Bio
By day I run a small organization working on big issues - like international human rights and women's health care.  By night I teach mid-career...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

How Not to Keep Up with the Joneses

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 12
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

How can we instill in our children an appreciation for what they already have -- especially when the people around them seem to have just about everything? Here's our family's holiday tip ...

This fall, my two children moved from a warm and caring New York City public school where a large percentage of the students live at or near the poverty level to a progressive private school composed of many families in (or close to) that much-scrutinized 1%, to use the Occupy Wall Street parlance.

What has the change meant for the kids on a day-to-day level?

One of the most obvious things is that they have come face-to-face with the stark reality of America's income inequality. For them, this is most apparent in the size of their friends' homes. While many of their old playmates live in cramped apartments in government subsidized housing, a sizable number of their new friends live in cavernous lofts and single-family townhouses. As is human nature for children and adults alike, my kids are prone to comparing what our family has to what they perceive is bigger and better.

stack of quarters

Credit Image: chrisdlugosz on Flickr


I've been spending a lot of time lecturing them about the detriment of "keeping up with the Joneses" and the false trappings of materialism, but that tends to fall on deaf ears. I also point out endless examples of good people really struggling, including the families who experienced massive loss during our recent storms here in the Northeast.

They grasp this, having seen a lot of this damage with their own eyes. They even volunteered setting up cots at a local shelter during tropical storm Irene. But nothing helped to cement an appreciation for what we have better than a simple holiday coin collection box from a nearby branch of Habitat for Humanity.

What puts this box right up there with the ubiquitous Trick or Treat for UNICEF is that children are asked to literally count the things they have to appreciate right in their own homes. A recent weekend evening found the kids excitedly tearing around the apartment, dropping coins into the box in response to questions such as:

  • For each room in your home, deposit 10 cents. Talk about what it would be like to live in a one-room house.
  • For each electrical outlet in your house, deposit 3 cents. (We have 31, not counting the outlets hidden behind bookcases and sofas. Who knew?)
  • If you have a pantry to store extra food, be thankful and deposit 25 cents. Many families live day to day for meals.

And the question that got my youngest reaching deeper into his own allowance money:

  • What more would you sacrifice to give others a more abundant life?

You can see the full 30-day giving calendar here: Holiday Giving Calendar (We cheated by doing it all at once.)

The Habitat for Humanity in Paterson, NJ will use the cash collected this season for new, affordable homes.  What's more, we can feel good that the houses will be energy efficient and economical for families to maintain in the long-term.

Has this project cured my children of the tendency to want more and more? No, of course not. But the act of pausing to look at the everyday conveniences we take for granted made for a unique introspective exercise in appreciation. Best of all, it linked this new understanding with actual holiday giving.

And for these things, this parent is enormously grateful.

  • 12
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
BeyondSiri 6 pts

Great comments about the Joneses on Facebook - people are striving so hard to appear like they have it all, but so many are deep in debt to keep up these appearances. This is why I love organizations like the Center for the New American Dream. Take a look at their fantastic Simplify the Holidays Challenge: http://www.newdream.org/programs/beyond-consumeris...

Maria Niles 13 pts

What a beautiful post! I've worked on several Habitat Houses and it's great to see this way to get the whole family involved and appreciate the work that they do beyond swinging a hammer or digging a ditch.

BeyondSiri 6 pts

When the kids are a little older, I want to swing a hammer too! Great that you're involved, Maria. Happy holidays! Maria Niles

BeyondSiri 6 pts

Thanks so much for sharing this piece, BlogHer! We're working very hard this holiday to keep all our gifts in the realm of experience over things. It may not be our kids' favorite idea for the holidays, but they may appreciate it in the long-run! http://www.huffingtonpost.com/barbara-becker/art-c...

Conversation from Facebook

Cheri Loughlin
Cheri Loughlin

Also agree it never pays to try and keep up or out do anyone with new this or that, but sometimes even the "Joneses" who have new cars, take vacations or have a nice home do it wisely within their budget and live debt free.

Barbara Becker
Barbara Becker

Great comments about the Joneses - people are striving so hard to appear like they have it all, but so many are deep in debt to keep up these appearances. This is why I love organizations like the Center for the New American Dream. Take a look at their fantastic Simplify the Holidays Challenge: http://www.newdream.org/programs/beyond-consumeris...

Karen Lockinger Greenberg
Karen Lockinger Greenberg

Although I don't WANT to worry about keeping up with the Joneses, it is hard sometimes to not compare myself to others. Then I realize what Nora put so well. I would rather NOT have debt coming out my ears.

Leslie Whitney
Leslie Whitney

Yes, with kids it's really hard to deal with. Especially if all your friends have more money than you do.

Eryn Baron
Eryn Baron

What if the Jonses were debt-free? I wonder if THAT would spread like wild fire.

Kim Iverson
Kim Iverson

I don't care bout the Joneses, but my problem is keeping up with myself. That's a tough one.

Nora Breitenstein
Nora Breitenstein

We too deal with this on a daily basis when we hear " I want this.." or "I want that..." Or "why does everyone else get what they want?" My opinion is that keeping up with the 'Joneses' is ridiculous for so many reasons. Do we really know if the 'Jonses' are rolling in dough or heavily in debt even when flashing the newest electronic item or new car? We don't have new cars, a big house or go on vacations to exotic places every winter but our bills are paid, we have a roof over our head and food in our fridge. As far as I'm concerned, we're ahead of the "Joneses".

Rebecca Wolowiec
Rebecca Wolowiec

i could give a fig about the joneses.