Bio
I'm the Family, Moms...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Two Girls? Happy Parents! Four Girls? DOOM!

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 17
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

According to a new study, researchers say that our family is kind of happy. Not as happy as a family with two girls or a family with a boy and a girl, but much more happy than my friend who has four girls. It has nothing to do about situational issues, personality types or how much coffee I’ve had in the morning. It has everything to do with the number of children I have and their gender.

The study says that families with two girls are happier. Families with four girls? Not so happy.

The breakdown lists those two-girl families on top and then stumbles through a slew of variation, usually listing any combination of all girls before any combination of all boys -- except for the doomed four girl family.

  • 1.Two girls
  • 2.One boy and one girl
  • 3.Two boys
  • 4.Three girls
  • 5.Three boys
  • 6.Four boys
  • 7.Two girls and one boy
  • 8.Two boys and one girl
  • 9.Three boys and one girl
  • 10.Three girls and one boy
  • 11.Two boys and two girls
  • 12.Four girls

They list a whole mess of reasons as to why the families with two girls have an easier time than families with four girls.


Benefits of Having Two Girls Negatives of Having Four Girls
Rarely noisy Fight and argue all the time
Help around the house Difficult to reason with
Very few fights and arguments Ignore and dislike each other
Quite easy to reason with Bedtime routine is a nightmare
Play together nicely Create a lot of noise around the house
Rarely ignore each other Rarely confide in you
They confide in you Hard to deal with when ill
Very well behaved Takes ages getting ready for school
Rarely try to wind each other up Had to buy a bigger house and car
Really like each other Hard to cope with on a daily basis

Some of those points seem kind of common sense and obvious to me. More children? Louder house! Less children? Quieter house! Four girls take a long time to get ready for school? No way! But some of it is interesting in ways that this research doesn’t quite address.

While I was in a one-girl/one-boy household, I did not confide in my parents. Does that mean four girls confide even less? Or, is it really based on parenting style, personality types of children and parents alike and an any-given-day type thing? I don’t know. I’d kind of like to find out if more children equates to less open and honest communication and, if so, how do we fix it. And if it doesn't, what does and what do we do about it? I think that would be a more beneficial study than saying, “Yep, families with four children sure are stressed.” Duh.

Some of the comparisons and points made me laugh. I won’t lie; our house -- which has two boys living under the roof -- is loud. Apparently two girl households are magically quieter, though after reading some buzz on Facebook, I am not actually believing that is 100% true. I’d also like to point out that my boys help out around the house (if you don’t count their tragically messy playroom), rarely ignore each other, confide in me (tattle-tails who even tell on themselves), really are quite well behaved and, yes, actually like each other. Most

  • 17
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
lori.cartwright@heythingschange.com 5 pts

I've thought about this article a lot over the last few days...and then I blogged about it here:
http://heythingschange.com/2011/04/mom-momentour-h...

I come from a family of four girls and I have four girls and we are happy! Maybe a bit crazy, but happy too.

db1264 5 pts

I only have one daughter (aged 8 years) and think I really have it best.

Granted, my daughter does not have a built in playmate, but quite honestly, she doesn't need one with two parents who dote on her (I didn't say 'spoil'), and take the time to listen to what she has to say and talk to her.

We play with her when she is tired of playing on her own, but for the most part she is quite capable of entertaining herself during the day.

Would I have liked it had she had an older and/or younger sibling? Absolutely! But it was not meant to be as I had a miscarriage a year before she was born (a boy we would have named Aidan) and another miscarriage 4 years ago (a girl we would have named Aeryn).

So, while the research says that having two girls makes for a happier family, I would have to disagree with the results. JMHO

Donna

Jane Byers Goodwin 5 pts

Three girls and one boy. Two older sisters and a much younger sister and brother.

We loved each other, but never were there ever nor WILL there ever be four such different people. I firmly believe that if we'd all just had our own rooms, or even just a modicum of privacy, ever, we would have gotten along a lot better.

Mom made us share everything. I was the oldest, and my siblings helped themselves to everything I "owned."

I honestly believe having to share everything, including my underwear, is why I am so obsessively territorial now.

My kids had their own rooms with locks on the doors, and I even labeled their share of cokes, snacks, etc, so nobody could bother anyone else's. Yes, I am crazy.

But I do not believe in forced sharing, and I am a firm believer in having one's own stuff and having that stuff be inviolable, without express permission.

Hands off other people's stuff. Period.

"Don't be content with being average. Average is as close to the bottom as it is to the top."

Jane blogs as "Mamacita" at Scheiss Weekly, ( http://janegoodwin.net/ )hitting the fan like nobody can.

kario 7 pts

I have two daughters, two and a half years apart and I think that there are so many variables to consider I'm not even sure where to start. I'm sure that there is some difference that can be accounted for when you look at how far apart in age the girls are. My girls fight like mad a lot of the time, rarely ignore each other, and get along only when we're on family outings where they know they have no other option but each other. They confide in me, but I'm pretty sure that has more to do with them knowing they can do that safely than the fact that there aren't more of them.

I find it interesting that the family with four girls said having three is easier. In my experience, adding one to the mix makes things worse because it sets up a 2:1 situation.

I also wonder what the definition of "happiness" is in this study. Connectedness? Family time spent together? Willingness to be together? Happiness as individuals? That is so subjective and, in my opinion, subject to change with girls (especially tweens).

The personalities involved can also make a huge difference. My house is not quiet at all, ever, but my youngest is a tomboy and my oldest is a drama queen, so there is always singing or dancing or throwing lacrosse balls going on. The girls do help out, but again, I suspect that has more to do with house rules and expectations on our part than the fact that there are two of them.

I wonder what the purpose of the study was and if there will be further investigation. Seems totally incomplete to me...

Kario

http://www.the-writing-life.blogspot.com

JennaHatfield 10 pts

I shared another link with Elizabeth above about only children being happier in general ( http://theweek.com/article/index/209354/are-only-c... ), though it doesn't state whether the parents are happier... just the kids.

Family Section Editor Jenna Hatfield (@FireMom ( http://twitter.com/FireMom )) blogs at Stop, Drop and Blog ( http://stopdropandblog.com ) and The Chronicles of Munchkin Land ( http://thechroniclesofmunchkinland.com ). She is a freelance writer and photographer.

Rita Arens 7 pts

Rita Arens authors Surrender Dorothy ( http://bit.ly/Qp0sS ) and is the editor of Sleep is for the Weak ( http://tinyurl.com/9pg62e ). She is BlogHer's assignment and syndication editor.

elks47 5 pts

I think the study is a bunch of bunk! I am a female with 3 sisters and I am confident that not my parents nor my sisters would feel any differently. We had a VERY HAPPY childhood and likewise our adulthood. Oh, and we did this with shared bedrooms and 1, yes I said 1, shared bathroom. I believe the study should focus more on the quality of parenting and less on the number of siblings. We were raised with the imporance of family first and foremost in our lives. I consider my 3 sisters to be my best friends...mom also. We 4 girls are all now over 50 and still gather regularly for family time which includes the entire family (spouses and the next 2 generations)...family time that many smaller families would envy. We have just experienced some extreme hardship with the loss of our dad and then mom falling ill - don't know how i would have gotten through it without all 3 of my sisters. I guess you can tell...that study has struck a nerve with me!

TheBlackTortoise 5 pts

I come from a family of nine: 6 girls, 3 boys. I can say the harmony in my family was indeed, like The Waltons. The girls are all close, the boys are all involved with the greater family.

Everyone has families of their own, some large, some small, one has two girls, one as eight boys. Some are more harmonious than others. The greater moments of harmony ebb and flow based on where individuals are on their life's journey, including the children's. All of the parents try their darnedest to be the best parents possible.

I had two boys first, then two girls. We had tons of chaos, especially during the teen years.

My opinion: three of any combination is the hardest. You have two hands, two knees, two ears, and generally two parents, which makes two children a breeze. After three, easy-peasy.

Adela

Blogging at:

www.oncealittlegirl.wordpress.com ( http://www.oncealittlegirl.wordpress.com )

and

www.theblacktortoise.com ( http://www.theblacktortoise.com )

JennaHatfield 10 pts

Only children are the happiest ( http://theweek.com/article/index/209354/are-only-c... ), though it doesn't comment on their parents.

Contributing Editor Jenna Hatfield (@FireMom ( http://twitter.com/FireMom )) blogs at Stop, Drop and Blog ( http://stopdropandblog.com ) and The Chronicles of Munchkin Land ( http://thechroniclesofmunchkinland.com ). She is a freelance writer and photographer.

JennaHatfield 10 pts

LOL.

Contributing Editor Jenna Hatfield (@FireMom ( http://twitter.com/FireMom )) blogs at Stop, Drop and Blog ( http://stopdropandblog.com ) and The Chronicles of Munchkin Land ( http://thechroniclesofmunchkinland.com ). She is a freelance writer and photographer.

victorias_view 19 pts moderator

two older sisters and needless to say my father was a very quiet man.

However, I have two energetic boys who keep me on my toes with their no fear attitude. It can be loud and hairy at time. But I wouldn't trade it for the world :)

fouragainsttwo 6 pts

My hubby doesn't even have a male dog to bond with! He handles having four girls well though. Yes, fighting, fighting and fighting is about right! Also whining whining whining. The giggling does sometimes overcome though doesn't it?!

Mandy W.

FourAgainstTwo.com

homeroad 5 pts

I hate to admit it but I think you might be right. I am the mother of 4 girls.... They are 11 years apart and yes, it has been a long haul! Fighting, teasing, loud, fighting, cranky, PMS, fighting, whining.... did I mention fighting?
And oh yes,Dad, poor dad is just plain left out in this house, luckily he does have his dog.
I'm sorry I can not refute the stats... but I have to agree, 4 girls is NOT easy!

nellewrites 6 pts

girls, and whilst they were quite easy overall, they had their moments when they tangled.

On the other hand, I have rather proud memories of how my eldest protected her sister, and in fact saved her twice.

nellewrites ( http://nellewrites.wordpress.com/ )

Brenda M 5 pts

Brenda

http://www.grrlguide.com/

I have a boy and a girl, and by some strange twist of fate, they get along all the time. I know it's my little slice of heaven here on earth so I don't brag about it when I hear other Mom's horror stories. I think you are right when you said it has to do with dynamics of the individual home, parents, style, the kids themselves and how all of that mixes and comes together.

Denise 9 pts moderator

Three girls and three boys. Woe is me.

~Denise
BlogHer Community Manager
Life. Flow. Fluctuate.

texasebeth 6 pts

I come from a family of 2 girls and let me tell you - we were nothing like the article described. We wound each other up and do not like each other very much. I do love my sister but don't really like her (long story). My sister has never been easy to reason with. We were rarely quiet unless reading. And we didn't play together nicely much at all.

And what about us parents of only kids? Where were we on the scale? Not even mentioned?!

Elizabeth

@texasebeth ( http://twitter.com/texasebeth )  and My Life, such as it is.... ( http://texasebeth.blogspot.com )