Bio
Hi - I'm Maria, nice to meet you! I've been a Contributing Editor here at BlogHer.com since 2006. I joined BlogHer as a full-time staff member after...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Is Laughter Still The Best Medicine When The Humor Turns Dark?

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 15
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Is it OK to laugh about serious subjects? Is it acceptable to make light of events that are causing people real pain? Even if you are laughing instead of crying are you still keeping your focus on the negative rather than the positive? When is dark humor acceptable and when does it cross a line?

One of my favorite forms of humor involves self-deprecation. If my circumstances are difficult I try not to complain but I will make a joke. I am often admonished not to say such things and instead be grateful things are not actually as bad as I jokingly describe.

If some people are uncomfortable when we make fun of ourselves imagine the distaste people have for dark humor about the economy, illness or death.

I recently saw a link to a clip of comedian Louis CK performing a stand up routine about white (male) privilege. And I found it wickedly funny. But not everyone did. There are several comments on the YouTube clip calling Louis CK racist. Some of that comes from the common misunderstanding that privilege is not racism (Your thinking and behavior make you racist; privilege is a gift that you receive from society regardless of your thinking or behavior). But some of it comes from people simply thinking the subject is not an appropriate source of humor.

Watch and see what you think.

Recently President Obama was interviewed on 60 Minutes and Steve Kroft scolded him for laughing while talking about the economy and Kroft asked Obama if he were "punch drunk." Obama responded: "No, no. There's gotta be a little gallows humor to get you through the day."

Bonnie Erbe at US News & World Report wasn't laughing:

And therefore, having a lot on one's plate excuses that person from laughing about people being out of work? If you're busy, it's OK to joke about the economy being in a freefall and the ineffectiveness of the president's stimulus package thus far? I don't think so.

Leaving aside the critics who are looking for any reason to display their distaste for the president and reviewers who took him to task for his lack of comic timing, many just felt that it's just not right for anyone, especially politicians, to level levity at a situation that is bringing so much unfunny pain to so many real people.

Personally I keep going back to the old adage I mentioned at the beginning - we laugh to keep from crying. People like me make jokes about their own difficult circumstances. And if you think seeming not to take the economy seriously is bad what of those who got jokes about death and dying?

Years ago a friend of mine was killed in a car accident. A group of us gathered to share our grief when we learned the horrific news. As we reminisced our dead friend's best friend said "well, he always was a terrible driver." I cannot convey how and why this was funny but it was. The joke cut through the painful fog that enshrouded us and we all dissolved into a fit of giggles. It did not mean that the person who made the comment loved his friend any less or that those of us who gathered forgot our sadness even for a second. What that moment did do was kick off the sharing of many stories about what a wonderful loving friend he was and helped us find words to express how much we would miss him and move past collectively sitting around a table mostly weeping or stunned into silence. There is even some evidence that, when it comes to mourning, laughter may indeed help you to smile, though your heart is aching.

So again I ask - is it OK to laugh about serious subjects? Is it disrespectful to those who are suffering to joke about the economy? Are those who make light of death in order to cope disrespectful? And, if you are a believer in the law of attraction, do you think exaggerating your own difficulties just to get a laugh risks manifesting the exaggeration into reality?

Dark Humorists:

At her personal blog, Funny Business, BlogHer CE Elana Centor offers Financial Crisis Humor:

According to an email making the rounds, a Market Correction is the day after you buy stocks. In case your email filters prevent these humor emails from making

  • 15
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Tor_Hershman 5 pts

Howdy do, Ms. Niles, I just surfed in and thought I'd give you one of moi's REALLY darkly humorous works.

WARNING: Godless/Satanless crap

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_m6qC6FCiY0

Stay on groovin' safari,

Tor Hershman

Maria Niles 5 pts

To feature your terrific post and your blog. Thanks for your kind words and your comment.

BlogHer Contributing Editor ( http://www.blogher.com/blog/maria-niles )
PopConsumer ( http://consumerpop.typepad.com/popconsumer )
Beyond Help ( http://mariax.vox.com/ )

ktprince 5 pts

What a thoughtful article.  I can't believe anyone besides my 50 loyal readers even reads my stuff.  This is a nice way to featured.  Thank you.

Maria Niles 5 pts

it doesn't go too far. I've heard a couple of cautions since I wrote this that ring true about self-deprecating humor...

1. If you do it too much or too consistently (e.g. the answer to everything is "I'm an idiot! :D" people will lose respect for you or if it's a stranger they might never develop it.

2. Cokie Roberts said she finds she has to be careful from over using the technique when she's on the Sunday morning political shows because men are often quick to take you seriously and believe you when you poke fun at yourself.

Otherwise, like you, I'm a big fan and it is one of my favorite coping techniques.

Thanks for your comment!

katie84 5 pts

Honestly, the best way for me to get through a bad situation is just to make fun of it and myself. You have to laugh sometimes. People can think it's inappropriate, can think you're taking it the wrong way, or can just think you're being disrespectful. I just think it's trying to find a way through it.

Maria Niles 5 pts

Thank you for coming over and commenting here at BlogHer. I loved your post. I think your humorous approach is positive and proactive. Good for you for getting through the day and dealing with those around you in a way that works for you.

All the best and thanks again for your comment.

kerriemm 5 pts

Obviously you know how I feel about this issue (I'm the girl at the doctor's office) but wanted to thank you for writing this.  I've been battling with some issues for quite some time now - and truthfully - if I didn't laugh about it...I would curl up in a ball and never get up.  Making fun of myself also let's people know that they don't have to tip toe around me.  Thanks again for this great post.

Maria Niles 5 pts

I'm right there with you, Lucinda. Thanks for your comment!

LucindaA 5 pts

I always make jokes, especially when things are dark.  Because if you can't laugh, then you just end up crying.  I would hope and pray that at my funeral, people are making the most ridiculous jokes and laughing at my expense.

Maria Niles 5 pts

Thanks for sharing this story, Jenna. Indeed what a gift to receive Ray's lesson in death.

Maria Niles 5 pts

Thanks for your comment, SoMuchMoreThanAMom. I wasn't bothered by the president's laugh while talking about the economy. I do the same thing.

Maria Niles 5 pts

Beautifully put. Thanks for your comment!

BlogHer Contributing Editor ( http://www.blogher.com/blog/maria-niles )
PopConsumer ( http://consumerpop.typepad.com/popconsumer )
Beyond Help ( http://mariax.vox.com/ )

Jenna Woodul 5 pts

What seems like a long time ago now, my brother's partner Ray died. We were at the hospital with him, along with assorted other friends and his mom and sisters. My brother and I were the last to leave the hospital, and I dreaded the vibes in his house when we got home. Already it was too heavy to bear, and with Ray's mom and sisters staying at my brother's house, I felt apprehensive about what more sadness might await us when we opened the door. Instead, from the front porch, we heard them all laughing and giggling in the front room. For the next few days we joked at such inappropriate things as the craziness Ray'd had to say in his last demented stages. What a blessing it was to laugh; I'm still so grateful to them all for teaching me that. And I'm sure Ray would have agreed that it was hilarious.

SoMuchMoreThanAMom 5 pts

Dark humor is one of my favorites, because it can be therapeutic.  We laugh so as not to cry, just like you said.  Your example about your friend always having been a terrible driver is a perfect example.  As far as President Obama, he is human.  He comes across as "real" when he behaves like anyone else.  This instills confidence, at least for me.

http://somuchmorethanamom.wordpress.com/ ( http://m/ )

LizzieH 5 pts

My own personal philosophy is that I can't really control the circumstances of life, but I can control my reactions to those circumstances.  Being sad and depressed isn't going to improve the economy, bring back a dead friend, change a cancer diagnosis, increase my property values or lower my mortgage payments, so why not make a joke about it or at least try to see the humor in the situation?  It certainly can't hurt, and it just might help!

 --Liz

I blog about creating a life worth living at:  http://inventingliz.blogspot.com