The Infertility Dating Analogy
by Melissa Ford

It's an easy parallel to draw especially since many times the two situations intertwine: trying-to-conceive bears many similarities to trying-to-partner. In both cases, we believe the timing is within our control until we discover that life has its own timetable. We can put in hours and hours of hope and hard work and have nothing to show for it on the other end. It may be the thing we want most, but the only aspect of our life that is completely out of reach. Both situations can move like a roller coaster once the tame ride picks up steam after the first twist or drop.

Those who find their partner with relative ease or conceive their child on the first or second try, probably wouldn't describe these life events as difficult or a roller coaster. But for those on the other end of the statistics, the ones who put themselves out there and try Internet dating and allow themselves to be set up by their Great Aunt Jane or the ones who turn to assisted conception or adoption to build their families after years of disappointments, wouldn't wish this time period on their worst enemy.

I was speaking about this with my cousin last weekend: dating sucks. Anyone who is stressed out about never having a first kiss again needs to take a step back and remember all of the horrible things about dating that they're blocking out of their mind. Yes, there is the excitement of a first date and those nights where you don't sleep, trying to find out everything about each other. And that certainly is more interesting than the day-to-day life of picking dirty socks off the floor. But there's also the anxiety--why isn't the other person calling and what did they mean by that and do they really like me and will I have to go alone to my friend's wedding in June?

It's a little bit like how we long to be back in college. Yes, you want to be young again and relive those college years, but would you really want to be apply for college right now? Because that is part of the experience too. The filling out of forms and stressing about the SATs and waiting by the mailbox for a letter. And even once you got to college, it wasn't always pulling all-nighters with your friends around a half-eaten box of Gumby's Pizza Pokey Stixes. It was about arguing with a professor and receiving a C for all of your hard work and stressing about what you wanted to be when you grew up.

The infertility world often debates this analogy and it's interesting because sometimes, the two situations intersect: because a person didn't find their partner until later in life, they waited to try to conceive until later in life and their infertility may or may not be attributed to age (just to be clear, infertility in your 40s may be a condition of age OR it may be caused by a situation that has always existed but since fertility wasn't tested until later, wasn't discovered until later). I imagine it can be salt in a very open wound to have experienced the waiting and difficulties of a long road to partnership only to be met with the waiting and difficulties of a long road to parenthood.

One of the most interesting posts I've ever read on the topic came from Teendoc at Welcome to the Dollhouse. She writes of both sides, first an exchange she had with a fellow blogger who tells her that singledom (when one wishes for a partner) is not like infertility because love can happen at any age--there can always be hope that love is around the corner since it holds no limits unlike reaching parenthood. Teendoc responds with an interesting point:

Yet going back to the original theme of this post, I have lived both lonely singledom and infertility. I’ve been to hell in both arenas and I wouldn’t wish either of these states on my worst enemy. However, from where I sit, I completely disagree with the blogger I quoted. For me, infertility was not worse that 2 decades of being single and lonely. Why? Because I had my love, my partner, my husband to travel the infertility road with me. His presence soothed my heart in ways that I cannot begin to explain.

So what is the point of all this writing? Well, while we are still caught up in the pain, frustration and loss of infertility, and want others to be sensitive to our feelings and needs, we must remember that others can be living their own personal versions of hell that are equally important to them. We cannot decide that our pain is greater than another’s pain. Pain is pain. The distress it causes must be respected and not judged.

What kicked off this long thought about the connection between infertility and coupledom? An internal question about whether it is polite to ask after a single person's love life. Is it polite or rude--caring or hurtful--to ask a friend if they're currently dating someone? I can only speak for the infertility side and say that when you are trying and failing to conceive, it can be salt in the wound to be constantly asked at family gatherings or when catching up with friends when you plan on having children. Do you admit that you've been trying and failing? Do you lie? Do you blow off the question entirely by changing the subject? Do you burst into loud, gasping sobs?

Is it equally hurtful to ask someone single if they're dating someone? Does it show an interest in all aspects of their life or is it simply poking at a sore spot to constantly be asked the same question? And are the two situation similar--asking about family building vs. asking about dating?

Your thoughts?

This Week's Required Reading

Melissa is the author of the infertility and pregnancy loss blog, Stirrup Queens and Sperm Palace Jesters. She keeps a categorized blogroll of over 1200 infertility blogs and writes the daily Lost and Found and Connections Abound, a news source for the infertility blogosphere. Her infertility book is forthcoming from Seal Press in Spring 2009.

Comments

 

So so true

This blog hit home for me.  I was single for a long time and didn't marry until I was 35.  When we started TTC, and it didn't happen immediately, I experienced some of the painful emotions of being single and dating all over again - dashed hopes month after month; wondering if, not when, it would ever happen; and wondering, like many women, if I'd waited too long to have children.  It felt like deja vu.  Luckily I was successful in the TTC world after 10 months, and so I never reached the terrible place I was in after being single for years on end.  FWIW, I hated the question "are you dating someone?"  It did feel like salt in the wound because answering "no" was so painful.  I would invariably receive that awful pity look (or, worse, the "what's wrong with you" look) and feel like a big fat loser.  I loved the quoted comments from Teendoc's post.   She - and you - said it beautifully.

 

Hitting the nail on the head

I agree with ADL, your blog is so true.

I  remember clearly dating and not dating and being engaged three times before finally marrying my sweet husband. At the ripe old age of 21 I had already gotten so so so sick of hearing 'when are you getting married' as if I could flip open a crayon book and say I Choose Periwinkle! An irony is that although I felt like I'd experienced a life time at 21, that is definitely not true at all in so many cases.

I remember sitting and asking God why I couldn't be like the other happy girls. Just wanted the perfect man to love me and didn't he come with a fantastic house and the ease of pregnancy?

Fast forward about 4 years. I had gotten married in a whirlwind situation and life never goes as you've expected. After not using birth control for 3 years I was plumb sick of the millions of insensitive people asking Are You Going To Have Children? I was a little tired of discussing the 'I guess it's not our time' topic.

We had lived through 2 single wide trailers, not fancy houses, and somehow were still barren. It didn't make sense, my plea to God seemed just as heart rendering.

Now at nearly 29 years old, still barren, now a military spouse and 7 years of marriage of my belt, I find your blog still ringing so true.  As we sit through rounds of the initial bloodwork, ultrasounds, Clomid and followup up feritility appointments my rose colored glasses just get clearer and clearer. This desire to have a child like the other kids on our block, and mainly because I JUST WANT ONE, is so strong. I watch my 20 year old friend who just lost her father and she desires to find the love of her life just as desperately.

Those of us who seek to find that one thing that is commercialised to be so easy and so expected and so wanted, really do walk such a similar trail.