Bio
Kveller.com is your Jewish parenting headquarters for all things bris, breastfeeding, matzo balls, and more.
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Recent Comments

Wearing Pink Shoes While Black -- and Male

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 11
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

By Liz Rose-Cohen

My son started preschool last Spring, and the more we learned the more we couldn’t believe our luck.

One of his teachers is an African American woman. That wasn’t luck. That was planning. Like we moved 700 miles so we could live in a town with a significant African American population and then chose a Montessori preschool with a significant number of African American teachers. That kind of planning. But the fact that she has dark skin was luck. Because my kids have fairly dark skin. And I know you don’t have to have dark skin to be African American. But my boys are still little; they don’t have it all figured out yet.  And now that we moved all this way so we could live among their people, I want them to know we made it.

Anyway, his teacher’s a middle-aged, black woman with dark brown skin. Already scoring tons of points, but then it turns out she has a gay son. And not just any gay son. He’s a professional ballet dancer. (My son, I’ll call him Moon Boy, loves to dance).  And he has the same birthday as Moon Boy. And, she’s the co-chair of Columbus PFLAG. So she reeeally likes Moon Boy. And we are feeling pretty proud of ourselves for facilitating all this good luck.

So the day Moon Boy came home saying he doesn’t like it when his friends laugh at his pink sandals, I knew I didn’t have to worry about finding support for him in his classroom. This was not the first time I’d heard of other kids commenting on Moon Boy’s pink shoes. But it was the first time I’d heard him tell about it. “They say I’m tricking,” he told me, all angry and pouty. “They say they’re not really my sandals.”

“Do they think your sandals belong to a girl?” I asked.

“Yes,” he confirmed, head down.

It surprised me to hear how clearly he understood the meaning of his friends words and to see how they had affected him. By the time our first child, Hot Shot, was Moon Boy’s age, she was well studied in the manifestations of sexism, but somehow I hadn’t thought Moon Boy was intellectually ready for these lessons yet. So when the pack of little girls at the end of our alley always asks me why he has on “girl shoes,” I answer for him.

“Oh, do you think pink is only for girls?” I ask them. “I know there are people who think that. But we don’t,” I say, rubbing my little guy’s head. “We think anybody can wear whatever color they want.”

I asked Moon Boy if he’d like help talking to his friends about how their words made him feel. He said he would. We made a plan to talk with her the next morning.

But when I told his teacher what happened, her response surprised me. She didn’t ask how long this had been going on and how Moon Boy was feeling about it. She didn’t offer to help him talk to his friends. Instead she reminded me that my son is an African American male.

“He can get shot for standing in the wrong place,” she said. “You can’t go with him everywhere,” she said. “You have to teach him what people are going to say, and how to respond, and let him chose when he feels like taking that risk.” Her son can be very flamboyant, she told me. But he decides where and when.

I wanted to hate her. I was mad, for sure. I thought I was mad at her. For not saying, first and foremost, that her classroom should be a place free of bigotry. For not hugging my little boy and squeezing out all those yucky, betrayed feelings. And I wanted to write off her advice. To say, fine, she’s a dark skinned, middle aged, African American woman who co-chairs PFLAG, but I don’t have to listen to her.

Except I’d moved 700 miles so that I could listen to her. That was the problem. Of course I knew I didn’t have to follow every bit of parenting advice that came from a black person’s mouth. But I couldn’t deny I’d gone through a lot of trouble to put myself in a position to receive this advice. I had to at least consider it.

I wondered if maybe this was internalized racism. Black boys being taught to sit and obey, blend

  • 11
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Southerngirl 5 pts

This was a blow to my heart. It is a struggle to help our kids navigate the world colorblind but make them aware of how their choices are preceived by others. Fairly or unfairly.

Liz Rose-Cohen 5 pts

Thanks all for your thoughtful reading of my post. The wonderful thing about the blogging medium is that it can move along with life. And right now were are living in a moment of resiliency. I wrote this post at the end of the last school year. Over the summer we went through two sets of black sandals: one got lost while traveling and the second broke just as the school year started. We gave Moon Boy the option of wearing his brother's sandals (blue and orange). Which he did for a few days, but then one morning he put on the pink pair. So on the way to school we did some role-playing:

"Why are you wearing girls' shoes?" I asked.

"Because I want to," he replied happily.

I was expecting something a little more political, a little more didactic, a little more defensive. Something like, "They aren't just for girls." Or, "Anyone can wear pink." I thought about talking to him about these alternatives, or doing a little feminism 101 review. But luckily, in the time it took me to think of what I might say, I realized the power in the peacefulness of his statement.

When I picked him up that afternoon a little boy asked me if Moon Boy is a girl or a boy.

"A boy," I said. "Are you asking because he's wearing pink sandals?"

"Yes," said the child. "Why is he wearing pink sandals?"

"Because I want to," Moon Boy said, with the same happiness.

"Oh," said the boy. "I like to play with my sister's wand."

Stacy Morrison 5 pts

Liz Rose-Cohen What an amazing update! Thanks so much for stopping by and giving us the news. Sounds like your son is getting some great mothering and has his own strong spirit to boot. Fantastic!

smilewithme 5 pts

I'm really glad I stopped by today and read this post. It was powerful. Thank you for writing it. I'm a mom of two, and though I'm not going through your exact situation, I'm going through my own, as we all are. It's a lesson learned, I just wish we could teach it to everyone.

Stacy Morrison 5 pts

Incredible story. So many layers of heartbreak in it. *sigh*

DonnaFreedman 5 pts

One of my great-nephews is very fond of the color pink. He also says he wants to be a girl, and he collects My Little Ponies, and rainbows are his favorite things in the world, and he loves to do his mother's hair.

I worry that he'll get bullied at school because he's not stereotypically manly. In fact, I stand prepared to pay for martial arts training so that he can defend himself if he gets threatened in junior high or high school.

And oh, how I wish I didn't have to do that. How I wish he could be anyone he wanted to be without having to choose which color to wear on which occasion.

Denise 70 pts moderator

I hate to agree with the teacher but I think she's right. I wish she wasn't though. Moon Boy should be able to wear whatever flip flops he likes.

midnightbliss 7 pts

its great that small children have their own choices that expresses their own personality at a young age, but society has different standards and its the role of parents to guide their children to learn to compromise with the society.

Rebecca Hafkemeyer Lmt 5 pts

Fantastic story and perspective. It is hard sometimes not to internalize our own judgement before passing it onto others. In a perfect world we wouldn't have to set up barriers of protection for ourselves or our loved ones. If he truly loves the color pink, masculine shirts such as polos still sport the light pinks and I am sure even for a little guy you could find one. Someone will always razz on with their own prejudice but it is an attribute of society with strong gender roles still prevalent.

Conversation from Twitter

Vidia2be
Vidia2be

blogher can you get me a vote and rt? http://t.co/v32Voyk vote Heather Purvis Social Media can work!