Bio
I like chocolate chip cookies.
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Recent Comments

Musing from a black woman: Barack Obama = African American

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 2
  • Sparkle (
    )
     


Yesterday I was greeted with this questionable, newsy article on the Yahoo! front page: Obama victory opens door to new black identity, by Jesse Washington, AP via Yahoo! News.

 

Before Tuesday, black identity and community were largely rooted in the shared experience of the struggle — real or perceived — [Apparently my struggle is now perceived] against a hostile white majority. Even as late as Election Day, many blacks still harbored deep doubts about whether whites would vote for Obama.

Obama's overwhelming triumph cast America in a different light. There was no sign of the "Bradley Effect," when whites mislead pollsters about their intent to vote for black candidates. Nationwide, Obama collected 44 percent of the white vote, more than John Kerry, Al Gore or even Bill Clinton, exit polls show . . .

. . . Certainly racism did not disappear after Obama's white votes were counted. No one is claiming that black culture and pride and community are no longer valuable. Many also dismiss the idea of a "post-racial" America as long as blacks and other minorities are still disproportionately afflicted by disparities in income, education, health, incarceration and single parenthood.

But white groups that once faced discrimination, such as the Italians, Jews and Irish, have moved from the margins to the mainstream. America debated whether John F. Kennedy could become the first Catholic president; now that's a historical footnote.

 

If I ever again have to hear someone mention groups of white people who had been discriminated against in the past, and then equate them with black people who continue to be discriminated against in the present, it will be too soon. There are historical differences amongst various oppressed ethnic groups, and it is unwise to ignore those differences. For instance, the ancestors of Italian Americans, Jewish Americans, Irish Americans and Catholic Americans (some of whom are all the same people) came to the United States relatively voluntarily. Whereas the ancestors of many (though not all) black Americans did not come to the United States voluntarily; they just happened to survive the Middle Passage.

This seemingly endless election and the final results have reminded me of something Wanda Sykes said in her Comedy Central Presents special. She repeated in her book, Yeah, I Said It:

 

I'm not politically correct. I still say black. I say it because with African American, there's no bonus. It doesn't make your life any easier. You don't see black people standing around, saying, "Oh yeah, African American. Man, I'll tell ya, this beats the hell outta being black. We should've made the switch years ago. Oh, this is nice."

You don't see any of us going into Bank of America, "Excuse me, I'm here to pick up my loan."

"Uh, Ms. Sykes, you were rejected for that loan last week."

"Oh, that was last week. I was black then. See, I'm African American now. I'll just go in the vault and take what I need. I'll sign on my way out."

African American ain't helping nobody. You think Rodney King's black ass is sitting somewhere, saying, "Damn, if I just would have waited two years before I acted a fool, they wouldn't have been beating my black ass. I would have been African American." . . .

  • 2
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Mrs.Micah 5 pts

I think the discriminations the Italians and Irish got is probably similar to what we see today against people of Hispanic origin. They're considered an outside threat, with strange ways and strange customs and "stealing our jobs." They were ghettoized but eventually became mainstream.

The legacy of slavery lends itself to a different form of discrimination. It's not the "immigrant problem," it's something else. There are definitely similarities--people being denied jobs, getting racial slurs, not being served in restaurants, but there's a different power structure. Only a few extremists would think it was a good idea to send black people to Africa, whereas that's always comming up with immigrants, for instance. Instead there's a much more ingrained set of assumptions/discriminations with a different history.

PartyPlanPat 5 pts

I have read with interest your post.  As one who was born and bred in the the ancestral home of Pres. Elect Barack Obama (KENYA), I really find the PC stuff just ridiculous.  What's up with Americans and compartmentalize everything?  I love it most when I refer to people as black and my friends are so quick to correct me with the African American clause (never mind that I am very very black, not necessarily colour wise, but I am from the mother land)!

Pres. Elect Obamas win is historical and means a lot.  And you are right there is a long way to go.  My friends and associates were visibly shaken by the win, panicked I would say.  I remember telling one friend, don't worry, no one is going to take away your white priviledge, rest easy, we have other things we are more interested in such as true equality!

As a woman, and a black woman at that, and might I add black, female and Mormon, I know a little of what it means to be in the minority.  My greatest concern is as this post indicates,

Open Letter To President Elect Obama: What Will You Do For Women ( http://homepartyplansuccesstips.com/?p=144 )

Here is what I am concered about : Statistics indicate, that in the 21st Century, for every $1 a man
makes, women make 0.77 Cents, and for women of color, we are looking at
0.67 cents for every dollar.

Equal pay for equal work!

What about the 5% govt. decree to reserve at least 5% of all govt. contracts to women owned businesses?  This is yet to be fullfilled!

Sincerely,

Party Plan Pat ( http://www.homepartyplansuccesstips.com )