Blog
JustLinda
Bio
Profession: Astronaut.  (Additional Information: Not really an astronaut.)Things I Care About: Cheddar Bay Biscuits and World Peace; of course...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

When Your Child is Invisible

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 40
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

“You take her.”

“No, we have too many – you take her.”

“I picked last – it’s your turn. You have to take her.”

My child turned and walked away without a word.

In the retelling, she tried to keep an air of bravado, but this child – she may act tough on the outside, but she has a creamy nougat center and I could tell that she was hurt by the exchange.

And now? She tells me she doesn’t really like kickball anyway.

In that story, she might have wished to be invisible.

What happened more recently, I was a first-hand witness to.

My two youngest wanted to sign up for the mini-cheer camp run by the high school cheerleaders. When the big day arrived, I dropped them off at 8 AM and went to run a few errands. I came back a couple hours later and sat on the bleachers watching the girls all learn how to cheer. My two were divided into separate groups – kindergarten through second grade in one group, and then third through fifth grade in the other.

It was the group with the older girls that caught my interest. I watched for a long time and couldn’t help but think that my child was deemed invisible out there. I watched a half dozen high school cheerleaders being playful and friendly with the adorable little girls and not even one interacted with my daughter.

Oh, sure – she’s got some culpability here. She might have been hanging back a little. She might have been anxiously chewing on her nails. But, see, that’s what you do when you’re too afraid to put yourself out there. When just last week, two team captains fought over who had to take you on one of their teams. When you’ve had experiences with other children where you were called fat and ugly to your face. You tend to start pulling away. You tend to not want to put yourself out there for fear of more rejection.

But she was there – she was present. She was learning the cheers and trying to be a part of the group.

I watched as the high school girls instructed the group to form a circle because they were going to play a game. I saw my daughter alone on one side of the circle while the other girls were clustered on the opposite side. I heard the older girls tell the grade-schoolers to spread out and form a full circle. I heard my daughter say “There’s plenty of room over here” and indicate with her arms that she had space on both sides of her. I watched how no one came over to fill those spaces until finally the high school girls did.

And then they played Little Sally Walker, a fun little game that girls often play. There is a subset of girls who skip around the inner circle while a song is sung. When the end of the verse arrives, the girls in the inner circle each stop in front of a girl of their choosing from the outer circle and do a little dance. The girl from the outer circle who was chosen now gets a turn skipping around the inner circle, and so it continues.

There were many rounds of the song and many girls got their turns skipping around the inner circle, some got multiple turns.

But not all of them. Some of them didn’t even get one.

Some of them were invisible. Some waited for their turns while they chewed nervously on their fingernails.

Or, more accurately – one. One little girl waited anxiously for her turn while she chewed nervously on her fingernails.

My child.

She was invisible today, and I sat on the bleachers swiping away the tears that kept forming without my permission.

I silently implored the high school girls to notice what was going on – to correct the situation. No one did, and the game ended.

At the end of the camp session, each of the groups put on a little performance for the parents. Cameras flashed and parents clapped wildly.

  • 40
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
sharongreenthal 6 pts

Whenever I witnessed these kinds of things as my children were growing up, it took all of my self-control not to go nuts on whoever was in charge of the activity. The truth is, I don't think most people are paying attention at all. Especially high school girls! I'm glad your daughter keeps putting herself out there and trying to be part of things...eventually she will find her way to what makes her feel good and happy (trust me on this!). I think sometimes its harder on the parents of the kids who don't quite fit in than on the kids themselves...because we want so much to make it better for them, and the reality is, we can't. emptyhousefullmind.blogspot.com

lovelifeproject 5 pts

My heart hurts for you and for your daughter. As a teacher, I see so many situations in which children are excluded. It never stops breaking my heart. I think that teaching assertiveness and empathy is as important as teaching reading and math. Schools and parents have to work together to create the world that we want our children to live in.

www.love-life-project.com ( http://www.love-life-project.com )

Shannon LC Cate 10 pts

I was often that kid, myself and she's the one I always pick first.
Meanwhile, I have two girls who sem to be growing into the kind of kids who are the hub of the social circle and we are making sure they hear plenty overt lessons about making sure everybody gets a turn/gets to play/doesn't get hurt feelings for unfair reasons.
Hopefully they'll be leaders in that area when they are older and kids get meaner.

Shannon writes about family at Peter's Cross Station ( http://peterscrossstation.wordpress.com/ ) and about writing at Muse of Fire. ( http://shannonlccate.com/ )

lynetteradio 6 pts

Reading this I expected to understand it from your point of view, but I was thrown into your daughter's spot - back 30 years to my own childhood. I now struggle with the same issues with my own (soon to be) 10 year old daughter.

My daughter is empathetic almost to a fault. She's the first of her small circle of friends to step forward to defend others, offer friendship to someone, or help someone in need - but I rarely see others reaching out to help her. I see the look of disappointment when she gets passed over, forgotten, or outright ignored or made fun of. I went through this all myself as a kid (and still a lot as an adult). I don't know how to let these forgotten girls know that they will grow up and be okay - because I know that some girls don't grow up 'okay'.

-- Lynette --

LynetteRadio.com : PurpleStripe.com

KPack 6 pts

Reminds me so much of my little quiet boy...

Nobody wants to be Ethel 10 pts

I will have to read the book that Pale mentioned "Odd girl out".

Let me just say one thing....this is one moment in time when these high school girls were "in charge" of how things ran. I work in environment where the chief of the dept was an odd girl out as a child. Now she is trying to include and exclude certain "girls" because she is now "in charge". This drama is BS. Everytime I have been included with the "cool kids" I have walked away because this peer pressure doesn't wash with me. It is childish and it occurs as children, adolescents and even as adults.

I used to sit on the sidelines praying that my son be successful with pitching and on and on. It was painful. I have no answer except that not believing in a higher power because of this event that happened to your child is a really interesting way of coping.

My adolescence was painful and living through my children's adolescent and childhood difficulties were painful too. Step back take a deep breath and choose the high road in what your child is involved in. It can't all be storybook perfect even though we want it to be.

P>The Patty Beat can be found at  http://pattyabr.wordpress.com ( http://pattyabr.wordpress.com/ ) where The Fearless Cook resides ready to take on your most feared items in the kitchen.

Milestonemom 5 pts

AS anyone who remembers "Lord of the Flies" knows, children in groups can be vicious. If memory serves me, the overweight, eyeglass wearing boy in the group gets murdered by the other boys. The book was written in the 1950's. How sad that the book is still relevant.

Children are easily influenced by peers and crave acceptance. That often leads one child to exclude another child who is perceived as "different". It takes extraordinary character for a child to disregard the group mentality and reach out to the outcast. I think it's important to guide children and tell them that they should do the right thing. But depending on circumstances, even the kindest child may be influenced by peer regard.

I am an avid skier and I started my son skiing when he was two. I thought he might switch to snowboarding, but he decided he'll stick to skiing. My son has ADHD and can often annoy others. However, the subculture of skiing and snowboarding seems to ignore personality quirks and likeability issues. The community accepts anyone who skis (or snowboards). That is the common element. I highly recommend this sport for any child who has trouble fitting in. Becoming competent at the sport instills self-esteem and confidence. It is not a team activity so anyone can progress at their own level. All ski areas offer ski clubs for ages 5 and up. The children in the ski club ski as a group and are sorted by ability levels.

For girls particularly, skiing and snowboarding is empowering. Clinics are offered which teach girls how to overcome their fears and push the envelope a little.

Until the time when children who are popular are able to reach out to the unpopular, I think that offering a sport such as skiing or snowboarding is a wonderful gift. NO one is "left out."

Nancy Konigsberg is a pediatric occupational therapist specialing in child development ( http://www.milestonemom.com ) and baby milestones.  She has a blog called Milestone Mom ( http://www.milestonemom.com )

Lucretia 5 pts

"but isn't cheer culture all about exclusion"

Wow. I hope not. I knew many cheerleaders growing up who would reject that statement. They were under the impression that they were embodying school or team spirit. While I was never a cheerleader, I knew some who were inclusive and some who were exclusive. The latter sort would be that way no matter what they were doing.

Maybe it's where I grew up - but cheer culture here is about excellence, community, and athleticism. If there's an "exclusivity" it's in the fact that there are try outs. But there are try outs for every sport too. And auditions for plays, and debate teams and other teams & groups. But that's different than including someone in a cheer camp in an activity.

Then again, I know that different places have different approaches - so maybe it's not that way everywhere.

Lucretia (aka GeekMommy) Raising a child in a digital world, still a digital girl

Lucretia 5 pts

I think it's those of us who remember that feeling so keenly who go to great lengths to make sure that those "strays" are empowered whenever we can.
It's one of the perks of being an adult who remembers.

Lucretia (aka GeekMommy) Raising a child in a digital world, still a digital girl

Jozet at Halushki 6 pts

I have one popular child for whom making friends and being part of the group comes easy. We have talks about how important it is for her to reach out and include the children on the edges. How because she is "blessed" with ease of making friends, it is her obligation to show the other children who look up to her how to not shun anyone, even when the shunning isn't intentional. She has to be the leader in letting other kids know that invisible children should be included.

I have another child who dislikes team sports, doesn't feel comfortable in groups, and who has been unpicked Sally Walker plenty of times. Part of this is about her: there are "skills" to making friends and making others feel comfortable around you. We try to teach her those skills and she starts to get it. It works. American Girl has quite a few wonderful books on the subject.

I'm also the kind of parent to take high school mentors by the hand and whisper in their ear that if they would pay a little extra attention to my kiddo today, it would cost them little, but go a LONG way in demonstrating to her peers that she isn't, in fact, invisible.

I sometimes do this with other children if the opportunity and situation is right; tell them they are such popular kids and I know how kind they are, and that my kiddo is feeling a little uncertain with activity X, could you give them an extra smile today, it would mean a lot. It's amazing how often kids say yes. It's amazing how often they just don't see themselves as having that kind of power. Mostly, I think, they are just relieved that someone is noticing them; they don't possess the kind of empathy to recognize others. It's a kid thing, mostly.

Theater classes help. Theater classes are filled with all kinds of "don't fit in" kids and in theater classes, they fit in.

As a parent, I volunteer often with kids' groups so that other parents and kids know me, know my kids. Know I'm watching and involved. When *I* make the choice to be the Girl Scout Leader, then I have a LOT of control over this kind of thing; it's a lot more effective than just hoping other adults in charge are, well, being in charge.

With my own invisible child, she finally found an activity that she enjoyed on her own, that she could do without being picked last, that competing in meant putting up with some subjectivity, but with a lot that she could control through hard work.

Here's my invisible kiddo, after a lot of hard falls, not being picked last anymore.

She's made the choice not to sit in a corner, and she has plenty of little kids now looking up to her.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EZpGjlmYz30

I'm not saying everyone has to land a double salchow to be popular. What I am saying is that we also have to be blunt with our kids and tell them the truth that sometimes, other people just stink. And sometimes, they don't realize it. All children have their own fears they are dealing with and are so busy hanging on just trying to be normal and included themselves, they don't always have the resources to help others. But, yes, sometimes it's just them being mean.

In any case, imploring others to play nice only goes so far. I like to help my kids find more active ways to deal with their shyness, to feel in control, to find their own power and self-esteem. To be a good friend to find a good friend. There are plenty of invisible kids out there...surely there is another my invisible kid can befriend and they can materialize together.

Halushki.com

Lucretia 5 pts

I'm sitting here with some of those unbidden and unwelcome tears myself.

As the mom to a second grade girl? I'm always aware of this sort of thing.
W
hen it's my daughter who is invisible, my heart breaks.
I mostly breaks though because I was that girl more often than not growing up. My own emotional scars never really healed over those moments spent wishing someone, anyone, would notice.

So I'm the adult who notices.
I'm also raising a child who notices.

If there is one thing that my husband and I both just burst over pride in her for, it is that my daughter always notices the "invisible" children and invites them in.

There was one girl I went to high school with who was beautiful, smart, talented and popular. A cheerleader, an actress, an athlete and still honor roll - she was the kind of girl you wouldn't expect to notice the invisible kids... but she did. She was kind to everyone and noticed when someone was hanging back and drew them in. She was amazing - and so I know that it's possible for those kind of people to exist. Now we just have to work on making more of them.

My solution so far has been to empower and encourage my daughter to continue to be the one who notices and to reach out to those who are being "invisible" - because she knows what it's like and how much it hurts and she doesn't want anyone else to feel that way either.

Thanks for writing this. Maybe it will have an impact. I hope so!

Lucretia (aka GeekMommy) Raising a child in a digital world, still a digital girl

Amanda_Magee 7 pts

You are so right, regardless of religious or spiritual beliefs, it is the responsibility of the folks on the ground living it to influence it. I felt a lump in my throat as you wrote of the tears coming unbidden.

This morning I read to my daughter's class and I reveled in making eye contact and really reading to each face before me.

Looking at your daughter's face I think it would be amazing to be the person that compelled her to ratchet that smile up to 100% joy.

Amanda

http://amandamagee.com

ourgrowinggarden 5 pts

Oh and your little girl is beautiful. I am sure you are doing a great job raising her to be a confident young woman. One day she will realize that she does not need anyone's approval but her own.

Breastfeeding, babywearing, first time mama writing about the trials, hilarity, and stickiness of motherhood. http://www.ourgrowinggarden.com ( http://www.ourgrowinggarden.com/ )

ourgrowinggarden 5 pts

I was teased (even to the point of harrassment) horribly in jr. high and high school. The boys even called me "dog face gremlin". I put walls up around myself and didn't have many friends- didn't really want friends for fear they would hurt me too. I blossomed socially in college and am no longer the shy, scared girl I used to be. But boy, it would have been nice just to have someone notice me, encourage me, let me play their dumb games with them.

Breastfeeding, babywearing, first time mama writing about the trials, hilarity, and stickiness of motherhood. http://www.ourgrowinggarden.com ( http://www.ourgrowinggarden.com/ )

Phase_Three_Of_Life 5 pts

This is such an important topic. I hate the thought that any child feels isolated or alone among so many peers. I'm not sure I can do much, but I do promise to watch for it and try to curb it any chance I get.

Blogging to maintain sanity at Phase Three of Life ( http://phasethreeoflife.blogspot.com/ ).

HappyMum 5 pts

Seriously, I don't know if I could have taken it....sitting there watching that, knowing how your child hurts....awful.

Shame on the big girls. If they are old enough to run such an event, and organize things, then they should be old enough to ensure that everyone gets a turn. They should have kept their eye on the young ones.

RaisingAmazingDaughters 5 pts

Please check out my blog at http://raisingamazingdaughters.wordpress.com

Once I asked my daughter if she could describe herself in one word what would it be? "Invisible," she said. She was in high school. She was smart, fun, funny and so pretty. Yet, she felt invisible. And, that continued into college. It's heartbreaking and, looking back I wish I could have helped her change that but I'm not convinced I could have. She's 26 now and much stronger but I guess she had to get their on her own. Hang in there. Continue to let your daughter know how you see her. It helps.

trigirl13 6 pts

My heart hurts for both of you. I found that the older I got, the more I could let those times go. But it's not easy. I'm sure your support means the world to her, and that girl who chose your daughter probably did more good than she even realized.

-julie

http://tri-ingtobeathletic.blogspot.com

cdrdash 15 pts

As a child I had mixed feelings about being included. Sometimes I wasn't ready to be included in an activity and did my best to be invisible. I used invisibility to help me cope with my extreme shyness. What I appreciated was being encouraged to join in but not be forced to join in. The best teachers I had seemed to understand this about me and gave me time to build up my nerve and join in when I was ready.

Cathy  R.

jeanettenyberg 5 pts

I was a shy little wallflower when I was a young kid, and can completely relate to feeling left out. I've always tried to seek out and engage the quiet kids who may not feel as comfortable in social situations as others. Ironically, my daughter is a little fire plug, so I'm making sure to teach her the importance of including everybody.

http://www.craftwhack.com

jeanettenyberg 5 pts

I was a shy little wallflower when I was a young kid, and can completely relate to feeling left out. I've always tried to seek out and engage the quiet kids who may not feel as comfortable in social situations as others. Ironically, my daughter is a little fire plug, so I'm making sure to teach her the importance of including everybody.

http://www.craftwhack.com

What She Said 5 pts

I was the girl in the circle who never got chosen. The one who was picked last for any and all team games (a system that I hate to this day, BTW). I was shy and sensitive and had trouble putting myself out there and making friends. It didn't help that I also wasn't very athletic, which made me even more self-conscious.

Among my many fears as a new parent is that my own daughter (only 16 months old now) will one day experience the same rejection I did. And it scares me even more that I might have to bear witness to it, like you did. I think it might break my heart.

So, I think I accepted your challenge a long time ago, without even realizing it. And it's a challenge that I'll implore my daughter to take as she grows older as well.

Kristin (@SaidKristin ( http://twitter.com/#%21/SaidKristin )) blogs about everything from parenting to social media to stink bugs at her virtual mind dump, What She Said ( http://twss-blog.blogspot.com )

justlinda 22 pts

I don't think I'm saying "always include everyone" - or at least I didn't mean to say that. LOL

I believe that our kids DO need to learn to deal with disappointments and failures, and I totally agree with you that they are a part of life. In fact, my position is that we often shield our kids too much from these things. But that's a different article too, maybe. haha

What I intended to convey in my piece here is that sometimes children need encouragement. Sometimes it's the ones who hang back the most who need encouragement perhaps more than others. And we as parents and teachers and role models can be on the lookout for those children and bring that encouragement. And we can even teach our children to do that!

( http://justlinda.net )JustLinda

fabulously imperfect

Twitter @JustLindaSTL

Nicole_Longstreath 5 pts

Yeah, but my comment wasn't really about cheer.

The bigger picture here is how children are taught to act in social situations.

Technically, this was a small situation; your daughter experienced a little bit of social rejection. However, I hope it was a learning experience for her that rejection happens to all of us and is going to happen all through life.

You're saying that people should be taught to include everyone - but that's not realistic. Not everyone is going to fit into every social group. And that's for a good reason; it's how we (as children) determine who we really are in life.

I believe the best defense against instances like this is to teach a confident attitude so children are prepared for when things don't turn out the way they expected.

Rejection sucks, but it's a part of life.

Sustainable living, community and politics - smartmouthblog.com ( http://www.smartmouthblog.com/ )

justlinda 22 pts

I really don't see any maliciousness in what happened at the cheer thing. I don't think the high school girls were mean-girls or anything. I honestly think that given the way my daughter hung back nervously, she would have been harder to notice, she wasn't open and chatty and friendly because she was feeling anxious. And because of that, she was less 'approachable'. And I don't think high school aged girls would get the nuance of that without being told/taught.

But I don't sense a bit of malice in what they did.

( http://justlinda.net )JustLinda

fabulously imperfect

Twitter @JustLindaSTL

justlinda 22 pts

I must confess that in the moment, when the session was ended, I didn't do anything. I was feeling very emotional and vulnerable and I didn't trust myself to do that.

But you're not the first person who has asked. And I know I absolutely SHOULD have thanked the girl who did reach out and give her a turn. (I'm embarrassed to admit that I am not sure I could identify her in a line-up because they were all in identical uniforms with identical ponytails and I am not sure which one I would have approached to give a thank-you.)

So my way of making people aware was to write this piece, which wouldn't be enough to provide the feedback to that cheer-squad at that particular school (though I am pleased that it has reached other cheer squads at other schools!)

I do have an obligation to follow up and perhaps I'll do that by writing a letter.

Thanks for your comment.

( http://justlinda.net )JustLinda

fabulously imperfect

Twitter @JustLindaSTL

justlinda 22 pts

I think the discussion about cheer-leading, in general, would be an interesting one to have, but I'm not sure it changes anything about the point I was trying to make.

She's 9 and this was just a fun thing to do and since we're trying to support active-fun toward the goal of fitness, I had no objection to my children participating here.

Cheering would pretty much be like any other competitive sport at the high school level - kids try out and some make it and some don't. I'm not sure it's any more an exclusion culture than football or soccer.

But your point is noted and it may be a good topic to delve into separately...

( http://justlinda.net )JustLinda

fabulously imperfect

Twitter @JustLindaSTL

tophersgirl 7 pts

Both kinds, actually.

I was the little girl that was teased mercilessly and never chosen. I turned inward and read and imagined and made friends with other kids who no one wanted.

I was also later (in high school) more popular and a more socially confident member of the dance team and the newspaper staff. But while I was friendly with the popular kids I wasn't truly friends with them. I'm to this day close friends with the band kids. And I always root for the underdog.

My question is, what did you do next?

How did you make sure that the neglect practiced by the cheerleaders was pointed out to them? Did you approach the coach and let them know that the camp was great but that some kids seemed left out? Did you approach the girls directly?

Because I guarantee you that if no one has told them, they have no idea it happened. And 99 percent of parents won't say anything.

If you haven't followed up with the group who facilitated the workshop yet, I strongly encourage you to do so. Consider even sending them this piece, I think it's powerful enough to make an impact on some teenage girls.

Best of luck to you and your beautiful daughter.

Mae Winter blogs at Parenting In Progress ( http://parentinginprogress.com ), tweets @tophersgirl1 because some poser who never tweets already took tophersgirl without the 1.

Jane HF 5 pts

I have passed your essay along to several teens who are the kind of youth to notice and reach out to the invisible children. I think those kids can use reminders to keep looking and also some reinforcement to see that their small gesture makes such a huge impact on someone else.

I was a lot like your beautiful Jadie and have a son who has found himself invisible far too often for my liking. This story touches my heart on so many levels. Thank you!

Nicole_Longstreath 5 pts

With the recent string of bullying in the news, I know we're dealing with a sensitive topic here.

However, I think the way you tell this story is from the role
of a "victim."

Yes, those high school girls were being really insensitive, but isn't cheer culture all about exclusion?

Maybe you're just hurt over what happened - anyone would be - but is this a pattern? If so, could you be teaching that victim pattern to your daughter?

She's adorable and I'm sure she is very bright - but she also might be a little shy, and that's okay. Maybe cheer isn't the best activity for her, and that's okay too, because there are plenty of other activities that can be so much better for girls' self-image.

Sustainable living, community and politics - smartmouthblog.com ( http://www.smartmouthblog.com/ )

elfsgirl 5 pts

Anyone who is mothering daughters can identify with the feelings you express. We all want our kids to feel included and valued by their peers.

And, regardless of your beliefs, your prayer was indeed answered. :)

sisboom@optonline.net 5 pts

oh the pain this brought back as a chubby child and having a chubby daughter . It's still lodged in my psyche and i experience it when I see exclusion of others whether it be a child or an adult. I am so in tune it can make me want to wretch. the good news is that through that pain I can be a light in this world and without that pain or sharing that pain I am indifferent . So what I'm trying to say as much as we can be mothers to other children and try to be present and see the oppression in any given moment, I am human and can't do it alone. I also need to trust when one of us is not there safe guarding our children from any kind of pain that God has a plan for that pain or injustice to bring about change in this world. I am grateful to Linda for using this experience to light a fire in those who may not know that this kind of exclusion even exists. I am a card carrying member of this group and in order to be seen and not invisible I use my voice.It is our collective voice that can make a difference.

Virginia78 8 pts

Thank you for you post. It was painful to read; I can imagine it was even more painful to watch your child go through it.

Since I was a shy child who was left out of games and picked on, I am very aware of the kids on the margins.

Because of that, I make sure that my own kids look out for those who are left out or picked on.

justlinda 22 pts

I love that campaign and I like how it is applicable to other kids and their challenges.

It does get better. And it molds us into the adults we become, which is no small thing.

The irony is that the kids who may need to add more physical activity the most are often the ones who are left out and who pull away. This child is a good athlete and I am trying to keep her engaged in the sports that she loves. So far, so good but when she comes home with a "They said I can't run good." story, I worry she may pull away.

(And then I tell her "Well, not good." and she rolls her eyes at me.)

( http://justlinda.net )JustLinda

fabulously imperfect

Twitter @JustLindaSTL

justlinda 22 pts

Pale - I've heard about that book, read reviews, and it sounds like it's a worthwhile read. Need to put it in my Amazon cart.

One of my struggles is that I, too, was teased about my weight as a child and I have this overwhelming urge to "save her" from that. Of course, I can't. But I do try to give her the tools and the confidence to persevere in spite of any ostracizing or teasing. She's a brave girl.

I'll just copy and paste what I wrote, in part, in the follow-up I posted on my blog:

This girl? She’ll be OK. She has some damn strong women in her life – older sisters, cousins, aunts and some might even add her mother to that list. Some of these women carry extra weight and yet it hasn’t stopped them at all. So sure, she’ll have to forge her own path – and sometimes that path will make her mother cry and wish she could take away the pain of it. But ultimately, this child will learn and grow and find her way and she will be stronger and smarter for all those experiences – and hopefully more compassionate, too.

In the Great Kickball Game of Life, my daughter is going to KICK ASS.

( http://justlinda.net )JustLinda

fabulously imperfect

Twitter @JustLindaSTL

Mausburger 5 pts

Thanks for your post.

I was once that little girl who was always left out and unfriended. I am now a professor at a university and I constantly use my position to make sure those who are marginalized find their way in. Some do it with stray animals. I do it with stray students. They are lost when I find them. After I give them attention and nurturing, I send them on their way, stronger, more confident, and better equipped.

It gets better.

Pale@BTPM 5 pts

I'm reading a book right now that I highly recommend, "Odd Girl Out: The Hidden Culture Of Aggression In Girls by Rachel Simmons. (The author has other titles on this subject as well.) I'm reading the kindle version -- I'm about a quarter of the way through the book and I've way overused kindle's highlighting feature because almost every paragraph rings a bell. I expected to read about the issues my fifth grader is having with her (KRAYZEE) classmates. What I didn't expect was how much the book would make me reflect on the culture and the way it socialized ME and my mother (just to name two of us) and how that has played out in unrecognized and unhealthy ways in past relationships (mostly when I was younger ... but some things, I must uncomfortably admit, persist to this day). Even though I pride myself on being a thoughtful and reasonably well-educated person, it seems like none of us are completely immune to a certain "can't see the entire picture from inside the frame"/ you -can't-fix-what-you-don't recognize quality to The Big Picture aspects of this issue.

I am sorry that your daughter is having these experiences and I agree with you wholeheartedly that everyone needs to take responsibility for fixing the problem. Unfortunately, like a lot of hard life experiences, unless and until you've walked a mile in the shoes, a lot of people just never seem to open their eyes completely -- if at all.

I think you would find the book worthwhile. I am hopeful that it will do more than just catalog the features the phenomenon, which goes largely unrecognized in any helpful way. I am hoping the later chapters will contain some satisfying suggestions.

Just to give you a sample, one passage spoke to the dilemma and the frustrations faced by parents ... "The attention shown victims and perpetrators of bullying often means the situation parents face is overlooked. Parents and guardians of victims harbor intense feelings of shame and helplessness, yet they are isolated from one another as their daughters. Often they can only watch as their daughters come home crying day after day. ... watching their girl's increasing isolation, they are embarassed the their child is scorned. Some blame themselves, while others are angry at their daughter's passivity. Girls, if they confide the problem, often beg their parents not to intervene, fearing retribution."

My daughter's negative experiences in fifth grade, where the behaviors seem to have come to a head in recent months (we were warned back in November by her teacher that spring tends to worse than the fall for some reason ... it's like some kind of developmental trajectory that plays out before the teachers' eyes each year). It's hard as a parent to put your finger on a productive response, which is what led me to reach for this book in the first place. Hopefully I will find my way, as will my daughter.

Also ... have you checked out The Exclusion Project on Melissa Ford's blog?

http://www.stirrup-queens.com/2011/01/the-exclusio...

Put It On My TAB 5 pts

As a parent I try teach the importance of not leaving anyone out. Our oldest son understands how it feels to be picked on and left out. It breaks our heart to see him go through that. I think what you said is important, but I believe our children should not care what other people think of them either. When you see your child nervous, standing back hoping to be picked, that's the time to pull them aside and encourage them. Tell them sometimes the only way to make friends is to be brave and go talk to people. Ask to be picked. There's nothing wrong with that. We can't always stand in the back hoping people will do the right thing.

I hope this isn't offensive, I'm just wanting people to see the other side to these types of situations.

Granny Nanny 5 pts

What a terrific post! I hope your readers take note of its importance.

When my daughter was growing up, we lived near the school playground, and I would watch the other children play while she sat on the sidelines. The bully in her class had made sure she was isolated. Why she was picked on, I still don't know.

I remember taking her to participate in activities outside our school district so that her self-esteem could re-establish itself. It did, to a certain extent, but then she had to return to her reality in her own classroom. If it weren't for terrific teachers and principals who made sure she was given positive attention, I'm not sure either one of us could have survived.

Now, as an adult, she is happily married, has many friends, is very successful and has blessed us all with a beautiful grandson. But she still has nightmares about her childhood torturers.

I can't emphasize this strongly enough - We need more empathy in this world, and we need parents to make sure it happens. Even though I'm not sure that empathy is totally a teachable trait, we should never stop trying.