Michael Brown and The Politics of Respectability
By Rae Lewis-Thornton on August 26, 2014
Featured Member Post
If we are honest, many African-Americans waited with baited breath hoping that Mike Brown was not killed while committing a crime. For many of us, it's our worst nightmare. That is, giving white America the fuel to say that our senseless death is justified. The politics of respectability have long been an issue for Black America. We have had to prove over and again that we are American too, in so many ways and so many times, that calling the role would be endless.
"And so, lifting as we climb, onward and upward we go, struggling and striving, and hoping that the buds and blossoms of our desires will burst into glorious fruition ere long. With courage, born of success achieved in the past, with a keen sense of the responsibility which we shall continue to assume, we look forward to a future large with promise and hope. Seeking no favors because of our color, nor patronage because of our needs, we knock at the bar of justice asking an equal chance." -- Mary Church Terrell
There has also been a duality in regards to the issues of respectability in the black community. While respectability has been used against us, it has also been one of the things we have believed would make America accept us. At the end of slavery, we sat out to prove that we could be American by how we dressed, our education, how hard we worked, how we worshipped and especially through moral dignity, i. e. what came out of our mouths, fowl language was frowned upon, as was drinking. Many of the Black Baptist women were strong supporters of the prohibitionist movement.
By the late 1800s, uplift of the Black community through morality was deeply rooted within the black community. I highlight this in my book The Politics of Respectability. Respectability influenced our daily living and how we did politics. All of our organizations that were formed during this period were rooted in respectability and many of those social or service organizations remain today.
Yet by 1896, equality in American was dealt a harsh blow with the Supreme Court ruling in Plessy v. Ferguson that declared separate but equal legal. That ruling would last until the Civil Rights Act of 1964. Plessy sent a strong message that Black people in America had no rights that a white person had to respect. Even the dissent in Plessy first argued that Black people were unequal humanly to whites, but that we should be given rights because the disenfranchisement of one group of people, even humanly unequal people, can create a slippery slope for the disenfranchisement of other segments of society.
We have seen this fundamental belief of human inequality play its self out in the legal system and in the media over and again through the ream of respectability. Respectability has been the litmus test rather than justice for blacks in American over and again. There is an assumption that he must be flawed in some way and that is what caused his death rather than injustice.
Most recently, we can look to the Trayvon Martin's case. The underlined assessment of White America was that he must have been a criminal or going to engage in criminal activity because he was wearing a hoodie! George Zimmerman's argument was that Trayvon, "looked suspicious" because of how he was dressed. A child on his way home from a grocery store carrying juice and a bag of candy was killed because of how he was dressed and his murderer acquitted because reasonable doubt was given based on the character of that child.
Time and time again we have watched the criminalization of the victim at the hands of the actual criminal, the legal system and the media. In the case of Michael Brown, after a week of silence from the Ferguson police we were told that minutes before his death, Michael had been involved in a "stronghold robbery." Mind you, this was a press conference to release the name of the police officer that killed Michael, but instead became an assassination on his character. Blindsided, many in Black America retreated. How do you argue for this child in the face of his behavior became one school of thought. I believe that this is driving the lack of voice among celebrities and public figures around this case. The video released was embarrassing, but within an hour Black Twitter had taken up Michael's defense. Murder is murder. No matter how you spin it, Michael was unarmed and shot multiple times. Ferguson residents increased their protest and have stayed in the streets
Tweets came hard and heavy dissecting Chief James Thompson's statement. By the afternoon the police chief held another press conference and admitted that police officer Darren Wilson did not know that Michael was involved in any crime when he stopped him. The robbery had nothing to do with the incident; Michael was stopped simply because he was jay walking.