Bio
Erin Kotecki Vest is BlogHer, Inc.’s Social Media Strategist helping BlogHer make the most impact in the quickly-evolving new media landscape. Erin al...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Recent Comments

Dear Four-Year-Old Princess: Love Is So Complicated

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 29
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

My four-year-old daughter is home from school today, so naturally she's spending her afternoon twirling in front of me in princess dress after princess dress.

Mommy, don't I look sooooo beautiful. I know a boy will marry me.

My heart sinks. My mind races. My eyes dart all over the living room, where she's created Valentine's decorations. A sea of red and pink hearts drown me as I try to come up with an age-appropriate way of explaining to her the reality of love, marriage, life.

Yes, Valentine's Day has sent my daughter into love overdrive and in her adorable mind love = marriage to a handsome boy.

She's clearly knee-deep in the princess syndrome, and I've done nothing to stop the madness. In fact, I think my behavior with her father and men in general has probably made it worse.

But how do you explain to a four-year old that the prince hardly EVER comes to save you (and you don't need him to) and despite every message around her screaming otherwise, what she looks like INSIDE is what matters ... not outside with her damn dress and primped hair?

How do you explain that a partnership based on love is very hard work? That sometimes it goes horribly wrong and that the prince is a monster or that potential suitor is really going to break her heart? How do you explain that sometimes it's so wonderful and mesmerizing and lifts you off your feet until your heart thumps from your chest and you can barely breathe? How do you explain how lovers turn to friends and friends to lovers and they come and go and leave memories and wounds and sometimes very deep scars? How do you explain how a relationship changes and morphs over time and ebbs and flows?

She sees her father and me, and she sees nothing but love. I can't blame her for thinking that's all there is. Its all she is shown at home, on TV and anywhere. In her mind, it is the only way love exists.

How do I teach her just how complicated love really can be ... and how painful? Do I? Of course I do. I'm just not sure how.

Maybe she's smarter than I think, and she does see it. She sees the daily routine in this house where husband and wife sit in the same room and do their own things, barely talking. But she also sees the love pecks in the kitchen as we cook and the surprise butt-pinches as I bend over to grab something off the floor. Maybe just witnessing the roller coaster and mundane drudgery that IS the cycle of love is enough?

Or perhaps I've done her a complete disservice by not showing her it all. The tough. The boring. The very ugly. Because of that she moons over handsome boys and dons dress after dress talking about weddings and brides and her prince.

Maybe I haven't shown her, because I haven't figured it out myself. I have no idea how to explain the unexplainable. How I can be committed to her father yet flirt with other men? How I can be content in the routine yet throw a tantrum over it all in one day? How I can want more and love my life all in the same hour? How I can put on the adult version of the princess dress, that little black number, and paint my face and charm and smile and notice that indeed boys are soooo handsome? How I can come home to her father and cuddle on the couch while I remove my heels and then discuss bills? How I can remain happily married to my best friend sans dress and in sweats when it's not all flowers and romance and horses and carriages and glass slippers?

How can I talk to her about love as the restless mother who can't seem to get a handle on her own role in love well into a now almost 10-year marriage? Because in that little girl I see myself, wide-eyed and hopeful and willing to give away her heart with an intense passion that will sting, suffocate and be spectacular.

So many conflicting images and moments for her young, female mind to absorb. Resulting in twirling in front of me today, showing me how beautiful she looks.

I want my daughter to be strong, confident, and to not rely on

  • 29
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Erin Kotecki Vest 5 pts

and I'm very lucky that my kids do A LOT of it... a lot. A lot. 

lol

Politics & News Contributing Editor Erin Kotecki Vest ( http://queenofspainblog.com/ )

RedMongoose 5 pts

I was a princess.

 And look how seriously I took my job! ( http://www.redmongoose.net/images/princess.jpg ) (image)

I dressed up to play SimCity because I was the princess of AmyLand.

I think all girls grow up and out of it at some point if you let them -- the problem with those girls who are so incredibly princessed-out that you just need to roll your eyes is more in their parents encouraging such behaviour.

Otherwise, letting her pretend is good for her.

Erin Kotecki Vest 5 pts

oy. scary. 

Politics & News Contributing Editor Erin Kotecki Vest ( http://queenofspainblog.com/ )

Erin Kotecki Vest 5 pts

Politics & News Contributing Editor Erin Kotecki Vest ( http://queenofspainblog.com/ )

Erin Kotecki Vest 5 pts

am now very glad I wrote it. 

Felt good. 

Politics & News Contributing Editor Erin Kotecki Vest ( http://queenofspainblog.com/ )

Erin Kotecki Vest 5 pts

Politics & News Contributing Editor Erin Kotecki Vest ( http://queenofspainblog.com/ )

Erin Kotecki Vest 5 pts

oooh and then I can hear my son going "that's not nice!" 

Politics & News Contributing Editor Erin Kotecki Vest ( http://queenofspainblog.com/ )

Erin Kotecki Vest 5 pts

and even that has changed over time. I do really think she learns best by seeing it all. And I'm sure she does.... 

Politics & News Contributing Editor Erin Kotecki Vest ( http://queenofspainblog.com/ )

Janers0217 5 pts

The only actual Disney character that I can ever remember dressing up as for Halloween was Maleficent from Sleeping Beauty.  I always loved the Disney princesses, but when I chose someone from one of the movies to do for Halloween, I picked Maleficent.  I was 6, and I think my mom was both worried and amused.

Mothershaffer 5 pts

I couldn't wait until my daughter grew out of the princess phase. I was so proud of her when she chose to be Peter Pan for Halloween at age 3, but then the next 2 Halloween's were a succession of classic damsels in distress: Snow White and Cinderella. The year of Cinderella, she had concluded that she would be Sleeping Beauty the next year (augh), but by the time another Halloween came around, she had moved on to classic bitch, I mean witch. This year, it was tough not to buy her something that bordered on "whore" and I wrote about it on my blog:

http://mothershaffer.wordpress.com/2009/10/05/my-d...

I'm not a girly girl myself. So I find it fasinating that she's so interested in dressing up and putting make up on (despite the fact I never do this). Today, at age 10, she prefers sweat pants and soccer and I'm so ok with that. I know the age of boys is coming, but so far, she thinks they are noisy and gross. Her father re-enforces that characterization every day. God bless him :)

Janers0217 5 pts

I was one of those little girls who went through the princess stage, and I came out of it.  Girls just go through that kind of thing, I think.

I think she's too young to explain the intricacies of love and romance and some of those things, but she'll probably understand it all one day.

avflox 5 pts

WOW. Erin. Oh my god. Wow. I adore you. You just made me cry -- in the best way possible.

Tre - 5 pts

Erin, it's your utter honesty with the question that will ensure success..by success: you don't have the answers and you will let her know this

and by that you will help her see that love isn't a gift we open or a dress we put on or a one time celebration but a life long pursuit...just like life :)

and by being as open with her as you always are with us through your posts, she'll learn to think...to ask...to challenge...to doubt..to wonder....

and by doing this already, you're already giving her the self empowering skills you so want her to own and live.

my only add on: the lesson that we don't ever have to wait for good...whether it come as a prince, a job, a career, a dream...

whatever we want we dont have to wait for...

too often people think we have to wait for good: the job, the being in love the whatever.

we don't...i know there's much that says we have to find the companion....not even that is true....b/c the more you create your now..the more you can fall inlove with every aspect of your life...and still want more and ask for more but be so satisfied with the now.

that's how come you can flirt w/ 10 men and still be in love ....dress up and be on CNN and come home and flop on the couch in sweats....b/c you've fallen in love with your now....and she'll get this from you...and then maybe not....she may well struggle much. But your the kind of mom that is forever..and you will always give her the shoulder she will need to lean on....b/c that is how you love....trust it so much. :) it feeds all of us and we don't even see you in person day in and day out as she does :)

hugs for your heartfelt questions....and here's to hoping you feel more at peace amidst them ...sooo deeply respect you're asking them :)

Tre~

tw:   @tresha ( http://twitter.com/tresha )

fb:    http://facebook.com/treshathorsen

e:     tre@thoughtbythought.net

blog: http://thoughtbythought.net

shanbrentris 5 pts

She needs a very older brother. Not kidding. Ship her here for a month and she'll say what my daughter said just now when I asked her what boys are...."Butts. Boys are butts and we kick them."
Mr Lady: 
whiskeyinmysippycup.com

IsleDance 5 pts

Sometimes, I think we help them most when we just let them be.  Let them enjoy.  Let them learn as they grow.  They will.  All too soon.  And their lessons will be different than ours.  We have to let them have their reality...whatever it is.  Uniquely theirs.

One Friday night, Isle Dance ( http://isledance.blogspot.com ) loaded up her life and headed out...

MdMommy2Two 5 pts

In some ways, I think some of it is hardwired and some of it is taught.  I have a 5 year old boy and a 3 year old girl.  My 5 year old has never "nutured" a doll, he uses them for target practice, and has lately been "shooting" everything in sight despite us not having any toy guns or allowing any TV with gun references.  The giant box od dress up clothes sat getting dusty until my 3 year old got to be old enough to use them and she spends most days running around wearing every single tutu and dress we own--all at once--and mothering her stuffed cat.  And she loves Tinkerbell because she's had her crammed down her throat by my mom.

Anyway, I don't think it's harmful for a child to see a loving relationship.  Instead, it gives them something to use as a comparison for an unhealthy relationship.  My parents have been married since 1975, and it means I went into my own marriage expecting it to last for the long haul.

Adventures In City Living http://greatwallsofbaltimore.blogspot.com

Erin Kotecki Vest 5 pts

Maybe I should start telling her everything is sunshine and roses! Always! 

Politics & News Contributing Editor Erin Kotecki Vest ( http://queenofspainblog.com/ )

Erin Kotecki Vest 5 pts

"And their lessons will be different than ours."

Politics & News Contributing Editor Erin Kotecki Vest ( http://queenofspainblog.com/ )

Erin Kotecki Vest 5 pts

...and playing pretend doesn't bother me as much as how she talks while she's doing it. I guess that's all part of playing the part, but even last night after my husband got home and she was showing him how pretty she looked in her dress... he even did the usual 'oh honey you're always pretty, you don't need a dress to be pretty' she threw a TOTAL FIT screaming about how she was pretty WITH the dress. 

So now we're worried we're giving her the opposite problem. Telling her TOO much she doesn't need anything to be beautiful, it's what's inside that counts, etc. 

Phases. Bleh. 

Politics & News Contributing Editor Erin Kotecki Vest ( http://queenofspainblog.com/ )

Erin Kotecki Vest 5 pts

shooting, play fight...and no guns here either... 

Politics & News Contributing Editor Erin Kotecki Vest ( http://queenofspainblog.com/ )

JennaHatfield 10 pts

I grew up in a noisy but very loving home. When my Mom tried to explain that boys would/could hurt me and that love wasn't always what it seemed, I laughed at her.

And then I learned. The hard way. Over and over. Because I'm a stubborn, slow learner and, damn it, I didn't need to listen to my Mom. Double damn it.

But really, I don't know the hows and whats of teaching children, girls and boys, these kinds of things. I feel like I have a wealth of knowledge on the topic that I want to impart but, at the same time, I know that they will need to go through some of that on their own. I think your point of watching you, triumphs and failures alike, is likely key. In addition to that, being available, supportive and present as they go through their own triumphs and failures will hopefully result in a child who grows into a happy adult who is capable of loving (and failing) with something resembling grace.

Unless you're me. I'm not graceful at all. Ever. Whoops!

@FireMom ( http://twitter.com/FireMom ) from Stop, Drop and Blog ( http://stopdropandblog.com ) and The Chronicles of Munchkin Land ( http://thechroniclesofmunchkinland.com )

TW 6 pts

My girls went through serious princess phases and came out the other side. Now I have one princess who thinks boys and sex are disgusting and icky and she is not interested in either-unless it comes with a vampire attached. Even then, she probably isn't interested. On the other hand, she has identified the fact that Denise and I are like peanut butter and jelly, macaroni and cheese. It messes a bit with her to explain that her father and I were in love at one point and that all three of them are children of love.

I have an 11 yo who is the princess of 6th grade with legions of boys and girls drawn to her...if tales are to be believed. Then again, at 4 she was going to marry my now-supervisor-then co-worker at a different company's child.

Then I have a 20 yo who is as princessy as the rest but is sure the prince may be a frog or may be a princess or may be herself.

Oldest girl? Is a princess. Totally. But on the other hand...is there really a problem with that?

That accounts for the ones marked girl on the birth certificate.

The boys too had their princess phases. We didn't get too stirred up about it (ok, I mostly missed older boy's princess phase-though his skirt in high school phase did more to make my 16yo son a feminist than probably anything we as parents have said to him). After all we grew up on Free to Be You and Me. William's Doll. Their daddies fretted, we might have looked at it as a gender issue, but shrug...we had time. Besides-a boy with a sister is going to grab her boa or princess jewelry or play pretty pretty princess or princess dress at some point. We didn't take that princess phase to be a statement on a future weak willed boys are so handsome life.

So add a "or a girl" if you want. Or enjoy a princess. Soon enough she will be averse to boys altogether or not. It isn't a big deal.
( http://twitter.com/thatwoman )
( http://retro-food.com )

Retro-Food.com ( http://retro-food.com )

cctate 5 pts

First of all, beautiful post and so relatable! It sounds to me like you are demonstrating a realistic, loving relationship and that is the best way to teach children. And it's totally OK for her be innocent and optimistic at this age. Why ruin that! I have two boys, but if I had a girl, I think I would talk to her a lot about her own strengths and opportunities and independence rather than try to discourage the marriage/boys/love talk.

And by the way, it's a similar thing with boys. Even though I never allow them to play with toy guns or other play weapons, they take anything and turn it into a "shooter" and play-fight with each other all the time. I really now believe that some things are just innate.

Cristina
Working Mom, Democrat, Patriot ( http://workingmomdemocrat.blogspot.com/ )

Erin Kotecki Vest 5 pts

but somehow...somewhere...at some point I need to turn that into finding not a prince but 'healthy relationships' .... gah

Politics & News Contributing Editor Erin Kotecki Vest ( http://queenofspainblog.com/ )

Mama Murtz 5 pts

...the same night she tried to give me an open-mouthed kiss, then asked how she would know her prince if she finds him.  She was 4 at the time.  Sigh.  I haven't showered her in princess things, have tried to limit the Disney exposure, so this floored me.  She got it from the Disney book, The Little Mermaid.  We haven't read it since. :)  She's more girly than I can relate to, but, she sees this stuff at day care and if you look, it's really everywhere.  Developmentally, I'm cool with the pretend and dress-up thing.  Realistically, she's not old enough to rationalize kisses and finding a prince.  Like you, I just want her to be a kid, and it seems like hard work these days to let them just be kids.

Erin Kotecki Vest 5 pts

I guess that's where the whole 'age appropriate' thing comes in. Right now, I just want her to have fun and be a kid and not worry about those things. Sigh. 

Politics & News Contributing Editor Erin Kotecki Vest ( http://queenofspainblog.com/ )

Erin Kotecki Vest 5 pts

So there is hope.

Politics & News Contributing Editor Erin Kotecki Vest ( http://queenofspainblog.com/ )

TreniaP 5 pts

This warms my heart and makes me laugh. I never had a princess phase growing up. My parents were never married, and while my father was an active part of my life, men were always minor characters in the lives of the women in my family. I was mostly around women growing up and while I would get crushes on boys at school it never occurred to me that they would somehow come and save me. I also loved watching all of the Disney classics but it just seemed like a beautiful story. Unfortunately, I saw the human frailty of men and the hurt of love gone wrong too early on in my life, but I do wish I had that phase of innocence, a purity almost. I say let your daughter enjoy it, you'll get plenty of opportunities to teach her about the reality soon enough.

www.fatgirlweightlossmap.com ( http://www.fatgirlweightlossmap.com )

www.fatgirlweightloss.com ( http://www.fatgirlweightloss.com )

Bridging the gap between weight loss & body acceptance

Rita Arens 7 pts

Is there some dress-up/imagination phase that all kids -- boys and girls -- go through between the ages of two and five? Because every little kid I know wants to be someone else at that age. I think the girls glom onto princesses because they are in all the stores. If you live in America, it is impossible to avoid princesses unless you never leave your house. Even if you don't buy the stuff, they see it everywhere -- EVERYWHERE. Interestingly, they also seem to grow out of it as they decide to be themselves instead of someone else.

Rita Arens writes at Surrender Dorothy ( http://surrenderdorothy.typepad.com ) and BlogHer and is the editor of Sleep is for the Weak ( http://tinyurl.com/9pg62e ). She is BlogHer's assignment and syndication editor.