Moneyfesto: Want vs. Need

Featured Member Post

Things I heard a lot as a kid, yet try really hard not to say to my kids include, “We can’t afford that,” and “Do you think money grows on trees?”

First of all, some things that we don’t buy we could easily “afford” if we didn’t pay some of our bills or chose to carry a credit card balance. So technically, while I might feel like we can’t afford something, I want to be clear that, “I choose not to allocate our budget that way.”

Secondly, paper money does indeed come from trees, my checkbook still has checks in it, and all you have to do is go to the ATM and stick your card in the machine and -– like magic -– out comes money. Duh! So how can I, or anyone, ever be out of money? That is about what kids know until we teach them otherwise.

Money is not the root of all evil; it’s the love of money that is, as the saying goes. This means that if you put the pursuit of money above all else, that is where things can get ugly. But money itself is power -– not in the sense of the “wallet bully,” i.e., he who has the money has control. I mean that if you have money, you are empowered with choices and freedoms. At the very most basic level, you can choose what to buy at the supermarket. At the other end of the spectrum, you can choose to take a vacation and where to go on vacation. You are also free to live without the oppressive burden of debt.

My kids get allowance and it is tied to chores. While I think it is important to contribute to the family and to know how to do things around the house, there will be a period in their lives (starting about now) where no one is consistently going to hand all their meals to them on plates, pick up their dirty clothes and towels and wash them, or clean up the bathroom after them, and, “Of course I am sure your girlfriend or wife will appreciate it very much if you already know how to do these things when you meet her." I need leverage to get them to do said chores. That is partially what allowance is for. The other part is so they learn how to budget, plan, sacrifice, trade off, delay gratification, and -- regardless of the amount one earns -- spend less, invest the rest, and watch it grow.

I do get tired of hearing my kids say, “All my friends have swimming pools,” and “Our backyard is way too small,” and “I wish I had my own room!” All I can say tell them is some people have more than us, and some people have less. Everyone can’t be the same. You’re right, life isn’t fair. Some people are happy with more or less. Those that are not ought to be motivated to make a change.

fenway fudge

Credit Image: hillary h on Flickr

To illustrate to my kids that they have it pretty good, I made a list of needs and wants and left it on the kitchen counter near the cereal and cracker cabinet. Items in the need category included shelter, utilities (not including cable), property maintenance, clothes, and groceries. Items in the want category were things like allowance, sports, sports equipment, school lunch/meals out, and brand-name clothes. The list stayed there for a few days, with no comment. After I had gone grocery shopping one day, I hauled out items from the bags one by one before putting them away.

“Kids, milk: luxury or necessity?”

“Necessity,” my middle son answered. He probably drinks two gallons a week himself.

“Yuck,” my youngest said. He prefers yogurt or cheese from that food group.

“Bread: luxury or necessity?”

“Necessity,” my older two chimed in.

“Chicken tenderloins.”


“Well, not so fast -– you can get protein from other sources, right?”

“Oh, well, yeah ... ”

“Beef jerky,” I continued.

“Necessity,” my oldest stated.

“Well, again ... you don’t need meat for protein, and couldn’t you make your own beef jerky?”

“You can?”

“Sure, Uncle does.” I went on, “Chicken nuggets.”

My youngest perked up and said, “What’s a luxury, again?”

“Something you want, not something you need,” his brothers answered, in almost-unison.

“Necessity,” he answered affirmatively. He would eat chicken nuggets at every meal if he could.

We all laughed. “Of course he would say that,” my middle son commented.


In order to comment on, you'll need to be logged in. You'll be given the option to log in or create an account when you publish your comment. If you do not log in or create an account, your comment will not be displayed.

Trending Now

More Like This

Recent Posts by Caroline Poser