Bio
I'm a zen master in a neurotic sheep's clothing.
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Just A Kiss: Leisha Hailey and Southwest Airlines

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 21
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

It's 2011.

I've been out for over 20 years and I've seen incredible progress towards GLBT equality. In the face of such progress, it is easy to believe that full equality is inevitable. Sometimes, it is even easy to believe that it's near.

And then something happens to remind me that, as far as we've come -- we haven't really come that far after all.

Leisha Hailey
Image: © Rick Mackler/Globe Photos/ZUMAPRESS.com

Yesterday, actress and musician Leisha Hailey took to Twitter to report an incident that occurred when she and her girlfriend shared aa kiss on a Southwest Airlines flight. A flight attendant reportedly approached the two women and told them that their behavior was inappropriate for a "family" airline. When Leisha and her girlfriend questioned the flight attendant about this and made it an issue, they were escorted off the plane. (See Autostraddle for the best run-down of the outrage that spread rapidly via Twitter.)

I was immediately offended by the use of the word "family." A "family" airline? Obviously not my family's airline.

Later in the day, Southwest responded with the following statement:

Initial reports indicate that we received several passenger complaints characterizing the behavior as excessive. Our crew, responsible for the comfort of all Customers on board, approached the passengers based solely on behavior and not gender. The conversation escalated to a level that was better resolved on the ground, as opposed to in flight. We regret any circumstance where a passenger does not have a positive experience on Southwest and we are ready to work directly with the passengers involved to offer our heartfelt apologies for falling short of their expectations.

Several passengers complained that their behavior was excessive. But who decides what is "excessive"? There are people that will see any display of affection between a GLBT couple as excessive.

GLBT people understand this. That is why we choose our moments of affections carefully. When we want to kiss or hold hands with our partners, we do a quick calculation of our safety in doing so. We consider where we are and who is watching and we decide if we can take the risk because it is a risk. We risk harassment and more. The ability to quickly determine the public display of affection to safety ratio is one of the first survival skills you develop after coming out.

I have watched many straight couples kissing on planes. I have had straight people making out inches from me on a crowded bus. I have seen straight people kissing passionately at concerts. I have even seen straight couples do blatant ass grabs in public places. I am willing to bet that none of those people ever stopped to think, "Is it safe for me to do this?"

The incident with Southwest Airlines reminds us that GLBT people still need to ask themselves that question every single time.

Recently, someone said to me, "I don't care if someone is gay or lesbian. Aren't we past all of that? Does it really matter anymore?" I thought of bullying and hate crimes and suicides and amendments to ban marriage equality. I took a deep breath before giving my answer.

No, we are not past it all. Yes, it matters.

If you have any doubts, consider the kiss. We'll likely never know if it was truly "excessive" but read articles about it. See how the women are being portrayed by some in the press. Scan the comments on articles about the incident. Search Twitter. If you do, be prepared for the hate and bigotry.

It's 2011.

We all deserve better.

  • 21
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Happy Hour 5 pts

So sad!!! Other than no longer flying SW I can raise my daughter to not only think differently but to stand-up to such hate. Sorry you had to go through that. There are many whome you know, many you do not that support you in this.

www.happyhourwithanxietygalandholly.com

loraleechoate 6 pts

This makes me sad and furious. They could have been totally making out with tongue and still should never have been kicked off a flight. Unless Southwest is willing to kick off every heterosexual honeymooner flying to cancun, they should have been left alone.

kisschronicles 7 pts

The good news: What was just a kiss has exposed a company for apparent hypocricy. The situation will also raise awareness of the level of intolerance that exists today.

Kisses. Powerful stuff.

I'm going to be following this story as it develops. I feel like the the other shoe hasn't dropped yet, especially with a formal complaint in progress, but we'll see.

Melissa Ford 11 pts

Until the wrong is righted -- with more than that statement -- it's not our family airline either. We're willing to give second chances but only when we feel reassured that the same mistake isn't going to happen again. I cannot even begin to count up the times I have leaned over and kissed my husband on a plane without incident. The times he has held my hand during take-off. Anyone who enjoys that for themselves should be working to ensure that everyone gets that right.

I know we all cracked up from my daughter over Twitter last night (http://www.stirrup-queens.com/2011/09/southwest-ai..., but it's also heartbreaking to have these talks with her, to open her eyes to what happens in the world. She is of the mindset that the more brides the better, the more kissing the better, the more happy people in love the better. I hope she never loses that outlook.

Polly Pagenhart 9 pts

Thank you for this post, Vikki, and for the update as well. Barring an heroic change of vision on SWA's PR people's part, I am ready to slice up my Southwest Airlines VISA card and find other ways to make the various plane trips I now make for work and the family vacations I plan for my family of four.

I wrote a ton of other comment stuff and just deleted it. All reasoned argumentation. The simple truth is, I've read what you wrote, I read what SWA wrote, I read the Autostraddle piece, I've read Hailey's statment, and I've read accounts of this elsewhere. An SWA employee did not tell the bigoted passenger that, all things being subjective, Hailey and her companion were not being vulgar nor were they running afoul of anything other than the complaining passengers' attitudes.

Instead–and without any checks from any of her higher-ups–she told Hailey and her companion that SWA was a "family airline," which, as you put it Vikki, is a code we totally understand. This whole system relies on all of us tacitly understanding that and some of us (the LGBT ones) remaining tastefully invisible.

I am not suprised Hailey was upset, and frankly, as diplomatic and conflict-averse as I am, I'll bet I would have been, too. To the point of being kickable off an airline? Who knows. I don't like to cause a fuss, but then again it's the conflict aversion of decent people like me that makes the bigotry seem more reasonable (because it's more familiar, and unchallenged) than the modest shows of affection from a minority couple.

Meanwhile MY family, all four of us (that's $1,832 plus taxes for a transcontinental trip for all of us, SWA, a drop in the bucket of what would have been many years and many thousands of dollars of brand loyalty) will be very glad take our business to an airline that understands the difference between family and bigotry, and trains and supports their staff to do so as well.

Vikki 5 pts

Polly Pagenhart

Luisa and I are flying to NY via Delta on Friday. Maybe we should put Delta to the kiss test? ;)

Vikki 5 pts

Leisha Hailey and her girlfriend, Camila Grey, have issued a formal statement regarding the incident.

http://www.msopr.com/press-releases/uh-huh-her-cam...

LizaWasHere 5 pts

Vikki, great post. As you and Deb mentioned, of course we don't know whether this was a peck on the lips, a full-on makeout session, or somewhere in between. But let's be realistic -- Leisha Hailey is a grown woman, and not someone infamous for crazy media stunts. Odds are that it was no more action than you could show in a PG-13 movie, likely even less. Do I want to sit next to people smooching all over each other on the plane? Not really. But I didn't want to sit in a middle seat next to a gigantic Russian body builder all the way to Istanbul either. Air travel involves risks. ;)

I'm disappointed in SouthWest Air, and I'm totally down with the call for a boycott unless they make a serious public apology and promise to do some anti-homophobia training of their staff.

Polish Mama on the Prairie 11 pts

Well what can you expect when they kicked a toddler off a place recently for saying over and over "bye bye plane"? What an antisocial world this is becoming.

Judy Schwartz Haley 20 pts

Ok seriously, I don't want to be stuck next to anyone making out - regardless of who they are. But that's really beside the point here. This two steps forward one step back mode of progress is painfully slow. Discrimination still exists, bullying still exists, racism and bigotry still exist, and we still have to stand up and say this is wrong every time we witness it.

floatingprincess 5 pts

Oh how I wish we were past it. I keep thinking if I wish it hard enough, it will happen. Soon.

Vikki 5 pts

floatingprincess

I keep wishing too.

ohjennymae 5 pts

i gotta say this really pisses me off. for a kiss? a simple kiss?!? oy. the hate and bigotry that is still alive today really scares me. it's why i try to teach my kids to love everyone and to be kind to everyone. i want to see the other passengers on this flight who weren't offended. i'd be speaking up out loud if i was one of them, for sure.

Vikki 5 pts

ohjennymae

I honestly don't know how "simple" the kiss was. I believe the bigger issue is that, so often, GLBT people depend upon on the kindness and tolerance of strangers when expressing affection for our partners.

Deb Rox 13 pts

" There are people that will see any display of affection between at GLBT couple as excessive."

So well explained, Vikki. I have flown a lot, seen snuggling and kissing couples and only once have I ever seen a flight attendant interrupt any behavior--and that's because two people were in a bathroom together.

Southwest is using the phrase "comfort of all customers" as code for "please stay in the closet as you are making us uncomfortable." Which---no. Just no.

Vikki 5 pts

Deb Rox

I've also see people who are clinging to the fact that the women became angry when confronted and the situation escalated. I'd be angry too. Maybe they were making out like crazy, maybe it was too much - I have no idea. Like you said - it shouldn't be our responsibility to make sure that everyone is comfortable with our displays of affection.

Also - have you seen some of the comments on articles about the incident? Some of the comments are frightening.

Conversation from Twitter

divamomrockstar
divamomrockstar

LesbianDad hey there! Was wondering where you'd been. Need another conference so we can chill out

uppoppedafox
uppoppedafox

blogher Thanks for the RT.

Conversation from Facebook

Celeste Douville
Celeste Douville

excellent article, thank you. I don't care how uncomfortable it made any number of other people on the plane, it's not a health and safety hazard of the drunken/drugged idiots. And yes, I have seen all manner of public displays of affection in public and have never seen anyone in any authority say one word to them, though I have heard the occasional passive aggressive "get a room"