Bio
I'm the Family, Moms...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Mommies Can Die?

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 7
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

oak hill cemetery 10.29.09 - 16Two weeks ago, a dear friend lost a courageous battle with leukemia. From her diagnosis to her death, only 15 days passed. It was a shock to the community. It still feels kind of surreal. As an adult, I'm struggling with anger and confusion; she was just here and now she is not. My oldest son, however, seems to be having an even more difficult time processing her death.

My children have had the unfortunate privilege of learning about death at a young age. This is partially due to the makeup of our family. I was blessed with young grandparents and didn't really attend a funeral until my teen years. My children, however, have had to deal with the dying off of my grandparent's generation in ways that I didn't. In 2010, we attended three funerals in three months for beloved members of my family and my husband's family. My children asked questions, behaved at the funeral home and generally accepted that "old people die."

But my friend was not old and was also a mom to one of my older son's friends. When I told them that his friend's mommy had died, my oldest son looked at me with those big dark eyes and said, "But why?" I gave him a brief, age-appropriate explanation about cancer and leukemia. He shook his head and said, "But she's a mommy."

I nodded, choking back tears.

When I was in ninth grade, a friend's mom died of cancer. It rocked the school, and the decision was made to only have a half day of school so those of us who wanted to attend the funeral could do so. No one's mom had died before. Grandparents and an aunt and even an older sibling in a car accident. But moms just didn't die on us. Except that they did. And they do. And they always will.

I've been fielding a lot of questions from my oldest son; he's a thinker. He has skirted around the question of, "Will you die, too?" I've done a lot of reassuring, a lot of "look at how old Great-Grandma is," and a lot of hugging. We're getting together to play with his friend soon, and I'm sure I'll field more questions after that playdate.

I think I'm handling it in an age-appropriate, non-scary way. I've been bopping around the web for the past two weeks, reading others' attempts at discussing how mommies die. It seems we're all flubbing our way through it as best we can.

Jennifer at Just Hide the Dishes in the Dryer recently fielded the question from her four-year-old.

I told him that yes everyone dies when they get old and he got very concerned and said "I don't want you to die mom, I want to stay with you forever."

Lisa at A Bushel and a Peck pointed out that even kids who know about death because their mothers have died can have questions and issues surrounding the whole mess.

“Why didn’t my Mommy give me a family in Ethiopia?” he paused again, “Do other kids get new families when their mommies die?”

He crawled in my lap and I rocked him while he sat stiffly with his back to my chest.

“Yes, Eby,you have lots of friends who got new families after their mommies died. Honeybee and Dimples came to us after their mommies died, and M, D, R, and lots of other kids you know have new families who adopted them after their parents died.”

I hugged him, “Your Ethiopia mommy loved you so much, you were precious to her. We sure love you too, Eby, and I’m so glad to be your Mommy.”

Married with Toddlers may have taken the easy way out in a discussion about death with her toddler, but she shared a great list of books as resources for young children dealing with grief and loss.

"Well, sometimes, when someone gets very, very old, older that mommies and older than grandmas and grandpas, they die."

"Oh, so, you and Daddy aren't going to die."

"That's right."

Ok, I lied. I took the easy route. But, I needed time to rethink my strategy.

And, of course, I turned to Matt Logelin to see how he's discussed these things with Maddy. How he has chosen to handle the truth with his daughter after her mom's death and

  • 7
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
kgirl 5 pts

My kids learned about death early and honestly when my dad died weeks before my second daughter was born. We couldn't do the 'only old old old people die' routine, because my dad was only 64 and my first daughter still had 3 living great grandparents. So we told her, and later our second daughter once she began asking, that everybody dies, but we will take as good care of our bodies as possible so that it doesn't happen for a long, long time, and that it's something we don't have to think about every day.

I've heard people say that they have lied to their children about the death of a pet - I say be thankful you can introduce them to it that way. It's much tougher to explain the death of a grandpa than a dog.

Karen authors the blog, The Kids Are Alright ( http://kidsarealrightto.blogspot.com/ )

JennaHatfield 10 pts

I love your points. If parents are honest, we're all thinking the same thing but just not verbalizing it.

I'm sorry for the loss of your friend, by the way. Thinking of you and yours.

Family Section Editor Jenna Hatfield (@FireMom ( http://twitter.com/FireMom )) blogs at Stop, Drop and Blog ( http://stopdropandblog.com ) and The Chronicles of Munchkin Land ( http://thechroniclesofmunchkinland.com ). She is a freelance writer and photographer.

JennaHatfield 10 pts

I've never been a death-shielder. I kind of err on the side of over-sharing about most subjects. It's just how I parent and, really, how the dynamics of our family have kind of forced me to parent.

That's why I took both boys to the viewing. Some of my friends absolutely hate that I do that, but I think kids sometimes need visual help with death. I've been fielding questions and admitting that I, too, am sad. I've shown some tears. He still hasn't asked me about his own parents dying, but I know his questions are working there. I will definitely use your wording -- that most people live to be very old. Thank you for that. :)

Family Section Editor Jenna Hatfield (@FireMom ( http://twitter.com/FireMom )) blogs at Stop, Drop and Blog ( http://stopdropandblog.com ) and The Chronicles of Munchkin Land ( http://thechroniclesofmunchkinland.com ). She is a freelance writer and photographer.

Beverly Diehl 5 pts

I know people want to protect their kids from the horrific fact that not all people who die are old, but IMO, parents do a disservice by suggesting that's the case. The fall of Freddie the Leaf is an excellent book for very young children.

Rather than giving an almost-promise that YOU won't die until you are very old, suggest that *most* people die when they are very old, but sometimes when people are very sick, or very hurt, they die. That this doesn't happen very often, but sometimes a mommy or a daddy can die, and that it's goodbye for the rest of *this* life, but (insert appropriate religious/spiritual beliefs here.) You don't want to create a covenant with your child that nobody else can/will die, because if it happens, there's the trauma of the death, plus the trauma that you "lied" to them.

Hope Edelman's "Motherless Daughters" is a MUST-READ for women who've lost their mothers to death, substance abuse, desertion or mental illness - or those who love a girl or young woman in those circumstances.

You probably also want to express your own shock & sadness, acknowledge your child's fear that something will happen to his own parents. Don't try to belittle the fear, but give him/her a safe place to explore it, and understand, kids process death and grief very differently from adults, and from one another, depending on what age they are.

PriscasVoice 5 pts

This came up with my 7-year old daughter just last week. We lost a good friend (in this case, a daddy my age who has children the same age as my kids) to leukemia in March. One night last week my girl was especially weepy and clingy,and she kept telling me she didn't want to go to camp the next day because she didn't want to leave me because I was the right age to die and she didn't want me to die. After repeating this off and on for the better part of an hour, I asked her directly why she was so afraid that I was going to die. She said "Mr. Chuck died, now I think you are going to die too." I started to tell her that mommy was strong and healthy and she didn't need to worry about me, but that didn't entirely satisfy her because our friend was strong and healthy too... and then leukemia shocked us all and ravenously took him. Even at 7 she is too smart to be content with that explanation. So instead I told her the most profound truth that I could in that moment: that God is watching over all of us and he loves us and that he doesn't want us to live our lives worrying about when we will die. I will continue to point my daughter to God's love and to looking for the positive things that come even through the most horrible of circumstances. And at the same time I am reminding myself, because the truth is that adults struggle with these things too. We are just seldom as open and honest about them as children are.

poks 5 pts

i could never imagine my mom dying.. i'd rather die ahead of her than to see her leave me. =((

eric cantona ( http://www.confessionsofamanunitedfan.com )

jbcarney 5 pts

My experience is a bit different, but the questions have started already. I nearly died in childbirth with my second son. I developed eclampsia (preeclampsia but with seizures) and HELLP syndrome. My older son was 4 at the time. He is now 9. I volunteer with the March of Dimes and the Preeclampsia Foundation. My older son is just now figuring out why. He hears stories. He knows that he almost lost me. My younger son doesn't yet. He also doesn't know that he almost died. It's hard. My older son decided a few years ago that he wished we were all made of Legos so that we could be put back together when we die. I worry that the "almost" part of my story will lull him into thinking that death is always an almost. He has fish, and three of them have died, but he knows that they can be replaced with almost identical fish. He calls the new fish by the old fish's name and considers it a reincarnation. I can't argue, but I do worry. I hope he won't be faced by the death of a grandparent or other family member any time soon, but there are no guarantees.

Jenn