Bio
Unwilling to fully abandon my Chicago-area upbringing, I live in Manhattan with my husband, my teddy bear, and a 10 lb. rabbit, but insist on calling...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Legal Abortion Is a Legitimate Campaign Issue

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 19
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

In the summer of 2008, I was shocked to discover that abortion rights was not a top issue for left-leaning people I knew who participated in an informal poll about what issues matter to them. My 100% anecdotal evidence was derived from a writing class in which I was enrolled. Comprised of 12 individuals - nine of whom were women, and 11 of whom were admitted liberals/progressives - we went around the room and named our top three issues in this election. Only one person said reproductive rights. Yes, that person was me.

WASHINGTON - JANUARY 22:  Local pro-choice activist Lisa King holds a sign in front of the U.S. Supreme Court as a pro-life activist holds a rose nearby during the annual 'March for Life' event January 22, 2009 in Washington, DC. The event was to mark the anniversary of the 1973 Roe v Wade Supreme Court abortion ruling.  (Photo by Alex Wong/Getty Images)

Given the obstacles that many people must overcome to obtain and/or provide abortions, reproductive rights are always in my top three issues when I evaluate a candidate. In the past, I've explained that I usually find that candidates who are pro-choice tend to support a ranges of other issues that are important to me, such as the environment, fixing our social safety net by ending tax cuts for the wealthy and corporations, and expanding health care coverage. Thus I assume that other progressive women are like me, and they prioritize reproductive rights as an election issue. This year I might be on to something.

An article in the New York Times reports that Democrats are making legal abortion a big issue this year. Their opponents claim that attention to their anti-choice platforms (abortion should not even be available in the case of rape or incest) is a distraction from “real issues” (my quote marks, since I think self-autonomy is a real issue) and “simply an attempt to change the subject” (real quote from Ken Buck, the Republican candidate for Senate in Colorado. Buck continues, “The No. 1 issues are jobs and the economy.”

Right. Because having the ability to decide whether to bring a child to term has nothing to do with jobs or the economy. Obviously, pregnant women never develop complications that prevent them from working and supporting themselves or their families. Plus, high quality child care is affordable and available to all women who want it. Further, the jobs that are “created” by Republican “plans” pay well enough to raise tons of children well above the poverty line.

If only that were the case. It turns out that 1 in 5 women in the US are placed on bed rest at some point during their pregnancies, report Amie Newman at RH Reality Check. She asks some crucial questions:

How do pregnant women ordered on bed rest pay their bills if they can no longer work? For low-wage workers, living paycheck to paycheck, is bed rest even possible? Does family leave cover bed rest? If a woman has saved up vacation or sick days but uses them up during her period of bed rest, does she have any way to take leave post-birth and still have the guarantee of a comparable job to which to return afterwards? Are there other coverage options available?

The answers all indicate that pregnant women are pretty much financially screwed. So yes, abortion is 100% about jobs, economics, and the economy.

If a woman did decide to bring a pregnancy to term and needed to work to support the child, she’s also probably out of luck on finding high quality affordable child care, particularly if she is a low-income worker. The Mama Bee weighed in on the child care conundrum:

While caregivers in general make very little money and are often without benefits, childcare costs represent a large piece of family budgets. The National Association of Childcare Resource and Referral Agencies estimates that care represents roughly 15% of family budgets; they point out that infant care costs more in 43 states than tuition at a public college...

The irony of daycare is that, while it’s a cheaper and better solution for working families, it also is virtually inaccessible for large numbers of those same families. First, there just aren’t enough high-quality center-based programs, particularly for children under

  • 19
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
livingabsolute 5 pts

As an agnostic, democrat, feminist who just experienced a stillbirth. It makes me very sad that we cannot educate women equally on all of their options, without ridiculous religious arguments. Abortion is harmful to women. Abortion is a sign that we have not met the needs of women. Women deserve better than abortion. Women often turn to abortion because they feel they have NO OTHER "choice". Women are threatened into abortion by parents in order to keep their puritan image...by boyfriends in order to not pay a lifetime of child support. I do not support making abortion illegal...but I do support fully educating women on the repercussions of abortion. Telling women the truth about what they are aborting. Many women are finding out years later that these "cells" that they thought were aborted, was actually a fetus...a living thing...with a beating heart and a full set of human DNA. To not educate women, we are oppressing them. Choice is not really a choice when it is a lie or a stretch of the truth...and when women are suffering from guilt, infertility and regret following abortions.

Von 5 pts

Don't know why the women of America and their partners allow their politicians to get away with these appalling conditions.

denverlori 5 pts

... one word, CHOICE! When there are choices we have the freedom to do what is best for us and for our families. I totally agree that you never know what curve balls life will throw your way. Lost jobs, difficult pregnancies, increased cost of daycare etc are not always easy to "plan" for.

queenmommy 5 pts

I'm going to assume you just didn't read all of my comments or understand what I was saying. I read Suzanne's article as a way out for people who get pregnant on purpose and then decide to abort because they didn't go into their pregnancy prepared. I believe by the back and forth I had with her that she didn't mean that at all. I was speaking at this from a purely, "I wanted this baby but I can't afford to quit working, oh well" point of view.

wrw28 5 pts

I guess the same personal responsibility should account for overweight people and overweight children who tend to have heath problems as a result. Unfortunately that is not the way our country works--my health insurance still goes up regardless of how well I take care of myself.

Additionally I have no say in how many children people have, but I still have to pay for school funding, live on an overcrowded polluted planet and put up of the results of poorly raised (or worst case) abused children.

Somehow the choice for abortion does seem the "responsible" choice especially when there is no 100% full proof birth control other than abstinence.
Economically speaking your tax dollars will in one way or another pay for a child who cannot be provided for by their parents--so much more expensive than your tax dollars paying for an abortion. Do the math, I'm sure you will come to the logical conclusion--just not the one that meets your morals.

dianaelee 5 pts

Maybe they should but our rights are not contingent on using them in a someone else deems responsible. We are entitled to them either way.

Visit me at Somebody Heal Me: The Musings of a Chronic Migraineur ( http://somebodyhealme.dianalee.net )

Follow me on Twitter @somebodyhealme ( http://www.twitter.com/somebodyhealme )

JennaHatfield 9 pts

You're kidding, right?

I was a perfectly healthy woman when I got pregnant. Or, so we thought. At 18 weeks pregnant, I spiked a horrendous fever, was hospitalized and underwent surgery. It was at that point we learned of a birth defect that would forever make pregnancies incredibly complicated, risky and life-threatening for me and the baby. I was put on level III bed rest. I was unable to work.

I chose a different path, but to suggest that I should have had the foresight that I wouldn't have been able to work is absolutely ridiculous. Don't make what happened to me my fault. Don't blame other women for experiencing sudden complication. Attitudes like this are exactly why I had no support during that pregnancy.

Contributing Editor Jenna Hatfield (@FireMom ( http://twitter.com/FireMom )) blogs at Stop, Drop and Blog ( http://stopdropandblog.com ) and The Chronicles of Munchkin Land ( http://thechroniclesofmunchkinland.com ). She is a freelance writer and newspaper photographer.

j_gumieny 5 pts

I cited the website where I found the rape statistic... This was one of many that I found... Have you researched this, I only looked into it briefly and was surprised myself at what I found without much effort?

I did say "choose to have an abortion" and I will take claim of my word choice... Just because it's a choice doesn't mean that it is necessarily correct. I love how in America we've become a nation of do as you please and we'll all nod our head in agreement. I'm not nodding my head and this is my own personal stance... I know that we have differing view points and have lived different lives so we'll simply have to agree to disagree.

onblank 5 pts

I couldn't agree more. Abortion plays a key role in our health as a society. And how refreshing to have someone point out the economic side of abortion rights.

A long time ago I realized that knowing a candidate's stance on abortion rights tells me most of what I need to know about them: do they feel it's their job to govern morality? In my state, we keep electing legislators that represent the minority of people and make governing morality the top issue. (For instance, our alcohol commission writes alcohol sales laws and is made up mostly of people who do not drink alcohol.) If a candidate dares to declare that women have the right to choose, that tells me that for the most part, he/she is going to respect our basic right to choose how we live our lives.

Of all the progress we think we made with Women's Lib, I am astonished that abortion is still such a hot issue. If you think abortion is wrong, then by all means, don't have one and educate your family and loved ones about your opinion. But it is not your right to tell another woman that what she chooses to do with her body is immoral. Particularly in an arena so critical as bringing another human being into society.

And I hate to sound like a feminist extremist, but biologically speaking, men cannot make a valid argument against abortion because they have never, in all our evolution as a species, had to bear the burden of carrying a child. For a man in today's seemingly educated and liberal society to tell a woman she must carry a child that she desperately does not want to term is horrifying. That is telling a woman to do something with her body that she does not want to do. This is glossing over the free will of a gender. How is this any different than treating women like property?

I am still saddened at the passing of Dr. William Harrison, abortion provider so moved to service by a young, poor woman who, upon learning she was pregnant, told him in all honesty, "Oh, God, doctor, I was hoping it was cancer." Some women would rather die than bring a child into this world. Who are we to force them?

NatureMom 5 pts

Abortion is not one of my top considerations as a woman though I usually will not vote for someone who is anti-abortion. To me the anti-abortion stance almost always go in hand in hand with Bible thumping and gay marriage hating... two things I have little respect for. I am neither pro-abortion or anti-abortion. I am pro-itsnoneofmybusiness. So while I wouldn't call it a big issue for me, I am all for keeping my nose out of it and allowing women to choose. People who oppose abortion have an unusual interest in what other people choose to do with their lives and bodies. They need to get a life and stop worrying about what others choose to do or how much personal responsibility they display... the reproductive rights of other women is not any of our business.

Tiffany

http://www.naturemoms.com/blog

Suzanne 5 pts

I'm glad that I could clarify. It is always good to have these discussion, and I also thank you for sharing your thoughts!

Suzanne also blogs at Campaign for Unshaved Snatch (CUSS) & Other Rants ( http://cussandotherrants.com ) and is the author of Off the Beaten (Subway) Track ( http://offthebeatensubwaytrack.com ).

queenmommy 5 pts

Ok. I see where you're coming from now. Don't necessarily agree, but your point of view is clearer. Interesting take on abortion issues with the election coming up, that's for sure. Thanks for the late night discussion! :-)

Suzanne 5 pts

You first wrote, "Suzanne, it's called personal responsibility."

I agree that it is personal responsiblity to take into account all of these issues. I assume many of the people who have abortions did not intend to become pregnant, and therefore women are responsible decision makers if they terminate pregnancies they do not want/can't afford.

Suzanne also blogs at Campaign for Unshaved Snatch (CUSS) & Other Rants ( http://cussandotherrants.com ) and is the author of Off the Beaten (Subway) Track ( http://offthebeatensubwaytrack.com ).

queenmommy 5 pts

I didn't ask if you thought abortion was responsible.

I asked; "Shouldn't women, as responsible decision makers, take their own financial issues into account before becoming pregnant?"

Suzanne 5 pts

You did not discuss rape, but the person who commented after your comment did. I addressed both topics in one comment. As for personal responsibility, I think it is absolutely responsible to have an abortion. In fact, in some cases it might be a more responsible decision, given various circumstances.

Suzanne also blogs at Campaign for Unshaved Snatch (CUSS) & Other Rants ( http://cussandotherrants.com ) and is the author of Off the Beaten (Subway) Track ( http://offthebeatensubwaytrack.com ).

queenmommy 5 pts

Personal responsibility is relevant because your arguments for abortion being a prime issue included women not being able to afford childcare and/or the possibility of having to go on bedrest, therefore not bringing in any income. *Again, shouldn't women, as responsible decision makers, take financial issues into account before becoming pregnant?* This is obviously where personal responsibility comes into play. Rape was not included in this statement. It wasn't even mentioned in your article, so I'm not sure why you tried to relate it to my thoughts on the issue.

Suzanne 5 pts

I am passionate about it because I do feel that abortion is a responsible decision. But even if I did not, I'm not sure how personal responsibility applies to someone who was raped. I supposed people who were mugged or had other crimes committed against them should take responsibility and not file insurance claims or whatever since they should live with the consquences of what happened to them. Further, I'd like to know the sources of those "studies." And even if 99% of rape victims who become pregnant "do not choose" (your own words) to have an abortion, I would never deny anyone who wanted to make a different choice her right to do so nor would I force someone who did not want to have an abortion to have one. That's why it's a choice. It's based on an individual's circumstances, values, and religious beliefs, not mine circumstances, values, and religious beliefs.

Suzanne also blogs at Campaign for Unshaved Snatch (CUSS) & Other Rants ( http://cussandotherrants.com ) and is the author of Off the Beaten (Subway) Track ( http://offthebeatensubwaytrack.com ).

j_gumieny 5 pts

queenmommy - you said everything that I was about to say but better... Well put! I'm sorry Suzanne I feel for your plight because you seem to be very passionate about it but I am in complete disagreement...In addition it seems like your rally for pro abortion concerning the rape clause is weak... Studies conducted have cited that 75-85% of raped women do not choose to abort their babies (http://www.afterabortion.org/rape.html).

Cheers.
j
www.gfinkfamily.blogspot.com ( http://www.gfinkfamily.blogspot.com )
Beneath the Acacia Tree

queenmommy 5 pts

Suzanne, it's called personal responsibility. Shouldn't one take into account that bed rest is a possibility and that they might not be able to work? Shouldn't they consider childcare options that they can afford before becoming pregnant? This all seems like you are all about giving people the easy way out when the shit hits the fan. If money is an issue for someone, it's probably the responsible thing to not get pregnant in the first place. Furthermore, if socialized health care really happens and we head the way of Europe and Canada, explain to me why my tax dollars should pay for someone to have an abortion because she doesn't have a decent babysitter?