Bio
Hi - I'm Maria, nice to meet you! I've been a Contributing Editor here at BlogHer.com since 2006. I joined BlogHer as a full-time staff member after...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Learning to Listen: A Humbling Lesson

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 7
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

I can't stop thinking about her. As I watched her walking away, already almost to the end of the mall parking lot, pulling her backpack tight around her shoulders as if it could make her invisible, I debated for a split second asking my friend to drive me up to her so I could beg her forgiveness and ask for a do over. But I didn't.

Instead I've turned our encounter over and over in my mind until it has become like a stone polished smooth by ocean waves. My prayers vacillate between petitions to make me a better person and then feeling too full of hubris by making it about me and asking God to just simply watch out for her.

It was a routine event I've experienced many times but I wish I could go back in time and open myself to being present and listening to another human speak to me.

I had dinner with a group of friends and had planned to pay for my portion with a credit card. The card I gave the server was declined. I had been fairly sure that I had room on that card but when it was declined I panicked a bit and hesitated to give her a different one unsure if I had mixed up balances or if there was a problem (I've been a victim of identity theft in the past but it turned out I had forgotten a yearly fee that had automatically processed that day). So, with the help of a couple of my friends chipping in, I spent my remaining cash on my share of the bill.

As we left and were getting into my friend's car a woman approached me and asked in a very soft voice if she could ask me a question. She asked a second time, a bit louder, to be sure I heard her and knew that she was directing her question to me. I didn't answer. Instead I told her sharply that if she needed help I was very sorry but I did not have any cash. Taken aback by my curt lecture, she slunk down and hurried off.

As I got in the car I realized that I had half my meal left over in a doggie bag. I had been so busy focusing on my worries and embarrassment and feeling of lack that I completely forgot what I had right in my hand. When I am approached by panhandlers I am often in a rush and alone. Not that it excuses my impatience but it makes me unlikely to stop and dig through my purse to find my wallet and open it up on the street. Also, given the recession and the fact that I live in a large urban area, simply running errands and going to the grocery store means that I can encounter half-a-dozen requests for aid or more in a single morning. But I feel helpless in the face of relentless need. I think to myself, better to give to a good organization rather than trying to pick and choose between individuals. The result is that I have already answered "no" before I am even asked.

I didn't give the woman in the parking lot a chance to speak. I don't know what she wanted to ask me. I just assumed, my heart hardened by the weight of so many requests. If I had allowed her to ask me what she wanted perhaps she would have requested money or indicated a need for food. I still had two dollar bills in my wallet and some change in addition to the bagged up food I planned to take home to have for lunch the next day. If that is what she needed, I could have given that to her. I had a check in my wallet, a bed to sleep in and kitchen to return to - I could live without a few dollars and some leftovers. Maybe she could not.

I have not been immune to the difficulties of the recession many of us have struggled with. But there for the grace of God go I. This I know. I wish that I had stopped and listened to the woman who wanted to ask me a question rather than the voices of fear in my head. I wish I had remembered the the stories I've never forgotten of similar encounters and how women I admire reacted in similar situations guide my actions

  • 7
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
lovenlaughterb 5 pts

Wow Michelle what a powerful story. I have tears in my eye from just reading it. The way you reached out to her by giving her your number and befriending her is truly something to be proud of. It obviously speaks volumes to your character.

I will remember what you said "Truth is, every time I think about that day I think of the blessing of a new friendship I would have missed out on had I got those words out."....what a great lesson.

Thanks for sharing.

b from http://www.notasparrowfalls.com/

Maria Niles 6 pts

Thank you so much for sharing it, Michelle. Your lesson and your father's advice are both excellent.

BlogHer Contributing Editor ( http://www.blogher.com/blog/maria-niles )
PopConsumer ( http://consumerpop.typepad.com/popconsumer )
Beyond Help ( http://mariax.vox.com/ )

Southerngirl 5 pts

I had a simular situation happen to me. I am an old man magnet. The dirty old ones too. Well a few weeks ago at a gas station an older man walks over to my pump and says miss you look soo pretty today. I did not feel like getting hit on by yet another one so I was getting ready to let him have it but when I looked at him he had tears in his eyes. It stopped me cold. He said I just wanted to ask if you could tell me where you shop because my daughter's house burned down a few weeks ago and her husband died in the fire. He said I have no idea how to help her get through this but I know ladies like to look nice. I want buy her one of those store cards because everything she has right now has come from the older women in my church. He said she is just as pretty as you and as a father I want her to know that too you know. I felt like grade A crap. Below market low. I told him where my clothes came from and gave him my number for his daughter to call if she needed someone her own age to talk to. Turns out she moved from another state and had no one here she really knew. I had her over for brunch with some of the women from my church and my friends. Truth is, every time I think about that day I think of the blessing of a new friendship I would have missed out on had I got those words out. It makes me feel shame everytime. The other thing is my dad used to tell me that no matter if I like a guy or not it takes nothing from me to be nice. It takes a lot of courage to walk up to a stranger. Treat those guys the same way I would want my brothers and cousins treated. 25 year old advice and it still applies.

Michelle

I blog at http://www.mommycan.blogspot.com/

Southerngirl 5 pts

I had a simular situation happen to me. I am an old man magnet. The dirty old ones too. Well a few weeks ago at a gas station an older man walks over to my pump and says miss you look soo pretty today. I did not feel like getting hit on by yet another one so I was getting ready to let him have it but when I looked at him he had tears in his eyes. It stopped me cold. He said I just wanted to ask if you could tell me where you shop because my daughter's house burned down a few weeks ago and her husband died in the fire. He said I have no idea how to help her get through this but I know ladies like to look nice. I want buy her one of those store cards because everything she has right now has come from the older women in my church. He said she is just as pretty as you and as a father I want her to know that too you know. I felt like grade A crap. Below market low. I told him where my clothes came from and gave him my number for his daughter to call if she needed someone her own age to talk to. Turns out she moved from another state and had no one here she really knew. I had her over for brunch with some of the women from my church and my friends. Truth is, every time I think about that day I think of the blessing of a new friendship I would have missed out on had I got those words out. It makes me feel shame everytime. The other thing is my dad used to tell me that no matter if I like a guy or not it takes nothing from me to be nice. It takes a lot of courage to walk up to a stranger. Treat those guys the same way I would want my brothers and cousins treated. 25 year old advice and it still applies.

Michelle

I blog at http://www.mommycan.blogspot.com/

Southerngirl 5 pts

I had a simular situation happen to me. I am an old man magnet. The dirty old ones too. Well a few weeks ago at a gas station an older man walks over to my pump and says miss you look soo pretty today. I did not feel like getting hit on by yet another one so I was getting ready to let him have it but when I looked at him he had tears in his eyes. It stopped me cold. He said I just wanted to ask if you could tell me where you shop because my daughter's house burned down a few weeks ago and her husband died in the fire. He said I have no idea how to help her get through this but I know ladies like to look nice. I want buy her one of those store cards because everything she has right now has come from the older women in my church. He said she is just as pretty as you and as a father I want her to know that too you know. I felt like grade A crap. Below market low. I told him where my clothes came from and gave him my number for his daughter to call if she needed someone her own age to talk to. Turns out she moved from another state and had no one here she really knew. I had her over for brunch with some of the women from my church and my friends. Truth is, every time I think about that day I think of the blessing of a new friendship I would have missed out on had I got those words out. It makes me feel shame everytime. The other thing is my dad used to tell me that no matter if I like a guy or not it takes nothing from me to be nice. It takes a lot of courage to walk up to a stranger. Treat those guys the same way I would want my brothers and cousins treated. 25 year old advice and it still applies.

Michelle

I blog at http://www.mommycan.blogspot.com/

Maria Niles 6 pts

It's not always an easy call what to do. And your friend's story shows why it can be tough (and thank goodness for his training). I can't imagine ever pulling out my wallet on the street for exactly that reason.

Sometimes I remember to carry a bit of cash in an external pocket or gift cards to grocery stores or fast food places for such opportunities.

Thanks so much for sharing your experiences and for your comment, Maria.

BlogHer Contributing Editor ( http://www.blogher.com/blog/maria-niles )
PopConsumer ( http://consumerpop.typepad.com/popconsumer )
Beyond Help ( http://mariax.vox.com/ )

Maria Young 5 pts

when I can. If my car is stopped where a person is panhandling, if I have extra cash I will give it to them.

You must be careful though: a friend of mine in SF was asked for change the other night and when he went for it, the guy pulled a knife on him and tried to rob him. Little did he know that my friend is trained in Muy Thai and dropped him immediately. But what if he wasn't, you know?

- Maria Young

immoralmatriarch.com ( http://immoralmatriarch.com )

@maria0305 ( http://twitter.com/maria0305 )