Blog
PicApp
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

A Jewish kid during x-mas

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 5
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

 

My older daughter is definitely going thru some serious x-mas jealousy this year.

Until this year she has been attending the JCC Preschool where they would celebrate Hanukkah. We also used to live in San Francisco in a very diverse neighborhood.

This year-- we moved to the suburbs (I'm still adjusting--- different post all together) she goes to public school and houses in our neighborhood are fully decorated for x-mas.

I was talking to a friend about "x-mas envy" , is it the gift, Santa, decoration, what is it that kids love about x-mas, or more specifically what does my Jewish girl is jealous of?

I don't think it's Santa- we went to her ballet class last Saturday and her teacher, self promoting the school's new sweater was saying to the girls:" maybe you can ask Santa for one", my daughter looked up to me and made a funny look as if saying- silly teacher, I don't have Santa, so clearly Santa is not the THING.

I also don't think it's the gifts, my friend was recommending I reinforced the fact that in Hanukkah you get a gift every night but I believe she has so much "stuff" and she gets things all the time so a point that gifts while still exciting are not the THING either.

With her, as it became clear this week, wondering around the neighborhood- it's the holiday decoration, she just loves GLITZ. The sparkly lights, the shiny, frilly ribbons.

There isn't really a punch line to this post, as it turns out we are going out of the country for a week for my younger sister's wedding so we are just putting this topic off for yet another year.

Happy holidays everyone, enjoy your families, the holiday food, the decor/ glitz, gifts or whatever that THING is for you.

Special Winter Holiday

Niran

 

  • 5
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Niran 5 pts

Thanks all for the valuable comments and insights, I'm back in San Francisco after spending winter break in Israel, attending my sister's wedding.

I'm back with a new perspective on things.

First, when I was in Israel I noticed quite a few x-mas trees at friends houses, when I asked the response was- "it is pretty, no harm in having it". I guess when you live there you're less concerned about maintaining yours or your kids identity, there is less of the "guilt stuff", which was a good lesson to me- so less guilt in 2009!

Second, you're all right, self identity is developed and reinforced by several things, holidays, trips, by talking about things and others, this last trip definitely reinforced this, unfortunately because of the security situation- as it turns our bad things do just that as well.

Happy 2009 everyone, to a peaceful safe year to us all.

Niran

Niran Amir

PicApp.com

Because a Picture's Worth! 

Lisa Stone 6 pts

My nieces, who would drink from sippy cups adorned with sequins if we provided them, absolutely love the sparkle too. Our family combines many faiths -- Christian, Jewish, Catholic -- as well as some atheists. This year the word is simplify, across all fronts. Perhaps we can get back to the true meaning of the season.

Lisa Stone
BlogHer Co-founder ( http://www.blogher.com/member/lisa-stone )
Surfette ( http://surfette.typepad.com )

BlogHer is non-partisan but our bloggers aren't! Follow our coverage of Politics & News ( http://www.blogher.com/topic/politics-news ).

rebellious thinker 5 pts

The one time that I went to a friend's house for Christmas was in college. She lived in a small town in upstate New York. We were all there in her big house around the big tree, and it was all of the things that I imagined a Christmas celebration to be. That is until the gifts. The brother-in-law got a rifle. How does that celebrate Christmas? That gift burst the bubble for me. 

Laura, www.RebelliousThoughtsofaWoman.com ( http://www.rebelliousthoughtsofawoman.com/ )

Mamaliciousinthecity 5 pts

My mom always took me around the neighborhood to look at the glitz, and that kept me satisfied. 

Also, as I'm sure you know, celebrating Jewish holidays and lighting Shabbat candles throughout the year make the Christmas v. Chanukah showdown sort of moot.

www.mamaliciousinthecity.com ( http://www.mamaliciousinthecity.com )

rebellious thinker 5 pts

I guess the moral of the story is to ask them what they are thinking about before jumping in with our own assumptions.

We skipped the whole Santa drama by living in Israel for most of their childhoods.  

Laura, www.RebelliousThoughtsofaWoman.com ( http://www.rebelliousthoughtsofawoman.com/ )