Bio
Hi, I'm Karen Ballum, but I'm better know around the web as Sassymonkey. I live in Ottawa, Ontario -- Canada's national capital. (No, I do not li...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

To Kindle Or Not to Kindle?

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 6
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

If you don't know what Kindle is you are neither a technogeek nor a regular visitor of Amazon.com. Launched in November the Kindle is Amazon's take on the e-book reader. If I believe what I read the Kindle is handy because you can connect wirelessly to Amazon and order a book with will appear on your device almost instantaneously. It also has electronic paper display. Don't know what that means? Good. Me neither. But apparently I should be impressed by it.

I will freely confess that I am not an e-book fan. Between using the computer for work and using the computer for play (because really, I can't imagine a day without blogs) the last thing that I want to do when I shut down is stare at the screen of an e-book reader while I lie in bed at the end of the day. I'm far more likely to want to curl up with a sideways book than an electronic device. It doesn't help that I have this whole conception of e-books as "disposable" books. With the way technology progresses at the speed of lightening (or so it seems) will that e-book stay with me forever? Not likely. Will the format and software become ancient all too soon? I've just never embraced the whole electronic book thing. Because I love books. I just don't love to read them but I love the feel of a book in my hands. The way the paper feels under my fingers - how a page can be sturdy with rough edges or as delicate as tracing paper and edged in gold. I'm probably not the ideal customer for this product am I?

But clearly others are snapping it up. As I sit here and type it's out of stock and orders are being shipped on a first come first served basis. But what do the bloggers say? Because you know we can count on them for an opinion.

Who else would you expect to review such a device but Scoble? He gave it a one week, two book test. I think he made some really good points about what we expect from devices. If it's on the net we expect social networking. If it connects to Amazon why can't we also order (paper) books to be sent to our home? How come we can't sent e-books to others with Kindle? His final verdict:

Would I buy it? Yes, but I’m a geek. I can’t really recommend this to other people yet. Sorry.

On the flip side, Mary at the LibraryLaw Blog loves hers.

Delightful to read the newspaper, magazines, books, your own documents. You can read for hours comfortably. In fact, I believe that in many scenarios, I'd PREFER this, yes you read that right, I'd prefer the KINDLE to a real book or magazine. That surprises me, even though I was looking for the convenience of an ebook reader (dozens or hundreds of titles), I always expected to say, "of course the paper book is a better reading experience." That may be changing. This not only rivals the paper experience, it surpasses it in many ways. It's EASIER to hold than a hardback, easier to turn pages with one hand than a paperback or newspaper, and that's all before the extra features.

Mary's post has Nicole almost wanting one:

Sounds like a pretty darn cool toy - my only problem is the price - I’m not sure I want to pay $400 for a tool to allow me to read books and then buy the book as well - when I could just buy the book for $15 … in short, this is a technology I’m going to keep my eyes on and will probably give in to once its price lowers just a bit.

Kassia at Booksquare suggests that it could be a positive tool for the education system:

It’s really kind of sad, watching today’s students as they trudge to and fro. They look like sad turtles, what with all those heavy books and lack of on-campus storage (what we used to call “lockers”). Plus, it seems like you always need your book for homework. We are raising a generation of serious back problems.

Hmm now there's an idea that could almost sell me on it. Not so much for children because although I do hate that they have to carry around so many books, most kids I know would end up dropping, stepping on or losing their device. And

  • 6
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
ebabe 5 pts

A lot of the feedback on the Amazon Reviews is positive - but there are enough feature issues noted that I think I might just wait until the next version is released. Just like ipods, the price should also go down. But... if I were to receive this as a gift (hint, hint) I don't think I'd be returning it very soon!

Being a commuter - a subway one that is, safety first girls! - this is a great product. No longer will I be tied to whatever is in the free Metro paper or whatever I've brought that day. At a fingertips ready, I have all the books, magazines, blogs, and zines I could want! Also - it's super compact and portable. Perfect for the subway smoosh.

I have to agree with jjulesss though - one device for everything would be IDEAL!

jjulesss 5 pts

Kindle will strip out illustrations in order to fit as many books in as it can and speed up downloading, so it isn't useful for anything that required pics. The storage is relatively small, just looks huge because it's text only. When they start putting PDFs on the number of books will decrease a lot. Maybe that's when they'll increase the storage. I do like the sound of being to connect up anywhere to download things, but once again, using the mobile phone system for anything except straight text is going to be a killer.

I like the idea of electronic reading because I commute an hour each way five days a week and I like to use the time reading. I also like to listen to music and I would like to be able to do some journaling, gaming or other electronic based work. My problem with the Kindle is that it doesn't do enough for me.

I'm hanging out for the affordable one-device-for-everything. I can carry a book for reading, a book for writing, a machine for music, a phone and I can play some limited games on that, or I can carry all electronic versions, or I can wait for the UMPC with a decent sized storage that does everything including phone and networking. Yeah!

Zandria 5 pts

I think my biggest problem is the price. I get a vast majority of my books from the library because I usually only read a book once, so I enjoy reading for free. Having to pay for the device AND pay for each book would just be too much.

Personal blog: Keep Up With Me ( http://www.zandria.us )
BlogHer blog: Life - Singles ( http://www.blogher.com/blog/zandria )

sassymonkey 6 pts

I just pulled this from the Kindle site: PDF conversion is experimental. The experimental category represents the features we are working on to enhance the Kindle experience even further. You can email your PDFs wirelessly to your Kindle. Due to PDF’s fixed layout format, some complex PDF files might not format correctly on your Kindle.

So if you wanted to use the Kindle mostly for library books it's probably not the best option for you at this time. But, and this is just my opinion, I think it's something they will have to improve in the future. I thinks there are a lot of people who are waiting for the second generation version and are expecting this to be one of the things to be improved.

Sassymonkey ( http://sassymonkey.ca/ ) and Sassymonkey Reads ( http://sassymonkeyreads.wordpress.com/ ).

Denise 9 pts moderator

If your library offers ebooks in PDF format, you can probably game the Kindle and get them uploaded but the display isn't always great, from what I read on a review somewhere.

~Denise
BlogHer Community Manager

Fast Times @ Homeschool High ( http://fasttimes.clubmom.com ) & Flamingo House Happenings ( http://www.flamingohouse.net )

Virginia DeBolt 5 pts

I don't have the money to buy one of these right now, but I'm interested in any new tech tool. When I think about whether it would be useful in my own life, I have questions about library books, or any form of freely available but limited time reading. (I read about 4 books a week and could never buy them all.)

The question is, can you read things like library books with a Kindle?

http://www.webteacher.ws/
http://first50.wordpress.com/