Bio
My name is Laurie. I have always loved words, pictures, stories, and people. I read and write obsessively. Over the years I've kept paper journals, w...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Jon & Kate Plus 8: What I (Really Don't, Probably) Want to Know About Your Family

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 24
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Before last night, I had watched Jon & Kate Plus 8 once, and vowed to never watch it again. And except for following the most basic of information in Tweet exchanges with my friend Jodi, I did not.  Until last night. Right.

I mean, why not? As a voracious consumer of both trash and treasure online, I have been bombarded by images of these people since news broke of Jon's alleged affair and then Kate's maybe-affair with the bodyguard and the rounds of the trash entertainment shows as I have been by the pre-emptive strike death coverage of both Patrick Swayze and Farrah Fawcett (who have not passed away, either of them, but when they do it will feel to me a little bit like they already did, thanks to Access Hollywood, closed captioned at the gym.)

There are allegedly 20 unforgettable Jon & Kate moments, Entertainment Weekly says, but I can't name more than a few and those happened last night in one miserable episode, which has left me thinking, I'll admit it. It drew 9.8 million viewers, more than any other TLC episode ever, so clearly I'm not alone. I'm thinking mostly, why do I care about this family? And do I really care, or is it just the power of utter media bombardment and blog chatter? And perhaps more to the point, why do they want me to care about them (except for Jon, who after five years appears to have woken from his slumber and realized he doesn't want me to, apparently?) Is it all about the money? Were the birthday party kids real or were those paid extras?

Most importantly, what about the Plus 8? What about the children, Jon and Kate? They're so cute. They're so young. They seem very bright. They still seem to like you. Is this the point where you're filming their birthday parties while pointedly not speaking to each other when you decide that maybe that kind of interpersonal drama - that intimately involves them - ought not to be shared on national television? Because even though I'm not a parent, I'm 99.9 percent certain that's what I'd decide (although I'm also that much certain that I'd never allow my family's life to be broadcast for public consumption. Just not my thing.)  

There is absolutely no reason for me to care, other than the horrible human draw to drama and real time train wrecks that makes some of us talk about people like this like we know them, like we're entitled to have an opinion about them and the choices they make as parents and family units. I have enought to do, what with my own family with its various issues and my ton of friends whose families I care about and it's just family family everywhere up in this joint. I didn't and still absolutely don't want to care about Kate Gosselin's (horrible, omg) hair or Jon's slack-jawed expression or the girl in the car (you've heard about the girl in the car, right? And the bodyguard? Sordid little story, the lot of it, really.)  I don't want to have my head invaded by images of and stories about a reality tv family from Berks County, Pa. (Right up the road, a couple hundred miles, not even, maybe! I wonder where they live? See?) who had sextuplets and twins and put those six littlest babies on television lickety-split right out of the womb.  

Even in this age of pre-fab reality, of people racing around the world for prizes and working out with trainers in insane fitness challenges, most of the shows are still about people living in houses and watching the drama unfold, let's face it, with a variety of strange twists thrown in. Jon and Kate aren't much different. Except now they're not doing well in the aftermath of her schlepping around the country to speaking engagements while he stays home and minds the farm. Now there is a huge big season premiere that interspersed awkward "KATE RULES THE WORLD" party footage (sample dialogue from Kate, pre-photograph: "Take your sunglasses off, Jon.") with very serious off-camera interviewer counselors. 

But who really knows? The stories conflict. Tonight didn't answer a whole lot,  especially for someone like me who's seen the show once, and never wanted to see it again until I, like probably thousands of unwitting souls, just wanted to see what the fuss was about.

With all I know about the cult of

  • 24
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
sasha_J 5 pts

SaSha J
i love jon and kate plus 8 i watch all the new show.....i think there just going through sum things right now that everybody go through we really dont knoe what really going on with there family just what the mag and tv  tell us how true is that??? i mean everybody got attitude u can tell kate loves her kids more then anything and she keeps it together there just being real u rather them be on the show and be fake dont u have attitude sumtime 8 kids is alot  stressfu;. i just watched the new show for the kids fith birthday  party and i felt bad for jon and kate cause these tabloids is making it more then what it is. they are both good people and and i will always be a fan of there show no matter what everybody thinks they take care of theres they are not out her on drugs not paying there bills  so everybody should just leave them alone cause there kids are takin care of no matter what

lauriewrites 6 pts

That's how your last sentence sums it up, Elana.
Laurie

lauriewrites 6 pts

Viewers will likely have to see them go to therapy. Eek...even with the voyeur issue, I know I couldn't hang with 40. Horrible. 

Laurie 

shanbrentris 5 pts

I have never once watched that show, and I certainly won't now.  

Elana Centor 5 pts

 I still remember the day the dad walked out on the family in hte Loud Family series. The big difference  between the Loud family and Jon and Kate is that The Loud Family was much  rawer , less packaged. It felt very unedited even though I knew it was but there was a different sensibility in those days.

 I do not fault jon and kate for doing the reality series in the first place - they have eight kids and it has to be a good way to earn money. I actually enjoyed the show a few years ago, recently it seems more like a product placement opportunity and the kids and their issues no longer feel front and center and this was before all the relationship drama.

Nothing good can come out of watching your family implode on national TV  except for TLC's ratings.

elana
Blogher Contributing Editor,Business&CareersFunnyBusiness ( http://funnybusiness.typepad.com/funnybusiness )

mysailorsmistress 5 pts

I have thought about that as well...

I choose what I write wisely. The fits, weird pictures, and so on are one thing. EVERY kid has them because either mom wants to take the pictures or kids just throw fits. 

Not EVERY 5 year old boy still wets the bed, I would not put that out there or for goodness sakes, if my daughter started her period. KWIM???

Also, that is ACTUAL footage of reactions stories and what have you. I feel embarrassed for the little guy. 

This show is just REALLY personal. Now with the parents in the tabloids it makes it worse. I was reading on my trashy gossip sites that they had a boost in sales for US Weekly. 

I am not really into reality TV, I have my own reality but I do not think that when the parents relationship is on the rocks in the news that the show could go on. Close shop. Do what is best for the kiddos

Jennifer

www.mysailorsmistress.net ( http://www.mysailorsmistress.net )

fittothefinish 5 pts

I've got 7 children (no multiples) and after the first season or so i got so tired of Kate's atttitude that I decided to stop watching the show. As as a parent of a large family - I can't imagine having our lives broadcast on national television. I would never choose that for myself. It's hard enough raising a family these days without the world watching! 

Diane

www.fittothefinish.com/blog ( http://www.fittothefinish.com/blog )

isuloribell 5 pts

Jennifer - your last comment has really got me thinking... most of us mom's who blog (myself certainly included) talk about our kids, and share funny (probably embarrasing) stories about them.  In this day and age we are so public with most aspects of our lives through blogging - and it will all be available when our kids are grown!  Is it much different to have a TV show vs. blogging about our lives?  (Besides the obvious, I don't have 9.8 million people reading my blog)  You made me think... thank you!

Lori

mysailorsmistress 5 pts

I have not watched many shows. Someone on CNN proved a good point. 

I guess one of the little boys still wets the bed. She stated that he will most likely hate his parents for having that on national TV and when people get a idea that he was on the show and it was him he will get made fun of. 

In reality, this is common for little boys. Really, who wants that to be remembered for people down the line!!!

Then to top it all off the stuff with the parents it is just a stock pile of ammo for people to pick on the kids.  

Jennifer

www.mysailorsmistress.net ( http://www.mysailorsmistress.net )

mysailorsmistress 5 pts

I saw on the news that TLC signed them on for 40 new shows this season!!! 

This all due to such high ratings for the first show of the new season

Jennifer

www.mysailorsmistress.net ( http://www.mysailorsmistress.net )

lilmommythatcould 5 pts

My husband wondered how I could listen to 8 kids scream on the TV after complaining about my 2 screamers.

Going off what Kim said, I have yet to see a reality family walk away unharmed from these reality based shows.  Divorce, drug abuse.  I think people should take a second look at what they are signing up for.

~Susan

http://lilmomthatcould.com/

lauriewrites 6 pts

And your second-to-last point was at the core of what I've been thinking about here. I don't like when my own relationships end or face troubled times, or the ones of the people I care about, and I know for sure that those are real. Can't escape that drama. But to seek it out on television , and I'll reiterate, when a gaggle of little kids is involved, is just too much for me.

Laurie 

lauriewrites 6 pts

I wonder how long it will take?And then I wonder why I wonder....can't win. ;) 

Laurie

lauriewrites 6 pts

It does draw the eye, does it not? I found myself wondering how and why one aspires to that style in the first place, and then how it's continually achieved. But then again I resent having to take the time to blow dry mine anymore. Interesting. I'd be surprised if someone way more invested in this than most of us (and likely for financial/photographic gain) hasn't hunted down her hair stylist yet.I'm NOT suggesting this, please - go do some volunteer work instead - but it's likely. 

Laurie 

lauriewrites 6 pts

I just don't enjoy watching relationships in turmoil on this level, with the extra layer of "what's real, what's not" added in. Yuck.

Laurie

lauriewrites 6 pts

I appreciated your analysis. (And sorry I didn't give your whole name above - that would have been nice.)

Laurie

lauriewrites 6 pts

It's hard to know what anyone's really like in this situation, but like you said I'd have to err on the side of the kids' privacy in this case. They've never had any but it might be a good time to try?

Laurie

MeghanM 5 pts

Well said, all of it.  I also used to watch the show and now refuse.  The show just needs to end.

Kim Pearson 5 pts

We've been here before. Back in 1973, there was a show called An American Family, with a middle-aged, middle-American couple, Pat and Bill Loud and their five kids (http://www.pbs.org/lanceloud/american/index.html) ( http://www.pbs.org/lanceloud/american/index.html )Everybody watched it. Anthropologist Margaret Mead said it launched a genre as significant as the novel. She was right in terms of the popular impact, but wrong, I think about the social significance.

The Loud family fell apart on national television. The oldest son, Lance, said "Television ate my family." The parents divorced. Lance came out as gay, moved to New York, tried to be a rock star, had some success as a writer, hung out with Andy Warhol, and died of AIDS and hepatitis C at the age of 50. Media ethicists debated the creepiness of it all.

I think I flipped channels once while this Jon and Kate show was on, but it never engaged me. Part of it is that I've had enough of my own childrearing and marriage drama that I really don't want to live through anyone else's. But the larger issue is that I've seen this movie before, and it wasn't cute. 

 I wish we could just say no to shows like this. 

KimBlogHer Contributing Editor ( http://blogher.org/blog/kim-pearson )|Professor Kim ( http://professorkim.blogspot.com/ )|

futureblackmail 5 pts

...her hair bothers me. I just want to yank out the piece that seems to be growing in from behind! And most of what she says is lost me on when she can't tuck it behind her ear.....lady, for all things holy....tuck!!!

megansul 5 pts

Way back when it launched the show was a lot of fun - adorable kids and funny parents.  Clearly, Kate got sucked into the fame and loved it.  Jon didn't know what to do with it.  It's a mess and I agree that the show should end - it's not fair to the kids.

sweetney 5 pts

Thanks for the props, lady!

Tracey Gaughran-Perez, aka Sweetney
CE, Entertainment & Culture
Author/Editor of Sweetney ( http://www.sweetney.com ), MamaPop ( http://www.mamapop.com ), & We Covet
( http://www.wecovet.com )

mysailorsmistress 5 pts

I have no longer watched this show. Kate has a major attitude to Jon and I think it is wrong. 

I feel for all of them in that situation. There are 8 kids involoved. They need to pull it together. 

Sadly, Kate does not seem like the "forgive and forget" type

Jennifer

www.mysailorsmistress.net ( http://www.mysailorsmistress.net )