Bio
I am the author of several books for young adults, including:  Suite Scarlett, Scarlett Fever, The Key to the Golden Firebird, and 13 Little Blu...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Manifesto: I Am Not a Brand

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 41
  • Sparkle (
    )
     
side profile of a woman lying on a couch and looking up

It appears, that I have . . . entirely by accident . . . developed a manifesto. Let me tell you how this happened.

So, because I am an author and am generally presentable and have shoes and things . . . and because I spend a lot of time online . . . I sometimes get asked to speak at conferences and panels. I laughed until I fell over the first time I was asked, but it’s a fairly regularly occurrence now, and I look forward to those weird, squat water bottles they often give you when you are up at a podium. I can spend a good five minutes of my speech just thinking about those little water bottles. That’s why I smile so much up there.

Anyway, more and more, I get asked to do talks and panels on social media. Lots of times, I don’t even know what people really want these panels or talks to be about. “Social media” is new and big and weird, and there are very few true experts. So they just scoop up whoever is around (like, for example, me) and stick us in front of a room and call us experts.

I did one panel very recently, and it broke me. On that day, the MANIFESTO came to me. And now, I want to share it with you.

I took my place up on the dais and immediately looked for my little water bottle. I was seated next to a woman I’d never met. We shared a microphone. I noticed that she had already grabbed it and was CLINGING to it like it might try to escape. I put this down to nerves until the panel started, at which point it became clear that if I ever wanted that microphone, I was probably going to have to engage in some form of physical combat.

My neighbor had a lot to say. She had a MESSAGE. She talked longer than anyone, and over everyone and through everyone. Her message, as far as I could determine, was that the internet is all about getting out there and SELLING yourself.

“I’m a brand,” she said, every minute or so. “I’m always thinking of ways to promote my brand.” It was all brand, brand, brand, brand, brand.

The other thing she said that made my head swivel around uncomfortably was, “Get your message and repeat it OVER AND OVER. Just keep saying your message OVER AND OVER in the same way. Just tweet it and put it out on Facebook OVER AND OVER.”

She was certainly not the first person I’d heard this from. I hear this almost everywhere I go where there are people talking about social media, and I feel that it is time that I rise up against it. In fact, I did, right there and then. I grabbed the microphone from her grasp and said, “I am not a brand.”

She grabbed the microphone back and started clarifying that she really, really, really is a brand and brands are awesome . . . and the more she went on, the more I thought: I am not a brand. I wanted to whisper it, but that would have been creepy.

Just to be clear on this thing I am not, maybe I should define my understanding of personal branding. A personal brand is a little package you make of yourself so you can put yourself on the shelf in the marketplace and people will know what to expect or look for when they come to buy you. For example, Coke is a brand. When you see Coke, you expect a dark brown effervescent sweet drink that is always going to taste like . . . Coke. McDonalds is going to sell you inexpensive, fast food. The Ritz or the Four Seasons is going to sell you a luxury experience. BP will now be known as the brand that destroys the costal ecosystem of the southeastern United States.

And yes, authors sometimes have these “brands.” Nicholas Sparks is going to sell you a Roman . . . love story, excuse me . . . where someone dies of cancer/similar disease at the end. V.C. Andrews will sell you something awesomely insane and creepy. Dan Brown will sell you a series of puzzles, facts,

  • 41
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
No Shoe Left Behind 5 pts

Your article made me want to applause and find a goldfish to carry out of the office. Well done. I liked 'The Notebook' as much, if not more than, the next woman, but there's only so much formula one woman can read.

I found myself whispering 'Amen' as I read your manifesto. And now I'm going to find a snack.

elizawhat 5 pts

I want to give you a high five (and a snack). While I understand why personal branding can be important -- note I said "can be" and not "is" -- too many people think they need to be, for lack of a better word, vomiting content and pushing their product. Somehow, instead of caring about building relationships with people, companies and individuals have become obsessed with the numbers. Initially, I set goals for my clients' social media campaigns by number: 100 followers on Twitter, 50 Facebook fans, 25 group members on LinkedIn... etcetera, etcetera. After experimenting and looking at my own personal accounts, I realized numbers weren't important, and that building relationships and talking TO, not AT, people is what is important.

I also have been struggling with my "internet identities." There's a part of me who uses internet for business, to network with people for website and social media jobs. Then there's the part of me who uses the internet for fun (and hopefully soon the career I've always wanted): blogging, sharing my writing, meeting and talking to other writers. All of this time, I thought that it would be best to keep them separate, but over and over again I found myself struggling, because my "business accounts" are boring and I don't enjoy them the way I do my "personal accounts."

Your blog made me realize that I shouldn't have to split myself. I'm me; this is what you get. And if you don't like it? Too bad. I agree with you completely: I am not a brand.

Anna @ Newlywed Newly Veg 5 pts

This was exactly what I need to read tonight. Thank you!

lauriegrif 5 pts

Thanks for articulating what many folks are thinking! I have an aversion to being "marketed" to. Start engaging in real conversation.

lettergrade 5 pts

I have also endured a lot of social media branding talks or articles that threw out 'genuine' and 'repetition' in the same breath without seeing the problem. Thanks for this.

Lene 5 pts

I can't thank you enough for this. This branding befuddled me for a while now and although whatever I do, whether it be writing or photography, does tend to have a sort of generalized theme - OK, so the generalized theme is that I do it and sometimes it's related to disability, feminism andor advocacy and sometimes it's not. Where was I? oh yes. The brand. And all this time I felt like I'm a huge failure with the branding, because I keep getting distracted into talking about things that matter to me, but don't necessarily connect to the "brand experience" that somehow ought to be seepnoing from my every pore.

I don't always want to sell myself, it isn't just about money, yet the term "monetize" is everywhere, as in monetizing your brand. And that's the point where I usually break into hives.

So thank you.

saidandsung 5 pts

Thanks, Maureen, for these insightful and sardonic words. I agree wholeheartedly that the Internet is interactive. As a freelance words girl, my projects vary, just as the topic of the songs I write vary -- and that's what keeps things interesting. We write what we're into, what astounds, what delights, what enrages ... and that evolves as we evolve.

One question: Can you recommend specific links for the Doctorow and Green writings that you enjoy? I can Google them, of course, but just wanted to know if there are Manifesto-esque postings of theirs you particularly found inspiring.

Thanks again for your bold statement. I recently had to choose whether I would go with a brand for my latest songwriting venture or stick to my own name. I'm glad I chose the latter, for I am not a brand.

You said it,

Carla

www.wordpress.saidandsung.com ( http://www.wordpress.saidandsung.com )

lmorchard 5 pts

So... talk some more about these snacks? What brand do you like?

therhouse 5 pts

i love you--hilarious, unapologetically honest and self-proclaimed weird-o. i think we should bottle you and sell you. we could make millions ...oh wait. ;)

great to remember as i pack my bags to head to one such conference (i have GOT to learn wordpress some time, some way!)

and i second the "bring me a snack" idea.

xoxo

jcravens 5 pts

Reblogged and praised here ( http://blogs.forumer.com/jcravens/43995/Enough+wit...!.html )

Off to get my snack, as there's no one to fetch it for me.

<><><><><><><>

Jayne Cravens

Web site: http://www.coyotecommunications.com

Blog: http://blogs.forumer.com/jcravens/

PeevedMichelle 5 pts

I do have a message that I have posted multiple times.

I am a person, not a product. I have a personality, not a brand.

When I first posted that, a friend of mine in PR at HP replied, "But you have a great brand!" No, I have a great personality.

You Grow Girl 5 pts

Great piece. I love speaking at conferences, etc but I've been on THAT panel with that person so overeager to self-identify as a marketable object.

The concept of personal branding isn't lost on me by any means and I think there is some validity to it... it's just that some people preach it like a religion and over-sell to the point that they become the brand they've created.

There is a difference between creating strong work that builds a recognizable name/brand and self-identifying as one.

You Grow Girl: Gardening for the People ( http://www.yougrowgirl.com )

zanepaul 5 pts

the "person as brand" thing is creepy and smacks of whoring yourself out. we are women and people and writers and not something to be labeled, packaged, and sold to the highest bidder.

by all means, let's be creative and write well and grow communities and blogs, but not by selling ourselves out (or short.)

keep it up:)

www.somuchshoutingsomuchlaughter.com ( http://www.somuchshoutingsomuchlaughter.com )

Nordette Adams 6 pts

I thought the point was that she has no "strategy" of which she's conscious. I thought that as a novelist who happens to blog and not a pro-blogger who happens to have written a novel, Maureen is making the point that her visibility grew organically, not by her sitting in a corner plotting but by her natural tendency to develop relationships with other humans. That's just me thinking. I'm running this through my mind because it's something about which I meditate often.

Nordette Adams ( http://www.bookotopia.com ) is a BlogHer CE ( http://www.blogher.com/haystackprofile/viewprofile... ) & you can find her other stuff through Her 411 ( http://her411.com ).

bexband 5 pts

It sounds like you don't enjoy speaking at conferences. So follow your own advice & start focusing on what you enjoy :)

"What I am saying is that I am tired of the rush to commodify everything, to turn everything into products, including people."

Sadly, there is nothing new about this, the internet has just facilitated the process. So it's important if visible and well-repected bloggers like you take a stand against it. Thanks for sharing your manifesto--now what's your strategy...?

~BeckyBlab~ ( http://beckyblab.com/ )

Jane Byers Goodwin 5 pts

When I hear people promoting their "brands," I picture a tattoo of a naked mermaid on their forearm, tail coiled, with a harp in her hands and the word "Sweethart" misspelled in permanent ink above her head. That, my dears, is a brand. So is "RRR" on the rump of a cow.

Kraft is a brand. The rest of us are people, talking to people, and listening to people.

Excellent post. Thank you.

"Don't be content with being average. Average is as close to the bottom as it is to the top."

Nordette Adams 6 pts

Last year I kept beating this branding horse you speak of in different ways, wishing it would die, and "experts" kept telling me I had to get over it, resistance was futile, until I felt I was a crone, and said so ( http://bigsole.blogspot.com/2009/08/for-tweetsake-... ). You are a successful novelist, and so, you have finished products to hawk. That you resist cultivating yourself as brand and painting by the numbers and that so many people applaud your resistance says to me I may not be as nutty and old in my thinking as I have been led to believe.

Thank you.

Nordette Adams ( http://www.bookotopia.com ) is a BlogHer CE ( http://www.blogher.com/haystackprofile/viewprofile... ) & you can find her other stuff through Her 411 ( http://her411.com ).

boomama 5 pts

...and amen.

Love this post.

And I'm all about #1 and #5, too. :-)

MauiFarmlet.com 5 pts

Thanks for the great piece. Someone (OK, I admit, my dad) asked me recently: "What's the point of blogging about your experience if you're not going to try to make money at it?"
I was totally nonplussed. Of course, money matters and this farm takes money, but I tried to explain to him that, ironically, after a career in software schilling brands, I now had something - sustainability, farming, healthy and humane food - that I actually wanted to write about, to share with folks who may have similar interests. And not with the almighty dollar as the singular goal.

amybhole 5 pts

Actually, it sounds like your issue isn't with branding. It sounds more like your issue is with marketing and selling techniques. They're very different things.

Also, branding isn't limiting. The best brands (and people) constantly reinvent and reinvigorate themselves. They just do it while staying true to some of their most valued principles. See: Madonna

kkffoo 5 pts

Enjoyable and thought provoking read..nobody wants to listen to a person who won't listen to anybody but themselves, and why would it be any different online? Thanks for presenting this in a way which makes so much sense.

WhitGrlwaFatAss 5 pts

At first I was horrified that I had branded myself "white girl with a fat ass" but your piece reminds me that I started my blog to have fun and do good with my particular brand of humor.

All of these 'branding' social media lessons turned what was a invigorating expression into daunting work. Thanks for the fresh air!

Saving the World One Fat Ass at a Time!

www.jellykean.wordpress.com ( http://www.jellykean.wordpress.com/ )

kristanhoffman 5 pts

ROCK ON, MAUREEN JOHNSON.

As a fellow writer, and one who doesn't want to be limited, I really appreciate this. You're not a brand or a commodity; you're a literary treasure. :)

--

kristanhoffman.com - writing dreams into reality

niseag03 5 pts

LOVE! This is how I've looked at the internet since I first logged on back in 1995. Its about PEOPLE. My favorite thing I've ever found on the Internet is dear, dear, dear friends all over the world!

I had always originally entered writing that way... then everywhere I've looked its been to be a brand. Be something people can predict and expect. Put yourself in a box and stay there. I've tried... but...

I CAN'T DO THAT! I can't just write about one topic. I can't write about some big message I am trying to convey. I just wanted to tell people what's on my mind, and I always hope and pray maybe, just maybe, someone out there is listening and will want to talk back. THANK YOU for writing this and giving me the confidence to keep with my own point of view...

Denise
Musician's Widow ( http://www.musicianswidow.com )

sheridanla 5 pts

I have enjoyed my endeavors because they are not a brand, but an adventure. While I would like for more people to join in those adventures that is not the focus. I think when you lose site of that adventure and enjoyment and focus on how to create a BRAND, you lose something important.

Barbara-The Middle Ages 5 pts

'Cause that's all I'm interested in now...

Seriously, am exhausted by the mere notion of branding. This was supposed to be fun and light and a joining-of-voices. When did it become about conquering the world?

...is it snack-time yet...do we get to curl up on side-by-side mats?

The Middle Ages ( http://themiddle-ages.blogspot.com/ )      Two Friends--different ages, different husbands, different opinions

ccarfi 5 pts

>I'm allergic to advertising

@ayse, if you haven't read it, check out william gibson's _pattern recognition_...the protagonist has the same condition. :-)

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pattern_Recognition_(...

Heather Clisby 5 pts

Well put, my dear. I find the rush to promote oneself more than exhausting and more than a little icky, like a high school election gone global.

Now then, where can I get a Maureen "Because I am weird" Johnson t-shirt?

~ClizBiz

BlogHer Contributing Editor, Animal & Wildlife Concerns, Proprietor, ClizBiz ( http://www.clizbiz.blogspot.com/ )

arse poetica 5 pts

Well said, Maureen, and thanks. I'm allergic to advertising in my walking-around life, where much of it is out of my control, and I'm possibly even more averse to it in my chosen online/online-spurred social interactions.

In fact, besides bigotry, I can't think of a thing that will drive me away from a person/product faster than "Buy Me!" being our first (and continuing) interaction.

Where's the joy? :)

Thanks again.

@ayse ( http://twitter.com/ayse )

ljlaubenheimer 5 pts

Yes, yes, YES! I am not a &%#%&$%#& "Brand", a slick, polished, dumbed down marketing package simplified to the lowest common denominator to a single target audience.

I have dimensions, and a lot of them. I am more than just a tech person, or a political person. I do crafts, am disabled, have a relationship that is not standard, and rant a lot. I shop for bargains in food and stuff, plus lots more. I write on the web under a pseudonym over half the time, too.

I don't fit into some specialized, narrow, market packaged pigeonhole.

I wish these social media people would quit trying to stuff me into one, or get me to stuff myself into one in order to sell myself (Even prostitutes have more self respect than people who become mere "brands", IMO.)

Also, I don't talk or do business with "brands", I deal with people. People who become mere brands shut themselves off from me, for they are shallow, and my time is more valuable to me than that.

sassymonkey 6 pts moderator

Love, love, LOVE This post. I'm a person. I'm not a company. I'm not a brand. I'm a person.

Now excuse me, I need to go put up cat photos.

Contributing Editor Sassymonkey also blogs at Sassymonkey ( http://sassymonkey.ca ) and Sassymonkey Reads ( http://sassymonkeyreads.ca ).

glamoursmith 5 pts

Great post, you were insightful, funny-- in the way of 'I almost snorted the beverage I was drinking' funny when I read that and so right on target.

annie 5 pts

I freelance under a business name precisely because I don't want my name to be my "brand". The more I hear about "personal branding" the more glad I am that I have that line in place. Thanks for this!

Just_Margaret 5 pts

I'm in the midst of a personal battle--on the one hand, I have various reasons for blogging and participating in social media, which includes a desire to get more widely read. But on the other I simply bristle at the notion of creating "Brand Margaret"...I squirm at the thought of creating and selling myself as a Brand.

Thanks for reminding me that there are plenty of folks utilizing this technology that don't just see it as another way to Sell, Sell, Sell!

~Margaret

Just Margaret ( http://maurhoffbarney.blogspot.com )

Annabel Candy 5 pts

Hi Maureen, great read and hilarious too. I don't think they'll be inviting her back to speak. I agree it's unfortunate that we have to be "brands" I hate it too but then I realised that every time I write a comment or leave my pic somewhere it is a little bit of me that represents what I stand for. Definitely not boring the pants of people and plugging my blog non stop but hopefully spreading a ray of light and hopefully some useful info too.

I hope you can break out of your niche and into others. So agree, who wants to just write about the same stuff all the time? Far to one-dimensional for 3-d women like us!

I write about small business Internet marketing ( http://www.getinthehotspot.com/ ) at Get In the Hot Spot and teach people how to win business online. Please swing by and check it out, I'd love to help you too.

mashadutoit 5 pts

Yes! This is something that needs to be said more often.

And then, I've heard too many people say - "you should use social media. It will get people talking about your brand."

How warped.

stirrednotshaken 5 pts

I really appreciate this post! I write because I want to share and connect and learn from others. I want friends. I read blogs that have the same goal. Hearing a persons thoughts and insights are half the fun.

All of the scanning and grabbing and feeling as though everything has to be bullet-pointed to get people to see just what you want them to see is so exhausting.

No thank you!

@ohaijoe 5 pts

I had my 15 minutes of internet fame once, and was invited to speak at various conferences. I turned them down out of fear of becoming one of the self-promoting, personal branding #doucherati.

Glad to see someone, even one person, being honest and speaking up for the internet rather than the individual.

propz.

ccarfi 5 pts

+1 on that.

great post, maureen.

stute 5 pts

I am talking TO you, love on you for this beautiful piece. Reminds of an old Greg Brown song, "Oh Oh The Bozo, He's In Love Again". There's no label you can hang on me and no expiration date. Barcodes are prohibited. You rock! I look forward to your next inspiration!