Bio
I'm the Family, Moms...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

MTV's Teen Mom Falls Short, Bloggers Step Up

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 21
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

NEW YORK - MAY 05: (L-R) TV Personality from MTV's 'Teen Mom' Maci Bookout and Bristol Palin attend' The Harsh Truth: Teen Moms Tell All' Town Hall Meeting sponsored by The Candie's Foundation at Lighthouse International Conference Center on May 5, 2010 in New York City. (Photo by Astrid Stawiarz/Getty Images)

Newsflash: television doesn’t properly depict the life of a teen mom. I know, shocking, right? If you’ve watched any reality television, you’re aware that episodes only give us a glimpse into the heavily edited “real” reality. Teen Mom, a spin-off of MTV’s 16 & Pregnant follows original “cast member” moms through their babies’ first year. It’s kind of train-wreck-y, kind of interesting and a world away from most young moms’ experiences with parenting.

The truth is that the teen mom journey is not easily depicted, even by multiple moms, on a television show, reality or fictional. Despite what supporters of reality television will tell you, cameras change things. So do editors. And prospects of fame. Even with the currently famous teen moms on MTV, we also don’t get to see what happens when the cameras aren’t rolling -- or what was deemed “too boring” for viewers. The eighth diaper change of the morning is not all that interesting.

Neither is a teen mom who gets her act together, strives to build a future for herself and her child and generally succeeds in life. Where’s the drama in that? Despite what television producers might think, those moms are immensely interesting and extremely important to our society.

Luckily, there are some great young moms (and some who have grown up but started as young moms) on the Internet who have chosen to blog their experiences with us. Sometimes they do it for themselves, as we all know blogging can be a form of therapy. Sometimes they share their experiences to debunk all of the myths and stereotypes that surround them, to hush the judgments and stop the nasty looks. Like most moms who blog, sometimes they simply want to share their experiences, pictures and life with other like-minded people.

Whatever their reasons for blogging, we are lucky that they’ve chosen to keyboard up and put their lives -- and hearts -- on the line. We can learn so much.

Recently, Cassie Boorn blogged her thoughts about the Teen Mom show, which she has not watched nor does she plan to do so. In her heartfelt post, she talked about avoiding the subject of how old she was when her son was born. She attempts to appear, talk and act older than she is to avoid the inevitable questions. She brings up an important point about young mothers and society.

As a society. As women. As humans capable of making mistakes. We have to stop focusing on the tragedy of having babies too young and start focusing on supporting and building up the young girls that had a baby too young.

Trust me, young girls know all of the reasons why they shouldn’t have babies. Very few sixteen year old girls want to give up prom for dirty diapers. They understand that motherhood is alot of work and can wait.

But the young girls that have found themselves in this struggle that is being a young mother? They are met with shameful looks. They are told how to parent not asked how they want to parent. They are encouraged to take the low paying job and to not shoot too high. They are put on reality television shows and giggled at as they fumble through what has to be the hardest time in their lives.

Cassie also has a great series of reader-submitted ""20something Letters", written to our younger selves. Some deal with pregnancy, others don't. But read them. They're fascinating.

Last month, Kim chose to combat comments on a previous post by another blogger at Momaroo with her own, entitled “I Got Pregnant at 18, and I AM Proud.” She takes on the idea that “no one who got pregnant at 18 should be proud” by describing all of the things that she did before and after her son arrived and just why she is proud.

No one should be proud of being 18 and pregnant? I'm really proud of the pregnant-18-year-old-me. Before my son was born, I graduated high school, got married,

  • 21
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
CroMom 18 pts

My husband is an "oopss" (that's what he calls himself).  His mom was 17 when he was born, dad 18. Mom dropped out of hs, got her ged. dad dropped out of college and got a job.  They were married for 17 years.  Were successful, in terms of money. They had a house, car, bills paid and eventually baby #2.  Baby #2 was the "maybe we could save our marriage if we have a baby" baby.  They divorced, it was bitter, and still is bitter almost 20 years later.  My MIL eventually got her cosmatology lics and now owns her own salon - so she is a success. They did have alot of family support (grandparents) these were the same grandparents who said "your pregnant so now you get married and you make this work".  they say they didn't have a choice in it, there was going to be a wedding, your the bride, your the groom. done.  A forced marriage at a young age certainly wasn't the answer (as my personal opinion is that this forced marriage is part of what was wrong with the marriage). 

 

Poky Puppy ADD It Again 57 pts

I wasn't a teen mom, but I was an ill-prepared mom at only twenty and I was single.  Whatever age you're doing it alone, I don't think you're prepared for the loneliness.  I don't think you're prepared for what it feels like to take your child on an outing that's supposed to be fun, when all you can see are the other families who consist of two parents ooing and ahhing over their child, taking pictures of one another with the child, and laughing together about how spectacularly cute and smart their child is. 

 

My child was pretty spectacular, too, but there were years in her life when I was so mired in the day to day survival of being a single parent, and in the loneliness of it all, that I functioned much of the time in a fog; not present at all, merely surviving.  I always picked my child, and tried to make choices that were best for my child, even when many other single moms of the time weren't.  What I fear I failed to do was appreciate those fleeting moments when I had my child all to myself. 

 

My advice to young, single moms is this: however hard and lonely the big picture is, be present in the moments with your child and appreciate them for the spectacularly funny, cute and smart little beings they are, just for you.  All too soon, you will have to share them with the rest of the world.

Miranda @ Keeper of the Cheerios 5 pts

I had my daughter when I was 16.. I went through the nasty looks as I'd walk through the grocery store with my baby in her carrier and the rude comments from older people who thought they knew it all.

What those strangers who insisted on being so rude didn't know was that I was bound and determined to not be just another Nevada statistic. I continued in high school and graduated with my diploma a year earlier than my peers because I busted my butt. Seriously, I did this while waking up every hour at night with my daughter who was eternally hungry. I wasn't your typical teenager before becoming pregnant anyways and so I did everything in my power to be a good mom and I was. I was also blessed with an amazing support system. I'm not saying it was easy by any means, it was terrifying and hard but parenting is like that no matter how old you are as a mom.

I think that while there are some really awful teenage moms out there there's also some really great ones. I can say the same thing for older moms, I've seen some so awful I don't understand why they're allowed to keep having babies. Sure mistakes can be made but even mistakes can lead to amazingly beautiful moments in life and I wouldn't trade my daughter for the world.

-Miranda

Visit my blog at http://keeperofthecheerios.com 

redbootsdownunder 5 pts

It's also lovely to see all the comments from other great mums who've done the young mum thing or in support of young mums. I had my first baby boy at 19, and my second just after 21. Sure it was a rough ride, mainly because their dad was the kind of person you learn from and leave, and really shouldn't try to settle down with. But I don't regret a single thing, or my decision to keep my baby and then give him a brother. My boys are amazing people I am overjoyed to have in my life.
And maybe us young mums missed a bit of travel and independence and some of the interesting jobs our peers got to do. But we also missed a lot of debt (because banks won't give unemployed young mums 6,000 for that giant plasma TV) and a lot of other nasties like ODs, STDs, bad relationships etc. Mainly because we were just too darn busy to do any of that!
I'm proud of what I've achieved, I have two amazing children who give me the motivation I previously lacked. I love being able to encourage other young mums that it's not the end of their life, and tell them that they can do it, will do a great job, and they and their child will be fine. I love being able to smile when people comment on my youth, and tell them (in front of my kids) how lucky I feel to have my beautiful children, and how wonderful these kids are. The stigmas only affect us if we buy into them; people only believe what you tell them about yourself. If we believe in ourselves, regardless of age, the majority of other people will believe in us also, and be incredibly supportive as a result!! Hugs and kisses to all those young mums out there, you're doing a great job!!

justlinda 24 pts

I don't regret having my children because they are phenomenal women and we did fine getting through the tough times. And for the most part, it IS tougher for a teen mom than for one who is more mature, better settled, etc.

But it's not like just because it turned out well for me, I would recommend it to others. I didn't recommend it to my own daughters. I did counsel them to wait for all the reasons I posted.

I have 5 daughters, and the youngest are ages 6, 8, and 14. I may have a pregnant teen yet. Things happen. If it happens, we'll get through it. If one of them were to have and raise a baby, it would grow up loved and cared for (just like my oldest daughters did).

There are plenty of teen moms who step up and do a great job. And yet I still would counsel any teen to wait...

JustLinda

fabulously imperfect Nothing to See Here... Just Linda ( http://justlinda.net )

Twitter @JustLindaSTL

mbteaches 6 pts

I will always remember the day the Independent Study Dean (I was kicked out of main stream High School once my pregnancy became public) pulled me aside for a chat. It seems that after giving birth to my son, I wasn't acting "teenager-y" enough. I was lectured on how, later in life, I would resent my kid for taking away my childhood, instructed that it was important for me to keep acting like a teenager, and encouraged to resume the teen activities I was involved in before I got pregnant.

My response rocked that woman's world!

I told her that I would NOT resent my son as it was MY DECISION, albeit a foolish one, to have unprotected sex and that I fully intended on being responsible for the consequences of that decision. Then I proceeded to inform her exactly what "teen activities" I had formerly been involved in and explained how my friend, who had also had a child six months after I did, was following her advice and doing drugs in the same room with her kid. Consequently, she excused me from Independent Study and signed me up for the high school exit and early college entrance exams.

At 18, after working full time and going to community college full time for 3 semesters, I choose to drop school because I couldn't stand my son being in daycare from 7am-6pm.

I married a wonderful man at 22, became a stay at home mom at 23, and starting homeschooling at 24. Today, I have 3 beautiful children whom I love dearly. My eldest is a Junior in college and on the Dean's List. There is a special and unique bond between us. I believe it is because, in a way, we grew up together.

I thank God each and everyday for that boy.

mbteaches 6 pts

It behooves us to remember that there are many wounds out there based on this topic, some raw and exposed, some that apprear to be thin faint scars, but able to bleed just the same.

Cynthia Occelli 5 pts

Hi Jenna:

I was a 9th grade dropout, pregnant teen, living in a garage, on welfare and married to a convicted felon. Growing up a biracial child in an all-white racist environment left me with little self-worth or direction.

The birth of my child was a magnificent moment in a very dark time. The prospect of raising my baby in that world terrified me.

I became absolutely determined to escape the ghetto, my abusive husband, poverty and every bad thing that came with my life.

Fueled by the greatest love I've known, I achieved the impossible. I moved away, got a job, convinced an accredited law school to admit me on probationary status, built a business and graduated from law school in the top 3% of my class (without ever completing high school or attending undergrad).

My child has grown up in safety, security and abundance with no recollection of the world we came from.

It wasn't always easy, but sometimes it was. And though I do not recommend my path, I am grateful for it.

I spend a lot of time talking with my 13 year old, daughter about her value and the unlimited life before her. She's chosen her own goals and interests. Being a teen mom isn't one of them. In fact, she now says she won't have children until she's lived all over the world. I'm all for it.

Cynthia Occelli writes at "LIFE: It isn't for the faint of heart ( http://www.cynthiaoccelli.com )" a blog about overcoming challenges and creating your best life using good sense, spirituality and wisdom.

BlondieChicago 24 pts

I haven't seen the girls in magazines, so I didn't realize it had become more pop culturish. I do see your point.

JennaHatfield 326 pts

Your reply kinda made me cry and not in the good way (though it's not your fault). You bring up a lot of great points.

Contributing Editor Jenna Hatfield (@FireMom ( http://twitter.com/FireMom )) blogs at Stop, Drop and Blog ( http://stopdropandblog.com ) and The Chronicles of Munchkin Land ( http://thechroniclesofmunchkinland.com ). She is a freelance writer and editor.

JennaHatfield 326 pts

Considering that there are threads of conversation about the original show, 16 & Pregnant, from teenagers who were purposefully trying to conceive in hopes of being on the show, yes, I think that there are some real issues with the original and the spin-off.

I think it matters less that Teen Mom might give real voice the exhaustive nature of young mothering and more that these girls are on the front of magazines. For a teen who might not be going anywhere in life, that seems like an easy out. Have a baby, get a show, get on a magazine with great looking hair to boot. If this was a documentary-like movie, the likes of which the larger masses do not watch, I'd be less worried. But on MTV? And on the front of US Weekly (or whatever check-out-line mag that was)? Nope. Don't like it.

Contributing Editor Jenna Hatfield (@FireMom ( http://twitter.com/FireMom )) blogs at Stop, Drop and Blog ( http://stopdropandblog.com ) and The Chronicles of Munchkin Land ( http://thechroniclesofmunchkinland.com ). She is a freelance writer and editor.

mbteaches 6 pts

I've seen teen moms want to keep their baby because they want to feel the unconditional love FROM the child! Hey, I can understand that, especially from a hormonal teen, but that is not how parenting works. Parenting is sacrificial, with delayed gratification. And that's putting it mildly.

"What I always emphasize when I give counsel is the child. Because the teen herself might not care about her own hardship - she might feel all selfless about that. What I learned in my own teen-mom experience is that I had made decisions that impacted these babies, these children, and put hardship on THEIR shoulders without giving them a vote."

Laura, THAT IS WISE COUNSEL. I completely, 110% agree!

BlondieChicago 24 pts

I think the show is really interesting and does NOT glorify having babies. In fact, I'm usually exhausted when the show is over after thinking about how I would manage all of the problems the girls face. I think they are brave to give us a window into their world. Yes, MTV milks plenty of things for ratings (hello Jersey Shore and The Real World), but I don't see anything "awesome" or "cool" about Teen Mom. I just see hard core reality. Am I missing something?

My futher thoughts on this:
http://talesfromclarkstreet.blogspot.com/2010/07/watching-teen-mom.html

justlinda 24 pts

Every single time I hear how teens are counseled about pregnancy, I bristle. The approach is always about THEM, the teen. You'll miss out on your fun years, it's so much hard work, you won't get any sleep, you won't get to see your friends, etc.

Now, I'm not saying all those things aren't true - they are. And frankly, I don't think most teens are going to learn that on an intellectual level. You have to experience it. People tend to think they can rise up and handle stuff even if others can't.

What I always emphasize when I give counsel is the child. Because the teen herself might not care about her own hardship - she might feel all selfless about that. What I learned in my own teen-mom experience is that I had made decisions that impacted these babies, these children, and put hardship on THEIR shoulders without giving them a vote.

Like most people, I wanted to give them everything they needed and a lot of stuff they wanted. I don't just mean material goods - I mean, time and experiences.

And while "Love is Enough" makes a great Hallmark card, the reality is that you need more than that. The child DESERVES more than that. She deserves good nutrition and inclusion in healthy activities and physical safety. If you don't have the means to provide that, you have made a selfish choice that impacts this being, this child - you have imposed your "sacrifice" onto her.

Now, I know - it's not all doom and gloom. We did fine. They ate a lot of peanut butter and macaroni. But it's not like they had a horrible, awful life. We eeked by.

But I was lucky. I had a good head on my shoulders and a good family support network.

Still, there were days... when I had to look into my kindergartner's eyes and say "No, sweetie - we can't go to Molly's birthday party." just because I couldn't afford to buy a gift, well, it broke my heart. Those little things happened all the time and they were because I wasn't more careful in my contraception responsibilities.

It doesn't matter how much the teen is willing to sacrifice; my message is they should wait BECAUSE they love their future child and they shouldn't impose that need to sacrifice upon someone who didn't have a choice in it.

I know there is no perfect time to have kids... I know that finances may always be stretched. But a person should give her child the best start and the best opportunity. I may not be able to define exactly where that line is, and I don't think it's all doom-and-gloom when we cross it - we can recover with hard work. Still, we should counsel our teens to be responsible and wait because they love their future baby, not because they don't want to give up partying with their friends.

Off my long-winded soapbox now.

JustLinda

fabulously imperfect Nothing to See Here... Just Linda ( http://justlinda.net )

Twitter @JustLindaSTL

justlinda 24 pts

The daughter I got pregnant with in high school when I was 17 is now 27. And 2 weeks from tomorrow, she will be married. She has a college degree and is a home owner. Her sister is also a home owner and currently pursuing her master's degree (she's 25).

It wasn't always easy for them or for me, but yes - it can be done. And many of us live to tell a story with a happy ending.

I, myself, didn't go to college because I've always had to earn a living. Oh, over the years I have worked in about 60 credit hours here and there, and someday I will finish - probably when I am over 50.

But me and my girls - we did it. When I watched them walk for their college graduations, I was more proud than had I done it myself.

I can't WAIT for the wedding because shortly after, they plan on trying to start a family. I taught them good, these girls. All those years of drilling reproductive responsibility into them, I'm finally at the stage where I'm all "Hey! You're 27 - lighten up on the birth control already, will ya?" LOL

JustLinda

fabulously imperfect Nothing to See Here... Just Linda ( http://justlinda.net )

Twitter @JustLindaSTL

Erin Knell 5 pts

I was 19 when I got pregnant with my oldest. I wish shows like this allowed for a little more reality. I was very, very lucky and had alot of support and love, but I would never want anyone to think it was easy.

tmpatton 5 pts

It's definitely not an easy thing to do. I wrote a post about my thoughts on MTV making this show on my parenting/life blog

http://juststopscreaming.com/2010/02/is-mtv-making-teen-pregnancy-and-mo... ( http://juststopscreaming.com/2010/02/is-mtv-making-teen-pregnancy-and-motherhood-cool )

I think the idea started out right but it has turned into more something for ratings imo. And that I don't agree with

Toni

http://www.juststopscreaming.com

Melissa Ford 65 pts

I feel for teen parents. As a former teacher, I've worked with years and years-worth of teenagers and can count on one hand the few who I thought could handle the responsibility of a child. Hell, there are plenty of adults that I don't think are prepared to handle the responsibility. And it doesn't help when school's liken a child to a bag of flour in one of those experiential, hands-on projects.

Melissa writes Stirrup Queens ( http://stirrup-queens.com ) and Lost and Found ( http://lostandfoundandconnectionsabound.blogspot.com/ ). Her book is Navigating the Land of If ( http://thelandofif.blogspot.com/ ).

tjefferson_08 5 pts

Thanks for highlighting my blog, The Young Mommy Life, as a resource for young moms. Very much appreciated!

In general, teen moms and young moms are invisible in the media. I can count on one hand the number of young moms I've seen on Bringing Home Baby or A Baby Story, or interviewed in Parents or Parenting magazine.

We don't get credit for being good moms, and parenting during what is arguably the most difficult time of our lives to do so. So much personal growth is occuring at the same time you're trying to raise kids and it's confusing and sometimes downright frustrating.

Usually we're working with less income, less security of a stable relationship with the child's father, few mommy friends, and more pressures to make moves in our careers when often we haven't figured out what we want to do with our lives. It's difficult.

But it's often fulfilling. We get to grow along side our kids, and they see all our hard work first hand. It's something special when it's all said and done. :)

JennaHatfield 326 pts

I wonder how I will address this in more detail as the boys get older. It's interesting, isn't it.

I love, love, love when we talk about these topics. I think our children (and theirs!) will benefit from our discussions. Kudos, my friend.

Jenna Hatfield (@FireMom ( http://twitter.com/FireMom )) is a Moms & Family Contributing Editor for BlogHer. She blogs at Stop, Drop and Blog ( http://stopdropandblog.com ) and The Chronicles of Munchkin Land ( http://thechroniclesofmunchkinland.com ). She is a freelance writer and newspaper photographer.

Hey Jen 10 pts

But I was too busy being a teen mom and some heavy duty issues surrounding my own parenting that I didn't have time to worry about or deal with other people and their problems with me being a mother.

Being a teen parent is hard work. Actually being a parent in general is hard work no matter what your age, but if you aren't mature enough to take on the responsibility then maybe you should question whether having and/or keeping the child is in your and your child's bests interests. I love my girls dearly, but I wish I would have waited. Until I was older and more responsible. Until I had a good education and career.

I was that teen mom that was on welfare, but then made too much money when I worked at Wal-Mart to make ends meet.

My girls are 12 and 13 now. Hell yes I let them watch 16 and Pregnant. We talk all the time about waiting until they find someone they love and not jump into bed with just any man who tells them they are special but dumps them the next day. We talk about abstinence and birth control. They know how old I was when I had them and the difficulties I faced, especially when dealing with the issues I did with their father when they were younger.

I made a lot of unwise choices that I would not wish on anyone, much less someone who still has a lot of growing up to do herself.

Don't get me wrong, I know there are PLENTY of young women who are teens that are mature and can handle the responsibilities of having a baby, but I know way too many that aren't. I also know a lot of older women who should never have procreated too. ;(

At any rate, my girls are awesome and I hope that my "preachiness" as my daughter told me last night, takes with them and they do wait, but if they don't and they do happen to get pregnant while a teen. I will be there for them, help them and support ANY choice they make regarding their baby.