Say the words "Internet" and "health" to anyone and they'll probably think that you want to talk about Dr. Google (sore + boobs + breastfeeding + help). Maybe, if they're really geeks, they'll think that you have something to say about the mental and emotional health benefits of online community, or about how immediate access to medical research online empowers us to better understand our own health.
Or maybe, if they're up on their reading, they'll anticipate your thoughts on how the Internet is rotting our brains and making us stupid and basically causing an epic, collective, neurological health FAIL.
Which is basically what some people who should know about these things are saying these days.
It all started with that article in the Atlantic last summer - "Is Google Making Us Stoopid?" (see what they did there? STOOPID. Ha ha ha. Google humor! Very cerebral!) - in which the author speculated as to the long-term cognitive consequences of our dependence upon the Internet. Then, just last week, a leading neurologist suggested that excessive use of online media could "permanently alter our brains and trigger neurological disorders." And today,on Salon, Rebecca Traister wrote about her decision to wean herself from her addiction to the Internet by downloading a program - tellingly called "Freedom" - to her computer to force her to take breaks from Internetting. She didn't say explicitly that she feared that her brain was melting, but it was strongly implied:
Even as a comparative Luddite, I find myself bewitched, bewildered and deeply bothered by the number of minutes, hours, days I spend circling the online drain. As anyone who spends most working days staring at a computer screen knows, there is no such thing as sitting idle anymore. Those little desk toys they used to sell -- the plastic bird who teeters and totters until its beak finally dunks into the water glass -- are relics at this point. Like the notion of being unreachable at certain hours of the day or night, they are laughable reminders of a world long gone. Who would have the patience to wait for the beak to hit water? We'd all be hitting "reload."
Instead of watching plastic balances, we stare idly into a scrim of ever-updating images, words, videos, letter threads, some that calm us, some that raise our blood pressure, until finally the day is over, and we go home, log on, and do it again. Or at least I do.
(Implied: HALP MY BRAIN IS MELTING.)
I read this and I thought two things: 1) I don't need software to enforce downtime from the Internet - I have hardware for that, and they are 10 months and 3 years old, respectively, and 2) uh-oh, mah brain, it is in trouble. Because even though my children force me give me ample reason to shut the laptop for extended periods of time, I still spend a lot of time on the Internet. A lot. Much of my professional life is here, and it runs 24-7. Much of my social life is here, too.
But it's not so much the online writing and socializing that has me worried. I have, after all, argued here before that blogging saved my life - if we understand 'life' as 'mental health' - and that mothers in particular are better off health-wise for having the Internet. It's that in the course of all that writing and socializing, I've come to depend upon havign immediate and unfettered access to information - information that I used to use my brain to find and process and apply to my work and social intercourse. Today, for example, I couldn't remember the title of the Jules Verne novel about travel that isn't Around The World In 80 Days. So I googled Jules Verne travel balloon, and got my answer. Which, awesome, right? Wrong. That book was on my bookshelf, not ten feet away. I forgot that it was there, because instead of plumbing my memory for details of my relationship with that work (did I use it in a lecture? write a paper about it? discuss it with academic colleagues over coffee? read it on vacation, over a latte?) I just defaulted to ask the Internet. I didn't use my brain; I used Google.
Which, some say, is just the first and most dangerous step on the road to brain meltage. That neurologist that I mentioned earlier, Susan Greenfield, said, in an interview, that "the brain is susceptible to being reshaped by our experiences." She then cited a recent study in which "London cabbies who memorized the streets of the capital displayed significant growth in the hippocampus--an area of the brain connected with memory." Using GoogleMaps, presumably, does not facilitate growth of the hippocampus. I'm the sort of person, now, who uses GoogleMaps. Is my hippocampus going to be stunted? According to Susan Greenfield, maybe.
Obviously, if my hippocampus shrivels, it won't be specifically because I'm a mom-blogger. Blogging isn't the source of the problem. But is it possible that - because so much of my Internet-information-trawling is done in the service of blogging - it's not helping?
I hope not. Because if it comes down to Hippocampus versus Blog, I'm not sure who's going to win.
I should maybe start stocking up on Gingko Biloba right about now.
Catherine Connors blogs at Her Bad Mother, where one of her posts earned her BlogHer of the Week honors! And now she's travelling around the world! Like Jules Verne would have wanted her to!
Comments
I'll risk it
It's a mixed blessing, for sure. I have to remember much less than before. On the other hand, having access to all that info is great. I'm not left wondering things, or having silly weeks-long arguments with my husband about the date that Elvis died. Maybe my dependence on Google Maps is causing my brain to melt, but it's also saving me from wandering around lost a lot of the time.
I think I'm willing to take the risk.
~ Amber
www.strocel.com
Sometimes I worry we are
Sometimes I worry we are becoming more and more dependent on technology, and if it will be taken away from us at some point, we will be in big trouble.
----
A Mommy Blogger and a Blogger For Hire
What takes the space of melting brain
I love scientific things like this. They leave so much out and leave so much for me to fill in.
If brain melts it leaves space, right? Space that I can fill in with what ever I like.
If hippocampus shrivels, something else can expand, right?
If brain melts, heart can grow, I am trusting my intuition more and more and that comes from my heart.
The tasks my brain is performing most of the day have been highly overrated and I have no problem having Google taking over those things.
It gives me more time to remember more and more loving memories from the heart. or dream.
If hippocampus shrivels can I grow my imagination muscle more? ... Thanks to Google maps I have a chance to focus my intention somewhere else, like to where I like to go instead of how I get there.
I really don't see any worry here; only advantages.
As I said, I love science.
Wilma Ham
www.wilmasblog.com
My Google Maps give me the
My Google Maps give me the wrong directions half the time. Now THAT is what makes me feel "stoopider".
From my perspective, the adverse effect on my health probably has more to do with more time on my butt blogging and less time on healthier pursuits, like exercising things other than my brain.
K-MEG
No way. Blogging is therapy for me!!
Great article! I hope I never have to go back to choosing Brittanica tomes or Thomas Guide instead of Google. I blog to keep my sanity and let my alter-ego fly freeley on the www - while lovingly tending to my flock at home.
Suzette Valle
www.mamarazziknowsbest.com
If you can still write "hippocampus"
... without your mind conjuring up children's music (like Rosenshontz's "Hippopatumus Rock"), I'd say you're safe.
On the other hand, since that's the first thing I thought of, I suppose I'm done for.
KimBlogHer Contributing Editor|Professor Kim|
At least blogging requires brainpower
Blogging must be one of the best things I do on the internet. The rest is just a pseudo personal assistant looking up the spelling of words and directions to places I've been many times and should remember.
http://FindYourBalanceHealth.com
If anything, the internet enhances the
intellect
The depth of information and knowledge that is freely shared and available on the internet makes laughable the notion that teh interwebz makes U more stoopiter.
;)
Tink *~*~*
My Mobile Adventures *~*~*
I agree.
The internet, just like TV, can be educational or mindless time-wasting, depending on how you use it. I waste plenty of time on it, but I also have learned so much from it. I agree that the worst side effect for me is my body's inactivity while sitting in front of the screen rather than being active & exercising.
Trying to get back to basics
I am a 20-something, therefore I basically grew up with the internet in the house and its been a part of my entire education. I have to admit though that I learned more in college from textbooks and by writing long papers, than I have by reading Wikipedia in my spare time.
My job requires me also to spend about 8-9 hours now in front of a computer - my own fault - I went for digital advertising! I worry that I'm losing my memory because as discussed above - I totally use Google more than my own library. I am a HUGE lover of books though and I'm trying to get back to that place where I read more than I use the internet - at least on the weekends. Its important to just log-off for at least a day or two! I refuse to even blog on the weekends to keep that off-line lovely feeling going.
Anyways - I agree with you. Less internet - More reading! I'm going to have to enforce SSR with my kids (When I have them) at home! (SSR: Silent Sustained Reading - anyone else have that? Haha)
www.bloggingforchocolate.com