Bio
Paula Gregorowicz, owner of The Paula G. Company, helps you discover and successfully create the work you are meant to do in the world. Through the p...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Monthly Home Office Expenses: Is It Feasible to Use Cell Phone Only and Lose the Landline Phone?

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 12
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

I am pretty diligent about reviewing my monthly expenses periodically to see where and what I can trim. Recently, I got back into doing an overhaul of expenses in light of the increased cost of every little thing and as part of the Week 1 exercises in the Business Rescue teleseminar series I've been attending. When it comes down to it my philosophy is to minimize necessary expenses (insurance, taxes, utilities) while consciously choosing what I want to spend my money on and why. The why factor is important to me because we all place different values on different things. The key is finding the right balance while doing right with your overall financial goals.

One of the monthly expenses that constantly confounds me is a combination of my cell phone bill and household/home office landline phone. Because we both live a distance from our families and I use the telephone extensively in my coaching business, we have one of those unlimited long distance type plans from Verizon. It's a pretty penny each month, somewhere around $70 or $80 but it sure beats paying actual long distance when I am on the phone for hours at a time conducting or attending teleclasses or coaching sessions. Believe me, I did that early on and almost had a coronary when I saw the monthly bill.

From a cell phone standpoint we've always had a pretty generous "family plan". While I was working full time and building my business my cell phone was my precious link to the future because I could use it for freelance related calls on my lunch hour and breaks. Now I use it as my primary business number on all my marketing materials. While it can be a drag getting business calls on personal time, I can use the caller id to screen them out. Not to mention I get to turn the cell phone OFF. It sure beats the alternative -- getting business calls on the home line at midnight because someone is calling from another time zone. While I could get yet another, separate business line in my home, I faint at the thought of having a third phone bill.

That always leads me back to the question -- is it feasible to go to a cell phone only life? Or, is it reasonable to shun a cell phone altogether? Martinique at Queercents asked the question "Monthly Expenses: Is it worth living without a cell phone?":

I was adding up our expenses, and every time I do this I get so angry at how much we pay for our cell phones each month. Between the two of us our $70 plan adds up to $120 each month - that’s $1440 every year! What a lot of money just for the luxury of being able to text, "getting off the train, be home in 15? or "where are you guys? we’re here," or being able to squeeze a chat in on the bus or while walking on my lunch break - is all that really worth nearly fifteen-hundred dollars a year?

Before cell phones we did just fine. We managed to make plans and meet up with people as easily as we do now.

I laugh when I read this because it is true - before cell phones we managed to make appointments, meet with friends, and conduct business just fine. In fact I often take it back a bit further to the days before voicemail. Now that makes me really wonder how we ever got anything done. Although I have to say I do miss those little pink "While You Were Out" message pads with all the little checkboxes.

Personally, I couldn't imagine giving up my cell phone entirely because of the safety factor involved while traveling alone and doing all the road cycling I do. Of course at times it is debatable how convenient and safe it really is because I often find myself out of range when I might need it most.

While Martinique considers ditching the cell phone entirely, many others, especially Gen X and Y folks seem to swing the other way -- skipping the landline entirely. Of course with VOIP (digital phone over the Internet) there is now a third choice as well.

Kathleen McDade explores her conundrum in "Landline or Cell?":

I’m hesitant to give up having a landline phone - even for something like @home.

  • 12
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
seattlegirluw 5 pts

 There are a few different options here:
 If your main objection to ridding yourself of a cell phone, consider a prepaid phone for emergencies such as being stranded or injured. I really think getting rid of a landline is a bad idea. Dollar for dollar, you get a lot more bang for your buck from a landline. If you have a lot of bells and whistles, pare those down. A single, basic line from a phone company is usually $12 plus taxes. So about $15-17/month. Maybe $20 total since you'll need call waiting.  Oh, but what about voicemail, you say.  Well, even my mom's crappy, free-after-rebate Rite Aid phone gives you the option of checking your messages remotely.  Also, be sure to actually check the average number of long-distance minutes you spent over the last six months or so. It's always good to be mathematically sure it's worth the money. And call around to other phone companies. Qwest offers a plan wherein you pay a flat $25 for long-distance calls.(http://www.qwest.com/residential/ld/index_oor.html... That's only for long-distance service but $25 sure beats $60-70.
 And despite my commitment to landlines, if those other options don't work, ask yourself why, if you have a cell phone, you choose to also pay $60 extra for unlimited long-distance calls on your landline. Putting half that into your cell plan could give you plenty of minutes to coach, I am betting.  Or, on the other hand, if you're already paying $20-30 for landline and another $60-70 for the unlimited long distance... You're already basically paying for an unlimited minutes cell phone plan. They run around $100. So (and this would be my last resort but that's just me since, like you, I hate bad connections that sometimes come with cell-only users)you can nix the landline and get unlimited free minutes for probably $40ish more than you're paying right now for your cell plan. Meaning you'd save up to $50 a month.

         ( http://ipickuppennies.blogspot.com )

flamyngo 5 pts

Before we had our daughter, we did NOT have a home phone line, and it was so nice!  No solicitors EVER called us, and we never had to worry about answering calls from in-laws!  (an added perk that I didn't realize until AFTER we had given up the home phone, BTW) but then when we had our daughter... I decided that it wasn't worth it to give up the phone because there just might be some sort of emergency that you couldn't forsee.  I remember a while back when some cell phone company did a thing where you could like walk in your house, plug in your cell, and then all your home phones would work off that, and that would be cool because then you could just have one service with one company and not have to worry about all that other stuff! 

http://www.totallythebomb.com

kishau 5 pts

I would prefer to replace the landline phone with a service like Vonage, but our existing home security service doesn't work well with VOIP phones (Vonage etc.).  We hardly use our landline phone, but it is handy when the cell phone battery dies or reception is poor.

- Kishau 

WEB: http://www.websmithgroup.com

BLOG: http://www.websmithgroup.com/blog

lifediscourse 5 pts

I would love to ditch the landline.  But without any DSL in my area, I needed the landline for dial up.  Yes, that is me, in a small town, in a third world.  :)

Soul ( http://lifediscourse.wordpress.com/ )

"A baby is God's opinion that life should go on." - Carl
Sandburg

tchberger 5 pts

My husband and I too have been cell phone only for a couple years now. Of course it depends on if you're in a location where reception is generally good...well 99% of the time good. I just worry about emergency situations...like if it will be easy enough and reliable too.  But so far, so good.  I'd say if you can cut the expense of a landline and don't really need it; go for it!

Teresa H. Berger

www.elebelly.blogspot.com ( http://www.elebelly.blogspot.com/ )

www.InnovateServices.com ( http://www.innovateservices.com/ )

Doris 5 pts

Paula,

I've had no problems, but we've always had great service and never had the problems with dropped calls that others do.

My husband and I both use our phones all of the time for work, as well as for personal stuff.  The transition didn't seem abnormal at all, we just got rid of one line.  The only adjustment was when filling out official forms.  You just have to get used to placing you cell in the home phone blank.

Doris

The Leaky Cauldron ( http://www.leakynews.com )

Reading and Writing and Chocolate ( http://www.the-leaky-cauldron.org/blogs/Doris )

BetaMommy 5 pts

My husband and I used to move a lot for work, so for us it made more sense to have cell phones instead of a land line. Now that we're settled, we still don't see the need for a land line. Sometimes the reception is bad and that can be irritating, but overall it's been pretty good so far.

ccarfi 5 pts

haven't had a land line for about 3 years.  not a problem.

froggemom 5 pts

When my partner and I moved in together about 5 years ago we decided we didn't need a landline, because we both used our cells or work phones exclusively. For the past 5 years I have only had problems when I couldn't get reception in my house, but otherwise I'm so glad we dumped the landline. We have saved money and a lot of annoying calls. I do occasionally worry about an emergency situation, but so far so good. My phone has worked when I needed it. Plus we live in a friendly neighborhood. I could always use a neighbor's phone if necessary.

Win a subscription to Brain, Child Magazine ( http://thinkmama.blogspot.com/2008/07/brain-child-... )

Doris 5 pts

About a year ago we searched the house for a lost remote phone.  I'm not even sure how long it had been lost, since we had stopped using it.  For us, we could talk to each other and all of our friends on the same plan for free.  I'd added unlimited texting and picture messages because I have three teenaged boys, and well sometimes it's just needed!

Once we found the phone, we realized that we did not need it.  I cancelled that day, and we became a family with only cell.  We did keep one line at the house for my fax line and our home security system. 

One year later I find that we still don't miss it.  We lost the cost of the phone and we gained the freedom of not having to answer the endless calls for our kids.  Because both my husband and I work for ourselves we were able to find good deals on "all inclusive" plans for the boys along with what we needed for ourselves.   One added bonus, I never liked the look of the telephone sitting next to my bed, and now it's gone.  Replaced with my sleek (currently pink) mobile phone!

 Doris

The Leaky Cauldron ( http://www.leakynews.com )

Reading and Writing and Chocolate ( http://www.the-leaky-cauldron.org/blogs/doris )

paulag01 5 pts

Thanks Doris & Froggemom for the comments & your experiences.

Do you experience any quality of reception problems? Do those you speak with complain of it?  I know I experience it alot when I use my cell or speak with others on their cells and it drives me nuts. I know many people just accept it as the way things are but I find it like having a thorn in my shoe & refusing to remove it.

If you're happy with your choice, I'm guessing it doesn't bug you but was just curious if you found any decrease in quality of the lines.

Warmly
_Paula

Paula Gregorowicz
The Paula G Company

www.thepaulagcompany.com
www.coaching4lesbians.com

lepetitchic 5 pts

My husband and I haven't had a landline for the two years we've been married, and honestly, I don't miss having one.  Our cell phones work just fine in our house and not having a landline is just one way for us to save some money :)

www.lapetitechic.com