Bio
I am a registered nurse women’s health care expert who spends a lot of professional time answering health related questions from a variety of professi...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Recent Comments

I Know A Secret!!!

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 13
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Don’t you just hate when someone taunts you with that phrase.  I do!  While I am the kind of person who loves surprises, if I know that one is coming, I will go to all kind of lengths to find out what the surprise is all about.  While there are good and fun secrets, such as those that are necessary for planning for anniversary or birthday surprises or unanticipated friend visits, there are secrets that can be painful or hurtful if not kept private.  

The Mirriam-Webster official definition of a secret that is most appropriate to this is: kept from knowledge or view (hidden).   Let me begin with my ending statement about secrets and that is:  Some secrets need to stay that way forever out of respect to the person asking that it be kept and other secrets need to be shared no matter the reason for asking that it not be shared.  

Why I am I now blogging about secrets??  There are two reasons, actually.  The first is because a friend recently told me something very private about her health.  She and I talk on occasion about her issue, as well as other things we both like.  To be clear, I am not her NURSE friend, but a very close friend who is also a nurse.  I had not told a soul what she confided, as I respect her reason for not sharing her private stuff.  Recently I had several couples over for dinner and she shared about her illness with another woman present.  She was at first surprised that the other friend of mine wasn’t aware of what she had gone through.  I told her that what she was experiencing was only hers to share.   

To anyone who knows me personally, I AM A SECRET KEEPER…now and forever!!  You can confide in me.  Have you ever heard of the Yiddish word YENTA?  If so, you know it means someone who tells all to all.  A major repercussion of sharing a confidence is that you destroy the trust between yourself and the person who confided to you.  You can try all you want and you may never get that trust back.  What a loss.  You may also get a reputation as some who is a YENTA.  I can assure you that being called a YENTA, or gossipmonger, is not a pretty way to be described.  

There is a featured article on beinggirl.com about secrets.

http://www.beinggirl.com/article/keeping-a-secret/?utm_source=blogher&ut...

It includes a paragraph on how to keep a secret, as well as a description of the difference between a good and bad secret.  In the article, it states that: “A bad secret might concern a friend or family member who is in trouble and risking her health and safety. Whether it’s drug-related or bad-crowd-related, those secrets that make anyone feel scared, uncomfortable, sad, or angry should be shared.”  I will add that it should be shared with someone who can help ensure that the person gets the support that they may desperately need.

There is also an interesting statistic in the beinggirl.com article:
“A recent study of 3000 women in England found that four in ten women had trouble keeping a secret, no matter how personal or confidential the news was. And two-thirds ended up feeling guilty after spilling the beans.”

Let me tell you about my guilt inducing behavior:  One time, a group of my “girl” friends and I were sitting around drinking some vino and complaining about work stuff and people.  I listened and then added a comment about something someone at work had said about someone else.  One of my friends personalized it, even though it wasn’t about her.  Whew, did I kick myself in the butt for telling the group what I should not have.  I mention the wine because it may have loosened my tongue.  But, I tell you all from the bottom of my heart, I am personally responsible for causing an additional rift in an already fragile relationship.  I felt terrible about that for the longest time, and still do.  Now though, you would have to stick pins in my fingernails to get me to share something that was said in confidence.  I learned a painful lesson.  It seems that we are never too old and crotchety to learn life’s lessons, as I continually do for sure!  

Hate that I may be sounding preachy, but wanted to talk about secrets and the difference between good and bad secrets, as well as secrets that should be shared and those that should

  • 13
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
HomeRearedChef 214 pts

I forgive you, Elaine. (Smile!) I've had to face exactly what you have face, telling what shouldn't have been told, and still regret that moment. Once it is out, it is out! Now I think before I answer. I give myself a quiet talking to, before I speak. If I am ever not sure about something, even if I haven't been told "don't say anything," I won't open my mouth. Better not to say than having said it and can't take it back!

Great, great post!

~Virginia

elaineR.N. 70 pts

HomeRearedChef Thanks Virginia: I needed a dose of forgiveness! You are so right about it being better to not have said it, as it can never be taken back.

isthisthemiddle 194 pts

A person who can keep a secret is the kind of friend I look for. When someone confides in me, I do take it seriously. I've put my foot in my mouth in the past, and I'm sure I will again. But I try my best not to violate a confidence, no matter how small. It's a point of honor and respect for the other person. Enjoyed the post!

victorias_view 444 pts

isthisthemiddle Lovely post! It is very important to have friends that you can confide in and trust. If you can't than how can you have a real friendship? I have friends that I trust and cherish the connection I have with them. You know they are the ones that will be there when the going gets tough.

elaineR.N. 70 pts

Hi Victoria. Thanks for your comments. One of the good things about aging, is that my friends are my friends for that much longer. I value them so much. You know when you have been friends with someone for over 40years, neither of you is going anywhere. Though, I am fortunate to have new friends too. A promise to all of my new friends, I will be a good friend and not be a yenta!! victorias_view isthisthemiddle

HomeRearedChef 214 pts

elaineR.N.victorias_viewisthisthemiddle And I, too, here promise not to be a "yenta" to my new friends on BlogHer. (Smile!)

HomeRearedChef 214 pts

victorias_view AMEN to that! isthisthemiddle

elaineR.N. 70 pts

Thanks for mentioning the foot-in-the-mouth, as it always helps to know that you aren't the only one who makes mistakes of that kind. I, like you, really value someone who doesn't betray a confidence. I strive to be that person too! isthisthemiddle

HomeRearedChef 214 pts

elaineR.N. My hubby is the best secret keeper, EVER! I can tell him absolutely anything!! isthisthemiddle

elaineR.N. 70 pts

HomeRearedChefisthisthemiddle My husband is a good secret keeper too. But, I still tell him when it is secret in case it isn't evident. There have been times he didn't quite realize that something should be kept confidential because he didn't know the whole story. I don't leave it to chance anymore.

isthisthemiddle 194 pts

HomeRearedChefelaineR.N. You are lucky! :-)

HomeRearedChef 214 pts

I enjoyed this post, too, Melanie. And isn't it nice to be able to talk amongst each other, openly? As long as it is not a secret! isthisthemiddle

isthisthemiddle 194 pts

HomeRearedChef Ha-ha! I have met some wonderful ladies on Blogher, that's for sure!