Bio
Rita Arens authors Surrender, Dorothy and Surrender, Dorothy: Reviews. She is BlogHer.com's senior editor.  Her parenting anthology and BlogHer'...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Recent Comments

Maddison Is Too Sexy for Thirteen

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 7
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Twelve-year-old Maddison Gabriel (she’s 13 now) is the face of the Gold Coast Fashion Festival in Australia. She’s on the catwalk at the age my mother first let me wear make-up.

Is this what 13 looks like?

I’m disturbed.

I mean, let’s talk about 13. Thirteen is the beginning of high school or the end of junior high (if they even still call it “junior high” these days). Thirteen is braces, study hall, wishing you could drive, navigating catty girls and still-too-short boys, slumber parties and lip gloss. Thirteen is the tip of the adult iceberg, when your body starts to go there but your brain and emotions have not caught up yet.

Thirteen is dangerous for anyone, let alone girls who look like Maddison. Thirteen is when you need your parents the most, when you’re not sure if you have to leave childhood behind just yet, when you want to be older, but it’s kind of scary. Thirteen is when many girls start to look like women, when their bodies blossom without the cellulite and stretch marks of an adult woman. Thirteen is American Beauty.

Thirteen is when you start thinking you have to do things you’re not sure if you want to do in order to move up in the world. I know – I was in dangerous waters at 13. Thirteen reeks of cheap cologne and sweaty boys, varsity football games and chewing gum. Thirteen is when you believe that everyone is doing it. Thirteen is already oversexed. Who needs a runway flanked by adults to help it along? Thirteen thinks adults know what's best. Thirteen needs adults to be the adults in the room.

From across the ocean, people in Australia and abroad are upset about Maddison. It even makes Janice Dickerson, self-claimed world’s first supermodel and reality-television weirdo mad.

And Dickinson said that she will not allow any girls under 18 to model for her agency.
“I have about 32 girls who are dying to break that 18-year-old mark,” she told TODAY co-host Matt Lauer. “Get your high school diploma and then come and see me.”

In Maddison’s Australia, Sheridan Voysey writes:

What’s interesting about this whole scenario is that even more liberally-minded countries like France and Italy have enforced a minimum age of 16 for models hitting the catwalk. The British Fashion Council has announcing (sic) models aged 15 years or younger should not be allowed to enter the London Fashion Week—one of the world's most famous fashion events. And another British inquiry this week recommended that models provide "health certificates" from doctors to prove they don't have an eating disorder. At the very least these moves abroad show the danger inherent in the modeling industry to young women.

Why is everyone so upset? Are we upset for the girls, or are we upset that we find them so alluring? Are we secretly disgusted with ourselves for idolizing nubile youth in the way we do, trotting them about in a way that is unmistakably sexualized? What is the difference between this and child pornography? About three yards of cloth.

Raven writes:

The age of innocence is getting younger and younger. More and more, we hear stories about 3, 4 and 5 yr old girls being the objects of some men’s unholy affections; it’s not shocking anymore to see grown men drool over these 13 yr old “models” either.

Perhaps we have always been fascinated by young girls. The best know it is wrong to exploit them.

She was Lo, plain Lo, in the morning, standing four feet ten in one sock. She was Lola in slacks. She was Dolly at school. She was Delores on the dotted line. But in my arms she was always Lolita.

-Vladimir Nabokov, Lolita

  • 7
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
calya 5 pts

I think it's up to her parents to guide her in the right direction since she is still so young. Also, why do organizers of these events allow such young contestants? I am glad that Janice Dickinson won't allow anyone younger than 18 to model for her agency. It is the responsible thing to do and shows that she is not just after the money that can be made.

Calya

www.cookiediaries.blogspot.com ( http://www.cookiediaries.blogspot.com/ )

Miss Vicki 5 pts

I'm disturbed too. Because she is a girl. Not because she is beautiful, which she is, but because she is a child. And she will probably not be able to enjoy all of the wonderful (and not so wonderful) things that go along with puberty and growing up normal. A very important part of her life is being stolen from her. It makes me sad and I hope she is not one of those faces we see plastered all over the Enquirer in a few years like Brittany and Lindsay and so many others that the public seems to love watch come apart. As far as stealing these girls before they fully develop hips, I really would love to know who it is that finds skinny and underdeveloped attractive? Sairy makes an good point. Somethings got to give.
Link Text ( http://www.vickisdrawerslingerie.com )Sexy lingerie for all women

sgranger 5 pts

I did a tad bit of modeling at age 14 and it was local and fun. I didn't do it for long because there weren't many opportunities where I grew up (and I did not have "the face" that would launch a major New York modeling contract anyway). All I know is that in that environment, there was no major risk to me more than going to the movies or the record store.

I think the real issue is that this girl is being taken across the globe and asked to model clothes that she probably doesn't understand. I think it should be a judgment call on her parents' part, but I do understand why some countries have an age limit. It's not like there aren't opportunities for teenagers to model teenage clothes; it's just that they get more money and publicity modeling adult clothing.

There are other issues related to this topic like why we have to have such a skinny body type. At 13 or 14, girls may have mature faces and breasts, but many don't yet have hips, so they work well as walking clothes hangers. I think if there was a little less focus on the culture of skinny, we would have fewer early teens being sought for the runway.

Sairy ( http://www.sairy.com/ )

adriennez 5 pts

Come on! She's a kid! And she is a kid modeling clothes to over 20's, 30's 40's and whatever!
Remember she is wearing makeup! She is in a sense plasticized to appeal to all of us...consumers.
And, those marketers are right on the money. She is a topic of discussion here and in the news!

Adrienne Zurub
Author
'Notes From the Mothership The Naked Invisibles'
http://chasewunderlickpublishers.com.cn
http://adriennezurub.com

kimber30 5 pts

She is drop-dead gorgeous and I imagine she will be beautiful for the rest of her life.

All the more reason for her to be a kid for a few more years, allow her destiny to wait.

Just because you're destined to be a Doctor, doesn't mean you need to start doing it when you're 8.

Kim
http://whats-next.typepad.com

5resolutions 5 pts

Rita,
Great post. We wrote about this story, too:
http://5resolutions.blogspot.com/2007/09/tween-run... ( http://5resolutions.blogspot.com/2007/09/tween-run... )

As you noted, many people within the industry have been quite vocal about keeping girls off the runways, and we agree with them. We recently interviewed the chair of the Council of Fashion Designers of America's Health Initiative. She is very focused on enforcing age guidelines:
http://5resolutions.blogspot.com/2007/07/fashion-s... ( http://5resolutions.blogspot.com/2007/07/fashion-s... )

Aside from the long hours and travel, girls of this age are insecure enough as it is. Throwing them into a world where they are judged solely on their physical appearance can be a recipe for disaster.

Claire Mysko & Magali Amadei
5 Resolutions to Transform the Fashion and Beauty Industries ( http://5resolutions.blogspot.com )