Bio
I'm a mom, a blogger, a private dayhome operator, and a big fan of quiet activism.  I love to read, swim, bike, watch my kids discover their wor...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Money Where My Mouth Is, and Other Bullsh*t

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 35
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

I haven't spoken to my mother since Christmas break.

She has a t-shirt that reads "Mother and Daughter by Chance, Friends by Choice", and she would wear it every time she came up to visit me.  We've spoken on the phone at least once a week for almost all of my adult life.  She had me when she was seventeen, and we grew up together, she and me.  She had foster children when I had toddlers, and we would talk about what it is to be a parent, now, when there are so many rules and so much judgement and such a competition to Do it Right.

We talked a lot.

At first it was me calling to rant because there was no one else in the world who understood me quite as well.  There was no one else in the world who had my back, all the time, no matter what, and would just let me be FURIOUS over whatever petty thing.  And laugh with me when the mad was gone and I could see for myself my own ridiculousness.  But then, my mum, whose life has always been a roller-coaster sinking to Incredibly Bad and then rising again to Tenuously Good before rocketing straight back down again....  My mum had a bad year.

At exactly the time that I was accepted into graduate school, with all of its ancillary expenses, my mum's bad year turned into something horrific.  It sucked the air out of our lives and made it hard to breathe.  It left her, in her fifties now, without an employer or any prospects, with a stack of unpaid bills long past due and a rent payment that had been hard to make when life was Mostly Okay.  It's that part of the rollercoaster where you really start to wonder how well this rig had been tested, you know?  Where the speed and the force make you wonder if your heart could actually stop this way, right here, before screaming back up the rise, again.

Except, of course, the ride has slowed down.  No one makes a rollercoaster-type recovery from something like this.  It's slow and incremental.  The air is viscous.  The wheels are jammed.  The motor is straining, gears are slipping, and it's hard not to wonder if today is the day it just.  Stops.

But we were still talking.  And Christmas was wonderful.  We had the most relaxing holiday meal together that any of us have enjoyed in a lot of years.  We laughed, together.  We felt like a real family, together.  We talked about getting together again, soon, for skating and fun just hanging out.  For a family like ours, having gone through three deaths in a year, and one major crisis....  Making plans to hang out together just for fun was a very big deal.

My sister called me out of the blue a few days later.  She lives at home, and neither of us are phone people, so our lives get communicated to each other through social media unless it's really important.  We exchanged pleasantries while I waited for her to tell me Mum needed more money.  I was sure that was why she was calling.  And my stomach tied itself in complicated knots while I tried to figure out how I was going to answer that.  I could do it, if I had to.  But that debt-of-gratitude resentment had already started to build between my mum and me, you know?  Because when you're an independent woman, when you've been a single mother just-barely-hanging-on for more than thirty years, calling to ask your daughter for money is hard.  And when you're forced to do hard things too often, well....

So, when my sister finally came out with it; when she told me that she had decided to leave college I just about fell over.  With only a single two-week practicum between her and the end of her program, it was the absolute last thing I was expecting to hear.  But when she explained that she had finally landed a decent job, and that she'd been refused the time off to complete her practicum, I understood in a way that made me fall into my chair.

She was closing the door to keep the house up.  She was working her part-time job, plus two paper routes, plus helping our mum out with childcare contract work.  She was turning her back on almost two years of post-secondary education because her household needed the money.

That was hard to hear.

I've always believed that education

  • 35
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
SabrinaBlogs 84 pts

This is very powerful.  My father was the sole provider in our household so when his health began to fail and, I looked old enough, I went to work. He passed when I was 14 years old and I became a major contributor to the household expenses. Several years later I had my daughter and, while there was little conversation about college prior to that, there was none after that.

 

Our families are the training wheels of life.  We want to help, save and shield but we don't normally see how we hinder more than we help.  I commend you for standing your ground even when you heart so wants to help.  You will be able to help from a better place, from your overflow, if you just continue on. For your sister, I'm praying that she "gets it" sooner than later.

 

Savior is a hard part to play, we don't normally get through it without some form of resentment. And we resent everyone, the ones that needed saving as well as those that wouldn't sacrifice along with us. I often remind myself that while climbing up on cross might draw attention, the whole "hung His head and died" thing has already been done.

 

I can relate to your sister from where I've been and to you from where I fight to stand. I wavered from one end of the spectrum to the other until my mom passed.  Stay on your sister to finish school and your mom to regain her confidence in herself. Praying for all of you. I know, it's hard.

DesiValentine4 478 pts

 SabrinaBlogs Thanks so much for this!  "The whole 'hung His head and died' thing" has been done and done – amen to THAT!  I don't want to be anyone's saviour, nor their lifeboat for that matter.  But, like you, I've been providing for my mother's household in some way since I was fourteen years old and stopping is complicated.  For now, I'm done.  It's great that my sister stepped up, but horrible that she decided to drop out of school to do that, and absolutely infuriating that my Mum would accept her help under those circumstances.  And, you're right, once I've finished school I probably will be in a better position to help them.  And they will have had a couple of years without me enabling their continued dependence.  I'm hoping hard we'll still be friends when we get there.  Thanks for your prayers.  :-)

HomeRearedChef 2031 pts

An education "[is] our best bet for breaking the poverty cycle."  I so agree with you on this, Desi. That is why we pushed our son to finish his college education NOW, or move out ~ when he'd threatened he was "taking time off from school" After all we'd been through in that last almost 14 years, I was not about to let him off the hook that easy. Getting a job now is difficult enough. Times are hard; and it is very competitive out there now. Without a degree, without an education, his chances are really bad.

 

Thank you for sharing this post, Desi. I get to hear someone else agree with what I have believed all along. An education is NOT wasted!

 

Big hugs my friend,

~Virginia

DesiValentine4 478 pts

 HomeRearedChef ((hugs))  Thanks, Virginia.  On the one hand I feel like, if she is going to learn how to be an adult, I have to treat her like an adult.  I have to respect her decisions as I would expect her to respect the decisions I make for myself, you know?  But on the other hand, I feel like her short-sighted decision-making process, the "I have a job right now so preparing for a better job later is useless" is inherently immature – If that makes any sense.  I wish my mum would just step in and tell my sister to get back in school or get out of her house, but she can't afford that, and I think she's also afraid of being alone.  So many issues at play here!  Big hugs right back atcha, sweet lady.  Thanks so much, as always, for your kindness :-)

HomeRearedChef 2031 pts

 DesiValentine4 Today, Desi, this feels like we've sat down to have a heart-to-heart about our loved ones and their future. What to do...what NOT to do...  Sigh!

 

You take care, and let's try not to worry too much.   :)

 

HUGS,

SunbonnetSmart.com 948 pts

OK...No...you can't be responsible for the decisions your Mom and sister are making. They both probably think you will support them when you finish school, so you are going to have to face this again and again, that is choosing your family over your extended family. It's a sink or swim survival situation. and remember, drowning people just pull you down with them. Sometimes, you can't save them. You're making wise choices...don't know the whole story, but doesn't sound like they are...you are going to have to be so strong. If it were me, I would tell you sister to finish up school before they close the books on her, while she still can. And, then you could choose to explain that unless she does, you will not feel comfortable in aiding them financially. Tough love...easy for me to say, hard to do, but two weeks from a program degree is more than I can take...OH! Life is so hard. Still love you, Robin

DesiValentine4 478 pts

SunbonnetSmart.com My husband has been telling me the same thing – without malice, just a sort of sad awareness. Both my mum and my sister have a hard time making good choices, and we have spent a lot to try to help keep them afloat. After this last crisis, it started to feel more like enabling than helping, though. My sister has a big temper, but I think your advice is valid. I'll talk to her. Sometimes tough love is the only way to show just how big your love is, you know?

SunbonnetSmart.com 948 pts

 DesiValentine4 Yes...no malice, but sad awareness...LOVE that phrase. I know, I know...and people who make bad choices...and we all do it on occasion...seem to think everyone with their life going well, or better at least, has it easy. Oh Sweet Desi! Been in this situation...be STRONG! Think of your kadiddles....Much Love, Fondly, Robin

Denise 1048 pts moderator

I would have shouted, "SHE IS", too. That doesn't help you one bit, but I would have.

:-(

DesiValentine4 478 pts

Denise It helps. I feel like a total shit for not being more understanding or more compassionate of Mum's situation, so it does help to know I'm not the only one would be upset about this.

SunbonnetSmart.com 948 pts

Desi! With all of your worries and problems, what hits me in the face is your powerful writing. This is one of the neatest paragraphs I've ever read, both in its sentiment and word tempo which echos the meaning:

"Except, of course, the ride has slowed down. No one makes a rollercoaster-type recovery from something like this. It's slow and incremental. The air is viscous. The wheels are jammed. The motor is straining, gears are slipping, and it's hard not to wonder if today is the day it just. Stops."

I think I'm going to cross stitch that and hang it on my wall as we're trying to get to the next truck stop for a hot meal and shower as well. Much Love, Fondly, Robin

DesiValentine4 478 pts

SunbonnetSmart.com Thanks, Robyn. What a compliment! I hope you get to that truck stop, soon. Sometimes the best hot meals are the ones we have to wait for. ((hugs))

SunbonnetSmart.com 948 pts

DesiValentine4 They are surely appreciated. :) And I was thinking and wondering what could be done for your sister to get emergency financial aid to stay in school...other than that, there are certain truths to life, written in granite. Education is the ONLY way to help your mother in the long run. Odds are, she'll still need help when both of you are out of school. One thing that hits me though, is your sister as driven to complete her education as much as you are? Maybe not...just thinking....but, remember, those financial aid people can often come up with tuition wavers and lots of fun options to help the serious (and that's the key) student through rough times. Much Love with the Blue Plate Special on top, Fondly, Robin

DesiValentine4 478 pts

SunbonnetSmart.com The decision-maker for my sister wasn't tuition – she's eligible for financial aid and has been using student loans and grants to get to this point. It was that she would have to give up her job – her household's only source of income – to finish her college diploma. Because the other adult in the house is my mother, not my sister's husband or legal dependent, she was denied additional funding to cover Mum's expenses. And she wasn't confident that there would a decent job waiting for her once school was completed. It's a bad position for her to be in. I wish I could get the two of them out of this without damaging our relationship even more.

SunbonnetSmart.com 948 pts

 DesiValentine4 OK...another approach.  I bet the school would work with her to do the work outside of the regular path...understanding the situation and bringing attention to the fact she is the sole support of your mom. THERE IS A WAY....if you want me to call the school and approach them, I will. I have lots of experience in working with oddball situations in academics...if you feel comfrotable and want me to...Friend me and we'll make plans...Tee-Hee! Lots of Fun! Sleep on it, maybe...Much Love, Fondly, Robin

DesiValentine4 478 pts

 SunbonnetSmart.com Canada has a pretty rigourous Freedom of Information and Privacy Act, which basically means that once you are an adult, any school or public body is prohibited from talking about your situation to anyone other than yourself, unless you've been deemed medically incapable of communicating on your own behalf.  I did call the school in January, anyway, and ascertained that anyone in my sister's position can re-register to complete her program – without penalty within two years of withdrawal.  Since none of the organizations on the practicum roster provide any sort of evening or weekend work, I'm working on my sister to re-register in the fall and organize her practicum around the holiday time she will have earned at her work, by then.  Here's hoping!

KarenLynnn 1172 pts

my mom and i are 17 years apart in age also. there have been many things said that can't be unsaid. so i do like you... put some distance between us for a bit of time and then call. but i usually dance around the problem and just pretend every thing is ok. i'm 55 and she's 72 so at this point in my life, i'm riddled with guilt putting distance and time between us but the fear of saying something that might hurt her keeps me from calling. i hope your sister can finish up soon.

DesiValentine4 478 pts

KarenLynnn Oh, we do that, too. We've had smaller fights where we've just been really polite to each other for a few months until we're both calm enough to pretend it never happened. I don't know how healthy that is, but it's what we do! I hope my sister can finish up, soon, too. Getting her to agree to college in the first place was so difficult, I'm skeptical that she'll go back. But still. You gotta hope, you know?

sassymonkey 733 pts moderator

I'm sorry Desi. It's not any easy position for any of you to be in. You are probably far smarter than I would be because I doubt that I'd be able to not talk and NOT say the things that I'd probably later regret.

DesiValentine4 478 pts

sassymonkey Thanks. Sometimes I wonder if the not talking is making things worse. Like we need to clear the air and just be done with it. But I doubt she and I would be any kind of friends afterward, if we were to give that a try.

SabrinaBlogs 84 pts

 DesiValentine4 I think things would be different but who's to say you don't keep the parts of your friendship that are supportive in a more healthy way. 

 

On one occasion I reminded my mom that I wasn't her only daughter. I was firm but respectful. For the next month or so, she contacted my sisters for help and COULDN'T WAIT to tell me how great they were. LOL! My stomach turned because I sat in a different seat in her life but it allowed the relationship between all of us to expand. Wasn't long before I was back in the hot seat but I learned some things in the process.

DesiValentine4 478 pts

 SabrinaBlogs I'm a little ashamed to admit I've been enjoying this distance.  I miss her (so much!), but her needs are many and exhausting and to have this space for myself when all the rest of my life is so busy....  It's selfish, I know, but I obviously needed this break.

SabrinaBlogs 84 pts

 DesiValentine4 Nothing to be ashamed of.  Selfish keeps you sane.  :-)

Laine Griffin 472 pts

Oh my, Desi. What a horrible situation to be in.

I admire you for taking a step back and not talking about it until you are ready.

And hopefully, your sister will be able to finish at some point.

DesiValentine4 478 pts

Laine Griffin Thanks, Laine. Your admiration means a lot to me :-) I really do hope this is just a break for her, or that she's lucked into one of those jobs that will let her work up to some level of comfort. Maybe if I can focus on the hoping part, I'll stop being so thoroughly pissed off.

victorias_view 2371 pts moderator

I'm so sorry Desi! I feel like you have been put between a rock and a hard place - it must be devastating to hear your sister did not complete her degree within a few weeks of completion. It also isn't fair for you to be put on the spot like this...

The best thing you can do is put you and your family first. I strongly believe education is key to a bright future. You are such a wonderful example of a smart independent woman and loving mother to your children.

Sometimes emotional distance is a good way to step back and put everything in perspective. I know it has been a difficult year - if you ever need a ear I am here.

DesiValentine4 478 pts

victorias_view ((hugs)) Thanks so much, Belle. I did the same thing when I was 19 – dropped out of university to help Mum make ends meet, and then it took me 10 years to finally finished my degree. There was a lot of time lost at dead-end job, and a lot of things left unsaid in the meantime. I don't want that for my sister. But she's an adult, now. It's up to her, now. That's hard.

victorias_view 2371 pts moderator

DesiValentine4 Your sister has to make-up her own mind and sometimes it is hard to break away from our parents. But at times like this she isn't doing herself any favors nor your mother by not completing the degree.

I think there would be strong words in my household - I commend you on being so composed :)

SunbonnetSmart.com 948 pts

DesiValentine4victorias_view No...it's up to you...you will have the purse strings...

SunbonnetSmart.com 948 pts

victorias_view What !?!?! A few weeks within her degree? I didn't understand that. Reading too fast...Then I would tell the sister to get back to school and finish up. That is the most foolish thing I've ever heard of....and I'm not cross stitchin' THAT! What an excuse to grab defeat out of the jaws of victory! OMG...get me going....Love you! Fondly, Robin

Now...I better go back and read this more carefully.... :)

DesiValentine4 478 pts

SunbonnetSmart.comvictorias_view It's nuts, I know. To get so close and then just walk away.... Yeah, I'm having some trouble rationalizing that one.

victorias_view 2371 pts moderator

DesiValentine4SunbonnetSmart.com Do you mind me asking what is she studying?

DesiValentine4 478 pts

victorias_viewSunbonnetSmart.com She had completed all but two weeks of the Early Learning and Childcare diploma program – all of the classwork, but not the final practicum. In September she called to tell me she was going to use the diploma for advanced placement in the child psychology B.A. program with the goal of working in juvenile mental health and already had strong employment connections in that area through her volunteer work with at-risk youth and at women's shelters. What a loss!

victorias_view 2371 pts moderator

DesiValentine4SunbonnetSmart.com That is heart-breaking! She needs to make the right choice for herself :)

DesiValentine4 478 pts

victorias_viewSunbonnetSmart.com She does. She's already dropped out of this semester and has no plans to re-register in the fall, so really her decision is made. I hope, though, that after working so hard and paying all of the household bills for awhile the novelty of "being a grown-up" will start to wear a bit and maybe she'll see how close she was before it's too late. Hope is good. Thanks so much, all of you, for your kindness, here :-)