Bio
I'm a Windy City native who now lives on a tiny old Florida island, Matlacha in the Gulf Coast.  I am a true recessionista at heart, won't think...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Recent Comments

How will brands react with today's new Klout scoring model when most scores...dropped?

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 39
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

 

 

 

 

51.

There it was staring at me like Santa Clause in a blue polka dot suit...my new Klout score said 51.  Granted just literally hours before it was an impressive 65 and now it dropped...eee gads...14 points in a few hours. Hmmm....I double-checked my tweet stream to make sure nothing was lost.  I could plainly see my numerous RT's and the back-and-forth social dialogue I was having with those whose scores were higher than mine....one would think you have some sort of influence...right?  So how could a score drop that much in such a short period of time?

Ahhhh...what the @#$%^ happened? 

I looked at Klout's tweet stream - nothing.  I tweeted a question and moments later - there was my response.  "@Ad_Chickadee we have a new scoring model release today, see..." and a link to their blog post with the gory details.

"Today we’re releasing a new scoring model with insights to help you understand changes in your influence. This project represents the biggest step forward in accuracy, transparency and our technology in Klout’s history"

And then in big bold letters it said...

How will this affect my Score?

A majority of users will see their Scores stay the same or go up but some users will see a drop. In fact, some of our Scores here at the Klout HQ will drop — our goal is accuracy above all else. We believe our users will be pleased with the improvements we’ve made. Below is a distribution of the Score changes. You’ll note large decreases in Score are rare.

Rare hunh?  Judging from Klout's tweet stream since the changes went live - large decreases are in fact not rare.  Me thinks the Twittersphere is a buzz almost as much as the 10k tweets per second when Steve Jobs died.  At last count there were 187 very upset comments on Klout's blog post not including the numerous "Like" and replies to other tweeps frantic postings.

Think about that for a minute - when was the last time your blog post had...187 comments?  Correction - in the time it took me to type that last sentence there are now 195 comments.

Why is this an issue? Well - social media is really still in its infancy.  And - there's no "true" social media measurement of your influence...that was until Klout came along and pumped themselves up as "the" social media scoring authority.  As a result, brands like Chevy, Subway, Stephen King and many others started flocking -- and partnering in droves -- with Klout. 

If you've been fortunate enough to land a Klout Perk - details are listed what you need to be influential about in order to score that Perk and...the score you need.  Influential about fashion? Well Macy's offered those gals $25 Macy's gift cards as a Klout Perk during New York Fashion Week.  

But it's not just landing Klout Perks...marketer's and PR people now ask what your Klout score is before they work with bloggers.  I had a PR gal at BlogHer11 in San Diego just tell me she won't work with bloggers who have a Klout score under 60.

So...if so many folks experienced a significant drop in their score - even gals like Shelly Kramer who Forbes named as one of "the" marketing and social media authorities, saw her score drop 10 points - how will Klout now work with brands to account for this shift that really is not rare?  Will they even acknowledge there's an issue with their new modified "more accurate" scoring model when so many folks did in fact see a significant reduction in their score?

Oh and by the way - there are now 295 (and counting) negative comments on Klout's blog post.  And social media God Mark Davidson who had an astonishing Klout score of...80 and now has a...60 suggests we opt OUT of Klout.   Hmmm...I'm liking his thinking #KloutOptOut

READERS: Did you experience your score dropping, stay the same or increase?

  • 39
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Marcy Massura 5 pts

Klout is now dead to me as a tool to vet bloggers. They basically 'netflix'd' themselves.....

Karen Moran 8 pts

Marcy Massura I'm totally inclined to agree w/u Marcy!

Sheila Cameron 5 pts

Mine went WAY up. I new to the Klout scene and blogged about it today. It is so strange how an arbitrary set of measures can make you feel so antsy. I wish I was big enough to not care but I do. I also have message board that are branded with my name and I am the sole admin of. I have lots of "followers" there but they don't even count according to Klout.

Karen Moran 8 pts

Sheila Cameron Good luck to you Miss Newbie - It's fun and I'm sure you'll get the hang of it! But Klout does seem to be putting more emphasis on Facebook now vs. other social media forms - I deactivated FB from my Klout - and my score went up to 55. Go figure...

Snarky Amber 5 pts

Mine went down 11 points. Maybe @klout defines "significant" differently from me (and the majority of users).

I don't really care much, but it was a bit of a shock when I logged in. Seeing as how most people I know dropped around 10 pounds, I'm not so sure it's a big deal.

Karen Moran 8 pts

Snarky Amber@klout Oh so sorry to hear - The thing that's curious for me is how will brands and bloggers work together now when Klout says a score drop is "rare"...even when it isn't?...

JennaHatfield 63 pts

Snarky Amber@klout Dropped ten pounds?! I WISH! heh

JennaHatfield 63 pts

My Klout score dropped 13 points. On the one hand, I think that sucks. On the other hand, it's just proof that Klout means absolutely diddly. I've always been kind of wary of Klout. I don't like "popularity contests," online or off, and "clout," with a c, is not why I engage in social media. It's just not. On top of that, the site rarely works properly on first load. You can't expect me to place any sort of value in your "system" if you can't even produce a site that works properly.

Would I like my old Klout score back? Well, sure. Will I log in and give @sassymonkey +1's for bacon? Sure. But Klout now means even less to me than it did the day before yesterday -- and I didn't think that was possible.

(BTW: It WAS interesting to me the business concept of lowered Klout as I know BlogHer and their section accounts took a hit score wise.)

Karen Moran 8 pts

JennaHatfieldsassymonkey It's unfortunate to hear so many folks too a hit - what seems to be very odd are the folks w/lower scores - saw theirs rise. A gal in my office who is RARELY on social media saw her score increase from 23...to 47. She has all of 19 tweets in the last year. I've been VERY active for almost 3 years and my 65 drops to 51. Yesterday I unconnected all my social networks - except for Twitter - as only Klout can do that (?!?!) and saw the score increase to 55. Ugh. Clearly their model is a weee bit hookey. Just wonder how brands and bloggers will work together now when Klout says a score drop is "rare"...even when it isn't. :(

ArchWeek 5 pts

Thanks for posting on the @Klout debacle today. The thread at #Klout now has 824 comments, still going up fast:

http://corp.klout.com/blog/2011/10/a-more-accurate...

Karen Moran 8 pts

TwoPretzels Sorry to hear - do you blog for business?

Conversation from Twitter

markdavidson
markdavidson

milgard So to get an accurate representation of my score in relation to someone else, I have to consider what accounts are linked.

markdavidson
markdavidson

milgard If I only have my Twitter account linked (default), my klout score will be lower relative to someone with more linked accounts.

Ad_Chickadee
Ad_Chickadee

markdavidson Actually not really I deactived every acct from Klout except Twitter Saw score increase to 55 from 51 Granted it was 65

markdavidson
markdavidson

milgard I don't see klout as an accurate benchmark of anything. User score's are somewhat relevant to the number of accounts linked.

AjeetMinhasGTB
AjeetMinhasGTB

GavWard Mine plummeted by 10 - my hard-earned points, stolen! Are you joining Nov 10 #TweetingLegals Gavin? - http://t.co/AUapd3Ki

GavWard
GavWard

ajeetminhasgtb Hard earned indeed. Maybe I was gaming it too much? Won't be making #tweetinglegals unfotunately A. Catch up another time!

AjeetMinhasGTB
AjeetMinhasGTB

GavWard I thought it was a bug at first re Kout... Sorry you can't make this tranche of #tweetinglegals but hope to see you before too long

tartanmedia
tartanmedia

GavWard why does anyone care about Klout and it's rating? Oh that's right, the holy grain of ROI.

GavWard
GavWard

tartanmedia Perhaps one of the former holy grains of ROI. Now, not so sure. My position on Klout is still here http://t.co/fyafEt0v

tartanmedia
tartanmedia

GavWard I'm still waiting for someone to develop an ROI for talking to people

richquick
richquick

GavWard They won't give a shit cause it's just a random number that makes no difference.

Stazzy
Stazzy

markdavidson You rascal.... what are you up to today? :)

Hipstercrite
Hipstercrite

thetsaritsa ahh. i will have to read. thank you, you social media maven, you.

theTsaritsa
theTsaritsa

You are very welcome, my hip blog friend :) Hipstercrite

newmomsurvival
newmomsurvival

blogher Mine increased! =)

BlogHer
BlogHer

newmomsurvival Congrats! You and marriedn2usmc have something in common. Lucky girls! -Momo

MarriedN2USMC
MarriedN2USMC

newmomsurvival Congrats! So did mine. By 20 points... Somehow?

newmomsurvival
newmomsurvival

marriedn2usmc Mine was by 12 points. At the same time my reach exploded. #KloutTheNewOz

MarriedN2USMC
MarriedN2USMC

newmomsurvival Mine did too. This one actually made more sense, though. Was wondering why it was so low. Not sure how they score?

newmomsurvival
newmomsurvival

marriedn2usmc Agreed. Their transparent blog post was anything but.

KitchenMagpie
KitchenMagpie

blogher Klout is the most useless thing I have come upon yet! It was a nice try, but people are bailing like it's the Titanic.

MarriedN2USMC
MarriedN2USMC

blogher Mine went up a lot. I'm still confused by it.

BlogHer
BlogHer

marriedn2usmc That's because you probably met and added some key influencers at #blogherwriters. ;) -Momo

MarriedN2USMC
MarriedN2USMC

blogher Touche!

momsreview4you
momsreview4you

janenation blogher I am curious about this too

JaneNation
JaneNation

momsreview4you I think it will be really interesting to see too Especially since klout says that lower score is rare http://t.co/5sg4pmYz