Bio
Katherine is author of the blog Postpartum Progress, and a writer for Babble's Strollerderby. She has also been syndicated on BlogHer. You can follow...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

The Impossibility of Lists & Postpartum Depression

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 3
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Tyra Banks focused her show yesterday on postpartum depression.  She included a psychiatrist as a guest on the segment, who provided the usual list of things depressed new moms should do for our depression: prioritize, sleep when the baby sleeps, avoid isolating, etc.  Looking at the list made me think about the fact that, when you're depressed, you couldn't care less about lists.  Lists are for those people who actually want to DO things.  You know, like Martha Stewart ... women who get up at 5am ready to tackle the day, do some ashtanga yoga, whip up a pumpkin souffle, give their baby a massage, plant an autumnal container garden and fashion a Christmas tree out of pipe cleaners.

From what I remember, I couldn't really do much of anything.  What I really wanted to do when I was depressed was stay in bed and do nothing.  It took a monumental effort to get up and do my best to take care of myself and my newborn in between bouts of sobbing.  I think someone giving me a list of things to do would have made me feel like I was being crushed under a Buick. 

I realize, of course, that people are only trying to help by providing suggestions of things that will help us get through the day positively.  But I'm not sure they know that it usually takes a rational person to execute a list.  When you're not rational or logical, it becomes very difficult to do rational and logical things.  So if you give us a list and we don't do much or any of it, don't give up on us.  We'll get there.  It takes time.  And remember that people don't recover from postpartum depression just because they follow a list, but because they get proper medical care and love and support from the people around them.

I like the perspective of this blogger at Impacted Nurse who says: "My advice is to never take much notice of anyone who purports to be able to improve your life in ten bullet-point steps… unless you know them very well and they are proof writ large of the effectiveness of their list."  For a good laugh about list-making, check this out from The Onion.    

  • 3
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
virgofem 5 pts

Wow, I really feel such a connection to these comments. I also had postpartum anxiety. I was scared out of my mind ..racing mind! I called my doctor as soon as I knew that I had to have someone around all the time because I felt like it was all too much! As soon as I started feeling these intense feelings, my husband suggested calling a psych. I did, I found one on-line that dealt with PPD and I called his cell phone on a SUNDAY morning. It took about 2-3 weeks on an anti-depressant to start getting some balance. I also had a colicky baby, I tell you , it felt hellish but there was hope and I felt SO much better after a couple of weeks. Communication and being honest about your most intimate feelings is the key. Surround yourself with supportive people..that was also KEY

MyGoodFinds 5 pts

Family and friends should look out for the symptoms of PPD with a new mother and help her come out of it.

I agree with you KatStone. People who never have gone through post-partum depression are in no authority to give these to-do lists. I have gone through my PPD silently because I am the kind of person who was seen as the cheerful one by default and I didn't want people around me to worry. I was always "in-charge" of myself but I got knocked over by PPD because I couldn't understand why it took so much effort to even get up from bed. I wanted oblivion to take over. What was worse, it was Winter and couple that with SAD! I wanted to go back to the tropics so bad.

My advice? Seek the sun.

I've also heard of taking omega-3 vitamins because child birth robs the body of it because of the deficiency we are prone to depression. I have to remember that next time.

Erin Kotecki Vest 5 pts

What annoys me most about coverage of this kind, is some of the lesser known, yet just a prevalent conditions are never mentioned. I had postpartum anxiety. I had a racing mind that focused on imagined scenarios in which my baby could be hurt or taken, etc. It took us until my SECOND child (and 9 months after her birth) to realize it was a condition and get a diagnosis. There is so much more to postpartum than crying and laying in bed! I'm so glad we have editors here at blogher to write about the issue and ALL it entails!

Politics & News Contributing Editor
Queen of Spain ( http://queenofspainblog.com/ )