Bio
Hi! My name is Elayne and I am the author of“Turning Moments Into Memories”! I am a full time blogger, crafter, Alzheimer's disease expert, fairly de...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Recent Comments

A Missed Confirmation & a Broken Promise To My Daughter's Birth Mother

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 12
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

This past Sunday, I told my oldest child that I was thinking about going to church. I don’t go often. She asked me in a very serious voice to be sure to pray for her sister. I was surprised by this and jokingly asked her if she wanted me to pray for her sisters soul. She said, “Yeah mommy.” I asked her why, and she told me that when the girls attended a memorial service for a friend earlier in the week, she was saddened that her sister didn’t seem to know the words to the prayers that are so deeply instilled in me that I can recite them in my sleep; that she didn’t take communion; and that she didn't even seem to remember when to stand, when to kneel or how to pray.

She totally caught me off guard -- I felt like she kicked me in the stomach. Wow… Where did that come from? I didn't go to church on Sunday after all. I have spent the past couple of days reflecting on what she said. Although I am comfortable with my own spirituality and my relationship with God, I am not so comfortable with the fact that I have evidently broken my promise to my daughter’s birth mother.

Twenty two years ago when this precious baby girl was placed in my arms, I was given the most amazing gift. Her birth mother trusted me to raise her child, provide for her, protect her and love her unconditionally. She asked for just one single thing in return… That I raise her child as a Catholic.

From the day we brought her home, she was raised just as my husband and I were raised: in a good, Catholic home. One of her Uncles is a priest and he baptized her within the first month. I took her to church and she learned all of her prayers. She made her first confession and she brought me to tears when we celebrated her first communion. We recognized all of the holy days of obligation and to this day, we say grace every night before dinner. She attended a Catholic pre-school and kindergarten and I taught CCD classes. For years, her religious life was happy, consistent and never questioned.

When she started high school, she started playing basketball. Everything she did revolved around her team, her games and her friends. She loved it. It was the most important thing in the world to her. We supported her, attended her games, and encouraged her to give it her best and most of all to have fun.

As a freshman, she attended CCD classes to prepare for her confirmation which she would make the following year. No problem. When she became a sophomore, the evening CCD classes conflicted directly with her basketball schedule. Big, BIG problem. Here was a kid that ate slept and breathed basketball. She was on the varsity team and there was no question that she was doing what she loved.

I called every church in town to try and find classes that might be held on a Sunday after Mass. Nothing. Every single one only offered CCD class during the week, after dinner.

I sat down with her and told her I was sorry. She would have to speak to her coach as there was no way she was going to miss her CCD classes and not make her confirmation. She didn't argue. She knew my position. She knew about my promise. Her coach however, saw things differently. She needed to be at every practice and every game or she was off the team. Period.

And so it began… The crying, the screaming, and the begging. There was door slamming and foot stomping. There was my precious baby girl, curled-up in a ball on her bed, truly heartbroken. As adamant as I was that she attend CCD, she was adamant that I was ruining her life. It was a complete and utter disaster. Because it’s what I’ve always taught my kids they need to do, it was now my turn and we decided to compromise.

She would stop going to CCD, remain on the team, and attend adult CCD classes when she got out of high school. This was a huge compromise for me. I felt sad that she wouldn't be making her confirmation with all of the other kids her age; and guilty that I was not living up to the promise I had made to her birth mother. I believe that my promise

  • 12
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
wdolderer 27 pts

Sorry you are feeling so sad over this.  You did what you could.  You gave her a loving home and exposed her to church and started her on that path.  It is up to her to continue down it if she chooses.  My parents raised all 6 of us, and some of us attend and others of us don't.  Same parents, same upbringing.  Mom used to feel bad like she "failed", but she realized that we have to choose our path and all she can do is guide and give us the tools.

Grace Kull 106 pts

Elayne, Stop beating yourself up.  You raised your daughter in the Catholic religon as you promised,  When she became of age, she made the decisions.  You could not have forced her into anything.  I have three children who I brought up as Catholics,  we went to church regularly, they received the sacraments and as each one left home, they also left the religion that i had forced them into.  As adults, they tell me how much they disliked religious classes, how rigid and unforgiving the Priest was, and how much of the basic Catholic teachings they just can't bring themselves to believe or embrace.  I don't feel guilty.  I did what I thought was right and gave them the foundation.  What they chose to do after that was their decisions.  I respect them for having the courage to follow their hearts.  BTW, once that birth mother gave you that baby, you were the babies mother.  Although, I admire you for trying to keep your promise to her, keep in mind that as that child's mother you did the very best you could and what you concidered the best for the child at the time.  Love, Grace

KosherKayls 6 pts

You haven't failed. You raised your daughter in a home with Catholic values. If you had tried to force your child through CCD classes and confirmation, as my mom did with me, she may not have felt truly Catholic. In my belief, religion is an important *decision* everyone must make for themselves. My mom forced me into a religion I never believed in. I felt miserable every time I, a misfit depressed gay kid, had to sit through a teaching by my Lifeteen group telling me I was going to Hell. I never felt accepted by the community, and I never accepted the beliefs of the community.

5 years later, and I'm a happy Jewish convert. Your daughter will know what is best for her when the right time comes. She is an adult now. This is her decision, you have done your part.

SunbonnetSmart.com 2663 pts

Oh Elayne! I always enjoy your posts, but this made me sad. With all you have accomplished for and with this young women, how have you NOT raised her Catholic? When your beautiful daughter's beautiful birth mother asked you to raise her Catholic, she didn't specify the length or duration of the "raising." Nor, would she want you to build your daughter's resentment for you personally or for the Church. It's a "bring a horse to water situation." You built the trough, filled it with water and brought her to it. Now, when she drinks is between her and the Almighty. Think of it this way: if you try to make her drink, you're playing God! Now, no Catholic I know would take THAT on! :) Peace be with you....and much love....Fondly, Robin

Whymommy 9 pts

I don't think it's too late ... why not go this Sunday, and ask her to come to church with you?

poohzer74 5 pts

I think that you did raise her Catholic as you had promised. I am the non-Catholic who made her son go to PSR classes for two years so he could get his First Communion. This year, his dad, the Catholic, said that he did not have to continue. Well, I am not going to argue because in his family, First Communion matters, Confirmation does not.

thepsychobabble 13 pts

You *did* raise her as a Catholic. And then, when she was plenty old enough, you stepped back and allowed her to make her own decisions about religion and it's place in your life.IMHO, you have nothing to feel guilty about.

anneisanne 26 pts

My mother pushed me to get confirmed in high school. It doesn't mean a whole lot to me. I hated those classes; the program wasn't very good. A lot of it included doing skits about premarital sex and listening to rock songs for their values. Frankly I felt like it was insulting to my intelligence; was there not more to spirituality than this? I had 12 years of Catholic school, but somehow got put in the "remedial" class with a bunch of thugs who couldn't recite the "Our Father." Seriously. It got to the point I would happily write a paper (the "punishment" for missing) rather than go to the class. Despite this, I got confirmed, my mom did her 'duty' and all is well, right? Well, no. I still feel like I just don't fit in with the Catholic community. I try to find a place for myself; my family has been Catholic for hundreds of years. My godfather was a bishop. I miss that sense of community I had with others growing up. But it just isn't there and I just can't connect. My mother feels guilty, too, that I don't feel the same way about church that she does. But it's not my mom that got in the way. And it's not you. It's your child's choice, your child's comfort level, your child's path. It's not about you. You did what was right when she was a child and she will do what is right for her as an adult.

Carmen Tourney 9 pts

I'm not really religious but here's my two cents. You kept your word pretty well. Your daughter on the other hand is another story. Which is appalling of her considering that you made a big sacrifice of keeping your sacred promise and if basketball was so important to her maybe she should consider what it means to keep her word when she could have lost out big time if you hadn't trusted her to do something she ultimately couldn't be bothered doing like she said she would. Also, maybe you should tell her how that makes you feel.

Denise 1919 pts moderator

I don't think you failed.

At some point in our children's lives, they have to be allowed to make their own decisions. As your daughter got to high school age, and beyond, it became her responsibility to take care of her spiritual life and commitments. You DID raise her in Catholicism. You kept your promise.

Morgan Shanahan 31 pts

Elayne - this is a beautiful post. It's so clear that you love your faith. I was raised Jewish in a home with two parents who are very close to their faith. My sister and I were raised in the same synagogue, with the same values, and the same exposure to Judaism, and yet she feels little to no attachment to our faith and culture, while I treasure it and continue to celebrate holidays with my family. I don't think you've failed at all. You've raised a daughter who is passionate about the things she loves and has a mind of her own.

...And I wonder if you've asked her if she says a prayer before a basketball game. ;)

Elayne 16 pts

Morgan Shanahan Thanks so much Morgan.... I WILL ask her :-) Have a wonderful weekend!