Blog
Zandria.us
Bio
Hi! My name is Zandria, and I live in Washington, DC. I wrote for BlogHer.com for over three years (on topics related to single life and online datin...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Is It Possible to Give Up the Gym and Stay Fit? Would You Want To?

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 20
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Sometimes I look at the money I spend on my gym membership every month and wonder if I could achieve the same results if I worked out on my own. I only use the cardio machines on rare occasions, and I don’t attend very many group classes. Most of the time I'm going there to use the weight equipment, like dumbbells and assisted weight machines. While I know that it is possible to get a good workout outside of the gym, you have to be prepared.

I usually go to the gym 2-3 times a week, and I pay $40 per month for that privilege (that’s a $65 gym fee minus the $25 subsidy that I get from my employer), which is something I addressed a few months ago when I asked, How Much Would You Pay to Be Fit? Another gym in my area charges over $80 a month for a single person (and I won’t even go into the really fancy-schmancy clubs that can charge upwards of several hundred dollars for working out in their facility).

I’ve read that gyms across the country have been losing business due to the bad economy. Lots of people are trying to save money. They’re not hiring personal trainers as often, and if they do join a gym they’re more likely to choose a less expensive membership at a gym that doesn’t have all the “extras.”

My only problem is that I’d be worried about a lack of discipline. (Elana Cantor referenced this issue in her post, How Bad Does Your Personal Economy Have To Get Before You Give Up Your Fitness Club Membership?) I’m already accustomed to doing cardio outside of the gym, so that’s not a problem, but when I go to the gym I have a mindset that I’m going to be there on certain days of the week, stay there for a certain period of time, and work a particular muscle set (either upper or lower body).

It’s nice to have all the dumbbells, benches, and assisted-weight machines laid out for me, nice and neat and in one central place. Maybe if I had the same setup in a designated workout room at home, it would be easier -- but I happen to live in a small space, so anything I used would have to be stored somewhere and then pulled out when I needed it.

However, an advantage to switching to non-gym workouts is that it would force me to look outside of my normal routine to stay in shape, and mix things up a bit more. Right now I’m so used to doing the same dumbbell and weight-machine routines, it can be hard to motivate myself to change things up. Also, I could take the money I save and take more of those random classes that I like to try.

After doing a bit of research, I’ve identified some equipment it would be helpful to have at home if I decided to forego the gym (I’m focusing on weight-bearing exercises instead of cardio).

1. Dumbbells/kettlebells

2. Barbell and plates

3. Bench

4. Jump rope

5. Pull-up bar

6. FlexBand (an industrial-strength rubber band that can be used to do assisted pull-ups, in addition to other exercises)

7. Regular resistance bands

8. Medicine ball

9. Inflatable stability ball/BOSU

10. Yoga/Pilates mat

11. DVDs: these aren’t for everybody, but if you like DVDs you can find instruction in all sorts of things (and the variety could be beneficial).

12. CrossFit: although there are specialized gyms you can visit, the workout-of-the-day is posted daily and it’s possible to do it yourself.

13. The YMCA: Alternatively, if you’d still like the option of going to a gym, the YMCA offers income-based pricing. Also, I’ve heard there are no long-term contracts -- just let them know a couple of weeks in advance that you want to cancel, and they won’t draft your bank account the next month.

What do you think? Do you stay fit outside of the gym? If so, what do you do?

Related Reading:

For a great list of links, resources, and ideas about how to maintain Healthy Living on a Budget, check out Cranky Fitness.

Listening After Dark says she’s “generally grossed-out” by gyms and doesn’t want to sweat in the company of strangers. She says, “Who, particularly on a calm, low-cloud, balmy Wyoming evening just under 40 degrees, would choose to spend the evening in a loud, bright gym whose windows are dripping with

  • 20
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Zandria 5 pts

"Real fitness is a lifestyle, not an obligation or a chore on the checklist." So true! :)

Personal blog: Zandria.us ( http://www.zandria.us )
BlogHer blog: Singles/Fitness ( http://blogher.com/blog/zandria )

Zandria 5 pts

They offer yoga classes at my gym, and I've been meaning to check them out...it's been too long! Thanks for the reminder. :)

Personal blog: Zandria.us ( http://www.zandria.us )
BlogHer blog: Singles/Fitness ( http://blogher.com/blog/zandria )

sylinthecity 5 pts

Good for you, considering this new direction! You have the right idea. Slaving away in the gym is very Madonna circa Blond Ambition. Revolutionary at the time, but now so dated. Yoga, pilates, hiking, and walking everywhere (in addition to taking the steps every single time) are where it's at. Real fitness is a lifestyle, not an obligation or a chore on the checklist.

http://www.somewherethesunisrising.com

shoalswriter 5 pts

 Working out at home to exercise DVDs is my favorite way to get/stay fit for two main reasons: convenience and variety. It's convenient because I can fit it into my schedule and work out any time I want. It gives me variety because I can have dozens of different DVDs for the cost of a year's gym membership. I can learn dance, do step, practice yoga or Pilates or try out new techniques. Using the same equipment or going to the same classes at the gym always makes me feel bored and burned out after a few weeks. Result? I don't go. With DVDs at home, I look forward to my daily fitness time. Really!

Cathy

cathylwood.wordpress.com

TheSabina 5 pts

 I suppose it's somewhat a good thing that I am living in Thailand because everything here is so cheap including the gym membership. I started doing Yoga almost two years ago and sometimes I feel like it's one of the activities that keeps me sane and focused. 

 For those of you who have small space, I am sure there are some postures you can google on, is it possible to just do umm .. sun salutation in the morning? I heard that's an all in one exercise (mind and body). I don't know if it's a myth! 

TheSabina (www.the-sabina.com ( http://www.the-sabina.com )) is blogs about 'A Cup of Love, A Bite of Life.'

jessie63 5 pts

I had a gym memership for years and was motivated to go everyday. But, soon it became a social event instead. I still worked out but would find myself there longer than I had intended. I love working out at home, i get up, don't have to put on some cute work out clothes, i have my coffee, throw on some sweats and it is done in an hour. It has become a routine, a part of my life. I have my own clean shower, I don't have to look at naked women walking around the locker room and I can watch what i want on the tv...lol

Zandria 5 pts

I think I'd be more motivated to give up the gym if I had a workout partner, too. As it is right now, it's just me a majority of the time. :)

Personal blog: Zandria.us ( http://www.zandria.us )
BlogHer blog: Singles/Fitness ( http://blogher.com/blog/zandria )

Zandria 5 pts

Good point! I like going to a gym where the General Manager greets me by my first name whenever he sees me. I don't talk to fellow workout-people there all the time, but when I do, it's always nice to have a little break.

Personal blog: Zandria.us ( http://www.zandria.us )
BlogHer blog: Singles/Fitness ( http://blogher.com/blog/zandria )

Zandria 5 pts

In certain situations, I guess the option to go to the gym or not simply ISN'T an option! Good point. I tend to be fairly spoiled in the DC metro area, having multiple gym-options near where I live and work.

Personal blog: Zandria.us ( http://www.zandria.us )
BlogHer blog: Singles/Fitness ( http://blogher.com/blog/zandria )

Zandria 5 pts

I definitely wouldn't drive that far to go to the gym! It must be within 5 miles of where I live, preferably closer (the one I go to now is just over a mile from me). I'm sure that's easier for me to say, though, since I live in a busy-enough area. :)

Very good point about the leg machines. I do squats and lunges and stuff, but there are definitely leg machines I utilize as well.

Personal blog: Zandria.us ( http://www.zandria.us )
BlogHer blog: Singles/Fitness ( http://blogher.com/blog/zandria )

Zandria 5 pts

Well, I definitely wouldn't call myself a "bad ass" (I wish, though!). The weather in northern Virginia isn't so cold that it makes it prohibitive to go outside. If it's super-cold (like low 30s or below), or super-windy, then usually I won't exercise outside that day. And when it's hot/humid in the summer, I wait until the evening after the sun has gone down. :)

Personal blog: Zandria.us ( http://www.zandria.us )
BlogHer blog: Singles/Fitness ( http://blogher.com/blog/zandria )

sandhillsis 5 pts

When we were getting out of debt, the gym wasn't an option. So I started a DVD workout and walking program at our church, free to anyone who wanted to come. It's been great. I've developed some awesome friendships and have lost all that baby fat I was toting around. All it cost me was a DVD, dumb bells and tennis shoes. I would say I've gotten good return on my money.

As long as I have a partner, I don't need a gym. Great Post.

www.reclaimsimplicity.com ( http://www.reclaimsimplicity.com/

Discover how rich and hilarious life can be when it's simple. Tales and tips on making money mind, riding the recycle, simple food, homegrown music gardening and more.

runningcate 5 pts

but not as much as I thought I would.  Not having access to a gym here has really opened my eyes to all the ways to work out for free.  I'm running a lot, doing yoga, and I've started doing lots of exercises with just my body-weight: pushups, lunges, squats, plyometrics, etc.  

kazari 5 pts

I cancelled my gym membership last July.

I now spend a similar amount of money on membership of the indoor climbing gym, and one belly dance class a term.  Oh, and since christmas, I've lost 5 kilos - three of which I've been trying to lose for at least a couple of years.

The upside?  I have a great bunch of climbing buddies. The downside?  You can't really climb by yourself (well, bouldering is an option, but it's not as much fun if you're a wimp like me).  Oh, and I have calluses on my fingers.

So now my fitness and my social-life are much more entwined, and I don't THINK about exercising - it just happens.

But I am thinking of buying a pilates dvd for home, for some extra strength stuff.

Debra Roby 5 pts

Honestly, I gave up having someone clean my house a couple times a month to pay for a trainer. And if it came to that, I'd give up eating out or alcohol or something else before I'd give up my gym membership.

Working mostly at home, the gym is my social life. The work is sanity. The place is my "me" place. I need to escape these walls almost every day- my gym is the ideal place to do that.

At home, it is much too easy to think: I will sweep, dust, check email, walk dogs, sort rooms, do too many other things before I'd exercise at home. And I'm sure I'd be quitting earlier than I do at the gym.

That said, our house is under water restrictions. I've successfully kept us completely under our ration number by taking my showers at the gym. Which just might save me in higher water costs almost what the gym costs.

Debra
A Stitch In Time ( http://astitchintime.blogspot.com )
Weight for Deb ( http://weightfordeb.wordpress.com )

anotherjen 5 pts

There's no way I could stay in shape if I didn't go to the gym.  Once I get home, I find it really difficult to motivate myself to workout.  I don't have any workout equipment (other than a few free weights that I do use occasionally) and I don't have much room, so I'm not sure what I could even do there! 

Besides, I find that when I pay for the gym, it motivates me to really use it.  I also find it useful to have that time clearly delineated -- when you go to the gym, there's not much else you can do but workout! 

http://www.NextRichGirl.com ( http://www.nextrichgirl.com/ )

I Wanna Be A Celeb 5 pts

We have a Wii Fit we use regularly-the kids we bought it for? Not so much. I never really thought of it as a weight loss device, but my mom told me two of her senior citizen friends have lost a ton of weight using Wii Fit. I also have a treadmill, pilates reformer, free weights, a stripper pole for serious working out, and nearly every workout DVD known to man. We don't have a real gym within 20 minutes of us since moving to the country. It is possible to get a good workout out home, but I find it takes so much more commitment than it did to drive to the gym with it's lovely heated pool and hot tub. Sigh.

http://iwannabeacelebbutimtoopoortoaffordit.blogsp...

http://lvmomssincity.blogspot.com/

PositivelyAnna 5 pts

I agree with Paula.  I hate walking to the subway in the winter so doing cardio outside in the colder months isn't really an option.  Zandria are you one of those bad asses who workout outside all year round?

http://positivelyanna.blogspot.com/

paulag01 5 pts

Since I lost my gym membership when I was laid off I really really miss it. I discovered no gyms I liked near my house and wasn't willing to spend 20-30 mins driving to gym each way.  I am self-motivated & have lots of things I already do (kayak, walk, hike, cycle, yoga class)... so I didn't see it as a necessity (the gym that is).  

My biggest stumbling block is the winter. When it is too bad to be outside I get mega bored and I get tired of my weight routine. I have dumbells, a theraball, and a variety of bands I attach to a door.  good workouts, I vary them, but ennui inevitably sets in...like right now (late Feb) as I yearn for spring.

I also miss the machines that allow me to do much higher weights than I could do at home and do leg weights I cannot do the same at home (and due to old knee injuries I can't do those usual recommedations like tons of squats, etc.).  

So it is a trade off, but so far it is working...except for the low points occasionally. Thankfully spring is coming...

Paula Gregorowicz
The Paula G Company

http://www.thepaulagcompany.com