Bio
Laina Dawes is a contributing editor for Blogher and is also a music journalist whose writings can be found at Exclaim! Canada and...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Is Race-Based Bullying the "Elephant in the Room?"

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 8
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

According to reports in my hometown paper, the Toronto Star, Ontario-based hockey coach Greg Walsh was recently suspended and could face a lifetime ban from coaching junior-league hockey because he pulled his entire team off the ice when an opposing player called a black player on Walsh's team the N-word.

They were sent to the penalty box for two minutes, where “we were chirping each other,” McCullum recalled.

The other boy then called him “the N-word.” The referee didn’t hear it, so couldn’t impose a penalty.

The Austin Trophies coach benched his player for part of that period. But when the boy was put back on the ice the next period without offering an apology, Walsh was furious.

“In order for us as a team to protect our player from that, we said that we weren’t going to play and we went to the dressing room. Simple as that,” he said.

Despite the public outcry in support of Walsh, with many feeling that it should have been the other coach who was suspended for letting the hockey player continue playing, Walsh might still be banned.

In Canada, where hockey is not only beloved but our national sport, there have been a number of reports over the past few year of on-ice racial bullying and taunts between young White players and young minority men, many who have grown up idolizing the primarily white sport. As the Greater Toronto Area is exceptionally diverse, it is certainly not uncommon for young boys to want to get involved in a sport where, despite the general lack of melanin, is seen as almost a ritual in becoming a "good Canadian" (insert sarcastic smirk here). But with more Black, South Asian and East Asian kids picking up the sport, there have been more reports from players of racial slurs and taunts. Unfortunately, the Hockey Association decided to ignore the real reason why Walsh pulled the team off the ice and instead, chose to follow their rulebook and punish him for it.

The above story reminds me that despite all the recent online campaigns and the media’s effort to increase awareness of the effects of bullying, there has been little interest in discussing the cause. There have been several public initiatives to combat racism, but no one has looked at the effects race-based bullying has on its victims. We do not hear about the suicides, the depression, the inability to trust people and the ability to forgive. Instead what happens is a whole lot of denial: Structural initiatives might be effected, but still, no one wants to talk about why it happens in the first place.

I was bullied in both public and high school. In public school there were maybe three other black kids, and my first account of being harassed began at age six. I asked my parents for earplugs because I didn’t want to hear "jigaboo" and "ni#$er" on the school bus every day. In high school, there were maybe six black kids out of 800-900. Perhaps like the kids who presently face harassment because of their presumed sexual orientation, my black friends and I did complain to teachers and told our parents, and I’m assuming that there are also similarities in that nothing was done about it -- the parents were more concerned that future educational opportunities could be hindered if they got involved (and perhaps in relation to sexual orientation, maybe the parents felt more comfortable avoiding talking to their kids instead of protecting them and championing their right to be "different" than their peers).

Looking back twenty-plus years after my high school days, I can understand why parents might be reluctant in defending their children within the educational system -- but they do not realize how their inaction, whether on purpose or by accident, leaves a lasting effect on their children. We might forgive, but we do not forget.

But the harassment wasn’t just racial taunts or threats of physical violence. There was also an uneasy silence and a feeling of thickening tension that never seemed to go away. An absence of words that were anticipated, but were never verbalized. As bullies get older, they understand the power of insinuation -- how to convey a feeling without having to open their mouths. How taking the long and measured approaches to exert control over another’s emotions is more satisfying when it's drawn out and unsettlingly anticipated by the victim.

  • 8
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
har 6 pts

I hate to be the one to introduce unpleasant facts into the conversation, but in the interest of truth I will do so. When I was a child, the biggest bullies were black. White children had to watch their backs after schools were integrated in the late1960s and early 1970s. We never said anything rude or not nice to the black kids in the school, but they hated us for being white and loved to beat on other children.

Now, many years later, I do not live in the US any more and my children were brought up in a different country where racism according to color is not a problem. My adult son [who served in one of the best armies in the world] was in the US visiting relatives when a bunch of black guys thought that they'd found an easy target in some skinny Jew boy -- well, they found out that skinny Jew boys that weren't brought up in America aren't afraid of anyone, especially not those who served in the army. They never bothered him again and befriended him [it was better for their health than starting up with him :-)].

I don't think that it is nice to call other children names no matter what but I would be very surprised if bullying according to color went only one way these days.

randamace 5 pts

I never equated being taunted by the KKK with being accused of the KKK association. But I wasn't talking about the association, I was talking about bullying in general. I was severely bullied and sexually harassed all through grade school. However, I didn't want to use heavy anecdotes since I was showing examples of intolerance in general.

lainad 5 pts

Okay, I'm totally lost here, but I don't want to argue over semantics. I mentioned KKK because.....I didn't even mention it, it was part of a news article that I pasted in my blog post.

I don't really get where you are coming from, but if you think that there is a comparison to you being accused of being part of the KKK and a young black teenager being taunted with KKK by white kids, you know less about American history than I, a Canadian do, and you are sorely mistaken.

Contributing Editor - Race, Ethnicity & Culture

Blog: Writing is Fighting: www.lainad.typepad.com ( http://www.lainad.typepad.com/ )

Writer: Hellbound:

randamace 5 pts

Therefore I brought up slavery. Why is the default for intolerance the KKK (not that I care for the group one iota, but they are few and far between) and the default for racism slavery? You know the largest group of intolerant human beings on the planet most likely is not the KKK. In some countries, being gay or lesbian would mean death. In America, racism these days is thrown around and had lost it's impact. There's discrimination, yes. But the "societal privilages" that whites allegedly have is a combination of myth, perception, and pockets of affluence. In 20 years, the Hispanic community will be the majority, not the whites. Right now, more whites rely on welfare than any other group. While "minorities" (a term I loathe in general since most of us would be surprised what raceS we really are)have special interest groups and funds, the "whites" do not. In fact, a snapshot of the last 20 years, puts every other race in a societal advantage over the whites if only because of the special interest dollars funding the advancement of other races. Which, I in no way object to at all since advancing anyone is always a worthy cause. But take, for instance, three 20 year olds. My sister is college age now, so this actually is a topic I have experience on. One is a minority, one is a single parent, and one is from a blue collar white home with two parents. Who has access to the most grant and scholarship money? I can tell you from personal experience, that the most disadvatanged person financially is the person with the perceived best home! Even getting a Pell grant is hard when you're not a minority or have a presumed "disadvantage". As a single teenaged mother, it sickens me that I had more resources available for my college education than my sister has now. We came from the same humble and poor home! In fact, my parents net worth is now lower than it was when I was a "single mother".

Again, this is where I defer to anger. There's still very real discrimination, but it's being amplified and generating anger. Both offensively and defensively. This isn't progressing America or encouraging tolerance. There's no "equality" image most of the time, there's a blanket injustice and a blanket reaction and both sides come away with nothing but anger.

True equality is easier than people think. When we remove the special interests that serve only one small sliver of people that is based on a bias to start with, then true unity will occur. Take for instance the Montgomery County and Fairfax County school systems. They experience lower violence than similarly populated school systems and have a greater diversity than most school systems in the country. Know why? Because the focus isn't on what makes you different and why it's an advantage or disadvantage, but what you have in common and how those common goals can bring you together.

Again, after living in PG County where all I could think about is how I was different, then moving to Fairfax, VA where I saw everyone is different yet similar, I found true acceptance. My best friend is a Muslim business owner who doesn't practice ALL customs and traditions. My husband is Puerto Rican who practices religion differently than I do. I have a black sister in law who learned to make soul food from ME (I grew up in the South). And none of our differences have mattered in the 12 years we've known each other. So, why do they matter when it's time to go to college, join an after school club, become a member of an association, and even on television?

har 6 pts

randamace Well, I'm glad you're happy in Fairfax county, but they are very intolerant of Judaism there. Most people are very anti-Semitic in that county. One year a number of years ago the valedictorians at a particular school were twin girls and Jewish. Judaism forbids driving or riding in a car on the Sabbath and they asked for the graduation to be moved to Saturday night instead of Friday night so that they, the valedictorians of the entire school, could participate since they were religious Jews. The administration said no dice. Then the issue hit the papers and the comments against Jews and people who practice Judaism poured in to the local papers. So in the end the girls missed their own graduation that was held on Friday night and everyone else was happy that they didn't have to give in to those heathens that don't believe in their dead god. There were hundreds of other cases of Jewish children there being penalized because they took off school for the three holiest days on the Jewish calendar [Rosh Hashana and Yom Kippur]. School administrators said it was not their problem that your religions forbids you to drive, write, or go to school on the holiest days of the year.

Nice place you got there. You can keep it...

lainad 5 pts

I do understand what you trying to say, but there is a lot missing that would make your assertion realistic.

There is a level of understanding that the LGBT community, racialized minorities, those who are physically or mentally disabled, have a more difficult time in relation to bullying and the ramifications it has, versus White folks - not because you are 'White' but because you are in the majority of the population and have immediate access to societal privileges that others do not have. There is an understanding that people are less likely to be supportive of someone because of existing stereotypes about that persons racial group, sexual orientation, physical and/or mental abilities. While your story of being bullied is not an uncommon one and it does not negate the subject matter of this blog entry.

While you might have felt dismissed as a youth and not felt that people took your bullying seriously as a White person, that it was somehow 'okay,' well it wasn't. But that doesn't cancel out that others have been bullied who are racial minorities. Your comment seems based on the presumption that everyone in this whole wide world are seen as being of equal value and merit, but in reality, we are not perceived that way, therefore the after-affects of bullying based on race and sexual orientation have far more ramifications.

You say that you are Irish and that most likely that your ancestors were slaves.... and then you say this: “What anyone's ancestors did is BEYOND their control. The only person anyone can control is themselves.” This post has nothing to do with slavery, and I don’t quite understand what your point is. I find it funny how common it is when racism is discussed, that someone thinks that we are positioning our 'victimhood' through slavery. Like once the shackles were taken off, nothing bad has happened to Black Americans since then we have noting to whine about so why are we whining?

Damn, slavery happened a hundred years ago and 'dem Negroes are still bitching and moaning.

This isn’t a ‘tit-for-tat’ post. It’s not trying to shame or blame anything or anyone.

Contributing Editor - Race, Ethnicity & Culture

Blog: Writing is Fighting: www.lainad.typepad.com ( http://www.lainad.typepad.com/ )

Writer: Hellbound:

randamace 5 pts

You're forgetting the *other elephant in the room. It's seems kind of one sided. I grew up in a school where I was the minority but it somehow was acceptable to bully me as a white girl because white people "bullied" the other races. When I was in middle school in PG County MD near the DC line, I was beaten up constantly. Frequently on the bus, I was associated with the KKK. I did some research a few years later, not a single traceable ancestor of mine ever owned a slave, joined the KKK, or even had a history of intolerance. In fact, I have strong, repetitive latin roots. Yet, I suffered for years with the shrugs of administrators asking my mother and I to "understand the anger".

The irony? Sadly, when researching my Irish roots, I found out my ancestors were likely slaves themselves.

Racism isn't a white on minority issue. It's a general intolerance issue. I think that the anger is the root and needs to stop. What anyone's ancestors did is BEYOND their control. The only person anyone can control is themselves. There is never excuse to bully anyone for any reason.

I am now in an interracial marriage and couldn't be happier and both of us agree, it's not a race issue anymore, it's an anger issue.

Misplaced anger and intolerance is the monster we need to contain. Or this cycle will continue.

cynematic 5 pts

When I read your post, I was reminded of how I blogged about the Asian Canadian high school kid in Keswick, ONT a couple years back who was P i l l o w b o o k ( http://cynematic.wordpress.com ) and MOMocrats. ( http://momocrats.typepad.com/momocrats/ )