babies that are not mine. The answer is, I'm not.

What I am affected by, especially on planes, is children over the age of 3, whining and screaming their heads off because for once they are being required to obey when they are so used to getting their way. They don't understand why they have to sit in a seat with a seatbelt on when they don't feel like it, and outside of this experience, they have never been required to listen to their parents. But that's another issue entirely to the one that you are writing about, so I'll leave my rant at that.

Here in the Middle East, people can not stand crying children. "Just give her candy!" they will say, and then offer it directly to her when I've already refused. It's very undermining. Big pet peeve. Good for you, getting out of the store without having another fight on your hands over a toy truck because well-meaning strangers wanted to make themselves feel better.

Audrey @Mom Drop Box 9 pts

I never realized until having kids that they are such little attention magnets. I think people just love to look at and talk about little kids, and will take any opportunity to do so. Crying kids don't bother me, & I like to think that most people that have kids are sympathetic to the parents of the crying child.

LucindaA 36 pts

I probably worried more about my kids crying in public than I did about other people's kids. The only time it really bothers me is if a child is crying during a public performance of some kind and it interferes with my ability to enjoy said performance. Take your crying child out. It's rude not too. Restaurants are a gray area. It depends upon the kind of restaurant as to whether or not it bothers me.

Otherwise, when I hear a child crying, I mostly feel sorry for the parent because I know it can be hard to be in public with a crying child. Child may be tired, sick, cranky, hungry, etc. and all those things are more difficult to deal with than happy and peaceful. I don't generally comment on it other than to occasionally look at mom and say, "Yes, I've been there too."

midnightbliss 12 pts

i'm not really bothered with crying kids as long as they are not crying the whole duration of the trip and i'm not tired specially when traveling in enclosed vehicles like passenger boats or buses.

ynnej 6 pts

Oooh yes I am constantly worried that my kids are bothering someone, I also limit the places we go to places I am comfortable with them crying or where I have a good escape route. Except Target - Target is where all children go to scream. It is like some kind of unwritten children's law.

JennaHatfield 135 pts

I wrote about it this weekend as well as an infant being baptized in church cried the WHOLE TIME (before the ceremony, during, after, heh). It made me remember how much I thought I was bothering absolutely everyone when my child cried... and how it didn't bother me a bit that this kid was. Or that another kid did too. I hope the mom up front on Sunday knows that we have all been there, done that.

Conversation from Twitter

nightdaystudios
nightdaystudios

blogher They definitely don't (usually) stab at my heart. Can't believe those employees tried to interfere!!

MommaBeThyName
MommaBeThyName

nightdaystudios That was a little out of line, no??

nightdaystudios
nightdaystudios

MommaBeThyName sure seems like it! And two in a row seems kind of weird!

MommaBeThyName
MommaBeThyName

nightdaystudios It was the holiday season lol. Maybe commission?

nightdaystudios
nightdaystudios

MommaBeThyName Let's hope - haha. Or maybe that makes it worse ...

TheAmyTucker
TheAmyTucker

blogher I've been where you are with both things. The store part bugs me the worst.. Just when you have it handled they sabotage you...

MommaBeThyName
MommaBeThyName

theamytucker What's up with that??

TheAmyTucker
TheAmyTucker

MommaBeThyName I'm pretty sure they're asking to be smacked...all of them are asking. :D

danielpelfrey
danielpelfrey

blogher Not nearly as much as I hate people who hate crying kids (especially on a plane - people need to have more compassion)

BlogHer
BlogHer

danielpelfrey Agreed. -Momo

LenaLoves2011
LenaLoves2011

BlogHerMoms depends on where I'm at and the age of the kid.

TheNewCinders
TheNewCinders

BlogHerMoms when they're sat behind me on a flight for 2 hrs I'd have to say quite a lot!

Conversation from Facebook

Polish Mama on the Prairie
Polish Mama on the Prairie

If you don't take them out in public, then they don't know how to behave. Just my opinion. Take them out in public and if someone has a problem, oh well.

Snigdha Sen
Snigdha Sen

Usually not. Can't recall the last time it bothered me...

Alexandra Davies
Alexandra Davies

Crying? Meh. Not that bad. 3-6 year olds being loud and whiny in a fancy restaurant late at night? I *SO* wanted to say something... (This was at a resort...I assume the parents thought they were avoiding most customers by going at the end of the night, and I wasn't even that bothered by the kids running around...but the whining, OMG. I was seriously annoyed. This was on our honeymoon, we're not usually resort-frequenters!)

She Writes It
She Writes It

For me - it's like finger nails on a chalkboard. I have 3, but that's why I usually keep them at home, lol. When kids aren't behaving out in public, I don't stare & try as much as I can to focus my attention away from the parent who probably wants to run & hide. Not everyone has a tolerance for children & I am not offended b/c I'm a parent. If I didn't have my own, I probably wouldn't be as tolerant. My philosophy is pretty much don't take them out in public til their 10 - lol.

Leanne Burger
Leanne Burger

Julie..laughed when I saw the "topic", KNEW you'd be here shortly. lol

Julie Mabee Santopietro
Julie Mabee Santopietro

Not a fan of crying..I made it my business to keep my kids from disturbing the world and I had a difficult one ..if he was in a miserable mood I didn't take him out for dinner...didn't take my kids out when they should have been napping... did my food shopping at 10pm when they were sleeping.and when either one was just in a disagreeable mood I removed them from the situation. What bothers me is when a kid is screaming and the parent says louder than the screaming.." no one is listening to you...so you might as well stop" and they continue to eat their dinner. Well the rest of the room IS listening..get up and remove your kid already.

Jessica Smith McMican
Jessica Smith McMican

All depends on the reason for crying. Is it cause they need something? Then no, that's normal. Is it cause they are tired? Well, that isn't their fault someone brought them to dinner. Is it cause they hate being strapped in a cart, and lord knows mama needs to buy some dang groceries, like mine? Then, he screams. Because the only he stops would be to get him out. And if I did that, he wins. Sure, I could leave, but we gotta eat. Anyone who doesn't get that doesn't have kids...

Tiffiny Harmer Felix
Tiffiny Harmer Felix

It doesn't bother me. Some kids are harder than others, regardless who their parents are and how they handle the crying. And sometimes there isn't anything you can do and you still have to do your shopping (or whatever). My youngest is 4, so I'm out of the crying-in-stores-and-restaurants stage (phew!). Now I have the luxury of feeling bad for the parents whose kids are having a hard time.

Denise Mattox
Denise Mattox

I am ONLY annoyed when the parents are ignoring the issue. Past that, kids cry! Its NOT a big deal. I understand and I feel sympathetic to the parents as much as the miserable child. But, when I am in a situation where the parent is flat out ignoring the issue... THEN I get annoyed.

Roxanne Ellis VanWormer
Roxanne Ellis VanWormer

Sad, hungry, or tired crying makes me sympathetic. I feel bad for the kid, too [*rim shot*]. Whiny crying to get what they want makes me want to beat the parent.

Stephanie Bernaba
Stephanie Bernaba

Marla, sometimes we do our job and they still cry.

Lauren Barker
Lauren Barker

I'm bothered by my OWN child crying in public. Also, I am bothered when parents take their children to places that are inappropriate for little ones their age - like, say, an infant to a rated R action film in the movie theater, or a 2 year old at the grocery store at 9:30 at night. Of COURSE they are going to cry in those situations - they shouldn't be there in the first place!

Dianthe White Hall
Dianthe White Hall

i'm only annoyed if it's MY kid!!

Marla Baxter Sanderson
Marla Baxter Sanderson

Yes, it bothers me....in public. I'm being honest. But it isn't the child that bothers me as much as it is the parent, ignoring their children's screams because that is what they do at home. Or they think it is cute and they want everyone else around them to enjoy the ear piercing screams. If the parent is trying their best to quiet the child and taking appropriate steps to respect the hearing of the others around them, then it isn't a big deal. But if they don't, it really makes me mad. Sorry, but if I'm in a public place, especially a restaurant and I can't enjoy myself after paying my money to, it bothers me. I don't have children, but I do have nieces. If their parents ignore them and I see that it is distubing others, I take the child out of the public place....I've got no problem making my brother or sister angry when they are not doing their job.

Alisha Brignall
Alisha Brignall

no. crotchy old people with no manners bother me, but I am still required to share space with them. :/

Jenny Nicholes Tufford
Jenny Nicholes Tufford

If the kid is obviously not going to stop soon and the parent/parents ignore it, that bothers me. Otherwise, not at all. I have four kids.

Christine Leiser Schroeder
Christine Leiser Schroeder

The other day we were at Chili's - it's a family restaurant so it's to be expected and this child was screaming - really screaming... The mother kept taking her out of the restaurant and I felt so bad for her. If the world weren't such a scary place, I would have gone over, taken the baby and let the mother eat a meal in peace. It only bothers me if it's an inappropriate place for a baby to be screaming -

Brooke Harshbarger Schmidt
Brooke Harshbarger Schmidt

I'm bothered by MY crying kids -- not OTHER people's. Unless it's you know, a wedding or a movie. I did sit through a wedding where a baby cried THROUGH THE VOWS. Unbelievable.

Jessica Orlowicz
Jessica Orlowicz

only at restaurants.