Bio
A "recovering journalist," I spent five years as a staff writer at Fortune magazine, followed by several more years writing for The New York Times, R...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Parenting May Be Easy, but Being Human Is Hard

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 23
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Roughly five times a day, I screw up as a parent. However this morning’s antics may have earned me a spot in the Mommy Hall of Shame. At 10:00am, I had just settled down to work and a coffee, when my cell phone cheerily announced: “Chaperone Field Trip.” A pit instantly formed in my stomach. I was supposed to heading to a demonstration of the New York City Ballet with my daughter's class that very moment.

Royal Ballet SchoolIn a panic, I bolted for the door, sprinting the six blocks to her school. Just as I breathlessly rounded the corner, my daughter’s class was lining up to board the bus. “STELLA!!!! STELLA!!!!” I hollered (not my daughter’s name but you get the allusion). “STOP!!! I’M THE CHAPERONE. I’M THE MOTHER!!! THE MOTHER!!!” Mercifully, my daughter was already on the bus and missed her mother's theatrical display.

Since I do guilt particularly well, I apologized profusely to my daughter. But she could not have care less. Instead, her eyes widened with delighted. I had failed myself, not her. As a lovely morning unfolded, I managed to keep my guilt at bay. Self-flagellation would do nothing more than destroy my daughter's day at the ballet.

Oddly enough, one of Jeanne’s most dramatic “failures” revolved around City Ballet too. We were enjoying a pre-Nutracker dinner, when Mom realized the show began at 6pm, not 8pm. Since we arrived in the middle of the first act, we sat in the aisles. I saw it as an adventure. But what I remember most vividly was the fragile tone of my mother’s voice when she discovered her error. It was simultaneously heart-breaking and unnerving.

We make mistakes. Sometimes, they are of the logistical nature. Other times, I am, well, kind of a bitch. Instead of delivering sing-song homilies like Marmee in Little Women, I bark orders to “Put your shoes on!” I beg my daughter to “Just stop whining. No whining," or snap at my son for sneaking off with iPad to play Angry Birds…again.

These things happen. Yet I’ve found that when I eliminate the guilt, and simply admit that “Mommy can get grumpy,” my kids recover much better. They’ve also learned that when you push someone too far, they get annoyed, even angry. This is why I found Issa Waters’ BlogHer post No Excuses: Parenting Is Not Hard particularly unhelpful.

In an effort to argue that the refrain “Parenting Is Hard” cannot justify parents' bad behavior, she writes:

“Sometimes I participate in a discussion about someone in public being mean to their child. By “being mean” I mean spanking, slapping, grabbing, yanking, dragging, yelling, name-calling, belittling, punishing and so forth. And there’s always someone in these discussions ready to declare that “parenting is hard” and we should therefore cut the parent some slack. And I just reject this wholeheartedly. It is not hard to not treat people like shit. Children are small, dependent people, and we should be doubly sure not to treat them like shit.”

For starters, when did “slapping, yanking…and belittling” fall into the same category as “yelling” and “punishing?” By this definition, most parents I know are unfit to raise their children. We all stand accused, and are therefore…guilty. Waters’ argument turns a naïve eye to how dangerous such guilt can be to both parent and child.

Perhaps “Parenting Is Not Hard,” but being human can be excruciating. To me, these two roles are inextricably intertwined. I want my children to understand that I am not perfect. I am just a flawed person –one who forgets things and loses her patience -- but who also loves her children enough to chase after a bus to make things right.

What are some of your less proud moments as a parent? What lessons did you learn?

 

Photo Credit: scillystuff.

  • 23
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
southmainmuse 12 pts

I think you are spot on. We get so many mixed messages today as parents. And no child arrives in this wolrd with the same genetic code. Some programmed to be very, very challenging. And you can be patient, patient and patient....then you turn into a very impatient ugly person who you are not proud of. I would never, ever condone any abuse but we do crack. And when that happens, I do apologize. Did it last week. 

Sachas mummy 5 pts

It's great seeing that people who don't have children all seem to work with or around them and then belittle us parents for admitting that yes we screw up and they never do. I wonder why they don't have children, because they are scared maybe that they will become one of us and then be a hypocrite?

But the other problem with these behaviours that make us feel guilty is when you get upset and have reached the stress breaking point and burst into tears, not to your children but to someone else who said they were there to listen and then they turn on you and take these words to child protection and all your guilt is doubled. I love my daughter very much, and I couldn't imagine life without her now, but every action I make I feel is being watched, if I snap at her after telling her to eat her dinner for the 5th time, or if I don't want to read the 20th book for the evening after playing play doh for an hour and I just want 10 minutes to myself, or watch my favourite tv show. It's just quilt times 20, because I've already been labeled a bad parent for admitting this, and now I'm scared to talk to anyone incase they are working against me.It's just nice to know I'm not alone, I try my hardest to be the best parents, without being fake or giving in to my childs every want. What seriously can you do when your child won't eat and keeps asking for lollies, throws their food on the floor and screams. Give in?

amlindsey 15 pts

Sachas mummy If this is directed at me, someone who works with and around children, I'd just like to tell you to follow your own advice and hold it with the judgement. It sounds like someone judged you, and that sucks. Because all of the things you mention needing seem human to me, and taking care of yourself or admitting when you're tired are good lessons to model for a child.

I have to say this, though: assuming that someone is not a parent by choice? Not cool. I'd love to have a child. I'm trying to have one of my own. Yes, I'm scared about parenting, but you have no right to call me a hypocrite.

amlindsey 15 pts

I get where Waters is coming from on this level: it's not helpful for parents to yell at kids as if their offspring were simply very short adults. There is a difference between "No whining!" and "Why do you always do this to me?!"

My own mother is the first to admit that she really screwed up on the parenting front when the marriage was falling apart because "I was just so self-absorbed." My saddest memories are of feeling utterly lost when she yelled "Why do I have to do everything around here!! If you weren't so ungrateful, you would just clean your room!" (I'll tell you what, I did not clean my room after that. All I knew was that I was eleven and really mad.)

I totally understand and, as an aunt and child care provider, relate to moments like Stop Whining! and Put On Some Shoes! Adults totally lose my sympathy, though, when they say angry things to children that children cannot possibly understand.

sharongreenthal 36 pts

My biggest fail: not picking up my phone when my kids are calling from college. Sometimes I just don't want to talk. GUILT!!!!!

Karen T. Smith 6 pts

I'll admit, I cringe when I'm out in public and I hear parents being blatantly mean to their kids. We *are* all human, we do all deserve to be cut a break here and there, but some people seem to have lost the concept that these small people are WATCHING us and taking their cues from us. If we can't hold it together long enough to get through the grocery line, what's life like at home for them? Not to say I haven't spoken tightly through my teeth, or unceremoniously dumped a toddler back into the cart seat to keep her from claiming the entire candy aisle as her own, but there's a difference.That said, I screw up with my kids *all* the time. And I tell them it, honestly. I scream and yell about inane things, things that don't really matter. Like recently when my son wore my boots to walk the dog and got snow inside so when I put my boots on the next time I squished into a wet, cold mess, getting my socks wet and chilling me to the bone. Ick! I yelled. And then I started yelling about ridiculous things, so he could see i was just mad about wet socks, and frustrated at him not being more sensitive, not actually angry at him the small person. I yelled about the color of the mat at the back door and the fact that the wind was blowing and the snow was too white and all kinds of things that are unchangeable, and we had a laugh. I feel that because I spend great *quantities* of time with my children (primary at-home parent, though they are in school full time) I get a little bit more leeway from them on this sort of behavior. I have to gently remind my husband, who has much less time with them due to work pressures and travel, that me losing my temper has much less of an impact than him losing his, because they have less of him, it's a much greater percentage of their total time with him. It sucks, but it's a reality. It's helped him be a little more mindful of his interactions with the kids. And me, too, for that matter! I try to do a better job. And when I inevitably fail, I apologize and ask for my kids' forgiveness. Seeing mom screw up and admit it is helping them develop realistic attitudes about what growing up is like, I feel.

carrien 12 pts

"being human can be excruciating. To me, these two roles are inextricably intertwined." Exactly!

I'm far too human to do this parenting gig the way I think it ought to be done. I have to console myself that if my children get to see me try and fail and how I deal with that they will be able to be kinder to themselves when they fail to be super human.

Vesuvius At Home 11 pts

Great point, Amy. I grew up in a family that yelled. So for me, not yelling is hard. It's a tremendous struggle for any human to do better than was done to us--and so in that respect, yes, parenting is hard. Being human is hard. It's the hardest thing I'll ever do, and belittling myself or other parents when we mess up only makes it harder.

JennaHatfield 196 pts

Bless you. No really.

I'm so not perfect -- and it kills the perfectionist in me to say that!

I'm human. I hope to raise my children to be human, to make mistakes and learn how to apologize... even to their own children. I try my hardest and that's all I can do.

Robin Follette 11 pts

Great story! In spite of me, my daughters grew into happy, healthy young women. Parenting is the hardest, easiest, most rewarding job in the world. If anyone thinks they'll come out of it without scratches they aren't being honest with themselves.

ltorres78 15 pts

I get disappointed in myself when I find myself doing too much yelling and not enough constructive teaching. I'm too busy, too distracted, too annoyed. Those are the days that I look back and think that I don't like the mom i was that day or in that moment.

Cynthia M 18 pts

Wonderful post - thank you! I too (like many parents) occasionally lose my temper with my children - often when they've pushed too far, but sometimes when I'm just stressed out about something (getting to work on time, etc.), and I feel horrible afterwards. Thank you for the reminder that we're all human, trying our best, and that eliminating the guilt when responding after the blow-up works best.

Rita Arens 149 pts

Really nice post. I am most mad at myself when I lecture. I know it's an ineffective way to communicate with anyone, let alone a kid, and I catch myself doing it all the time. I don't feel guilt when I yell because I only do it occasionally, so my daughter knows she's pushed me too far and it's time to back off.

amykover 12 pts

Rita Arens Thanks, Rita. It's funny, my mom was a benign yeller, and it didn't really bother me, She was loving even when she yelled. She just had had ENOUGH!

TangledLou 88 pts

This is fantastic. Refreshingly well-reasoned and articulate. I am so very, very tired of parenting as a competitive sport.

amykover 12 pts

TangledLou Moi aussi! Because I hate losing!

brammynyc 7 pts

THANK YOU, AMY! None of us is ANYTHING all of the time. None of us is perfect. None of our children is perfect. I would hate for my parenting abilities be defined by the occasional grabbing or yelling that happens out in public. It seems smug and self-righteous to me, that that writer couldn't express empathy instead of quick-witted criticism. My five-year old is easily distracted, with ninja-like moves. There have been times when only a blood-curdling yell could get her attention and prevent a potential tragedy. Same goes for grabbing. I have walked many many blocks with my child screaming, whining and kicking, when the only way to keep hold of her is to grab. Am I proud of these moments? Do I think I might have found better ways to handle these situations? Of course. But I am in no-way apologetic about it. Thank goodness during these times, the moms and dads observing that long walk home with a screaming child gave me knowing smiles instead of frowns. I can imagine that those without children, or with children who haven't reached a particular age could have disapproving thoughts. Or perhaps they DO have that mythical perfect child? All I can say is, "don't judge lest ye be judged." We all live in glass houses, so try to keep the rocks on the ground!

amykover 12 pts

brammynyc Great insight. Another reader wisely pointed out that our relationship with our children lasts a life-time. The good, the bad, and the ugly. We have to believe it only makes our bonds stronger.

lolapaloozza 6 pts

being a good parent is hard work, just as being a good person is hard work. i'm assuming this woman has small children. small kids, small problems, big kids... well, there's more yelling. yelling and punishing are not the same as hitting and slapping. at all...

isthisthemiddle 1422 pts

Yep. I'm not a parent, but I fail at my various roles every day. If being a less than perfect human is a crime, come visit me in prison. There are already too many voices tearing us down-- let's back up and take a do-over on judging people who are doing the best they can.

Conversation from Facebook

Amy Kover Lox
Amy Kover Lox

These are both really strong arguments, but in response to your comment, Ruth. I appreciate that Waters wrote her column as an advocate for small children --something I think is incredibly admirable and necessary. I also think that belittling children is a cruel game, and "parenting is hard" serves as a weak excuse. My problem was that she was overly simplistic in her assessment. As a result, the article only made me, as a reader, feel guilty. i believe that guilt is also a dangerous game to play with your children. As one reader pointed out on my homepage's comments, "the post didn't give readers room to breathe." I love all of the opinions though. It's so interesting, and I have been more aware of what i say to my children as a result. Maybe the answer lies within our dialogue.

Polish Mama on the Prairie
Polish Mama on the Prairie

Yeah, the OP mentioning "punishment" was, imo, meant to be taken like punishment. Whereas, oftentimes, imo, people distort that word to mean "consequence", perhaps because they assume consequence is a nasty mean thing, aka the yelling, the hitting, the humiliating & belittling. But the yelling, the hitting, the humiliating & belittling, the OP meant as punishment, not consequence, in other words, something that is meant to make your kid feel like an outright piece of s*** for screwing up your day/moment/life. Usually, something stupid like a spilled drink.
Btw, can I point out that I think something else the OP makes me think of discussing, is that when we overreact to something small, our kids take that in. They learn how to handle life by the way YOU handle life. Is a spilled drink really anything more major than, well, just a spilled drink? No. But your child's sense of self worth is more than a spilled drink. And if you constantly fly off the deep end for minor... not even events, just regular daily life things, then you are setting your kid up for failure.

Ruth Gaul Schliessmann
Ruth Gaul Schliessmann

Unconvincing. The original article (by Waters) was good. Waters pointed out that we have a double standard, and her example of spilling a drink was a good one. Correction does need to be done on the spot but it does not need to involve yelling, and as for the "punishing," that can be appropriate or inappropriate. Waters made it clear that unreasonable anger was the type of display she opposed. "Barking" at home, versus making an already embarrassed child a public spectacle, aren't the same thing. Bottom line, both sound like good moms whose children know they are loved, but i don't think Waters said what Kover thought she said.